Tomb Raider: Ranking Every Game Worst To Best
Separating the best adventures from the misadventures.
Even though gaming was a predominantly male-focused practice in the beginning, there were a few openings for the females to live out their wildest fantasies through an on-screen avatar.
The first of these came in 1986 when Metroid's finale - to the shock and awe of millions - revealed that you were playing as a woman all along, in one of gamings most historical moments. This was but a precursor to the greatest female protagonist to embellish the title of video game legend; Lara Croft.
When she exploded onto the scene in the 1990s, the Tomb Raider license was issued to more institutions than Microsoft computers. Lara Croft hadn't only cemented her name into the annals of the pop culture history, she reimagined just how the public viewed females in fictional media at the time.
Lara wasn't your atypical, weak, damsel in distress. She was a capable fighter, a marksman with a vast array of weaponry and a badass heroine that blazed a trail, challenging those after to dethrone her as the pinnacle of not only female leaders, but one of gamings most elegant behemoths.
It's safe to say that with her popularity immediately taking off, the lass has more than a few adventures under her belt. Which one was the worst and which one was better than the rest?
19. Lara Croft Relic Run
Beginning the list with the oh-so dreaded run and gun shooter for mobile phones should be expected. However, the sheer laziness and lack of inspiration that this title imbues is just so abhorrently uninteresting that it was nearly left off entirely. It's another one of the endless clones that copies the Temple Run formula, sticking a familiar pop-culture icon in place of any other blank slate that can be interchanged at a whim.
There isn't much else to say other than that, if you've played Temple Run then you've essentially already played Relic Run. There are a few things that the developers do to make it feel more attuned to an actual Tomb Raider experience, but even then it's not enough to breathe new life in a dead genre.
Understandably, there are people out there who will engage with this based on the intellectual property alone, and if that's your cocaine, then fill your nostrils. However, don't be blindsided by the sinister method of easy revenue generation that is the micro-transactions. As this is practically the only reason for this game's existence, which makes it a blemish on the franchise rather than a premise with potential.
18. Lara Croft Go
Mobile phone games aren't always going to be exempt from these lists, and in reality, they never should be - especially when they find an unprecedented market on home consoles. Well, unless their only reason for existing is to cut a hole in your wallet and gradually drain all the funds through micro-transactions. Tomb Raider Go, on the contrary, is a title that shows its player base respect and its IP a level of understanding you rarely see with these titles.
Understandably, with its limited nature, it's never going to compare to the vaster, more fleshed out instalments from any generation of the legendary adventurer, but it certainly takes a swinging stab at it.
The game's beautifully designed environments, puzzle-based exploration and simple, yet immersive, mechanics are everything you expect to see in one of miss Croft's adventures. The basis of a stellar Tomb Raider adventure is unquestionably there, but, as mentioned earlier, in a canon that contains some of gaming's all-time best titles, this one was always going to slip through the cracks.
It's worth checking out if you're a hardcore fan, but other than that, it would be more fruitful to spend your leisurely time playing a more superlative iteration.
17. Tomb Raider: The Prophecy
Although it was designed for - and runs on - better hardware, The Prophecy isn't as prophetic as the name implies. It's an undeniably lacklustre experience compared to its earlier GBC counterpart, which unquestionably blows it out of the water and, realistically, that shouldn't be the case.
The sheer ambition of the title is exactly what presents the first hurdle, as the developers opted for a top-down perspective akin to Hotline Miami this time around, but unlike Hotline Miami, the games dynamics and mechanics aren't exactly in harmony with the camera angle.
The largest issue encountered by this option though is that, with all the environments looking not even partially different from one another, the game becomes exponentially frustrating to play. A lot of what makes the other entries so beloved to so many also feels like it's been predominantly stripped away, or watered down at the very least.
The exploration is rather limited; the puzzles are too vacuous to challenge even the most unintelligible of the human race and with such a short length, the experience just feels like an incredibly pointless one that most players won't gain anyone from. It's also one that you'll definitely lose nothing from if you decide to skip past it.
It's a commendable effort at best, but effort doesn't equate to exceptionalism.
