Watch Dogs 2 Review: 7 Ups & 6 Downs

A sure improvement... but still no GTA.

Watch Dogs 2 Marcus Lenni
Ubisoft

Watch Dogs 2 finally landed in gamers' laps this past week, and the consensus among critics and fans alike seems to be that it's pretty damn great.

It's been arguably the busiest fall period for gaming ever this year, yet Watch Dogs 2 does a great job distinguishing itself from the glut of AAA titles recently hitting the market with its unique hacking mechanics, filling the open-world third-person shooter niche that's currently left pretty wide open.

While most will almost inevitably view it as a stop-gap until Red Dead Redemption 2 arrives next year, it's nevertheless one of the year's most pleasant surprises so far, even if it's still beholden to a few unsavoury carry-overs from the last game.

Here are 7 ups and 6 downs from Watch Dogs 2...


Downs...

6. Driving Is Still Pretty Terrible

Watch Dogs 2 Driving
Ubisoft

One of the most vocal complaints about the original Watch Dogs was that driving was, well, garbage. The handling and controls felt totally at odds with the more refined scheme of the combat and on-foot movement, evoking an arcadey feel that didn't suit the style of the game at all.

Watch Dogs 2, to its mild credit, does definitely improve the driving by making it feel a little weightier, but it's still fairly clumsy when compared to the likes of Grand Theft Auto V.

Steering feels sluggish and unresponsive, which will likely result in the player crashing far more often than they really should. Thankfully driving isn't a massive part of the game mission-wise (and you can fast travel to almost every mission if you really hate it that much), but given how hard fans were on it the first time, it's a shame the improvements aren't more decisive.


5. The Tone Is A Complete Mess

Watch Dogs 2 Marcus
Ubisoft

Depending upon how you decide to play Watch Dogs 2, it can be a real tonal mess, especially if you decide to become a blood-letting Terminator.

It's fair to say that the game definitely encourages the player to use stealth and hacking to complete missions, but there will almost inevitably be scenarios where you'll need to use combat to confront enemies head-on.

Protagonist Marcus is at least supplied with a tranq gun (with unlimited ammo), but this isn't much of an option during more intense engagements, and you'll likely end up killing at least a few people throughout the main campaign.

It just feels...wrong. Marcus is this smart, slick hacker and the fact the player can commit mass slaughter feels actively weird.

It's worth distinguishing this from GTA, which has a history of more unhinged, irredeemable protagonists where the violence is more expected, because Marcus actually seems like a good, well-adjusted guy, and the fact you can just murder everyone in the mission area with an assault rifle strikes an odd sour note.

Playing this way, it feels kinda tough to support Marcus' actions, so unless you want to have a crisis of conscience, it's probably best to stick to stealth and gadgetry where possible.

This won't be an issue for everyone, but for those who like to dig in deep on the meaning of games and their characters, it may present a conundrum.


4. The Awful Checkpoint System

watch dogs 2
Ubisoft

It's 2016 and we're still getting games with horrendous checkpoint systems. WD2 really struggles in this department and it can result in some infuriating experiences for the player.

Basically, if you're killed while on assignment, you may very well get thrown back 20 or 30 minutes, especially if you've just spent a ton of time carefully scoping out enemies, carrying out hacks and basically favouring stealth (i.e. playing the game how it's meant to be played). The game refuses to recognise your efforts and harshly starts you way, way back.

Thankfully the game is on the whole fairly easy so you probably won't die all that often, but still, having to repeat the same sequence several times at great length just feels like an artificial way to inflate the game's playtime.

Hell, there's a set-piece where Marcus has five minutes to defuse a series of bombs, and if you fail, you have to sit through the same minute-long dialogue again before being able to re-attempt it. Who honestly felt like this was a good idea?


3. Cringe-Worthy Characters & Humour

WATCH DOGS 2
Ubisoft

As relieving as it is that this game ditches the funereal tone of the first game, Ubisoft don't always ensure that the humour actually lands.

While the game firmly plants its tongue in its cheek when it comes to depicting the hacking group Dedsec, the character banter is frequently quite cringe-worthy, coming off as what a middle-aged executive probably thinks young hackers actually sound like.

While the balance definitely wins out in favour of jokes and one-liners that actually work, the humour and characters themselves are often quite embarrassing, especially the villain Lenni, who is basically a not-quite-parody of your average 4Chan user. Anyone over the age of 20 will probably find the hackers pretty grating to listen to after a while.


2. Hacking Mini-Games Are Repetitive & Frustrating

Watch Dogs 2 Hacking
Ubisoft

Of course, the hacking mini-games are back...but sadly Ubisoft haven't really done a whole lot to make them more fun this time around.

It doesn't help that the game does a horrible job of explaining how the player is supposed to hack into cameras, locate keys and unlock networks, because let's face it, how many of us have actually touched the previous game since finishing it over two years ago?

The game assumes you're already pretty up-to-par on hacking, which can result in a number of head-scratching moments where you tirelessly spend time figuring out something the game probably should've explained better.

There are also some bizarre interface and aesthetic choices: one hacking section late in the game leaves the final "lock" tucked just out of sight so you can easily spend 20 or 30 minutes thinking there's something else you're missing.

While the puzzle aspect of the hacking can be fun, the experience gets pretty tiresome in the game's later stages as they become more complex and elaborate.


