Star Wars Battlefront 2 Controversy: 9 Things You Need To Know
A million voices are crying out, and they won't be silenced.
After one of the most turbulent launch periods in gaming history (it's up for debate whether this was more or less ill-received than No Man's Sky), for the most part the gameplay side of things, the mechanical act of playing Battlefront 2, was stellar.
Sadly, it's no exaggeration to say that EA's forced implementation of microtransactions atop DICE's loot box-based progression was a move only made to bring in as much cash as possible, and the resultant "pay to win" mentality caught the attention of everyone from politicians to parent groups and everything in between.
Hell, if rumours were to be believed, Disney's own Bob Iger rang EA to instruct them on removing microtransactions and essentially save the brand of Star Wars as it was being dragged through the muck.
Cut to 2018, and things aren't much better. Upon returning microtransactions to the game under the guise of only being for cosmetics, the Battlefront community was then told of a renewed "dedication" to the project, starting with a new mode... Ewok Hunt.
It wasn't the best foot forward, and with a key insider now leaking a ton of insider information as to what's happening on both sides of the consumer/creator divide, Battlefront 2's fanbase are teetering on the edge of giving up altogether.
9. The Elongated Wait For Season 2
Y'know what the original Season of content was themed around?
The Last Jedi. Which released on the 14th of December, 2017.
Since then EA and DICE have obviously weathered one hell of a storm to try and keep Battlefront as the Star Wars game, but many devs have been vocal about how all of these changes in direction have notably impacted the perceived rollout of content for the game.
Thankfully, EA didn't force a season pass for this iteration, but they did still sell a whole load of "Deluxe" and "Trooper" editions, meaning there are millions of players who continued to give them the benefit of the doubt at launch - only to be left waiting for additions to the base game that justify the investment.
Despite the lack of a pass, Battlefront 2 is still talked about as a platform for content to be "plugged in", and its content is thought of in terms of "seasons".
The combination of 'money paid' plus 'time invested' equalling "barely any word from the devs for literal months" has notably soured even the most devout players.
8. Two Major Studios Have Been Pulled Off The Project
(The initial post that leaked from inside EA/DICE HQ has now been removed, but various copy n' paste versions are available - including this, for now.)
Mentioned in the above poster's breakdown of what was to come in the Season 2 update (a "leak" that only gained credence after accurately describing two new skins for Lando and Leia that are now up on EA's own forum), a rather shocking, worrying detail is that two of EA's studios are no longer working on the game.
Both Criterion and Motive have apparently been redirected onto a "new triple A" game, leaving only DICE to pick up the remaining pieces and continue development.
Needless to say, this is more than worrying going forward, as fans are notably aware of putting money and time into a game that is no longer fully supported by EA.
The amount of money Battlefront 2's launch controversy cost EA is no secret, and if this has translated into any higher-ups cooking figures and realising it's worth "moving on", the fans deserve to know.
7. Developers Aren't Allowed To Communicate With Fans
Second on the most worrying comments from the leak comes from various developers apparently being told not to communicate with fans.
"Devs are eager to share info with you but they are not let to do so. The only way they could say something important is by receiving approvals by prod and others."
As you saw in an earlier point, DICE and various other devs working on the project have been more than vocal about the struggles they faced course-correcting the initial launch window fallout. Taking that away hasn't gone unnoticed across the game's various forums, and now the leak has confirmed it's down to EA remixing studios to focus on the next game in their pipeline, the result is more worry, anger and disappointment.
For a time, Battlefront 2 was sold on "righting the wrongs" of the first game - something done through transparency and acknowledgement of past failings. Shut those communication channels down and the old image of EA being a silent string-puller with the worst intentions comes right back into view.
6. "Night On Endor" Did VERY Little To Quell The Flames
As Redditor KillerAero thankfully pointed out, DICE aren't anything close to "lazy", nor have they straight-up not put any content out since launch. From bug fixes to Arcade mode reworks, we have seen at least one or two updates per month - the main issue is that The Last Jedi's "season content" didn't arrive until January, and even with that in tow, we've not had any new levels or meaningful additions since.
Again, DICE have outlined that all their efforts had to go into the "Progression Update" (the cosmetic store and microtransaction rework), but as is plain to see: Such an update is a tough pill to swallow when it obscures the very reason people picked up the game in the first place.