16. Tomb Raider: Curse of The Sword
The first glaring issue you'll notice when booting up this title is the abhorrent lack of music which gives the game a sort of hollow feeling which is an immediate putoff, but if that doesn't bother you as much as it probably should, then staring at a version of Lara Croft reminiscent of the Fusilli Jerry from Seinfeld might make you put the handheld down instead.
Just to correct the earlier sentence, the music isn't completely sparse, it does appear during the "cutscenes", but you'd wish it didn't once your ears begin to bleed.
Although the developers deserve some credit for genuinely attempting to make a good game with hardware that simply wasn't prepared for a full-length - or even short-length - Tomb Raider experience, the gameplay is just as unremorsefully bad.
Most of the game consists of running from one side to the next, hitting a switch or shooting some sort of endangered life-form and then rinsing and repeating until the game ends. Unlike the game which just kind of exists, the challenge itself is entirely vacant for the most part, only really coming in with the final boss, but by then most players have already checked out and are already checking out one of a million better titles out there.
15. Lara Croft and The Guardian of Light
Lara Croft and the Guardian of Light is admittedly a fairly solid title, but the primary problem is in regards to the expectations that come with a franchise like Tomb Raider, the standards are set ridiculously high. Which makes it more of a shame that this wasn't an unrelated, stand-alone title with a fresh IP. It's plausible that it could've spawned a franchise of its own.
While it technically spawned a spinoff franchise, which we will get to later, it didn't pick up much momentum or even garner much attention. Likely due to the inclusion of its protagonist in a top-down perspective adventure, which isn't what many people have come to expect from the franchise.
So, with an already big nail hammered firmly into the coffin, it wasn't surprising to see the game garner a lack of commercial interest. However, it shouldn't be understated just how appraising the critic reviews was for this title. Most were far from scathing, and some were had even rated the title higher than mainline entries in the series that are still considered bonafide classics.
Its lack of mass appeal was always going to doom it to a less obscure place than anything with higher production values and a more monumental etching in the franchise's echelons.
14. Tomb Raider (GBC)
Have you ever played a 2D platformer on a quite limited, mechanically archaic handheld device before? If you answered yes, then you've played the GBC port of Tomb Raider and you may not even realise it. Don't allow that to take anything away from the overall end product. However, as a transitional iteration from 3D to 2D, with very limited hardware, the game itself is rather impressive.
It's unfortunately just not going to hold a candle to nearly any of the other stellar titles in the series.
Let's weigh up the pros against the cons.
Pros: Until portable gaming became revolutionised with the introduction of both the Nintendo DS and the Sony PSP - both of which gave a new lease of life and innovation to what was becoming a subpar substitute as opposed to console gaming - it was immaculate for the time of its release. The gameplay was as fluid as most "realistic" games on any of the 2D handhelds and the developers did an incredibly commendable job with the limitations. Not to mention that it remains the best of the handhelds from this era.
Cons: It's borderline unplayable in this day and age. Which, in itself, renders it an obscurely obsolete piece of media that is doomed to fall into the realms of inconspicuous of platformers from days gone, with no little to no one remembering it.
Until reading this, did you even recall that this title existed?
13. Tomb Raider Chronicles
The last real breath in the legendary run for the series at its zeitgeist peak, Chronicles was best surmised by developer Andy Sandham, who worked on the game as: "effectively a load of old sh*t.
That was the most depressing one for us. We were effectively just doing that for a paycheck because no other team wanted to take it on. So we had to do it, basically. By that time, it had taken its toll. Three years of hammering it, and we were burnt out. That shows in the product".
The dreaded franchise fatigue had begun to set in and it was evident in the final game, especially when considering that the last title had just killed her off. Not only did this confuse the people that ventured through The Last Revelation, but it marked an imminent departure from form in the series, arbitrarily extinguishing the fire that distinguished the Tomb Raider franchise from the more lukewarm efforts of the era.
As most people know, once the story has been told in its entirety, anything extraneous that comes after needs to either reinvent the wheel, or will be doomed to become this.
12. Tomb Raider Angel of Darkness
The Angel of Darkness? More like the angel of death if the collective reception was anything to go off.
Back in her day, there was a fleeting moment in time where Lara Croft was an unparalleled icon, but as they say, all good things must come to an end, just not that they all end in as much of an unceremoniously painful death as this one. When the Playstation 2 released, there was abstained belief that a new Tomb Raider would be coming to the market alongside, and low and behold, they were correct.
