WWE 2K16: 10 Huge Problems Nobody Wants To Admit

From pay-per-wrestler DLC plans, to more godawful commentary.

There's a reason you've seen little to no gameplay when it comes to WWE 2K16; except for siphoned-off press junkets where they can highlight a working build for a few minutes, anyway. That being; it simply isn't anywhere near as polished as it needs to be, especially this close to release. It's one thing to build anticipation and hold things back until the last minute, rather like a band waiting to go on when crowd anticipation reaches fever-pitch, but at this stage what's been slowly trickling out of 2K's towers doesn't exactly exude the most confidence. Eve on the WWE's official site there's barely anything longer than a four-and-a-half minute clip featuring Stone Cold and Jake the Snake; a good 30 seconds of it being the now-legendary "Austin 3:16 says I just whooped your ass!" speech. Basically, it reeks of everything 2K have been doing wrong for years now, as following the reshuffle of the once-phenomenal Yukes/THQ combo from the 2000s into 2011, they continue to struggle putting out a product that can even begin to live up to the legacy left behind. We'll buy it - wrestling fans are some of the most passionate and doggedly devoted of all time - but at some point, you just have to wonder if this is the best they can do.

10. Roster And Attires No Doubt Be Outdated At Launch

It used to happen back in the day, when Smackdown's Just Bring It through the Vs. Raw games were in full flow, and it'll happen come October 27th. Somewhat due to inevitability, there's just no way to put out a WWE 2K game that can be bang-on up-to-date when it comes to roster inclusions, new costumes/attires, entrance animations or occasionally even finishers. Already we know thanks to the ongoing Diva revolution, Sasha Banks confirmed via Twitter she's being held back back from the already-overblown 127-strong roster, and that's alongside the likes of Roddy Piper, RVD and Dusty Rhodes (to name but three big omissions) as latent fan-favourites nowhere to be seen. Basically, it boils down to pure business; always keep your audience wanting more. Where's the impetus to buy the following year's instalment if you already have everything down-pat in its current form? Essentially it flies in the face of the whole "This is the most complete game yet!" marketing ethos, and as we've seen with the Assassin's Creed series, running it into the ground with yearly instalments is just about the worst thing you could do anyway.

9. Many Wrestlers Kept Back For DLC

Banks, Kurt Angle, CM Punk and more are forever left on the bench, whilst the flipside is we get shots of, erm, Haku, programmed in instead. Again, it's business, the mobile game industry has proven just how profitable segmenting your game into a million and one different packages can be, and as the 2K games aren't shy of packaging in content as DLC later down the line, that'll almost definitely be the case yet again. How else do you explain the stripped-back customisation options, that only this year are starting to make a comeback? You can sense 2K's hesitation, as many past iterations simply let us create fully-working versions of the omissions that were totally satisfying to play as, yet nowadays it's a difficult balancing act to fulfil fans' wishes, whilst also ensuring you subtly bleed them dry in the process.

8. Playing To The Attitude Era Only Has So Much Appeal - Feels Desperate

Have you noticed how nostalgically-fuelled every major part of 2K16's rollout has been? "Hey guys, we know we messed up with 2K15 and made Vince look like a sentient pork pie, but here's the Attitude Era! It hasn't aged a da- oh." Cue copious amounts of winking and nodding as 2K essentially admit - along with everyone else - that the WWE really isn't ever going to be able to top those late 90s/early 2000s golden years. I'm obviously not saying they weren't spectacular - and regardless of it being a sports entertainment show, the best week-to-week run of any TV show of all time - but at some point you just have to move on, both culturally and in the digital realm. Why not use the licenses they're clearly in possession of to tap into the Invasion storyline, but do it bigger and better than ever before? Have the cover art feature the trifecta of WWE vs. WCW vs. ECW, but have the story mode play out all sorts of alternate realities, just for kicks? Rather than having Stone Cold make the save at Survivor Series 2001, you could save the WWE, or defect yourself and see how things play out. Such an apparent need to 'play it safe' leads me nicely to...

7. Focussing On 'Realism' Isn't What The Games Need

Ever since the UFC came up and changed everything about how the mainstream public deal with both sports entertainment and the very idea of depicting martial arts/hand-to-hand competition, the games in turn have changed to accommodate. Honestly though, before 2K started really taking over the direction of these titles, it was a joy to see things like Triple H's angular mounted punches actually connect like they would, or watching something like Undertaker's piledriver be absolutely devastating, as it should be. Both WWE All-Stars and the mobile-only Mortal Kombat-style Immortals went a little bit too far into the realm of escapism, treating the roster like genuine superheroes - but you can't deny the appeal of watching these guys is supposed to ebb and flow between believability and insane spectacle. Pandering to 'realistic' match flows and 'the grapple game'-style mechanics just aren't what we're here for, and indulging in backstage brawls or pulling off all your favourite moves in a far more brutal, OTT fashion will always be far more satisfying.

6. Where's Create-A-Finisher?

"Far more customisation!" they scream, as it looks like we're getting a more in-depth 'Create a Diva' mode, alongside Create a Show, Arena and the standard Wrestler modes. However, although fans would most likely riot if the legendary CAW mode was removed, where the hell is 'Create a Finisher'? Last seen in the fantastic 2K13 and continued through to 14, it was ominously removed for last year's release, with no concrete explanation given. As the one thing that prevents you from creating a roster omission and finalising them with their finisher, you have to believe the motive is - again - business-related. Say you make someone like RVD, but there's no 'official' version of the Five-Star Frog Splash? Any fan who just simply wants the 'complete package' will throw up the cash to buy a licensed version of something they could already make - it's an impulse that's hard to describe, but something that 2K are almost surely aware they could exploit.

