WWE 2K17 Review: 6 Ups & 7 Downs
Glitches. Glitches everywhere.
WWE 2K17 is finally in the hands of gamers worldwide, and with 2K's fourth time up to bat, there's a lot of hope that they will have ironed out the litany of issues that has been holding these games back for years and years.
Sadly, not quite. While in many ways 2K17 is an encouraging step forward for the series, bringing some of the best gameplay and customisation to the table in a long, long time, it's also depressingly beholden to an infuriating number of nagging legacy issues.
As such, fans should temper their expectations, as WWE 2K17 is ultimately a fairly middle-of-the-road offering overall: brilliant in some aspects and woefully lazy in others. Either way, it leaves a lot of room for 2K to improve things next year (and this conversation will probably then repeat itself again).
Here are 6 ups and 7 downs from WWE 2K17...
Downs...
7. The Lack Of 2K Showcase Mode

In recent years the 2K Showcase mode has been a brilliant cornerstone of the WWE 2K titles, allowing fans to relive classic matches and storylines in a gleeful burst of pure fan service.
Sadly, while 2K were planning to center Showcase around Brock Lesnar this year, due to several of his opponents not being included in the game, it had to be scrapped, with 2K instead investing more of their time and effort in the MyCareer mode.
Boy, is Showcase conspicuous by its absence or what? MyCareer is fun to a point but ultimately quite the slog, high on repetition and clunkiness and lacking the cinematic invention and nostalgia factor that made Showcase such a hit.
Hopefully 2K will pay attention to the fan outcry and clear all legal red tape in time for next year's game.
6. Wildly Inconsistent Graphics

This has been a trend in wrestling games for years, and don't expect it to change any time soon: 2K17 is an almost hilariously erratic game in the visuals department.
On one hand, some wrestlers like John Cena and Randy Orton look absolutely fantastic for the most part (clearly having had the most time and effort invested in them), while Dolph Ziggler has a creepy, overly long mouth you could drive a train through, and so many other wrestlers simply have an uncanny look that helps make the game feel at least three or four years out of date visually.
It's all the more frustrating considering how amazing other 2K Sports game look. 2K should be especially ashamed of how horrible the crowd looks here, especially during MyCareer where the camera actually lingers on them for an awkward amount of time.
5. Commentary Is Still Terrible

Again, not a surprise but still disappointing as fans still hope that 2K might one day learn from it. There are so many problems with the commentary in this game: it's repetitive, they've rehashed dialogue from previous years (a CM Punk reference somehow made it in), and the game straight-up doesn't respond to the correct context sometimes: in our play-test, after pinning an opponent in a one-on-one singles match, Jerry Lawler noted that it was the "final elimination".
Honestly, so little effort is put into the commentary here that they're probably better off just leaving it out.
4. There Are Tons Of Bugs

It's a WWE game so, of course, there are going to be bugs, but even for the standards of the franchise, this is absoluely ridiculous.
Some of the more common bugs encountered by players include: no music playing at all, a wrestler's entrance theme continuing to play into the menu, wrestlers transporting around backstage or clipping through the environment, and the game straight-up crashing among so much more.
It's clear that the game was barely play tested, if at all, and while many of these issues will surely be patched in the coming weeks, it's still ludicrous that it was released in such a patently rough, unfinished state.
3. Outrageously Long Loading Screens

Make sure you've got your phone nearby when playing 2K17, because the frequently lengthy loading screens will otherwise make you want to tear your hair out.
Particularly when moving around in MyCareer mode and the Creation Suite, expect load times in excess of 30 seconds, and while your basic match set-up does seem to load faster than 2K16, on the whole the amount of down-time as the game loads seems wholly unreasonable.
This is sadly unlikely to change all that much as it's almost certainly tied to the game's engine, but perhaps that's simply another sign that the series could do with a major design overhaul.
2. Online Is (Still) A Hot Mess

Again, a feature that's long been problematic in WWE games, and it shows little signs of changing here: 2K17's meager online offering is an embarrassment.
During several play-tests on different days, matchmaking took from 3-5 minutes, and input lag meant that reversals would more often than not fail to register completely, making it easy for an opponent to relentlessly hammer the same moves until they pick up a win.
Compounding this is the lack of proper online leaderboards, which just exemplifies that 2K aren't really taking the online multiplayer seriously at all.
This shouldn't be difficult to get right at all, and yet they screw it up year-in and year-out.
1. The Lack Of Voice Acting