Instead of the classic formula of raiding tombs to solve intricate puzzles in a manner that made you feel like inspector Morse after solving a case and necking a big fat pint, eradicating nuisances in both primal and human form and using almost aerodynamic athletic abilities to traverse the world like an 80s action star. You were now failing to reach platforms, glitching all the way to your death and regretting your decision to purchase this poorly, not well-thought out shame of a sequel.
The removal of around half of what made these things good in the first place were prevalently vacant in this underdeveloped chore of a game to complete, with the tombs being substituted entirely for an uninspired iteration of a Parisian cityscape, when tied with the unresponsive controls and glitch-infested minutiae of bug testing the thing makes for an ill-tasting recipe you should never care to try.
11. Lara Croft and the Temple of Osiris
Following on from the communally divisive, yet critically acclaimed Guardian of Light that preceded it, The Temple of Osiris was predominantly an excessive copy and paste job of the former. Which, admittedly, isn't a hard act to follow, but it's an act that should've seen the curtains pulled over it subsequent to its first act culminating.
The primary issue presented with a game like Temple of Osiris is the equivalent of trying to catch lightning in a bottle twice, but without the initial weather phenomenon even attempting to strike, let alone being successful enough to warrant a sequel.
It employs the same top-down perspective as its original counterpart, imbuing the same isometric-standard gameplay associated with the genre and throwing some simplified, yet crucial, puzzles in there for good measure.
While it is technically a more polished, aesthetically pleasing adaptation of the groundwork laid before it, it's essentially just more of the same, with little to no changes other than the scope of the maps and the inclusion of a co-op mode which gives instant replay value to something with little to offer in that department, it's more a rehash, than a reimagining.
10. Tomb Raider Underworld
Underworld can be viewed as the last real entry into the original Tomb Raider canon, as the game marked a time of transition for gaming's most beloved heroine - becoming multi-platform and intergenerational - it's a game that feels like it should belong in her Golden age, but instead it's a middle child that's mostly forgotten about.
The gameplay doesn't do anything exactly new, it's absolutely fine and inoffensive for what it is, but that may in essence be Underworld's biggest problem. The fact that there's no real talking points really skewed the outcome of the critical and commercial reception of this title and, more than anything, it seems like people were just becoming flat out bored by her seemingly exploitative exploits.
As mentioned before, the classic gameplay of everything that made fans fall in love with her in the first place is present and accounted for. There's a continuation of the story from the prior entry (Legend), and despite being a little more linear in parts, the game still gives you a healthy amount of exploration. It's technically fine, but ultimately too innocuous to make an impression.
It's digestible, but its ultimately the sort of experience you'd get with the recent movie of the same franchise. You're not encapsulated, you just kind of go through the motions, and once it's all over, your mind immediately relinquishes the memory of it.
It's clear that a reboot was imminent for the stagnating franchise at this point.
9. Tomb Raider
Although the original is always better than the copy, and in most cases the sequel(s), Tomb Raider's influential industry-changing first iteration of everybody's favourite female archaeologist still is. It's understandably seen a deterioration in terms of graphical fidelity, but nostalgia alone pushes Lara Croft's debut into a respectable ninth slot.
It wasn't solely genre-defining, as much as it was a complete game changed altogether. Suddenly, and despite the groundwork already being laid in the 1980s with Metroid's unexpected reveal in the progenitor Samus - females in gaming were being taken genuinely serious as protagonists, as opposed to being male gaze eye candy.
Not that there weren't a myriad of not so dry dreams being incurred by her appearance - pointy boobs and all - but her appearance as an unofficial mascot for Sony was paired with her affinity for taking down anyone that stood in her way.
Lara Croft in her initial appearance was slick, sexy, resourceful, intelligent and fundamentally cool. She wasn't a damsel in distress that allowed the men around her to supersede her, she was a stone cold badass that wasn't roped into her expeditions she did it for pure fun, and that is why this iteration of the character will always be endeared. Even if her oirignal outing hasn't aged as well as some of her later adventures.