5. The Commentary Is Still Incredibly Flat In Places

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IXcyUvQvAYQ WWE's commentator teams have gone through all sorts of shakeups over the years, JBL and Cole's combo being a particularly lifeless moment - but something that's ebbed and flowed alongside is their implementation in the games. First introduced way back in 2001 with Just Bring It (and featuring the brilliance of Tazz commentating on his own match), Yukes implemented a 'slot name in' system that sits alongside larger chunks of generic dialogue, the combination of the two supposedly meant to create the atmosphere of a real match. Now obviously guys like Cole, J.R., Lawler etc. aren't going to be able to spend a huge amount of time in their booths recording endlessly specific lines, but you need only look at the current crop of entrances to hear completely flat, immersion-breaking lines like "Both of these superstars look geared up and ready to go!" or "I hope this superstar has everything he needs to win this one!" Seriously, "this superstar"? It's painfully obvious they're recording lines that could be applied to any scenario, and surely stuff like "I think that *KANE* has a good chance to win!", although patchy, could be edited together better from a better batch of original recordings, giving us something that sounds a bit more authentic and energetic.

4. Timing-Based Submission/Pin Systems Feel Cheap

If we're talking about a gameplay system that should mimic the 'dig deep and carry on!' will of whoever's in a bout, then putting that on a timer-basis feels absurd. You're essentially relegating every wrestler's stats to nothing more than a timed button press - something that if you miss, I guarantee will be infuriating. No longer will you lose a match because your guy just couldn't carry on and was completely down for the count, but you just missed the applicable window, and they gave up. Surely a button-bashing system would've been better for both submissions and pins? The former is literally just the UFC games' submission system where you 'chase' each other around an icon, lining it up to apply pressure, but a metered system where a certain ceiling had to be reached by hammering the buttons would've been a far more applicable way to showcase what it's like actually being in a submission. Your opponent does their best to hit as many inputs as possible, and you do the same - both your wrestler's fatigue factoring into an on-screen display for who's about to give in or break out. For pins it's much the same. Not to mention how impossible it'll be to hit a tiny timing window with online lag, you should essentially always be able to pull off the near-impossible if you can muster the willpower to bash enough buttons furiously enough.

3. Lack Of Real-World Competition Makes 2K Lazy

Like a water salesman in the desert, he can charge you a literal arm and a leg - and you'll cough it up, because you need his product. Okay, okay, it's 'just wrestling', but all the same, it's always been so much more than that. Apply such a model to the modern-day wrestling game climate, and 2K are the only people supplying the fluids, whilst the rest of us whither and doubt, before ponying up the cash anyway. When game development was a far cheaper and more freeing affair than the multi-million dollar budgets that cripple all artistic freedom in 2015, we had at least had Anchor Inc. (who? Exactly) putting out the woeful WWF Raw series on Xbox, or Nintendo's Wrestlemania franchise, providing a solid 'console war'-style setup to get everyone outdoing one another. Granted, Yukes were behind both Smackdown and Wrestlemania, but it didn't stop them trying out new features in one, before implementing them in the other, eventually giving fans on all sides the best experience. Now the WWE is simply too big and pricey to afford to split revenue across multiple platform exclusives. 2K want all the cash, all the time, and they're not about to do a deal with Microsoft, just to segment their developer base and establish some good ol' fashioned competition. However, like in every scenario where something is being offered to the public, healthy competition only breeds a better product for all involved. 2K having the monopoly on the license only benefits filling their coffers.

2. 2K-Led Games Lack The Confidence Of Yukes€™ THQ Run

There was a point back around when Yukes were showing off third PS2 instalment Here Comes the Pain, where they absolutely nailed everything they'd been attempting so far. Character animation had a fidelity to it that never came across before, the roster itself was balanced and varied, story modes were involving and engaging - and the control scheme was the final time buttons ruled all, before those damn analogue sticks came in. As mentioned earlier, the appeal to the Attitude crowd already feels like a last minute kick-out attempt before the series has a truly terrible instalment, and that's before you remember all the little flourishes that used to be layered on top of a perfected game engine. Pausing finishers to pull off slow-motion 360-spins always looked incredible, as did the option to do an instant-replay of any move in a three-shot combo. Physics for the tables both announcers and standard were always improving, as were things like animations involving chairs or ladders - all round it just exuded a sense of confidence that came from a developer going "We know what we've got here, so here's some extras". Now it feels like they're floundering, being rushed to put out a product for a publisher than demands deadlines be met - and although that might eventually lead to a truly great wrestling game once again, 2K16's misguided PR spin doesn't look to be it.

1. Yearly Releases Kill Innovation On Current-Gen Consoles

All of these problems come from the new-age 'need' to put something out every year, treating what's clearly a more robust product than your average FIFA or Madden, as something fans will snap up regardless. Everything, from the lack of real-world competition to the DLC plans and lack of moves like Create a Finisher are all caused by 2K forcing Yukes to put something out every year, much like Ubisoft do with Assassin's Creed, or EA do with their sports titles. This approach to treating WWE as 'just another' sports title does both the fans and the product itself a huge disservice. Wrestling fans are not UFC fans, nor are we football, hockey or any other 'type' of fan. We notice every costume change, every small animation that's motion captured or hand-animated, every slight change in entrance - everything. Yearly releases allow for cosmetics to be overhauled, but they don't do anything for entirely new game engines or completely reworked physics models. At some point 2K need to realise the current generation of hardware just doesn't operate like the old, and taking a year out would build hype and anticipation for the 'great return' - pleasing everyone involved. What are your thoughts on WWE 2K16 this close to launch? Let us know in the comments!

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.