WWE 2K16 Review: 5 Ups And 5 Downs You Need To Know About

A huge leap forward, but just not far enough...

WWE 2K16 is as close to a perfect fusion of performance and showmanship that has ever been seen from a wrestling game. 2K made a conscious decision to move away from 'arcade' gameplay into more simulation based content with WWE 2K15 and have pushed this on even further with 2K16. This has resulted in the new title being the most realistic WWE game of all time with many facets that make up a real life match - such as working holds where our beloved Superstars rest in the middle of a bout - making their way into the virtual version of a WWE ring. This new found level of realism has been complimented by a more strategic outlook which means that for the first time ever, a wrestling game is a thinking gamer's game. Gone are the days of endless reversals and relentless action that made it look like our favourite Superstars were powered by Duracell batteries, and in are rationed counters, rewards for kickouts and other measures that make you plan ahead while you're in the ring. 2K16 even saw the return of a number of key components that didn't make the cut last year, while the bumper roster is quite simply insane. That being said, the new game isn't perfect - not saying that WWE and 2K won't get there one day - so here's five ups and five downs that you need to know about.

The Downs...

5. No Four Horsewomen

Let's get the biggest gripe out of the way first, shall we? I could accept there being no Four Horsewomen in the game if 2K's reasoning was at all logical. However, it isn't. The powers that be have cited in many interviews that the reason behind four of the hottest entities in the company at the moment not making the game in any sort or form is down to timing. You'll notice that much of the game is up to date from around WrestleMania time early this year - in fact, all sorts of scannings for the new game took place backstage at Mania - and the reason Sasha, Bayley, Charlotte and Becky didn't make it was down to the fact that none of them had made their main roster debuts yet... Why then, 2K, has Samoa Joe - a man who made his NXT debut in June - been made available as part of the Future Stars Pack? Why couldn't we have had a women's wrestling DLC? In terms of their respective work for WWE at least, all Four Horsewomen's achievements outweigh the former TNA Superstar's by some distance. The whole thing makes very little sense.

4. Reactions After Pins

So you're well on top in a match and have just seen a pin fall attempt kicked out of by your opponent agonisingly close to the three count. A new feature on this year's game sees your Superstar react towards the ref in either anger or disbelief. It would be a lovely touch to have in the game if it was done correctly. However - and this has happened to me more times than I would care to mention - the Superstars spend so much time moaning at the referee that by the time they're done the opponent's stamina has returned to full and they're on the attack. Pin. Moan. Suffer. Repeat. With 2K17, the powers that be need to make the animations of the Superstar moaning at the ref shorter, or the time it takes for the opponent's stamina to return to full longer. It's so frustrating! You don't choose to have your guy moan at the ref and you get punished for it.

3. The Break Out Feature

This is such a shame. The breakout feature is something that WWE games have been crying out for since they came into our lives. However, there's one seriously bitter aftertaste that ruins the whole thing. So you've chosen to attack your opponent on the ramp, all is going well as you layeth the smacketh down all over their candy a**. You've hit your special and your finisher and have your opponent beat before the bell has even rang. What happens next? The referee disqualifies you and you're sent to the back... WTF! The bell hasn't even sounded meaning the match hasn't began. Why has the ref felt the need to step in? Can't he just let it go till we're ready to take to the ring? Feature. Ruined.

2. Renee Young's MyCareer Interviews

How to ruin MyCareer, volume I: Have Renee Young possessed by some sort of zombie, then give her black teeth, Medusa's (not the wrestler) hair and a robotic voice. Yet another huge shame that surely could have been avoided. The concept is exactly what we want to see from our career mode with more organic content where you are in charge of your own destiny, but these interview segments quickly become the bane of your life. Obviously everything needs to be pre recorded so limitations are there from the outset. However, the forced nature of how the lines are delivered, plus the awkward silences are things that could easily be better. It's a frustrating process to sit through time-and-time again. And when Renee decides to sign off an interview with "And thanks for the time..." Thanks for the time? Who wrote these scripts? Such a disappointment. https://youtu.be/7OfI4pQHH44?t=53s