8. Tomb Raider Anniversary
Before the industry began seriously capitalising on the lucrative practice of remaking classic games in too superfluous a manner, one of the earliest incarnations of this method - and potentially still one of the best - happens to be the 2007 remake of the game that birthed a legend.
Other than the obvious overhaul of graphical upgrades, which were designed specifically for the emerging technology of the time, the remake gave gaming's most revered femme fatale a new lease on life. The newly implemented controls of the former title (Legend) have been fine-tuned and fluidly accentuated to modernise a classic for a new generation.
Everything that made the initial experience such a memorable one is present and accounted for too! The levels are the same, the games structure and puzzles are still featured and Lara herself still feels just as fresh to the medium as she did in her heyday.
It's clear that Eidos has a lot of passion for making games starring their biggest cash cow, and unlike so many others that utilised the remake route further down the line, it's clear they weren't simply milking it for more than it was worth.
7. Shadow of The Tomb Raider
Probably the most unabashedly ironic name in the entire series, Shadow of The Tomb Raider is an absolute shadow of the two games that preceded it. Just as the sequence was commended for looking like it could replicate the original run in quality, even if not popularity, the final hurdle was just too high, with the resulting fall diminishing the returns for the trilogy.
Despite being easily the most beautifully designed game in the entire franchise, and maybe one of the best looking in the video game industry up until that point, the focus of style over substance is the pitfall that this tertiary unfortunately falls into.
Bringing back the jaguar in a lot of promotional material seemed like a good place to start. It even had fans riled up with excitement. But with excitement comes expectation and the final outcome just didn't meet the standards. The encounter was quite short and derivative of what came before. The addition of other animals, most notably the underwater piranhas that act as a blockade far too often, really disengaged the engrossment factor of the game, but the worst offence of all is just the painfully uninspired story.
A story that has so many predictable twists that M. Night Shyamalan should've spearheaded it, and one that feels like a repeat of what came before, and not in a fun way.
6. Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation
What can you do when your franchise is a fatiguing and so is your generation of new, interesting ideas for the protagonist spearheading all of it? Well, it's simple, you bring her endeavours to an end by ending her life alongside it.
By this point, Lara had done everything. She'd been around the globe - probably more than once - she'd fought every villain she could find and practically all the world's treasures were steadily in her possession. So, with the character running out of steam - despite still being wildly popular just before the turn of the millennium - the developers made a choice that would never stick.
By this point, and after creating 3 other titles in this franchise already, the developers were well aware of all the components that came together to create a definitive Tomb Raider experience, and nowhere has this been seen more prevalently since Tomb Raider 2.
It's irrefutable that there's nothing particularly innovative or exceptional about the games design overall, comparative to the prior titles which always built on the steady foundations of the previous title, the experience has been refined to a point where the only flaws could come in the writing. And as you can imagine, it's more than competent.
Contrarily to how you look at the narrative of what was supposed to be Lara's final excavation, her evisceration was never going to remain canon. Not when there's this much money to be made!
5. Tomb Raider Legend
Tomb Raider Legend isn't only the best of the bastardised middle-child trilogy that came courtesy of a combination of the PS2 and Xbox 360 - with Anniversary and Underworld succeeding it - it's essentially a belated revision of everything Angel of Darkness should've been. And if this game was released in its stead, then Eidos would've had more than momentum selling their titles.
This game is a bonafide, underrated classic that came at a time where the series' time in the limelight was seriously dwindling, and as a result - despite it being ported to a boatload of consoles - nobody really bothered to engage with it.
It's absolutely everything that came before, but bolstered and reinforced with no exceptions. There's vehicular levels that are still incredibly enjoyable today, an engrossing mix of platforming and puzzle-solving that have stumped players as much as they have immersed them and the game's pace is utter perfection.
Set pieces never occur for too long and are well aware of when they're beginning to overstay their welcome. The story isn't going to win any awards, but its vintage Tomb Raider down to the core of its anatomy, not only due to the sumptuous blend of fantastical elements mixed with a lot of realistic characters, and Lara herself feels like, well, herself!
Easily making Legend the last great game before the reboot(s) came along.
4. Tomb Raider (2013)
During the era of reboots in every entertainment industry becoming superfluously unnecessary, no major IP was safe from the treatment. So, naturally, Tomb Raider was a dead ringer to be called upon.