In previous WWE games, the presence of voice acting has added an undeniable layer of authenticity, even when it's not quite the best-acted or most convincing it could be.
2K17 sees voiceovers removed almost completely, with the MyCareer mode just featuring a few scattered recordings from the likes of Albert, Triple H and Paul Heyman (basically non-wrestler characters).
Probably the oddest omission is that of Renee Young, who frequently interviews wrestlers backstage yet, like the actual roster, is voiceless and therefore has to contend with some incredibly un-exciting text scrawls.
If 2K wants to properly replicate the WWE TV experience, they desperately need to get the talent voiced-up and on-board next year.
And with all that in mind, let's look at what actually works in WWE 2K17...
Ups...
6. Hugely Improved Core Gameplay

As easy as it is to dump on what 2K17 has screwed up, it's fair to say that it also gets an incredible amount right in terms of the core gameplay.
For starters, the traditionally frustrating, fiddly targeting system has been replaced with a manual one that allows players to change who they're looking at with the simple press of a button. It's just common sense and a nice quality-of-life fix for a long-nagging problem.
Then there's the brilliant new roll-out mechanic, which during multi-person matches will cause players to roll out of the ring after taking heavy damage. As their stamina recovers, the player can then decide when to re-enter the ring, either rushing in to break up a pin or ladder attempt, or holding on longer to get a fuller gauge. It adds a ton of strategy to these match types while also better reflecting the pacing of actual WWE matches.
And finally, after 2K16's submission received an extremely mixed reception from fans, 2K have added in an alternate submission system much closer to the button-mashing simplicity of earlier games.
5. The Comprehensive Creation Suite

One of the gems of this year's game is the ridiculously involved Creation Suite. Whether you're building a wrestler, move set, arena, video, entrance, victory celebration, title, show and so on, the wealth of customisation options are absolutely insane.
Though there are some tough loading times as already mentioned, it's hard to knock the sheer insane depth of the various creative aspects, which put as much power into fans' hands as possible, and provide a near-endless amount of replay value for those keen to put their own stamp on the game.
4. The Best Universe Mode Yet

It could still use a little work to completely maximise its potential, but on the whole this is the most assured and entertaining Universe mode to date.
Supported by the Creation Suite's ability for players to completely transform the WWE landscape, Universe mode is more ludicrously entertaining than ever, allowing players to play out their most outrageously creative wish fulfilment in the squared circle.
In addition to the mode having three save slots (compared to 2K16's single one), a concerted effort has been made to make the presentation feel as close to the real WWE product as possible, which helps enhance the already addictive "just one more match" factor.
3. Backstage Brawls Are Awesome

Fans have been begging for its return for years, and finally, backstage fighting is back in a WWE game. While like anything it could certainly be refined to be better, it's still incredibly gratifying for the most part, with Backstage Brawl allowing players to take their fight all throughout the backstage area while making the use of any weapons that just so happen to be lying around.
It feels like a major misstep that Backstage Brawl isn't available as an online match type (not that the online is really working right now), but at least on its own terms it recalls the brilliant brutality these games have sorely been in need of for a while, and exploring behind-the-scenes is always a lot of fun.
2. The Reworked User Interface

It's safe to say that, for all its flaws, 2K17 touts an incredibly slick and intuitive user interface, making menu navigation easier than ever, while Universe mode's move towards a more TV-esque UI just makes it feel that much more immersive.
Hell, even the menu screen has clearly had a ton of effort put into it, with random, fully-rendered wrestlers emerging out of smoke to strut around in the background. It's a nice touch and shows how much thought 2K put into getting the presentation right.
1. The Biggest Roster To Date

2K17 boasts the biggest roster of any game in the series to date, with more than 150 wrestlers when including DLC.
Wrestling games sure have come a long way from when 40-60 wrestlers used to be the normal roster count, and while this does mean that 2K have visually cut corners on some superstars, it does provide an enormous amount of possibility from a fan service perspective, especially regarding dream matches.
Yes, there are notable omissions (The Club and The Million Dollar Man, anyone?), but on the whole, it's ludicrously comprehensive and sets an incredible precedent that future games are now basically duty-bound to follow.
What do you think of WWE 2K17 so far? Shout it out in the comments!