Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order Review - 5 Ups & 3 Downs

The game Star Wars fans have been waiting for... with a few snags along the way.

Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order
EA

Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order released late last week as the first single-player focused Star Wars game since the start of the decade.

For a franchise that has such a rich history with the gaming medium as Star Wars, that's a pretty depressing statement - especially so, once you consider that the series' current license holders, EA, have had the rights to produce games based in a galaxy far, far away since 2013, and have so far only produced three triple-A Star Wars titles in Battlefront, Battlefront II, and Respawn's new single-player experience.

With two cancelled single-player Star Wars games looming over production on Jedi: Fallen Order, to say that Star Wars fans have greeted its release with a sense of relief would be putting things lightly. It's a game they've been waiting for for over nine years, and while Respawn's acumen was never in doubt, before release, excitement for Fallen Order ranged between tepid and cautiously optimistic. It soon became clear that demos shown to the public weren't selling the true scale or focus of the title, and as its release approached, many were starting to consider that it may just be the real deal.

Is it? Well, yes - for the most part. I wasn't fortunate enough to procure a review code before release (mind-tricks evidently get you nowhere, these days), but I have spent the last weekend playing Fallen Order to completion and, while it isn't perfect, it's a more than worthy addition to Star Wars' illustrious gaming past. It's ambitious, impassioned and massively refreshing - even if it is let down by a lack of polish and other issues in a select few areas.

So, with all that said, let's get into the nitty-gritty of what works - and doesn't - with Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order...


Downs...

3. There's A Frustrating Lack Of Polish

Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order Glitch
EA

Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order is a stunning looking game. DICE developed a knack for realising the look and feel of a galaxy far, far away with their two Battlefront titles, and while Fallen Order doesn't look quite as good, it's still just as lovingly created. The main character models all look the part, while the presentation on the whole is immaculate, whether you're scaling the arid cliffs of Dathomir or the lush jungles of Kashyyyk.

It's elsewhere, though, where the mask starts to slip.

Bearing in mind that I ran Fallen Order on a base model Playstation 4, my time with the game was littered with performance issues. Texture pop-ins were frequent, assets loaded into cutscenes in full-view (lessening the emotional pay-off of a pivotal story moment), and glitches in combat became frequent as the game approached its middle stages. Characters would refuse to fall off ledges and plummet to an early grave, while some would glitch into the floor, preventing progression when enemies had to be cleared in order to advance to the next stage.

Sadly, for all that the main character models looked the part, certain NPCs near-enough looked like they belonged on last-gen systems. The level of polish just wasn't there, and it's incredibly disappointing, especially given we're now at the end of the console cycle.

It's unlikely EA would've countenanced the thought of releasing Fallen Order after the holidays and after Rise of Skywalker, but a few more months to iron out the kinks would've definitely resulted in a better-looking product.


2. The Camera Will Literally Get You Killed

Star Wars Jedi Fallen Order Purge Trooper
EA

Fallen Order's combat is pretty great, but it doesn't take long before it can start to frustrate more than entertain.

When greeted with large groups of enemies, many will try and flank the player and cause them an issue. This would be fine, if it was easy enough to switch between targets quickly and securely, but the game seems reluctant to let you switch to someone directly behind you. It's a bit of a faff, and the lack of clarity over whether or not players should use the 'lock-on' mechanic when dealing with groups of enemies can prove to be a bit of a hindrance too.

Although the occasions where this resulted in death were few and far between, it did make a few of them feel just a little bit unearned on the AI's behalf.

Worse still is that when the player takes on a large group of enemies at once, Fallen Order's more considered approach to combat can quickly devolve into a panicked melee. That may be the point - to shake up the pace of combat - but that didn't always shine through when you're frantically hitting evade and locking on to everyone BUT the enemy you're trying to prioritise.


1. Backtracking Eventually Gets Repetitive

Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order E3 Trailer
EA

Fallen Order's Metroidvania elements weren't telegraphed too clearly before release, and that's actually quite a shame. Backtracking and discovering new areas you weren't able to access the first time around was really fun, while turning the tables on those early enemy encounters with new weapons, force abilities and experience helped showcase the development of Cal as a Jedi, as well as the player's own progress.

Unfortunately, there were occasions where backtracking erred on the tedious side of things. Fallen Order's story requires players to return to planets they were previously unable to fully explore, but in traversing the same areas a second time around, those old enemies and AI patterns pretty much repeat themselves. The same quantity of troopers in the same order and type appear over and over, and it happens to coincide with a mid-act lull that breaks up Fallen Order's brilliant beginning and final third.