In a year that saw Evil Dead precariously reimagined, the Man of Steel reinforced and The Wolverine stealing more revenue than it earned; Tomb Raider was the ubiquitous anomaly.
In other words, it was a practically perfect reinterpretation, with a grittier tone and appetite for bloodshed which was somewhat subjugated by minor flaws that don't necessarily derail or sully the experience, but certainly detract from the impact it should've had.
Although Lara's now reimagined with a new origin story that implores her soft sensibilities rather than her now archaic "badassery", along with a rag-tag group of researchers and new arsenal of widow making weapons, she herself is a large issue.
Understandably, in an origin story based around such a vulnerable protagonist, at the base of their development, they're naturally going to have much thinner skin.
Vulnerable? Did I say vulnerable, sorry, that should've read IMPENETRABLE. As Lara f*****g Croft is a gargantuan exception to this rule. This woman takes a battering reminiscent of a Dragon Ball character. The unbelievablity of her being stabbed, shot with arrows, falling from great heights and almost being sexually assaulted is egregious masochism.
Outside of this jarring problem though, the game's an absolute masterpiece that acts as a guide on how to perfectly resurrect an IP.
3. Tomb Raider 3
During the 1990s where Lara Croft absolutely reigned supreme over the majority of the video game industry, Tomb Raider 3 could've just as easily been a soulless, hollow cash-grabbing title that made money from momentum alone, but full credit to the development team, they made another unadulterated hit.
The biggest thing of notoriety with the third instalment is the grandiose level of scope. The first was expansive for its time due to it being a brand new infrastructure that games hadn't really seen before. The second utilised the intricacies of the character's personality to provide a more rounded experience with Croft Manor being a fully interactive environment.
But then the third takes all of that and exponentially builds upon it.
Whereas the former entries were veraciously based on reality, the third becomes somewhat whimsical, if not downright preposterous. The games tone shifts between science-fiction, horror and action from time to time, an outlandish ideology that had never been utilised before within the series, but complimented this games rivetting, but unconventional angle.
This feels both like a breath of fresh air, as well as an indication that the franchise may be beginning to slow down, and if the titles that proceeded it were anything to go by, the latter is probably more prominent in this case.
2. Tomb Raider 2
Who could ever forget the joyous rebelliousness we all felt when locking that poor pediatric butler in Croft Manor's freezer? Only to leave him there and not come back later on as he's presumed to be dead at this point, especially if you still have an old memory card from 1997 with a save file for this very game on there.
Pensioner homicide aside, Tomb Raider 2 was essentially the THPS 2 to its original counterpart, before either of those even existed.
It built extensively on what made it so popular beforehand, adding a fully explorable version of Croft Manor - as opposed to the three rooms in the original - generating all-round better graphics and more fluid controls for everything from textures to characters, to assets and improving the action oriented set pieces and creating more inventive puzzles didn't hurt its critical appraisal either.
The only destitution that Tomb Raider 2 has against its name is that it simply will not transcend time, as in 2021, it looks and plays extremely dated in comparison to what is available on the market currently, both for Tomb Raider games and inspired franchises such as Uncharted and Just Cause.
1. Rise Of The Tomb Raider
The original Tomb Raider was grandiose and spectacular for the standards set back in its day and its rebooted counterpart was pretty credulous too. Some might argue that Tomb Raider 2 dwarves both, and if they're referring to this iteration, then they're incredibly adept at comprehending game design.
The second of the reboot trilogy is a masterclass in everything a third-person, action-oriented sequel strives to be. It's perfectly paced, the combat is delicately refined, and the stories fleshed out enough to be engrossing without becoming distracting or convoluted. In this entry Lara has grown and adapted into the role that she's - now - willingly taking on.
After most of her friends were brutally slaughtered in the prior entry, Lara continues her endeavour to practically take down an entire faction while avenging the people she's lost. Or a person - in reference to her father - as the previously mentioned squad is ancient bloody history at this point. Well, all except for Jonah, the only hindrance the game has to offer.
The benefits of this title, though, besides the decadent campaign, are the multitude of game modes that range from fanastical to simply fantastic. The game's packed to the rafters with fanfare so superlative that it's a little serendipidous to a lot of rival franchises.