Put simply: Fans didn't purchase the new triple-A Star Wars game, to see a developer and publisher lose control of their game for months on end.
Yes, that's the reality of the situation, but when the official "We're back!" return statement ended with "And now you can play as Ewoks and microtransactions are back!", it did very little to convince the majority DICE knew what fans actually wanted.
5. After Everything, Season 2 Is Underwhelming
From launch day insanity to mistimed Last Jedi content to Ewok Hunt, all eyes were now on "Season 2" to right every last wrong, and make Battlefront 2 something that felt as good to navigate through, as it does to storm a checkpoint or pull off a Starfighter kill-streak.
Whether it be down to teams being removed from development or priorities being placed on restoring microtransactions, the new "season" - meant to tie into Solo: A Star Wars Story and be entirely themed around Han Solo - includes one map (Jabba's Palace, somewhat recycled from Battlefront 1), a 2v2 hero/villain mode, a Starfighter practice area and two skins.
You can read the full breakdown of every new addition here, and though there are some quality of life improvements like a main menu rework and the removal of holograms to view items, sufficed to say it's far from a "meaningful update".
4. Glitches & Bugs That Have Been In Since Launch
One thing the teams have clearly not had time to prioritise when all hands where on the Progression Update, is bugs and glitches.
Something that literally takes a huge amount of personnel to recreate specific scenarios and then communicate accurately how anomalies where discovered, these can dog even the biggest video games in the industry.
For Battlefront though, we're talking updates happening only every month or so - not anything close to the regular rollouts of other online service titles like Fortnite or Overwatch.
Yes, the reality is that EA are managing their studios in a way that doesn't prioritise polish (we saw it with Mass Effect Andromeda, too), but players are going to notice this stuff in any given match, or every given match.
3. The "Seasons" Framework Is Already Outdated
Another thing that contributes to the rising notion that "EA just don't care", this whole notion of Battlefront having "seasons" that would tie into the wider world of Star Wars has mostly fallen by the wayside.
DICE stated themselves that "Seasons will focus around a specific theme (such as a new Star Wars film, or an anniversary in the Star Wars Universe) and will usually span multiple months", yet with Solo: A Star Wars Story releasing in less than two weeks at time of writing, there's not one single asset from the film in the game.
We saw how this stuff is supposed to work with Rogue One, its DLC dropping on December 6th before the movie was released on the 13th. It helped build interest, and gave fans something to play when coming out the cinema.
In Battlefront 2's case, both The Last Jedi content was late (and underwhelming, considering the surface-level "pick a faction" stuff), and Solo's is... nowhere to be seen.
Needless to say, a set of Alden Ehrenreich or Donald Glover skins for Han and Lando would've gone a long way, and could've even made up for the movie's own lack of general hype from fans.
2. No Roadmap For The Game's Future
As Rocksteady found out back when Arkham Knight's season pass launched with a "Yup, just trust us... things are coming!" mentality (before a groundswell of fan response forced their hand), trying to ask for fan/consumer investment in your product with a notable lack of detail can go south, fast.
Now, there's a huge, some would say never-ending pool of goodwill for Star Wars, but even now the Han Solo season is detailed, fans don't know what's coming next.
The nearest thing to Solo content or new planets/levels is DICE's "Community Transmission" saying more "Han Solo Season content" will release in June "including details of a brand new world". It's arguably, depending on hours invested, time spent and your interactions over time with the wider Battlefront community, just not enough.
EA's "get out" card is that a season pass's worth of content was never required or detailed - though that doesn't help with the general lack of information surrounding the future of the game overall.
1. The Launch Controversy STILL Dogs The Game
You could argue that Battlefront 2 never fully recovered from what happened last November.
The annoyed parent groups, the label of a "Star Wars-themed online casino for kids", the tanking player numbers and the fact that as EA "turned off" microtransactions in response, even playing what we did get felt notably "in progress" - all resulted in detonating the game's future plans, as they were designed at launch.
We've had apologies from both EA and DICE, but the reality of whether you should play a game or not; whether you should be prepared to forgive X number of components or missing features, shouldn't require reading up on months of course correction.
The fact remains that EA are still dealing with the launch of Battlefront 2 to this day. Remixing priorities to address the business reality of a failed Star Wars game is what's happening.