The Evolution Of The JRPG
One of gaming's all-time greats, but how did we get here?
The release and critical acclaim around Final Fantasy VII's launch, way back in 1997, is often credited as the rise of the "Japanese role-playing game" in the West, and with good reason. It was a smash hit, as well as serving as a technical showcase for what Sony's first PlayStation could do at the time.
Before then, there was no massive "East vs. West" debate that we have grown used to now. Role-playing games in the States were usually confined to the home computer, with Ultima and Might & Magic leading the way, whilst companies like Sierra went for the more story-focused, point-and-click style of high fantasy with King's Quest.
The genre proved popular over platforming and shooters for favouring epic storytelling, and giving players more variety in customising how they saw their player character develop. Dungeons & Dungeons, the popular tabletop game, and Lord of the Rings proved popular source material to port or plagiarise, leading to eventual acclaim in series' like Warcraft, Elder Scrolls and Diablo in the early nineties.
Overseas however, fantasy games were following a different track.
Geared towards turn-based battles over point-and-click, overblown uses of magic and world-destroying stories on par with Eastern anime fables (which was also breaking into cinema with classics like Akira), large bosses and even larger hair styles, the JRPG became a massive staple in the gaming world. The major advantage that JRPG's brought were the accessibility of being on home consoles, like NES and Master System(s) over the PC, which on the surface may look simplified, but many were about to be surprised.
It may have been Square Enix's Final Fantasy VII that led the charge overseas in the mid-to-late nineties, but that doesn't mean it was slouching before that. Many a favoured franchise today, whether it be Enix's long-running Dragon Quest, or something more recent like Persona, all started as far back as the late 80's.
So what is it that made this particular sub-genre of epic fantasies, journeys across space and time or just more romanticised takes on Eastern myths so popular in their heyday, and more importantly, where are most of them now?
Let's have a retrospective look...
Breathing Fire Into the Genres
The Eastern-styled role-playing game had been treading ground on home consoles since the 80's, yet it took venturing new IP's out into the overseas market that the termed "JRPG" started to gain traction. The first wave to break new ground and expectations in Japan weren't Final Fantasy games, as many think, but a little title named Dragon Quest.
Bolstered by an art collaboration with Dragon Ball creator Akira Toriyama, this was cited as a game-changer for how narrative and storytelling could be delivered on console. The success of the series saw the rise of many others in its wake, including Square's first [and thankfully not last] Final Fantasy, as well as Sega's Phantasy Star series.
Whilst the first two may have walked familiar story beats with creatures based on myth and folklore commonly associated with dragons and dungeons, Sega went with a space-faring, galaxy-spanning adventure instead. Rather than being seen as fierce competition, this mix of options available saw a steady progression of all three series break into the nineties.
This steady wave allowed new publishers to break into the scene, such as Capcom with the first Breath of Fire in 1993 and Atlus with Shin Megami Tensei a year prior. If the latter sounds familiar to some, it's because the massively popular Persona series is an off-shoot of SMT.
Whilst Sega were still going strong with their efforts, the Super Nintendo was the popular choice for both continuations and new series to take root.
Taking It To The Next Dimension
The early 90s saw a steady period of success for the JRPG, but by the midpoint of the century, developers were looking to expand on their vision. Hybrid action/RPG's like Secret of Mana, Chrono Trigger and Terranigma were pushing the SNES to its limit, and it was time for something new.
That something arrived in the Sony PlayStation... and to a lesser extent, the Sega Saturn. Whilst the latter was home to a few decent ports, like the Lunar series and Grandia, it was Sony's first foray into consoles that saw the JRPG take massive leaps into what the bigger advancement in technology could do.
Whilst some developers were still playing it safe with 2D, sprite-based RPG's (with just a dab of 3D) like Capcom with Breath of Fire and Konami's oft-revered Suikoden series, others were pursuing this new dimension with absolute gusto. Game Arts and Ubisoft ported their 2D/3D hybrid Grandia over for larger success, but there just that little something that was missing for the genre to explode.
