Until Dawn: 10 Biggest WTF Moments

Keep your friends close and your enemies closer.

Horror games have had somewhat of a resurgence in the last few years, but a lot of the more successful titles have been from independent developers, like Amnesia and Outlast - not many big AAA horror games have been produced, let alone been successful. Until Dawn bucks that trend, however €“ it€™s a big title with big ambitions, and it€™s also incredibly well made. There€™s so much to like about it, from the stunning visuals, to the varied (if slightly cliché) characters, and the killer soundtrack. If you imagine an 80s slasher flick like Friday the 13th, mixed with an €œinteractive experience€ like Heavy Rain €“ well that€™s Until Dawn in a nutshell. Since it takes inspiration from slasher flicks, the plot is incredibly cheesy, but that doesn€™t mean it€™s bad. There€™s a reason that those films have a cult following, and as it turns out, they work well in a more interactive medium as well. Being the horror game that it is, there are obviously going to be moments that have your heart in your mouth, plot twists galore and scenes that have you peeking through your hands. Here, we run down the top 10 moments in Until Dawn that will make you shout €œWTF?!€

10. The First Fatality

There€™s nothing like a short, sharp shock in the introduction to let you know that a game is not messing around. The Last of Us did it perfectly with Sarah€™s death, and Until Dawn also captures this atmosphere by killing off Beth and Hannah right from the get go. After Hannah runs off into the mountain woods (since her friends were being humongous jerks), you have to follow her trail as Beth to try and get her back to the lodge and out of danger. She€™s pretty easy to find, and it looks like the game is going to be forgiving at this stage €“ until suddenly the twins find themselves hunted to the edge of a cliff by a mysterious creature. Your choices here are merely an illusion €“ whatever you do, Beth and Hannah will both tumble off the edge into the chasm below. And then comes the worst bit of this scene €“ the impact. Beth lands squarely on a rocky outcrop, breaking her back with a sickening crunching sound. Hannah doesn€™t fare much better. And the scene ends with the pair€™s lifeless eyes looking into the camera as it fades to black. Ten minutes in and two of the group are already dead. As we said before €“ Until Dawn does not mess around.

9. Ashley's Grudge

Ashley is one of the bubblier characters amongst the survivors €“ at least until the bodies start piling up €“ and her will-they-won€™t-they romantic involvement with Chris is one of the focal subplots in the game. Unless your heart is made of icy stone, you€™ll be rooting for the two of them to make it out together. However, it turns out that Ashley tends to harbour grudges €“ even when she and her friends are being ruthlessly hunted by an unfeeling murder machine. Midway through the game, Ash and Chris find themselves the victim of a twisted trap version of Russian roulette, in which Chris must choose between himself and Ashley. Should he choose to shoot her, even though the gun isn€™t primed, she will not forget what he was going to do. This proves fatal for Chris later on, as he flees towards the lodge with a Wendigo in pursuit. Pounding on the front door, he pleads with Ashley to let him in to safety, which is quite clearly the correct and sensible thing to do. Ashley doesn€™t forget, though €“ and she cruelly, coldly watches on, deliberately doing nothing, as the Wendigo catches up and rips off his head, while the collective player throws the controller at her in frustration. Good luck trying to repair that relationship.

8. Josh's Hallucinations

You never really play as Josh in Until Dawn (although there€™s a very good reason for that), so when you are placed in his shoes near the end of the game, it€™s a surprise in and of itself. Unfortunately for us, it only gets more surprising €“ and creepy €“ from there. The game makes it clear that Josh isn€™t exactly mentally stable, but it€™s only when he (and by extension, you) starts hallucinating in the mines that you realise just how far off the deep end Josh is. First, his dead sisters appear and start scolding him, which is creepy enough. Then the walls of the mines suddenly turn into pulsating, grotesque mounds of flesh, complete with guts and gore galore. Then you€™re attacked by a pig€™s head erupting from the flesh-walls by vomiting up more guts and intestines. These give birth to your sisters again, except now they€™re more€ rotten. And bloody. It ends with €œHannah€ ripping the skin off her own face and turning into a monster crawling through the flesh-walls. The whole thing is disgusting and incredibly freaky €“ but at the same time, it€™s really, really cool €“ and it really shows just how fragile Josh€™s mental state is. Definitely not for the squeamish, though.

7. Matt's Death

Matt€™s death is a big WTF moment for two reasons. Firstly, if (like most people) you€™re playing to try and save as many people as possible, then it€™s likely the first one that happens. And second, it comes out of absolutely nowhere. His death comes as a consequence of him and his girlfriend Emily trying to use the radio tower. Things happen, and the tower unbalances and topples over, sending both of them plummeting downwards towards the mines. Luckily, Matt gets a foothold on a ledge €“ but Emily is left dangling, clinging onto a railing for dear life. Now, the player gets the choice to try and save Emily, or abandon her and save himself €“ and it€™s very likely you€™ll make the wrong choice. Trying to save Emily collapses the tower, leaving Matt with no choice but to run for it, and he jumps to what seems like safety. Unfortunately, the monster has other ideas. Matt gets dragged unceremoniously through the caves and impaled through the jaw on a sharp hook. It€™s horrible, it€™s gory, and it€™s definitely not painless. But that€™s Until Dawn for you €“ one bad decision and suddenly you€™re a survivor short.

