Should More Classic Final Fantasy Games Be Remade? The Arguments For & Against

Just FF VII, or should the rest follow?

final fantasy 7 aerith
Square Enix

It’s now been almost two months since Square Enix unleashed Final Fantasy VII Remake upon the world after more than half a decade of buildup.

It has seemingly been a resounding success, as the game has quickly become the fastest-selling in the franchise’s history, and critical reception has been almost universally positive. Criticisms about pacing, fetch quests, corridors and changes to the story the original have attracted derision from certain aspects of the fanbase in small doses, however.

It remains to be seen how many episodes that the Remake is going to subsequently consist of given that the first only covered around 10% of the original game, or what the timeline for their release is going to be. You’d have to imagine they’ll quickly become the company’s top priority, given how the appetites of casual players and diehard fans alike have been whetted.

Though there is also the small matter of both crafting Final Fantasy XVI (and beyond) and maintaining the player base within Final Fantasy XIV.

Whatever their decisions going forward, Square-Enix will certainly be buoyed by the fact that there is still a huge potential market for their back catalogue if the immediate success of VII Remake is anything to go by. They certainly ‘could’ now create a huge revenue stream for themselves by remaking other games, but ‘should’ they do this?

Let’s assess the case.

6. Against - Not Enough Development Resource

final fantasy 16
Square Enix

Final Fantasies I through VI were developed and released over the space of just seven years between 1987 and 1994, equating to almost one huge game per year for the NES and SNES consoles. There was then a three year wait for the original release of Final Fantasy VII on the PlayStation in 1997, but VIII, IX and X all followed within the next four years.

Since the release of X in 2001, however, there have been just three non-online main series titles developed in nineteen years. There was a six-year gap between X and XII, a three-year gap between XII and XIII and then another six-year gap between XIII and XV, which is now almost four years old with no news of any developments pertaining to XVI on the horizon. This is quite worrying.

For whatever reason, Square-Enix’s development speed has slowed to a crawl and in the cases of XV and VII Remake, the actual releases of the game came many years after they were announced and showcased for the first time. The size and scope of modern games necessitates longer development times than previous generations, but Square-Enix’s are notoriously amongst the most unhurried in the industry.

Nobody wants a rushed and poor-quality Final Fantasy game, but given the emphasis placed on spin-offs and mobile titles since the Enix merger, adding more remakes to Square Enix’s slate could prolong that the wait for XVI and other titles beyond what fans will accept.


5. For - Commercial Potential

final fantasy 13 snow
Square Enix

Some criticism has been directed as Square-Enix for the fact that VII Remake will be episodic, with much of this geared around the fact that experiencing the ‘full game’ will end up costing at least £200 (based on an assumption of five episodes at a minimum of £40 each). This is despite the fact that each episode is being expanded into a full-length 50-100 hour experience comparable in value to any other new release, which will have already won over many cynics given the quality and depth of the content.

This practice may have already turned off the most stubborn of players and there will likely be an inevitable fall-off in player count with each instalment as some forget about the game and others simply choose not to continue with it, but the sales figures and financial returns so far look very promising for the board and shareholders. They can reasonably assume that a sizable percentage of episode one’s 3.5 million and counting buyers will end up shelling out for each subsequent instalment no matter what – it’s how addiction works after all…

Success in business is obviously based on revenues, so from a commercial standpoint, analysts within the company are probably seeing the success of VII Remake as a potential licence to print money going forwards. A lot will hinge on whether episode two and beyond are comparable triumphs, but making hundreds of millions from remaking one property will certainly make remaking others an attractive prospect.


4. Against - Taking Goodwill For Granted

Final Fantasy XV Episode Prompto
Square Enix

When Square-Enix first announced that VII Remake was not going to be a completely faithful retelling of the original story, there was considerable backlash. Much doubt will certainly have been destroyed by the quality of the finished product of episode one, but there are still elements of the fanbase that are sticking to their guns and decrying the game for not being a shot-for-shot remake.

It remains to be seen just how extreme any future changes to the narrative will be, as the ending showcased some shocking revelations. Goodwill could certainly go off the deep end if episodes two and beyond use these as a foundation to go in a radically different direction to before, which could put people off in their droves and lead to a stonewall rejection of any further reimagining of any other games.