With the new technology saw more scope from developers to tell their stories, as the standard fantasy tropes were beginning to evolve into something much, much more. Suikoden was based on a Chinese fable about warring states, whilst Sony's own Wild Arms looked to the Wild West for its story inspiration. Developers were looking to branch out, both in story and scope, and this was the format to do it on.
All it needed was one killer title to lift the lid on this style of turn-based, story-focused gaming...
Squaring Up To The Competition
Squaresoft, now the Square Enix we know, had already been dominating the market with their Final Fantasy series. Not only that, the aforementioned Mana titles and Chrono Trigger had proven that they had the chops for this particular style of gaming and its hybrid offshoots. But what else could they do? Where else is there to go when you're sat comfortably at the top of an equally comfortable genre?
Well, if you've got the inclination for it, you gamble. You put all your eggs into one basket, push all your efforts into that "just one more" title and you hope and pray it hits the spot for gamers and critics alike.
That title was Final Fantasy VII.
It may sound hyperbolic to say that it took the world by storm, but you only have to look at any list or ranking system to see it riding high. To this day you only need to look at the numbers, the companion pieces and the eventual remake (of gawd knows how many parts) some twenty three years later, to realise the impact this game had.
If JRPG's were the dammed water, idly building up behind the proverbial barrier, then FFVII was the game that broke that wall. The flood that followed was insane, and the genre reached loftier heights that all previous console generations combined.
Squaresoft continued with a few more numbered Final Fantasies (including the best one, FFVIII), as well as a sequel to the much beloved Chrono Trigger in Chrono Cross. Before that saw the massively ambitious, anime-inspired Xenogears, which took on such a complex range of themes and issues it'd need a retrospective in itself.
Yet it wasn't just the presentation side of the genre that got a shake up, as developers saw new ways to expand on the now-familiar turn-based battle systems we'd started to get bored of. Hybrid action/adventure games like Vagrant Story and Parasite Eve (again Squaresoft titles) saw variants of JRPG systems put to work in their respective games, to great success.
It'd be fair to say that Squaresoft dominated the market, but it wasn't just them. Konami continued with its Suikoden series, with its second entry in 1998 heralded as one of the best RPG's ever, whilst Enix brought over its beloved Star Ocean series to the PlayStation.
Considered the Golden Age of the genre, the PlayStation played host to many a series both new and established. The use of full-motion video for cutscenes, the capacity to spread epic stories over more discs and push graphical power to its limit had people wondering what could possibly be next in line for the JRPG.
How Much Higher Could The Rising Sun Go?
At the turn of the century, it'd be fair to say that both Sony and the JRPG were riding high. The former with its substantial catalogue on its first console, as well as making ground with the PS2, and the latter with what it could bring on the next evolution of console.
It wasn't just Sony though, as Sega's next foray, the Dreamcast, saw some killer titles in Skies of Arcadia and a timed exclusive sequel to Grandia. But Sega, for all their faults, wanted to go a different direction.
Remember Phantasy Star, mentioned earlier? Well, whilst the early days of the series may not be familiar to you, you may have heard of Phantasy Star Online. This Dreamcast title and its sequel are considered the first proper JRPG's, and with good reason. Again, like the genre that bore them, it took the focus away from the Westernised, PC-centric nature of online gaming and brought that luxury to the home console. The Dreamcast may not have had the longevity, but it certainly had the innovation. Oh, and Shenmue, I suppose.
But the market for the format was definitely in PlayStation's favour. The Eastern audience wasn't very receptive to Microsoft's flagship console, the Xbox, and as such it stuck to more Western RPG's. It did have some corkers that borrowed elements of JRPG's, such as Bioware's Jade Empire, as well as ports of the aforementioned Phantasy Star Online's. All eyes were on Sony to deliver.
To which they did, to an extent. We saw the tenth iteration of the [by this point] ironically named Final Fantasy's land in 2001 to rave reviews, as well as continuations from the Dragon Quest, Suikoden and Star Ocean stables. The Shin Megami Tensei spinoff Persona was also gaining traction, with its third installment releasing to critical success alongside its forebear.
Yet by the early 2000's, turn-based combat was becoming stale. Whilst games like Vagrant Story and Parasite Eve were smash hits on the previous PlayStation, the notion of any kind of sequel quietly dropped off into obscurity and rumour.
