WWE 2K15: 10 Superstars That Are Criminally Under-Rated

"Under-Rated... Clap clap, clap clap clap."

Getting the WWE superstars€™ ratings accurate in their showpiece games every year is an unenviable task for 2K Sports. World Wrestling Entertainment is a machine that is constantly moving, a machine that never stands still due to a number of reasons. With Raw and SmackDown airing every week, and with monthly pay per views that often include the culmination of a number of story lines, 2K are often expected to predict the future when it comes to rating the WWE's roster of talent. There are a number of things that could change from week to week or month to month. A fine example of this is Cesaro. Since winning the Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal at WrestleMania XXX, his career has hit a sizeable snag. That Battle Royal win came when 2K and WWE would have been well into the development process of 2K15. Cesaro looked like he was set for the big push his skills deserve and was awarded a 93 rating, putting him higher than the likes of Dean Ambrose (91), Roman Reigns (92) and the same as Triple H. Had he not put his feet in his mouth during an interview with the Liverpool Echo, his rise to the main event slots may have continued. Instead, he found himself jobbing to almost everyone and is now rebuilding himself as part of a tag team with Tyson Kidd. This shows what a difficult task 2K Sports has when deciding on a superstars' score. However, there are some that are deserved of a lot more, regardless of what has played out on television...

10. The Big Show - 87

The Big Show's showing at the Royal Rumble last Sunday means his rating should be closer to 100 than most. However, his role as nothing more than an utter confusion to the WWE Universe over the past year means that his rating is surprisingly low for a man of 7 ft and 430 lbs. It has got to the point with Show where the paying customer doesn't know whether they should be cheering or booing him. He, like his Rumble partner Kane, has gone through so many face and heel turns that it has been near impossible to keep up. Obviously, his association with The Authority and the fact he eliminated babyfaces-in-chief Dean Ambrose, Dolph Ziggler and Ryback from Sunday's over the top rope spectacular definitely means that we are meant to jeer him now. But WWE has messed around with him so much that it seems the most of the Universe couldn't give a hoot about what he does. Nevertheless, the largest athlete in the world is deserved of more than an 87 rating which puts him alongside the likes of NXT's Adrian Neville, Curtis Axel, Damien Mizdow and The Usos.

9. Tyson Kidd - 82

This rating is nothing short of blasphemy. If WWE talent was measured on nothing more than pure wrestling ability, Tyson Kidd would be joining the likes of Daniel Bryan on a 94 rating. However, as we know, wrestlers are judged as the total package and up until recently, Kidd has had one area that has been severely lacking. His gimmick. Tyson has gone through somewhat of a rebirth in the last year. Initially, his work with wife Natalya breathed new life into his career and resulted in a growing amount of appearances on the main shows. Taking on the role of the cowardly heel, Kidd managed to gain heat from NXT audiences by using his ever popular wife as a means to getting out of tricky situations, capitalising on their €˜real life€™ problems played out on Total Divas. All these shenanigans are a far cry from the pretty boring Hart Dynasty tag team with David Hart Smith. Subsequently, he has formed an utterly brilliant tag team with the much maligned Cesaro. The Swiss Superman is being held back from the main event slots for one reason or another, but still continues to be over with the WWE Universe. The pair let their wrestling ability do the talking and their showing in Sunday's Royal Rumble pre show proved they are the best tag team in the division, despite being the newest. Kidd should be pushing the high 80s quite easily should his gimmick be allowed to develop.

8. Kofi Kingston - 85

What has happened to Kofi? At one time he was one of the leading semi-main event performers in the company, slamming Randy Orton through tables in Madison Square Garden. Now, he's been repackaged in a terrible gimmick that looks like it'll never get over with the WWE Universe. Nevertheless, his rating of 85 is simply baffling when you look at his skill set. You'd have to put it down to the way he's been booked. There's very few wrestlers in WWE that you look at and think 'no one else on the roster could do that'. Kofi is one of them. We all know about the spring he has when he leaps, it's unrivalled. This past Sunday's Royal Rumble was the perfect opportunity for him to get some much needed traction, but even his 'moment' was uninspiring. Kofi was simply tossed onto Adam Rose's Rosebuds and placed back onto the apron. The crowd in Philly booed The New Day from the moment that appeared in the pre show, right up until both Kofi and Big E had been eliminated from the Rumble. WWE might as well cut their losses before Kingston, Big E and Xavier Wood's standing in the eyes of the fans gets too low. Kofi is a special talent and needs to be given the platform to showcase his skills once again, or WWE might loose him.