Now to be clear there's nothing wrong with repeating enemies, but it has to be done in a way that lends itself to the narrative. Returning to a planet you've already liberated and having the same groups appear in the exact same way, fighting the same amount of native wildlife with the same weaponry just isn't compelling, and is the one area where Fallen Order's Soulslike stylings grow stale.


Ups...

5. The Story Is A Fantastic Addition To The Star Wars Canon

Star Wars Jedi Fallen Order
EA

By far the most compelling element of a Star Wars game in this day and age has to be its story, and Fallen Order does not disappoint. Written by Aaron Contreras, Manny Hagopian, Matt Michnovetz and Megan Fausti, Respawn's Star Wars game brings players to the galaxy's lowest point - the transition between Episodes III and IV.

The Empire is an omnipresent force, and while the new Star Wars canon has already delved deep into this particular setting, Fallen Order finds itself in a unique position in that it elects to show the Empire's formative years. It's set only five years after the Jedi Purge, and the decision to open the game up on Bracca, a planet literally dedicated to scrapping those old cruisers and ships used in the Clone Wars, serves as a fantastic visual metaphor to showcase the transformation of Star Wars from the Prequels to the Original Trilogy.

Respawn have also assembled a compelling cast of characters. Cal Kestis (portrayed by Gotham's Cameron Monaghan) is a worthy enough protagonist, and he's far from the generic Star Wars archetype some predicted. Respawn's writers weave a harrowing past for Cal that lays bare the tragedy of the Jedi's downfall, while his mission - to effectively restart the Jedi Order - brings with it its own ethical quandaries that both Cal and the player will struggle to reckon with as the game nears its final stages.

Star Wars Jedi Fallen Order Inquisitors
EA

Joining Cal is Eno Cordova's lovable robotic companion, BD-1, a contender for Star Wars' cutest droid and who is really the heart and soul of Respawn's game. They're brimming with personality, and the bond between Cal and his droid anchors the story right where it should be.

Star Wars also finds itself with an additional assortment of compelling characters, thanks to Respawn's efforts. Former Jedi Master Cere Junda (Debra Wilson) is a complex character and an intriguing one at that, while pilot Greez, though underdeveloped in places, also has his moments. Nightsister Merrin more than deserves a game of her own too, and it'll be a huge shame if we don't see more of these figures in further literature - particularly the Second Sister, who emerges from Fallen Order as the most intriguing of all the Inquisitors seen in the franchise yet.

There is a tedious mid-act lull to deal with, but the first and final thirds are truly breathtaking.


4. The Lightsaber Customisation Is A Dream Come True

Star Wars Jedi Fallen Order Orange Lightsaber
EA

Not a lot was made of Fallen Order's customisation prior to release, and while the options to change the way Cal looks are disappointingly threadbare, lightsaber customisation is the best it's ever gotten.

Players can choose between three lightsaber colours to begin with (two if you didn't pre-order), in blue, green and - making its canon comeback - orange. The lattermost option is a unique draw, and it looks great, but it's not just the lightsaber crystal players can change. Respawn spared no expense and ensured that players can mix and match an array of emitters, switches, sleeves and even metals to create their very own blade. And when you factor in the unlockable double-bladed lightsaber, no other Star Wars game can really compare when it comes to allowing players full control over their weapon.

Without spoiling anything too heavily though, I will say that the customisation did feel at odds with a later story revelation. You see, Cal inherits his blade from his master, and while it's great Respawn gives players the tools to mess with their weapon right from the start, players searching for a more thematically resonant conclusion may wish to hold off changing their weapon until prompted by the story.


3. It Finds The Perfect Mix Between Empowering And Challenging The Player

Star Wars Jedi Fallen Order
EA

There's been a trend with a lot of licensed games over the last two console generations where those kinds of games never really prize difficulty as an asset. Most of the time that's because developers are more concerned with empowering players with specific roles; Batman: Arkham has Bat-fans become the Dark Knight by giving them an invulnerable skill-set, while The Force Unleashed put players in the shoes of a ludicrously powerful dark Jedi a year earlier.

These approaches are fine in and of themselves, but they do lose something without that element of challenge. Fallen Order manages to find the right balance between the two, by placing the player in the shoes of a Padawan who lost their master, and who is still learning how to be a Jedi Knight in a now unforgiving galaxy.

