The Game Awards 2018 Nominations: 4 Ups & 6 Downs

Spider-Man for Game of the Year? Really?

The Game Awards Spider Man God Of War
The Game Awards, Insomniac & Sony

The nominations for The Game Awards 2018 dropped on Tuesday evening, eliciting a wildly mixed response from fans as is always the case with entertainment awards shows.

The show's committed brainchild Geoff Keighley is clearly trying to legitimise the ceremony as "the Oscars of gaming", and while The Game Awards are still pretty far off from earning that moniker, it is at least daring to take itself seriously and somewhat succeeding.

There are definitely issues with this year's slate of nominees, though, from the obvious pandering to overpraised AAA offerings to the usual genre biases once again showing themselves. Not to mention the nagging feeling it's still a little too steeped in branding and advertising to be a truly legit awards show.

But the nominations also foregrounded a number of smaller indie titles and even saw a certain "ongoing" game snag a surprise nomination more than two years after its initial release.

We'll naturally all have our complaints to make once again when the awards have been dished out on December 6, but until then, here's what the jury got right and wrong...


Downs...

6. Forza Horizon 4 Snubbed For Game Of The Year

Forza Horizon 4
Turn 10

Despite being one of the year's best-reviewed games, the brilliant Forza Horizon 4 was inexplicably snubbed for a Game of the Year nomination, ultimately landing just a paltry two nods for Best Sports/Racing Game and Best Audio Design.

This mostly speaks to the tradition of critics and awards shows demonstrating an odd bias against racing games, presumably due to it being a "niche" genre and far less popular than typical action-centric AAA titles.

Even so, it's a major failing of The Game Awards and its pool of jurors that they ignored arguably the best racing game of the generation and one that scored stronger reviews than half of the actual Game of the Year nominees. For shame.


5. Too Many Nominations For Assassin's Creed & Spider-Man

Spider-Man PS4 Night Time
Insomniac

This might be an unpopular pair of opinions, but did Assassin's Creed Odyssey and Spider-Man really deserve so much love here?

They're both solid games, no question, but with Odyssey basically playing the series' hits and Spider-Man forcing players through some horrible stealth sections, to say nothing of its fairly formulaic open world, can either really be considered Game of the Year-worthy?

Spider-Man ended up landing seven nominations in total, and though most of its technical nods are pretty tough to argue with, the game just doesn't feel quite well-crafted enough to be standing next to God of War and Red Dead Redemption 2.

Voters were a little more restrained with Odyssey, giving it just three nominations in all, but again, why is a fairly by-the-numbers if well-executed open-world game talked about in the same breath as some of the most innovative and creative titles of the current generation?


4. Ni No Kuni II Nominated For Best RPG

Ni No Kuni 2
Level-5

The Best RPG category unsurprisingly saw the brilliant likes of Octopath Traveller and the ultra-popular Monster Hunter: World nominated and become instant front-runners, but one of the more baffling nods went to Ni No Kuni II: Revenant Kingdom.

Though the game was initially well-received by critics, the fan response was decidedly more vitriolic, rightly criticising its disappointingly cheap presentation, lack of difficulty and frustrating number of brick walls impeding progress.

A mere shadow of its incredible predecessor, one can only assume that the sequel is simply filler to pad out the category. Its other nomination for Best Score/Music makes sense enough, but Best RPG? Really?


3. The Emphasis On eSports

Fortnite Battle Royale
Epic Games

Of the show's 30 competitive categories, an entire seven are devoted solely to eSports, which seems a tad excessive, if not outright suspicious.

Obviously there's a ton of money in eSports and the scene's never been more lucrative, but even so, does The Game Awards really need "Best eSports Coach" and "Best eSports Host" awards?

It feels like blatant pandering to a section of the industry which can obviously bring a lot of advertising revenue to the show, and to that end it works against Keighley's attempts to make The Game Awards a "serious" awards event akin to the Oscars or the Emmys.

It's precisely for this reason that, despite Keighley's obvious efforts, the show still feels more like an advertising opportunity than a genuine showcase for the best games of the year.


2. A Way Out Nominated For Best Direction

A Way Out
EA

Co-op action-adventure game A Way Out received a single nomination in the Best Game Direction category, and while it's a decent enough game, was it really well-crafted enough to sit alongside the likes of God of War and Red Dead Redemption 2 in particular?

Yes, the co-op, split-screen cinematic gameplay is a neat gimmick, but the game's also jam-packed with jank and repetition, and the narrative too often becomes a corny mess of cliches rather than the poignant thriller-drama director Josef Fares was aiming for.

