The Elder Scrolls 6: 9 Things It Must Do Better Than Skyrim

Time for a change.

The Elder Scrolls 6
Bethesda

Almost seven long, torturous years have slipped by since the blight of Alduin and his crusade against the Dovahkiin was brought to a halt. The frigid winds billowing across Skyrim have settled, the dragons have had their fun, and arrows have ceased ending the careers of aspiring adventurers.

It's time for a new chapter to begin.

But what's to be expected of the next epic fantasy tale due to unfold in Nirn? Are we to assume iteration - rather than innovation - will be the order of the day, or is The Elder Scrolls VI to be the turning point; a blank slate facilitated by new hardware to replace the ageing Creation Engine?

With any luck, the latter's exactly what's in store. Skyrim was genre-defining for its time, but the world has moved on since 2011. Looking back now, much of its systems look and feel antiquated by comparison to modern-day RPGs. Combat feels sluggish and simplistic, NPCs roll off of a mass produced assembly line and the world, full of dungeons to uncover and winged reptiles to slay, somehow feels ever so empty.

These hangovers from yesteryear must be modernized if ESO VI is to ever truly justify its long gestation period, and we can only hope that Bethesda has spent the better part of a decade making sure Skyrim looks like an ancient relic by comparison.

9. NPCs

Skyrim Dialogue
Bethesda

The meme-spawning NPCs of Nirn's Northernmost province have become the stuff of legend since Skyrim's launch in 2011. From The Reach to Winterhold, there's no mountain you can climb or river you can cross where you won't hear about the nation's love of mead or the epidemic of retired adventurers all forced into taking up guard duty after a nasty career-ending accident.

Comedic, albeit unintentionally so, it may be, that Skyrim's population of generic NPCs exhaust their small pool of dialogue choices within hours of play, but we've had our fun with it. Bethesda needs to step up its game if Skyrim's successor is to avoid the immersion-breaking problem of characters parroting the same voice lines over and over.

Nobody expects every non-unique NPC to have individually-written lines, but there's an easy way to lessen the frequency in which the same stock responses reach the player's ears. By all means, up the quantity of dialogue, but go one further and restrict certain phrases from being uttered depending on geographical location.

That way, you won't have to hear about arrow-stricken knees from one end of the country to the other.


8. User Interface

Skyrim Inventory
Bethesda

Compared with Oblivion's antiquated tab-based menus, Skyrim's is the most user-friendly to have ever graced the genre, but Bethesda still have a ways to go before navigating layered character sheets and inventory lists feels intuitive.

Credit where it's due, the minimalist approach worked well for console players with no option other than to use a gamepad, but for PC players it was a different story. Scrolling through endless lists of uninformative item names with a mouse wheel felt more like spreadsheet management than a quick pit-stop to access any particular item.

Not until modders swooped in to fix Bethesda's mistakes did inventory navigation for keyboard and mouse users feel satisfactory.

But that's besides the point. It shouldn't be left up to fans to remedy these issues. Bethesda built its name on PC: ignoring it in favour of consoles wasn't a wise decision.

Nice visual feedback it may be, to see a 3D-rendered chunk of ore accompany its position in your backpack, but that development time could have been better spent on providing filters and sort functions to cut down on unnecessary busywork.


7. Asset Reuse

Skyrim Draugr
Bethesda

Barring a handful of exceptions - the vast subterranean expanse of Blackreach will forever remain a highlight of Skyrim's spelunking activities - the caves, crypts and ancient Dwemer cities that lie beneath Skyrim's frostbitten surface all too often struggle to distinguish themselves from the last.

Part of the pervading sense of Deja Vu comes down to the reliance - and overuse - of similar enemy types (so. many. Draugrs.), but their presence only serves to accentuate the overarching problem of Skyrim's gratuitous reliance on asset reuse.

For every one-of-a-kind dungeon like Shadowgreen Cavern or Blackcoast Cove, there exist several dusty tombs home to Nordic heroes of old and deserted Dwarven cities.

We'd be fools to expect every last dungeon to be kitted out with unique environmental design, but it's not all about quantity. Bethesda could easily prevent, or at the very least, slow the rate in which the sense of familiarity creeps in by slimming down the number of dungeons available in VI, and dedicating more time to making each feel wholly different to the last.


6. Optimisation

Skyrim Cut Content
Bethesda

As of this year, Bethesda's Creation Engine will be pushing six years of age which, in video game years, is around the time that funeral arrangements should be considered.

A slew of RPGs have come and gone in the years since that have put its ageing tech to shame, and there's really no excuse for Beth's flagship franchise not to include some of the bare necessities expected of the genre.

Loading screen transitions from open world to interior settings is one of the biggies. For the most part, CD Projekt's Witcher 3 was a seamless world from start to finish (and looked prettier to boot), requiring no dreaded black screen whenever a door was made ajar and the same goes for performance.

