WWE 2K24 Superstar Ratings: 10 Biggest Surprises & Snubs
6. Surprise - Tegan Nox (77)
It's safe to say that Tegan Nox's return to the WWE hasn't exactly set the world on fire.
A little over a year after returning to the company, Tegan's status was made worryingly clear in the Royal Rumble when she came out to crickets - crickets who returned in her tag match on the following RAW, in which you could hear every blow in the ring thanks to the all-consuming apathy of the crowd.
As such, her 77 rating seems a tad high, especially when you consider who she's placed above. Did Tegan really have a better year than Zelina Vega (74), who receives regular TV time and had the match of her life against Rhea Ripley in Puerto Rico? Did she have a better year than Kayden Carter and Katana Chance (74 each), who won the Women's Tag Team Championship? And Tegan definitely didn't have a better year than Chelsea Green (75), who became one of the most over acts on the roster thanks to her wildly entertaining role as WWE's most delusional narcissist.
Tegan has a lot of potential, but her rating is too high for where she is in the WWE pecking order. Hopefully she gets given a chance to justify it in the coming year.