Super Mario Maker 2 Review: 6 Ups & 3 Downs

Making Mario has never been so good.

Super Mario Maker 2
Nintendo

Rating: ★★★★☆

With every Nintendo console comes the inevitable wave of first-party Mario themed exclusives, from the standard platforming adventures and mad Parties he gets up to, to days out Karting and, these days, contract building.

In other words: Mario Maker.

The first game was an underplayed hit on the Wii U, and Super Mario Maker 2 brings the seemingly limitless creativity of the previous instalment whilst expanding on it in every single way. From the slight tweaks to menus to adding completely new modes, items and gizmos, there's enough here to keep avid creators building away for years to come.

This is a platformer like no other - the community around Super Mario Maker 2 is one of the friendliest, yet most competitive out there, with players constantly challenging each other with new levels designed to push each other to the limit. And when that has the trappings of Mario, how can you not love it?

In true Nintendo fashion, however, there is the odd thing or two here that completely baffles players, again raising the question: "why do they keep doing this in 2019?"

But hey, that is the company we have all grown up with affection to regardless. We wouldn't have it any other way.


Downs...

3. Co-op Making Doesn’t Live Up To The Hype

Nintendo

The Nintendo Direct which contained the announcement that a Super Mario Maker 2 was coming - and coming this year - dropped with an overwhelming flood of information. New Items, Enemies and Gizmos were on the way, as well as new world themes and even a Super Mario 3D World game style - which shakes up play quite a bit.

But of all the new features, co-op making and play seemed like it could change the game in the most drastic way.

Sadly, this isn’t the case, with co-op building offering nothing more than an extra feather in the new game's cap. Having two players building at once gets confusing really easily - which happens more often than not.

The screen real estate just isn’t enough for building (especially on an undocked Switch) with a friend or even a child. It's not ideal, given this should be the younger generation's gateway into classic Mario play.

Where the chaos of multiple players on screen seemed to only add to the experience of New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe, here it detracts from the overall enjoyment.


2. Friend Codes Are Boring

Nintendo / Dan Rycket

Oh, Nintendo…

Now where the company excels is in their games: they play great, have memorable characters and rarely ever flop, but it seems to be everything around the games themselves that this company just can’t seem to get right.

Take voice chat on a Switch for example - there isn’t any! Nintendo just expects players to download a shoddy app and live with that and that's the same attitude they seem to have taken with Friend Codes too.

In Super Mario Maker 2, this is a particular hassle as the game is all about making and sharing levels for countless others to play, but as there is little to no search functionality other than entering IDs for players and levels, the whole thing is clunky. The best thing to do here is to find your favourite creators on Twitter or post out an ID when it is done.


1. Removed Features

Nintendo

In recent years, Nintendo has really come around from what was the smouldering dumpster fire of the Wii U era, and seem on it when getting their first-party line up on Switch. Mario Kart 8 Deluxe for example, was quickly ported to the new console immediately making it worth the purchase.

Many other new titles followed suit, but the straight-up quick port jobs stopped there. 2019 looked to be a pretty empty year for Nintendo, and so it was speculated that Mario Maker would be translated to the new hardware wholesale. We got an all new game instead, but sadly with some features stripped out - as if Reggie got whatever he could before his last day in office.

Skinny Mario, probably the iconic mascot of the previous game is gone and even more egregiously, the ability to download and edit player-created levels has gone also. This was a useful tool for players to take extremely hard and demanding levels and break them down, section by section.

Now that's vanished, this may lead to some of the more notorious creators such as Dan Ryckert seeing their levels never completed.

(Skinny Mario can be found as an easter egg, but not in a playable form)


Ups...

6. There Is A Story Mode

Nintendo

The first Super Mario Maker seemed to just come out of nowhere, but was a welcome surprise. For the first time (legally) the keys to the Mushroom Kingdom were in the hands of the people and not just Nintendo's designers. However, getting a new entry in the series and not including some kind of story mode, just felt, well, wrong.

The story mode itself isn’t all that complicated, though it is refreshing; this time, the castle needs rebuilding instead of the Princess needing saving.

Playing a number of in-house created levels instead of users' ones is actually a really good way to start off, rather than going in blind. In fact, you could say the story mode is a stealth tutorial for players. And as an added bonus, completing the story will net plays some bonuses for Maker Mode.


5. New Items, Enemies, Gizmos & More!

Nintendo

Thankfully, Nintendo didn’t take the easy way out here. Instead of just simply calling this Mario Maker Deluxe and calling it a day, they went all out to unchain this from the previous Mario lineage.