Long-running Capcom series Breath of Fire effectively killed itself with fifth title, Dragon Quarter, by being too divergent from the norm, whereas hybrid adventure/RPG series Dark Cloud came and went with two titles.
People wanted innovation, but they also fear a dramatic change.
Something needed to happen - something as obscure and random as a chance meeting in an elevator...
Capturing The Kingdom With Hearts
Following a discussion with Final Fantasy's Sakaguchi and Square's Shinji Hashimoto about creating a new type of 3D adventure, the latter just happened to share an elevator ride with a Disney executive one morning. Alright, maybe not that coincidental as both companies shared the same building, but it was still a pivotal meeting nonetheless.
The concept of the wealthiest animation studio and the biggest publisher of JRPG's combining forces seemed like an odd choice at the time, but it soon became one of those "so crazy it just might work" notions that did indeed pay off for both.
Pairing Disney's most recognisable characters and worlds with that of Squaresoft's skills in the hybrid and traditional RPG market paid off for both companies, as Kingdom Hearts has gone on to be a multi-million dollar series. The story may have gone a bit convoluted, but the simplified action/adventure hybrid with some RPG elements made it accessible for newcomers to get into this kind of game.
Which, unfortunately, also began to mark the decline of the genre, as we stepped into the next generation of consoles - namely Sony's PlayStation 3 and Microsoft's Xbox 360.
That's not say, "Kingdom Hearts killed JRPG's for the hardcore", but for many it was the writing on the wall they'd been ignoring to that point.
When A "Golden Age" Becomes A Time Capsule
Ask anybody to name you ten JRPG's for the PlayStation 1 & 2, and it'll be easy enough. Yet ask that of the PS3 and Xbox 360 combined and I guarantee you'll get a few blank faces.
That's not to say there weren't any, but in the wake of the "interactive movie" and cover-based shooting boom these consoles brought, JRPG's suffered the brunt.
That's not to say there weren't any, but bar a few traditionalists like Persona and the Tales Of... series, many had switched to a faster paced, almost action style of gaming. The Xbox tried to recapture the old spirit with Lost Odyssey, helmed by none other than Mr. Final Fantasy himself, Hironobu Sakaguchi, which despite rave reviews failed to launch any sequels or Xbox's in the East.
Studio Ghibli, the animation behind such classics as Spirited Away and Princess Mononoke (to name a few of many) teamed up with Level 5 to create the wonderful Ni No Kuni games. Whilst the first game proved a hit for the PS3, there were again a more accessible level of JRPG for those that favoured story over the older mechanics.
Whilst it would be unfair to say by this point the more traditional JRPG had died out, by the time the PS4 and Xbox One came on to the scene in the noughties, you'd be hard pushed to find anything reminiscent of the glory days. All signs were pointing to a decline in what we had come to expect from the Eastern style of RPG.
Indeed now, if you were to search for "PS4 JRPG's", you get the likes of Bloodborne and Nier: Automata in your results. The evolution was clear: gaming-centric notions of what we considered a JRPG some twenty years or so ago have amalgamated into the faster, action-paced titles we know today. Even comparing Final Fantasy XV to any of its PS1 predecessors shows a marked change in how they're played.
Some elements remain, but barring the consistent efforts of Persona and Dragon Quest, tastes have considerably changed.
Diverged But Not Forgotten
However, whilst majority interests may have evolved over time, the genre isn't gone. Nor is it dormant, as evidenced by the earlier mentioned FFVII Remake, not to mention Suikoden spiritual successor Eiyuden Chronicle amassing a whopping $4.5 million Kickstarter amount (from an original target of $500k).
This kind of dedication proves the lasting impact that the JRPG has had on people over the years.
We do see remasters and ports, as well as spiritual successors and tributes pop up along the way, too. Grandia saw a port of its first two games make it to the Nintendo Switch, whilst 3DS newcomer Bravely Default is seeing one too. Octopath Traveler, also on Switch, harks back to a familiar time of classic JRPG games from the last century.
Indeed the format isn't dead. It may never reach the highs that it held, but that it's evolved into what it is today without burying those that lay the path for it is a testament to the titles the genre brought with it.