6. Emily And The Wood Chipper

Speaking of bad decisions, Emily is prone to making one or two herself. Having somehow survived the radio tower collapsing, she€™s wandering around the mines looking for a way out. Since the mines are where the monsters live, there€™s no prizes for guessing that it isn€™t long before she€™s attacked. In running away from the Wendigo, Emily decides to board a conveyor belt for a bit of extra speed. Not a bad idea, really. However, this particular conveyor belt is for a wood chipper, which needs jumping over. Now normally, you can usually call Until Dawn out on its bluff when it comes to QTEs. Even if you miss them, whether accidentally or on purpose, there€™s usually only a minimal consequence €“ so you€™d be forgiven for assuming this one was no different. Unfortunately for Emily, though, this QTE is vital. If you miss it, she falls directly into the grinder and instantly has her lower body crushed. No rescue, no chance of escape, just a horrible, painful death for failing a single QTE. And just like that, another one bites the dust.

5. Shooting Emily

Poor Emily just can€™t catch a break, can she? Then again, given her attitude throughout the game, maybe she deserves it. Whatever you think of her, there€™s no denying that having your friends turn on you for survival is a pretty terrible way to go. If she manages to escape from the clutches of the wood chipper, the Wendigo that€™s chasing Emily will eventually lose her tracks €“ but not before managing to leave her with a souvenir. More specifically, a bite on the neck. Now, Wendigos are not zombies €“ you don€™t turn into a Wendigo if you get bitten by one. However, the lads and lasses up on the mountain don€™t seem to know that, especially given the state of panic at the time. And unfortunately for Emily, Mike is in the basement with a gun. As the player, you have a choice €“ and you can choose to shoot Emily right there and then to protect the rest of your friends from potentially being killed. This death carries a bit more weight than a lot of the others, because it isn€™t a horrible monster that€™s killed you €“ it€™s someone you trusted and liked, turning on you in order to protect themselves. It doesn€™t feel good if Emily dies like this €“ but that€™s why it€™s on this list.

4. Jess' Kidnapping

Jess is another character who doesn€™t see a lot of playtime once things start to get serious €“ mostly because she€™s either dead or unconscious for half the night. Her abduction is the first real action after the introduction €“ pretty much everything up until then is a red herring or a false flag. In fact, you€™re so used to the tricks that even though it€™s obvious that something is going to happen, you just dismiss it as another prank. It€™s only as she€™s dragged kicking and screaming through the window that you realise €œOh hell, this is actually a real problem€, which is why it comes as such a big surprise. At this point in the game, there€™s been no indication of what€™s actually out there on the mountain, either. As far as you know, there€™s some kind of crazy axe-wielding psycho murderer out there waiting to pick everybody off one by one €“ one that also happens to be insanely strong. Jess being abducted marks the point in the game where the wheels fall off the happy camping trip €“ and it leaves you really hoping not to meet whatever took her away.

3. The Saw Trap

The saw trap is appropriately named, because it looks like something that torture master Jigsaw would have come up with. And even though later in the game it€™s revealed to be rigged, it€™s a super tense moment the first time you play through it. About halfway through the game, having been knocked out by a mask wearing lunatic, Chris finds both Ashley and Josh in an outhouse, tied to a wall. There€™s also a big saw blade in front of the pair of them, and it isn€™t just for show. Chris has to make a difficult decision €“ does he save his best friend, or does he save his romantic interest? Regardless of who you pick, the blade will make its deadly way towards Josh. And although you€™re sure that it€™s just a prank, that it€™ll stop along the way and there will be a big reveal - eventually the saw reaches him and cleaves him violently in two, right through the stomach spilling blood and guts everywhere (mostly over Ashley). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SZ7oyxJxBO4 Ashley and Chris€™ reactions are just about what you€™d expect €“ blubbering and retching all over the place, so it€™s not a particularly nice scene to watch. Don€™t expect it to get any easier the next time round, either.

2. Finding The Bodies

In Until Dawn, there is only one character that it is impossible to save €“ the Flamethrower Guy. Everybody else€™s lives depend on the decisions you make, so it€™s on your hands if any or even all of the group dies during the events of the game. In the final chapter, Sam and Mike are trying to find Josh, who has the keys to the cable car. Unfortunately, he€™s in the Wendigo€™s lair. The lair itself is no spookier than anything we€™ve seen before €“ apart from one particular room. One room causes the two survivors to react violently, puking and screaming at the sights within. And with good reason, as it turns out €“ if any of the group have died on your watch, then their bodies will be strung up to the ceiling in the cavern, on display for anyone to see. It€™s a pretty horrible sight: the headless bodies of their former friends, still in their clothes, and their rotting, mutilated heads rolling around on the floor €“ I think I€™d be throwing up as well. The real weight of this moment comes from knowing that you could have prevented this from happening, but you didn€™t. There€™s only one way to make things right €“ and that€™s to play through the entire game again.

1. Hannah's Diary

The biggest WTF moment in Until Dawn isn€™t a death scene, or even part of the main plot. It€™s an item that you only find by exploring everywhere in the mines extensively, but it€™s essential to tying everything together and figuring out the tragedy of the Washington sisters. You see, even though it looked pretty bad, Hannah didn€™t die from falling into the mines, like Beth did. If she had, it would probably have been a mercy. No, Hannah survived with bruises and a broken leg, with only her dead sister for company. Her diary documents her slow descent into madness €“ and hunger. Day by day it eats away at her, until she has no option to give in to the temptation and dig up her freshly buried twin as a last, pathetic meal (and unknowingly unleashing the Wendigo curse as a result). The writing in her diary slowly transforms from a cold, scared, injured little girl to a hideous, terrifying monster with no remorse and no shred of humanity. It€™s made all the worse with the knowledge that she was just an innocent victim of a childish prank €“ doomed to become a monster by those she considered friends. There€™s a moral in that story somewhere. What did you think of Until Dawn, total madness or absolute genius? Let us know in the comments!

In this post: 
Until Dawn
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Matty Coxhill hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.