Skyrim: 5 Reasons It Was Over-Rated

What gives Skyrim such an appeal?

Bethesda's latest was one of the best sellers of last year, and a massive critical success, but what gives it such an appeal? I mean, Bethesda can craft a world, but jeez, you can see through Skyrim's technical cracks and see it struggling to cope. While Skyrim did grab me, it's many flaws really didn't help the game blow me away like it should have. Technical flaws are nothing new to gaming, but in a title so reliant on the engine powering it, a key element was really missing. If Bethesda can fix these issues in future titles, then the Elder Scrolls series will set a new standard that all companies will have to struggle to meet. Until then, however, we're left with something a bit sub-par.

1. Graphics

We'll start with Skyrim's graphics. Todd Howard, the lead for the Skyrim team, said they considered waiting until the next hardware generation to do another Elder Scrolls game. Why? Even with Skyrim's "brand new engine" it can't hold a candle to Uncharted 3, Gears 3 or Battlefield 3. The textures are bland and the special effects are very basic. Characters look awkward and unnatural and only the art has any real, boastful potential. The image above is a comparison of character models between PS3 exclusive Uncharted 3, and Skyrim. Hard to believe there is only a week between these games, isn't it?

2. Combat

Another overrated element of Skyrim is the combat. The dual wielding system is quite good, but all you do is hit two buttons see the animation used on enemies who do nothing but run at you kamikaze style and get themselves killed. The new killcams should work fine, but the animations are jerky, there is a pause between normal gameplay and kill camera and the HUD disappears, further highlighting that you're watching a scripted scene. The combat is not only dysfunctional, but quite boring. The closest sword play game, by release date, was Assassin's Creed Revelations. AC: R has a great combat system filled with varied animations and engaging AI. Skyrim involves only left click, right click, dual click. Done.

3. The Acting

Another fan-praised element of Skyrim was the writing, acting and story. While I'll leave my judgement on the story out, as opinion on story is different to everyone and therefore irrelevant. But the acting is hardly revolutionary. There seemed to be 20 actors spread out over hundreds of roles. And aside from the repetition, the acting was sub-par at best. The accents were fake and goofy, and while every effort was spared to make the minor roles sound Nordic, the main roles all had American accents. Very suspicious.

4. The NPCs

Let's move onto a gripe of mine, and this one is in Mass Effect as well. The NPC's were all made in the character creation tool, so you can see repeated traits all over the game. It's possible to see someone who likes just like you. And they sound like every other NPC in the game. I understand having one system for making NPC's, but at least make it different to the players choices.

5. The Technical Faults

Back to the visual tech, particularly on the PS3 version. We've all heard of the frame rate issues on the system, but the FPS is consistently horrible regardless of how much you have played the game. My game freezes for a few seconds while it loads the dragon shouts, and moving about cities is a more clunky process than intended. So, Uncharted 3 runs at solid, unmoving 30 FPS while Skyrim struggles to even move? Good work, Bethesda. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w1x7L6-0JJE Ah, cities. You never cease to dumbfound me. The Creation engine loads the whole Skyrim world at once, but then can only load one house in one city? How is it I can have miles of land to explore, than only one house before a loading screen to only one city? While the Open Cities PC mod is a god sent, it's only on the PC, so the poor console only players will have to suffer Bethesda's lazy work. I could sit here and rant about the story telling, the sloppy re-use of buildings and towns or the dumb controls, but I won't. While Skyrim's freedom and art impresses, it is ultimately a technical failure. A poorly designed and conceived game, it suffers from same problems all other Western RPG's, especially Bethesda games, and it ultimately hinders player enjoyment. While I don't rate Skyrim as a bad game, it's still vastly overrated. The design of the RPG elements, watching NPC's fighting other without scripting and Jeremy Soule's unmatched score really give the fantasy land of Skyrim an engaging feel, but the technology behind the game really lets it down. I would still recommend playing Skyrim, but just make your own judgements and try not to follow the herd.

Contributor
Contributor

I live in Australia, love to write and play games. So what better than writing about games? I love all things action and fantasy, as well as my occasional shooter. I literally cannot wait for GTAV!