Whilst the original Super Mario Maker was trying to be faithful, the second instalment encourages creators to get wired when building levels by offering items and gizmos not available before.

Take the swinging claw for example. On the surface, this seems like nothing more than one of those rip off claw machine grabbers that are by design meant to take your money. But in Super Mario Maker 2, it blows open the level of creativity and customisable options. The claw can be used like one of those machines, used to hold enemies, items, or to carry Mario though a tight space that is only survivable whilst in a Goomba's shoe. This is just one example of how just a few items combined can have very different outcomes.

What might be the best of new big gizmos are the On/Off switch blocks. These can be triggered by Koopa shells, Bob-omb and really anything else thrown at them. Red is on and Blue is off, which simply activates red or blue blocks. Yes, this might sound basic, but adding functionality like this will have Makers perfect levels with puzzle-solving or scripted jump sequences for years to come.


4. It Isn't On The Wii U

Nintendo

When all is said and done, the Wii U will be remembered as one of the biggest flops in the video game industry this side of the Millenium.

Super Mario Maker had the unfortunate setback of being chained to the Wii U, and even though this was probably the perfect console to host such a game until now, it meant that it wasn’t getting the spotlight a Mario title deserved. It's an absolute delight that a wider audience will now get to experience the game's brilliance. Yes the original did come to the 3DS, but thas just not the same.

As reported by EuroGamer, the new instalment into the Maker franchise has already doubled the sales of the original, which can only mean that there will be plenty of community-created levels for years to come.

The Switch just feels like the perfect home for a Mario Maker: keep this console in your bag and at anytime, a level can be added to or a stage attempted, and with a capacitive stylus, constructing levels is a breeze.

There will be some complaints that there still isn’t a concrete solution to get video out for the Switch when it is in handheld mode, but for the majority of players, this'll never be an issue.


3. New Building Interface & Options

Nintendo

Super Mario Maker was a weird game, built by its community in more ways than one, because not only did the players make the levels, but they also discovered new ways of manipulating them to suit needs never before thought of in a Mario game.

For example, another way the community had to spread the word was with accessing new items. Simply shaking a grinder would turn it into a bumper - which wasn’t ever really made clear Thankfully, in Super Mario Maker 2, the build menus have had some overhauling and now display everything there for the making in a very neat wheel.

With the Switch's form factor, this means that Nintendo has to now design for multiple situations of play, unlike before. The Switch could be docked, in handheld mode or be perched on a rooftop somewhere during a party, just like it was advertised - which makes the menu wheels a perfect middle ground for all - even if building with Joycons or a Pro Controller are inferior to using a stylus.


2. Unlimited Mario On The Go

Nintendo

Yes, this might be hinted at or included in other entries, but the sheer fact that unlimited 2D Mario levels created by the community are at the fingertips of any Switch owner is mindblowing. For generations now, Mario in some form or another has been the standard-bearer for platforming (even partying) - so handing over the tools to create to the millions influenced by that has given us an ideal mix of perfect platforming and torturous trials.

Nintendo has come across something special here and it can only get better, or be expanded to its other core franchises such as Zelda or even Super Metroid - and we're already seeing a bit of that with the dungeon builder in the Link's Awakening remake.

Already in the first week, there have been countless creations ranging from the insidious to the downright clever and this is only going to continue. People talk about the forever game and it might be here in Super Mario Maker 2.


1. Clear Conditions Change Everything

Nintendo

In time, the creative community of the original Super Mario Maker found ingenious ways to force certain conditions to finish a level. These normally consisted of leading the player down a tightly designed hellscape to obtain a key, only now with no other choice but to venture back to pass a door.

In the second instalment, Nintendo has programmed in a variety of clear conditions to choose from if makers feel like setting specific challenges. Clear a stage without taking any damage, making sure Mario eliminates every last lonely Goomba or even collecting the useless 1UPs can be added for that little extra layer of play.

Proper boss fights can also at long last be placed anywhere in a stage. This just goes that much further to making a stage feel like a level.

There is one horrible clear condition for having Mario never jump which we won’t go into as it breaks some people's Mario brain. Who is Jump Man if in fact, he can’t jump? This might be the greatest question of our time.


Contributor
Contributor

Resident Evil Aficionado. Video Games & Fried Chicken are my passions. Occasionally some Wrestling. I used to work in Film & TV, but now I Write, Edit & Present for this website and its Youtube Channels.