Complete remakes (as opposed to remasters) are quite rare in the world of gaming, but in the world of film, it isn’t uncommon for them to go in a drastically different direction to their source material in order to be both unpredictable and stand out as something other than a rehash of the original. More often than not they don’t go down too well, evidenced by how the majority of film remakes are held in much lower regard than their predecessors.

Final Fantasy’s fanbase can be as fickle as they come. Square-Enix certainly won’t want to push them too far by completely upsetting the applecart.


3. For - New Audiences For Beloved Stories

Final Fantasy IX
Square-Enix

Few games are timeless and most get quickly superseded by advances in technology, particularly on the graphics front. Pop any classic game into a console of yesteryear and you can almost guarantee that happy childhood memories will be quickly overridden by frustration at non-responsive controls and clunkiness.

Given that Final Fantasy games are RPGs, however, most of them can be considered as such. Why? Because their heart is their story rather than their mechanics. Good stories do not age, hence why texts from hundreds of years ago are still commonplace in classrooms and as source material for films today.

There are always those that will turn their nose up at older games because of their lack of visual appeal, however, similar to how there are always those that will refuse to watch a great foreign film because it isn’t in English. Annoyingly, these sorts of people will be put off by the aesthetics of Final Fantasies I through XII, despite the fact that each has been reworked on several occasions to iron out many of their gameplay kinks.

By giving some of them the remake treatment and completely updating their graphics and gameplay to reflect modern standards, it would be possible to cultivate a new generation of fans that didn’t experience the stories the first time around and have neglected to explore them out of cynicism, lack of knowledge or an inability to source copies (VI’s best version is >£100 used on Amazon after all!). The stories deserve to be told.


2. Against - Risk Of Less Successful Properties

Final Fantasy VI Battle
Square-Enix

With worldwide sales of more than 13 million units, the original Final Fantasy VII is by far the most successful game in the franchise. For many, it was their first experience of the series, releasing on the PlayStation at the height of the system’s ascendancy. As a result of this, it is often regarded to be the best game in the series. That’s certainly debateable – many of its flaws are often overlooked by the rose-tinted glasses of nostalgia, but what cannot be questioned is that the widespread exposure and love for the game is what inspired (and has largely fuelled the success of) the Remake.

After VII, the most successful games in the series are XIV (10.9 million lifetime players), X (10.5 million units), VIII (9.65 million units) and XV (8.9 million units). XIV is still a live MMO game and XV is only four years old, whilst there aren’t many calls for a remake of X given that the HD remaster of the original 2014 game holds up quite well.

That leaves VIII, which can probably attribute some of its success to piggybacking on the release of VII. There is certainly a case for remaking VI and IX, which sold between 5 and 6 million copies each despite releasing at the end of their console’s life cycles, but its difficult to say whether Square-Enix would risk investing in something that has a much lower ceiling than their biggest property.


1. For - A Passionate Fanbase

final fantasy tactics
Square Enix

There is a reason why some of the earlier Final Fantasies have been remastered and re-released on almost ten different platforms over the last twenty years (IV holds the record, including a full remake for the Nintendo DS that wasn’t just an upscaled port). From PCs to phones, fans just cannot get enough of their favourite stories and are keen to re-experience them (and any additional content that Square-Enix throw in as an incentive) time after time. This is no different to how people are inclined to rewatch their favourite films on a regular basis, or start watching Friends from season 1 episode 1 once again after running through the series of Netflix for the nineteenth time.

If Square-Enix do ultimately choose to remake any of their other classics after they eventually finish with VII down the line, they can be assured of a high volume of almost guaranteed sales given how widespread and passionate the fanbase that they have harvested over the last thirty-three years is. The successes of XIV and XV have also ensured that the franchise bears a recognisable and bankable name once again after a rocky few years that saw the release of only the XIII sequels and the disastrous Before Meteor version of their now flourishing MMO.

Whether it’s a universally beloved classic like VI or an underrated gem like Tactics, anything made to the standard of the VII Remake thus far will be greatly appreciated by legions of gamers around the world.


The IMPOSSIBLE Final Fantasy 7 Quiz

Final Fantasy 7 Barret
Square Enix

1. What Is The Name Of Barret's Adopted Daughter?

Contributor
Contributor

Alex was about to write a short biography, but he got distracted by something shiny instead.