1. Online Co-Op Is Broken At Launch

watch dogs 2
Ubisoft

As with just about any game releasing these days, Watch Dogs 2 suffered some launch day woes, as Ubisoft were forced to disable the seamless co-op component due to the mode causing the single-player gameplay to lag and even crash.

While players can still manually invite a friend to play co-op with them, seamlessly teaming up with or hacking a random has been disabled until a patch is released to fix the technical issues.

Considering that most players will end up meeting randoms rather than friends, it's a shame this is yet another game that launches incomplete, but at least the single-player offering is substantial enough that it's not a huge deal.

And now, here's everything that worked in Watch Dogs 2...


Ups...

7. It Doesn't Take Itself Seriously At All

Watch Dogs 2
Ubisoft

Tonal issues aside, Watch Dogs 2 is basically the game the first one should have been: the serious, dour tenor of the original is largely gone, instead employing bright visuals and a satirical tone more in line with the Grand Theft Auto franchise.

An early example of this focus on fun and humour has the player hacking into the home of a man clearly intended to parody douchebag entrepreneur Martin Shkreli, and if you listen up later on, you'll hear a hilarious conversation debating the merits of Aliens and Predators.

Also, though the central Dedsec characters can be a little on the irritating side, the game is at least smart enough to make them ripe for mockery as well, so everybody's fair game basically.


6. Mission Variety Is Surprisingly Decent

Watch Dogs 2 Nudle
Ubisoft

One of the big problems with the first game is the lack of mission variety, which made it quickly feel stale and, honestly, a bit of a slog to finish.

Thankfully this time, the silly tone allows the game to throw more outrageous and varied missions at the player, including stealing an iconic car used in a movie, and sneaking into a Google-esque campus.

The missions are mostly PR stunts to increase your follower count, and while there are still a lot of "sneak into a fortress" missions, it's not nearly as arduous as in the first game, with combat feeling a lot less necessary for most battles.

The first game often felt like a copy-paste of Assassins Creed mission types, and while Watch Dogs 2 isn't completely free from that, it does a good job spicing things up. Also, the side missions are actually surprisingly decent and don't just feel tacked on, even if only completionists will probably end up finishing them all.

Plus, the player has so many ridiculous toys this time around to help you create your own emergent moments that make missions feel special and distinct.


5. The Protagonist Actually Has Personality

Watch Dogs 2
Ubisoft

Protagonist Marcus Holloway may be a bit of an obnoxious tosspot on occasion, but he actually feels like a human being, which is more than can be said for the first game's woefully dull, unlikable protagonist, Aiden Pearce.

Sure, the game is still miles behind Grand Theft Auto when it comes to characterisation, but it's a massive leap in the right direction, and actually results in a protagonist you're going to remember for the right reasons.


4. The Gadgets Are Insane

watch dogs 2
Ubisoft

A huge part of WD2's appeal is the sheer insane array of gadgets and abilities you can obtain. The two most notable gadgets are the Jumper, an RC car which can use vent openings to infiltrate buildings, and the Gyrocopter, which is excellent for reaching more far-flung areas. If you're going stealthy, they're absolutely invaluable.

Then there's the upgrades, which are unlocked by using research points awarded at the end of every mission. These upgrades can be used to enhance both combat and hacking skill, with the most memorable being the ability to control cars remotely, label an enemy as a snitch so a rival gang shows up to wipe them out, or straight-up call 911 on them.

There's nothing quite like camping outside a fortress, calling in both a gang strike and the cops, then sneaking around while the three sides blow the living Hell out of each other. It's hilarious and basically the game at its finest.


3. It's (Mostly) Visually Stunning

watch dogs 2
Ubisoft

The original Watch Dogs was a great-looking game despite all those pesky visual downgrades from the original demo, and WD2 presents another graphically impressive open-world.

Yes, there is a little slowdown from time to time (especially when driving fast) and the character lip sync is frequently awful, but San Francisco looks absolutely incredible for the most part, feeling like an actual living, breathing city, far more so than Chicago did in the first game.

Sure, it's no Uncharted 4, but then, what is? Plus, considering the ridiculous scope of the open-world and how seamless it feels, it's nothing if not a triumph.


2. The Awesome In-Game Music

Watch Dogs 2 Marcus
Ubisoft

The first Watch Dogs had a pretty cracking soundtrack, and the second follows suit with an even more diverse track list including the likes of N.E.R.D., Dead Kennedys, Bob Marley & The Wailers, NOFX, Duran Duran and Outkast to name just a few.

Anyone who's ever played a GTA game knows how much texture and attitude a great soundtrack can add to a video game, and it certainly helps enhance the live-in feel of this world. Driving around while listening to Duran Duran's Planet Earth is quite the hypnotic experience indeed.


1. It's A Solid Improvement Over The Original

Watch Dogs
Ubisoft

And finally, a lot of fans were worried that Watch Dogs 2 was either going to just repeat the same mistakes of the original or end up moving too far away from what made the first game remotely enjoyable.

Thankfully neither of those things are true, and while the game does significantly change the series' tone and aesthetic, it really feels like a move towards what most people wanted the original game to be.

It's far from perfect and the jury's still out on how the seamless co-op will go down, but it's a very encouraging surprise of a sequel, and should leave fans excited for the possibilities of Watch Dogs 3 in a couple of years' time.

What do you think of Watch Dogs 2 so far? Shout it out in the comments!


In this post: 
Watch Dogs 2
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.