Confrontations require patience, and it's likely that most players will fail several times before they finish the story even on the default difficulty. But that's really quite refreshing, with the more considered approach to combat only lending itself well to the Star Wars IP, and in a way, the 'Jedi way' with which audiences are already so familiar.

Fallen Order's bosses are also brilliant to come up against. They're big, cinematic and challenging in all the right ways - even if it is frustrating when you die and miss out on an optional encounter.


2. The Mantis Is Great To Explore (But Could Probably Be Better)

Jedi Fallen Order Stinger Mantis
EA

Respawn created something really cool when they brought Greez Dritus' ship, the Stinger Mantis, into a galaxy far, far away. It looks tremendous, and giving players the ability to roam the ship while in takeoff and hyperspace is a stroke of genius on their behalf. Players can customise Cal's lightsaber from within the ship, rest, and even admire Greez's terrarium if they find seeds out in the wild. Pick up a Bogling stowaway on Bogano, and you'll be able to see it hiding in the vents, while players can also change the ship's paintjobs by finding crates in different levels.

It's pretty fun, but the premise never gets expanded upon to the levels you'd really hope. Cere pays reference to Star Wars' famed 'holochess' game in dialogue, but even though there's a table on the Mantis seemingly built for such a game, it never gets used. I don't want to get bogged down in 'could'ves' and 'should'ves', but it just seems obvious that the Mantis, although a great addition, could've been even better if Respawn were willing to flesh out the space even further.

Why not have a space battle segment? Let Cal sample Greez's famed cooking, or even perform maintenance on the ship in the vein of Red Dead Redemption 2's camp - anything to make it feel more lived-in than it already does.

Still, for all that the Mantis seems like a missed opportunity, the fact you can effectively play the loading screen is great fun, and is surely representative of Respawn's dedication to immersing players in a galaxy far, far away.


1. It's The Game Star Wars Fans Have Waited A Decade For

Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order Second Sister
EA

When EA and Lucasfilm look back on the last generation of Star Wars games, it's likely both parties will draw negative conclusions. EA did resurrect the cult-favourite Battlefront IP and DICE weathered controversy with both releases to deliver two genuinely great titles, but there's no ignoring LucasArts' legacy or how the most beloved Star Wars games were single-player offerings.

To that end, the high-profile cancellations of Project Ragtag and Project Orca - two separate single-player Star Wars games - have led many to believe that EA doesn't see value in a single-player Star Wars game. Development on Fallen Order commenced before the publisher acquired Respawn outright, while the way the title was marketed before launch also ran into criticism when it became clear demos weren't showing the game's true focus.

But, for all the controversy, waiting and just general 'whateverness' when it comes to EA's Star Wars, make no mistake - this is absolutely the game Star Wars have been waiting for. Overdue in many respects but arriving at just the right time (a whole month before the Skywalker Saga draws to a close) Fallen Order reiterates the value of Star Wars single-player titles, and ranks alongside the very best licensed games ever released.

It isn't without its problems - and the lack of polish can derail it at times - but in whisking players away to a galaxy far, far away, Fallen Order succeeds and then some.

Final Rating - ★★★1/2


Watch Next


True Or False: A Star Wars Quiz

Count Dooku Star Wars Christopher Lee
Disney

1. Lord Tyranus Trained Qui-Gon Jin.

Content Producer/Presenter

WhatCulture's very own resident movie guy, Ewan has been working in the content creation biz for over 10 years now, having started as a freelance contributor to WhatCulture Gaming all the way back in 2015. After graduating with a First-Class Honours in History from Northumbria University in 2017 (where he won a prize for a totally killer dissertation on the Watergate years), Ewan took on the role of Comics Editor at WhatCulture and quickly developed WhatCulture Comics into one of the biggest superhero-focused channels on YouTube. He followed this with a brief hiatus at Screen Rant in 2021, where he worked across the Gaming and Film sections as a writer and editor, before returning to WhatCulture as a Senior Content Producer / Presenter in 2023. He started his own podcast, We Love Dad Movies, in 2022, and has contributed several written pieces to the Eisner-nominated comics website Shelfdust as well. In his current role, Ewan incorporates his love of cinema, comic books, and history into written pieces and video essays for WhatCulture's Film & TV channel, as well as WhatCulture Gaming and WhatCulture Horror, with a particular focus on nineties-era Dad Movies, old school Westerns, and Golden Age Hollywood Noir. John Carpenter is his fave, and he thinks Batman Beyond should never have been cancelled. If that's your vibe, you'll probably like his stuff.