Its ambition should absolutely be lauded, especially on a clearly modest budget, but compared to Fares' previous hit Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons, A Way Out felt decidedly sloppier and less-assured.


1. The Separate "Action" & "Action/Adventure" Categories

Call Of Duty Black Ops 4 Blackout
Activision

One of the weirdest layout decisions for The Game Awards is the choice to offer up two separate categories for "Action" and "Action/Adventure" games.

Under the action umbrella, the nominees were Call of Duty: Black Ops 4, Dead Cells, Destiny 2: Forsaken, Far Cry 5 and Mega Man 11, while action-adventure saw Assassin's Creed Odyssey, God of War, Spider-Man, Red Dead Redemption 2 and Shadow of the Tomb Raider nominated.

Is there really enough between these games to separate them into two different buckets? Why not just make a 10-game field under a unified action/adventure banner and be done with it?

Instead this simply adds another category to an already bloated line-up, in a show where sports and racing games are lazily lumped together no less.

So, The Game Awards still has some work to do, but it certainly wasn't all bad either. Here are the best takeaways from the nominations announcement...


Ups...

4. No Man's Sky's Incredible Comeback

No Man S Sky
Hello Games

Back when No Man's Sky launched in the summer of 2016, few could've anticipated how the game would grow and flourish following its initial, justifiably angry fan response.

Taken out of the oven too soon and released in relatively piecemeal form, the sci-fi exploration game has been lavished with consistent updates over the last two years, and in late 2018 actually feels like a complete, well-rounded title.

To that end, it received a Best Ongoing Game nomination, sitting alongside Destiny 2, Fortnite, Overwatch and Rainbow Six Siege.

While some might argue that those initial questionable business practises shouldn't be rewarded like this, or that Splatoon 2 was more deserving of the nomination, it's nevertheless impressive how drastically the game has changed since launch.

Furthermore, it's proof that with a high level of dedication, developers can overcome a bad start to make even troubled games genuinely great.


3. Celeste Nominated For Game Of The Year

Celeste game
Matt Makes Games

The big surprise Game of the Year nominee this year was without question hit indie platformer Celeste. While it's currently the second-best-reviewed game of 2018 - sitting just behind Red Dead Redemption 2 and tied with God of War - it's not typically the sort of title that lands in the GOTY conversation.

It would've been so easy for Celeste to be snubbed and leave its legion of dedicated fans fuming, but despite its niche appeal, the game's thoughtful premise and ludicrously, infuriatingly addictive gameplay resonated with even more casual jurors.

It hasn't got a hope in hell of winning, of course, but this is most certainly a case where the nomination itself is basically the win.


2. Astro Bot Rescue Mission Feels The Love

Astro Bot Rescue Mission
SIE Studio Japan

The Best VR/AR Game category was filled with quality titles such as Beat Saber, Moss, Tetris Effect and Firewall Zero Hour, and it was a relief to see Astro Bot Robot Rescue also make the cut.

The ingenious PSVR platformer is the headset's best-reviewed game to date and with damn good reason, though given its recent release, there was worry that it might get lost in the shuffle. With it and the just-released Tetris Effect both landing nods, though, the medium's very best efforts this year have certainly been well-represented.

With its cute visuals and shockingly clever platforming mechanics, Astro Bot might be 2018's most pleasant gaming surprise, to the extent that it would've been a worthy nominee for Game of the Year. Still, it's likely going to steamroll the VR category, and rightly so.


1. The Stacked Best Performance Category

Detroit Connor
Sony

Though most of the categories are pretty hit-and-miss in terms of nominees, the one slate that feels totally on-the-money is the Best Performance field, which saw Bryan Dechart (Detroit: Become Human), Christopher Judge (God of War), Melissanthi Mahut (Assassin's Creed Odyssey), Roger Clark (Red Dead Redemption 2) and Yuri Lowenthal (Spider-Man) nominated.

Each of the actors gave splendid performances which made the likes of Connor, Kratos and Peter Parker feel like living, breathing characters within their respective worlds.

With video game visual fidelity approaching a scarily lifelike level of verisimilitude in recent years, the standards are higher than ever for performances which can match those of the big screen, but the work of these five actors proved that gaming at its best is easily capable of matching film and TV.

Any of the five would be worthy winners, honestly, and it's tough to pick one standout among them.

What do you make of this year's The Game Awards nominations? Shout it out in the comments!


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.