1. Submission System

For me, this is a near impossible task. Having read all the pre-release info, I was expecting this to be a proper game of cat and mouse, with your toggling of the analogue stick completely controlling where your respective section in the circle heads to. However, there's simply no feel to the mini game. You find yourself twiddling your left thumb frantically but your section moves nowhere. Before you know it you opponent has caught up to you and you've lost the match. I can see how 2K have tried to use momentum and a pendulum-like swing to dictate where your section goes, but this - for me at least - makes it near impossible to escape the dastardly red bar. 2K need to change this so your movements on the toggle sticks represents where your bar goes. This would make for a lot more compelling, and lot less frustrating, facet of the game.

And The Ups...

5. The Size Of The Roster

We were promised 120 Superstars and have been given a whole load more. Despite there are a couple of notable Superstars missing due to one reason or another, this is by far the best and most diverse roster in WWE games. Period. There's nothing more to say other than the roster is awesome. (although there was surely enough room to fit those Four Horsewomen in somehow...)

4. Entrances

A lot was made about the features that were left out of WWE 2K15. Many speculated that 2K chose perfectly choreographed and lengthy entrances in place of certain features in the creation suite, for example. There simply wasn't enough room to include both. This led me, at least, to expect slightly lesser entrances in this year's game to make room for more facets of the game to return. However, 2K have used some magic to ensure that this isn't the case. 2K16 seems to show that the powers that be at 2K have found a perfect (ish, there's still a couple of features that need to return) balance between gameplay features and perfect entrances. Long may this continue, and in time we should have the prefect blend of playable features and step-for-step perfect ring walks.

3. Flow Of The Matches

Never has a WWE game felt more realistic. This, mainly, is down to the measures that have been put in place to ensure that you get a match that replicates something you would see on television. The main facet to this is the reversal system. Gone are the days when you could head into a sequence of 100 reversals in a row - the new game rations the amount of counters you can hit which makes matches flow a lot more like the real life product. It also adds a new level of strategy as you won't want to blow your load, so to speak, and have to wait a while for it to return. While this is somewhat of an acquired taste, the realism in general of the new game is something that can only be seen as a positive and a real leap forward for wrestling games - however frustrated it makes you feel at times...

2. Creation Suite

THEY BROUGHT THINGS BACK! YES! Drastic measures had to be taken on the creation suite in this year's game. 2K had no option after the reaction to what we were given in last year's game. As I mentioned before, many believe that 2K made the conscious decision to leave certain features out of the creation suite in 2K15 so they could have prefect entrances. Thankfully, they have restored the balance somewhat in 2K16. Favourites like Create a Diva, Create a Championship, Create an Arena, and Create a Show returned, while what the company described as €œkey improvements€ were also made to facets of Create a Superstar, Create an Entrance, Superstar Studio and Community Creations. Top work, 2K. I, for one, am certainly looking forward to what another year of developmental work will bring to the creation suit in WWE 2K17. It could be the best we have ever seen!

1. Stone Cold Steve Austin Mode

Expectations were rightfully low after 2K15 for the featured Stone Cold Steve Austin mode, but it's fair to say that 2K knocked it out of the park. And then some. Given the short Showcases we were given in last year's game, many expected the Austin mode to briefly skip over some of the Rattlesnake's best and most memorable moments from his main event run in WWE and that would be that. However, we were given an in depth mode that covered every single angle of Stone Cold's career, right from his mainstream start in WCW till his final match against The Rock at WrestleMania XIX. if I had to be picky, I would have liked to have seen the mode start from his WCW days - rather than starting from his 3:16 promo at 1996's King of the Ring - and have all of his top moments as bonafide milestones in the mode, rather than having his Steamboat/ECW Whipwreck rivalries as bonus content. But that said, at least those matches were included and were given a suitable going over rather than feeling like a bit of an afterthought. They've certainly done Stone Cold justice with this mode. Kudos, 2K.

In this post: 
WWE 2K16
 
Posted On: 
Content Producer
Content Producer

Video & written Content Producer for WhatCulture Wrestling. NCTJ trained journalist. BA Hons, Sports Journalism.