Unless Bethesda desires to court controversy, ESO VI will roll out as an advertisement for a brand new engine, and assuming that's the case, the bug-infested first few weeks of Fallout 4's launch will hopefully be avoided.


5. Progression & Customisation

Skyrim Smithing
Bethesda

For a series that sells itself on allowing players to forge their own path through the world in whatever fashion they see fit, Skyrim never quite manages to provide the tools to facilitate that. Once your physical appearance has been decided and you've escaped the chopping block in Helgen, what is there to differentiate your Dovahkiin from the millions of others roaming the land?

Short answer? Nothing.

For all the attention it attracted prior to launch for doing away with the restrictive progression systems of past ESO games, Skyrim's literal star-studded progression system felt frivolous and aimless. With no level cap or branching paths, every Dovahkiin would ultimately end up the same.

Smithing and enchanting, touted as the ultimate way to make your Dragonborn stand apart from the rest, ended up offering nothing but static armour sets and abilities with no room for individuality. In essence, everything was diluted.

No one change will turn the ship around, but bringing back Oblivion's spell crafting system, as well as allowing players to further customize their gear with recolours and a Transmog system à la World of Warcraft would be a good start.


4. Stealth

Skyrim Stealth
Bethesda Softworks

Do it right, or not at all.

Skyrim, and in fact, every Elder Scrolls title, has had trouble balancing the appeal of sneaky play with the brutish alternative - there's just not enough variance in AI behaviour and level design to make indirect combat enjoyable. If spotted, the enemy will charge you in a blind rage until either you're dead of they are, leaving no room for counterplay or emergent gameplay.

Not helping matters is Bethesda's apparent reluctance to reward stealthy play. Besides a damage boost from striking while unseen, the engagement tactic provides no special equipment, requires patience, more time and slower progression and for what?

A slow-mo kill-cam once in a blue moon? No thanks.

Why not integrate the playstyle into dungeons with shortcuts and secret passages that can only be accessed by lovers of subterfuge? Just please don't force us to crouch walk down corridors for the duration of a quest as if we've just soiled ourselves.


3. Companions

Skyrim Aela
Bethesda

Pack Mules. That's what Skyrim's companions amount to. Vanilla, underdeveloped NPCs that serve no purpose besides hauling your unwanted crap halfway across the country just to sell it. No character development, unique abilities or interesting side stories to tell, just an expressionless face that more often than not would go missing out in the world, waiting for their master to come and retrieve them from inside after no-clipping into a wall.

Granted, Bethesda seems to have somewhat learned its lesson since 2011 - Fallout 4 featured a memorable cast of compatriots with believable motives for tagging along - but there's still room for improvement. Why not take a leaf out of BioWare's book and give each available comrade their own unique skill set to promote or compliment a specific playstyle?

Do that, as well as fix the ropey AI, and there may actually be a purpose to hiring additional muscle besides a means to circumvent the encumbrance mechanic.


2. The Challenge

Skyrim Draugr
Bethesda

Difficulty is subjective, but in games like Skyrim, the difference between victory and defeat largely comes down not to individual skill or careful planning, but how many restorative items you're carrying on your person. Dragons, giants, Stormcloaks, Draugrs: it never really matters what size or shape your foe is. Keep hitting them until they die, chugging health potions whenever necessary, is usually the only prerequisite for winning any conflict.

The alternative? Well, replacing arbitrary difficulty (bloated health pools, ramped up damage), with a more natural-feeling difficulty curve wouldn't be a bad place to start.

Bethesda doesn't need to shoot for Dark Souls levels of tough, but there's more enjoyment to be gained from soundly defeating a Daedric minion utilizing grey matter and strategy as opposed to chipping away at a huge health bar for minutes at a time.

When all's said and done, though, there's only so much it can do up the challenge without overhauling combat...


1. Combat

Skyrim Combat
Bethesda Softworks

Bethesda's had seven years to mull over its options on how to make combat more engaging, and we have every faith that it'll see the necessity to reinvent the formula on a more drastic scale than adding ear-splitting Shouts with superfluous effects.

Could it opt to go the route of Ubisoft's For Honor and make every clash of cold steel a back and forth of parries, ripostes and combo-based button presses? Absolutely, though such a demanding system could turn off longtime fans.

The other alternative is one that's been staring Bethesda in the face since 2014. Elder Scrolls Online supplements the series' simple swordplay with a smorgasbord of different abilities depending on class choice that evolve to take on different properties.

Grafting that frame onto ESO VI and housing it in a new engine wouldn't just inject some much-needed strategy into the mix, but remedy a handful of other issues laid bare up to this point. Perfect.


Contributor
Contributor

Joe is a freelance games journalist who, while not spending every waking minute selling himself to websites around the world, spends his free time writing. Most of it makes no sense, but when it does, he treats each article as if it were his Magnum Opus - with varying results.