7. The Miz - 84

It has been the running joke in WWE for a while now. When The Miz makes his entrance and a "Awesome" bellows throughout the arena, the crowd screams "Awful." However, he's not as bad as an 84 rating on the game suggests. One thing this rating does show is a bit of consistency on 2K Sports' part. They've evaluated the entire package once more. The Miz is arguably the biggest heel currently in the WWE. He elicits the biggest response from the WWE Universe and doesn't seem to have one fan compared to the likes of Bray Wyatt, who is a heel with a plethora of admirers. His wrestling ability, on the other hand, isn't the best. Obviously, he knows what he is doing in there, he's manage to last in WWE for over 10 years now. But he does nothing that sets him apart from the pack. Quite literally all his move set is either borrowed or stolen for past members of the WWE roster. Miz' rating of 84 puts him lower than the likes of Titus O'Neil (85), Goldust (86), and Fandango (85). On top of that, and something that must hurt Miz the most, if he even cares about the game's ratings is the fact he's rated three less than his stunt double (although he isn't his stunt double in the game) Damien Sandow.

6. Sami Zayn - 85

When 2K15 was released back in back in October, it could be argued that an 85 for Zayn was just about right. However, it could also be argued that it was severely low when you look at other members of the game's roster. Zayn's best buddy and fellow NXT superstar Adrian Neville was awarded an 87 despite never having made an appearance on WWE mainstream TV while an 85 has him rated lower than a number of wrestlers that can't lace his boots, from a pure wrestling standpoint. Sami, who took the NXT Championship from Neville last month, proved he is just as good, if not better than his Geordie counterpart which begs the question: Why is there two rating points between them? They have both been wrestling for well over 10 years, they both signed for WWE at roughly the same time too. You'd have to put Zayn's comparatively lesser rating down to the fact he's been wrestling in WWE, and to their style guide, for less time. This is also reflected when you see the obvious passing of the torch that happened between the two at NXT R-Evolution in December. When they pair of them are battling for the Intercontinental Championship on a pay per view, it will be interesting to see how 2K Sports rates them.

5. Ryback - 87

This entry is also down to timing. And booking. When the game was being developed last year, Ryback had been relegated to the seemingly nonsensical tag team of RybAxel with Curtis Axel. The team seemed to be just thrown together with not a lot of thought and proceeded to job to other teams in the division. The pair achieved their most notable success when they became the number one contenders for the Tag Team Championships and battled for the belts at WrestleMania XXX. A month or so later, Ryback announced to his partner live on Raw that their days as a unit were over. Their careers have gone on to be polar opposites since. Axel has been demoted to NXT, and couldn't even make it to the ring at Sunday's Royal Rumble, while Ryback has become humanised character and one of the biggest faces in WWE. Despite the booking RybAxel were handed, The Big Guy's rating should never have been allowed to drop so low. His size and power should guarantee that doesn't happen. He was a 90 in 2K14 which is about right, and might even be a tad low when you look at the run he is currently on.

4. The Ultimate Warrior - 89

The Ultimate Warrior is rated 89 in the game. Yes, 89. A truly iconic figure in the wrestling business can't even break into the 90s. As The Hurricane would say: "What's Up With That?" Other greats in the game have all been afforded the luxury of being in the 90s club. Stone Cold Steve Austin (92), Sting (93&91), Hulk Hogan (91&93), Shawn Michaels (95) and Kevin Nash (90) are all in there. Let this sink in: Kane is rated 90. Other members of the game's current roster in Alberto Del Rio, Batista, Bray Wyatt, Brock Lesnar, Cesaro, Chris Jericho, CM Punk, Daniel Bryan, John Cena, Luke Harper, Randy Orton, Roman Reigns, Seth Rollins, Dean Ambrose, Sheamus and The Undertaker are all in the 90s club. Some in that list are obviously better workers than Warrior, but arguably non of them have made the impact that the Ultimate one did during his career. The reason for this low rating is unclear. The cynical viewpoint will look to the relationship between Warrior and WWE. All animosity seemed to have been put to bed, but maybe it didn't. Was this Vince McMahon getting the last word in? (Probably not.)

3. Dolph Ziggler - 85

What problem does WWE have with Dolph? It is widely recognised within the WWE Universe that Dolph's in-ring ability is deserved of a place in the main event slots. However, there is clearly an issue between the powers that be and Ziggler as they have only afforded him a brief reign as World Heavyweight Champion, when the big gold belt was pretty pointless in all honesty. Conversely, why isn't Dolph making himself the man event star that his talents suggest he should be. Vince McMahon makes a big deal of how he merely offers an opportunity for someone to make a name for themselves which may mean he obviously thinks Dolph isn't doing enough. Roman Reigns' biggest critics will ask why The Showoff isn't being given the same seemingly favourable treatment. To be fair to WWE, they looked to be turning the screw with Dolph as he was made to look like a superhero in the elimination tag team match at Survivor Series. This potential push was then quashed at Sunday's Royal Rumble as he was eliminated after just 02:19 of action. This harsh treatment has made its way into the realms of WWE 2K15 too. You don't need me to tell you that the former Spirit Squad member is under-rated. He has the look, the in-ring ability, the charisma, the gimmick and now the experience to make it to the top. Dolph should fully expect his rating to be a minimum of 89 when 2K16 is released later this year.

2. Rusev - 88

Rusev made his official WWE main roster debut at the 2014 Royal Rumble and still hasn't had his shoulders pinned to the mat once. So why when this game was being made over the first few months of last year, was this most impressive of undefeated streaks not taken into account? It must be noted that an 88 rating for a man who had been on the main roster for less than 10 months on the game's release is very impressive. It could even be said that it's impressive that he made the game at all. But considering the impact he's made, which has been huge and potentially bigger than anyone in the last 10 years, 2K Sports has done the United States Champion some disservice. No one has come close to beating Rusev fair and square in over a year. There has been a couple of sneaky count out victories but those haven't done his reputation any damage. Despite all this, he still finds himself in the middle of the road when it comes to 2K15's ratings. For example, Adrian Neville, who is yet to make his debut on the main roster, is rated just one less than the unbeatable Bulgarian Brute. Where's the logic in that? Rusev is heading into a match with John Cena after finishing second in the Royal Rumble which shows how high he is held in WWE's regard. With more time to exploit the main event scene on real life television, 2K16 should see Rusev well into the 90s.

1. Roman Reigns - 92

If WWE 2K15 was released tomorrow, the minimum rating Roman Reigns would receive would be 99. The machine is well and truly behind the Big Dog as his ascension to the top continued on Sunday with very little resistance. Faced with over 700 lbs of humanity in Kane and The Big Show, Reigns used superhuman power to topple the two giants over the top rope. He then overcame a sneak attack from the crafty Rusev to claim his first, and maybe not his last, Royal Rumble win. Reigns' current rating of 92 makes him one of the top current roster guys on the game. However, as it was so clear that he was going to be vaulted to the very top of the card in a short space of time, why wasn't he given a rating that truly reflected that? Roman is expected to defeat Brock Lesnar for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship at WrestleMania. By doing so, he will overcome a man that is rated a full two points more than him. Theoretically, this means that the former Shield member should be rated the same, if not more than The Beast Incarnate. And a lot closer to John Cena who is a staggering 96. The relationship between WWE's televised programming and its leading game is virtually non existent. The ball starts rolling with lack of current attires and it doesn't stop there. Hypothetically, imagine if a young fan buys the game post Mania with Reign's the champion after a clean win over Lesnar, but sees Brock as the far superior guy in the game Their little mind will be blown. This is a really petty reason for Roman to be given a higher rating, but surely a necessary one in the grand scheme of things. Believe in that. Follow me on Twitter: @WhatCultureTwed

Content Producer
Content Producer

Video & written Content Producer for WhatCulture Wrestling. NCTJ trained journalist. BA Hons, Sports Journalism.