Zelda: Link's Awakening - 10 Problems Nobody Wants To Admit
Because every awakening leads to eye-opening.
Remaking classic video games is fast becoming a guaranteed money-making tactic for studios and developers worldwide. For the most part, they're the perfect blend of nostalgia and modern console capabilities. You only need cast your eyes over the sumptuous Final Fantasy VII remake and you immediately realise how much you desperately need to play it.
Nintendo themselves are no strangers to remaking one of their marquee franchises, either - The Legend of Zelda. However, the bulk of their efforts so far have been re-textured or HD versions of N64 & Gamecube classics with little done to change up gameplay, save for a few 'quality of life' modifications.
Ocarina of Time & Majora's Mask both found new life on the 3DS, Wind Waker and Twilight Princess look a fair bit better in HD, but Nintendo's most recent remake, Links Awakening, was probably the most ambitious of the lot. Making a 26 year-old, top down GameBoy Zelda title for the modern age is a pretty massive task.
Studio Ghibli-inspired graphics, a 3D treatment and releasing more than two years after Breath of the Wild's dust had settled meant sales were always going to be strong for Link's Awakening... but is it really that good?
On reflection... not so much, no.
10. Reduced Appeal For Returning Players
For the Millennial generation, Nintendo's GameBoy was one of the first video game consoles anyone was allowed to own themselves. Console games, at the time, were just starting to step away from the 'tear your hair out' difficulty curves that the likes of Battletoads put us through but most of the home consoles were nearing the end of their lifespans as the N64 and PS1 loomed on the horizon.
In short, the GameBoy was the introduction for many to the world of gaming and Link's Awakening was probably many young gamers very first experience of the franchise. The Easter Egg laden landscape was just tricky enough that it was engaging and just short enough that virtually everyone who played it completed it and experienced the catharsis of the end credits.
But... because pretty much everyone completed it back then, why should we do it all over again with no real changes to the story or the gameplay (on the whole, more on that later).
The few extra bits simply aren't enough to bring everyone back to Koholint Island for another playthrough - especially when you consider this isn't the first remake...
9. It's Been Done Before
1993 saw the release of Link's Awakening on the GameBoy and the monochromatic, 8-bit green dot matrix screen didn't really do the game justice in terms of visual appeal. The same can be said of so many GameBoy titles such as Pokémon Red & Blue and even Tetris but the world was already used to seeing Zelda games in full colour thanks to A Link to the Past, among other titles.
Happily, Nintendo realised Koholint Island needed to be presented in colour and the colourised, expanded Link's Awakening DX was released on the GameBoy 'Color' in 1998.
Not only did the game realise Koholint in colour, it also added a new dungeon to really hammer home the fact that there was colour and compatibility with the GameBoy Printer that allowed the photograph sidequest to have some meaning.
Just in case it wasn't clear, the colour version of Links Awakening became fairly definitive and was even made available on the 3DS Virtual Console in 2010... so what was the point of doing it all over again? Really? When 'A Link to the Past' has been patiently waiting for exactly this treatment, we were given a 'direct sequel' instead...
Just get on with it, Nintendo.
8. It's Too Much For Too Little
As a generalisation, Nintendo products have always been more expensive than their direct competitors and this mostly down to their bizarre decisions regarding hardware. In the 1990's, Playstation owners could buy a brand new, AAA game for about £20 because Sony sensibly chose fairly standard discs as their medium... Nintendo opted for cartridges that were TWICE as expensive as an absolute minimum.
As time went by, the teeny-tiny 8cm Gamecube discs continued the trend being more costly than XBox or PS2 discs... so on and so forth. It should come as no surprise, with this in mind, that Nintendo Switch Game Cards can also be rather pricey but the sheer enormity of games like Breath of the Wild usually offsets this expenditure.
Not the case with Link's Awakening. At all.
Eight dungeons, a few sidequests, a bit of fishing, a weird Mario Maker style dungeon designer and even more collectable bits makes for a short game, on the whole, and a minimum of £50 at launch was just way too much for so little.
Preying on nostalgia and Zelda hype is utterly shameful Nintendo, hang your heads immediately.
7. Nerfing The Boomerang
Trading quests in Zelda titles are often a point of contention for the players: some love the concept and others see them as irksome tag ons to just get over and done with. On the whole, however, the trading sequences normally gift the player a gamebreaking, overpowered item that truly rewards their efforts: Biggoron's Sword, the Fierce Deity's Mask, Magic Armour and the Boomerang.
In the original game (and DX), Link acquires the Magnifying Glass for completing the 14 stage trading sequence and this grants him the power to see a hidden Goriya in a cave on Toronbo Shores. Another trade for any one of Link's inventory (usually the Shovel) and the Boomerang is yours to hurl around in sheer overpowered bliss.
This thing was so powerful, it could even take down the game's final boss in a single blow but... you can't have a nice thing like that in the 21st Century! Don't be silly!
In the remake, the trading sequence remains largely the same but your Boomerang reward is so heavily nerfed that it's barely worth using at all. This means there's almost no reason to do the trading sequence at all either... so what was the point exactly?
6. The Graphics Are Too Cute
There are very few Legend of Zelda titles that match in terms of graphical style, with Ocarina of Time & Majora's Mask being the most obvious pairing to use the same character/world aesthetics, so it should have come as no surprise that Nintendo would totally shake things up for the Link's Awakening remake.
In truth, it wasn't a surprise and the initial response was quite positive but a lot of this appreciation came from fans who were wrong about the Wind Waker's cel shaded design being aimed at kids. Many were confident that the cute 'Ghibli' stylings would be backed up with solid gameplay, akin to the Wind Waker, and that the graphics would grow on them with time.
Sadly, 'many' were wrong. The design of the characters, the island itself and even the items is just too toybox and is a naff way to portray one of the sadder stories in the Zelda timeline. Link himself actually looks more like a Funko Pop than anything and it screams merchandise more than top drawer recreation of a classic.
5. Gotta Collect 'Em All!
A very common issue in modern video games is the dreaded collectable sidequest mechanic that generally mean the end of the game is not the end of the game. Some are fairly straightforward and have no real impact on gameplay but this isn't the case with the Zelda franchise - Korok Seeds anyone?
As gamers once experienced in Majora's Mask, a relatively low number of dungeons in a Zelda game means very few Heart Containers are available - just four in Majora's Mask and eight in Link's Awakening. What does this mean? You're going to need a LOT of Heart Pieces to max out your health.
What's worse than having to do every minor tag on and check every screen for a hidden Heart Piece? Secret Seashells! That's what! There were 26 hidden Seashells in the original game but Link only needed 20 to exchange for the Koholint Sword (Master Sword rip off!). This was a decent amount and most would be found throughout a normal playthrough without too much effort, happy days.
Cue the rug pull as Link's Awakening for the Switch had a whopping 50 Secret Seashells for you to search for and you need 40 to access the sword upgrade. It might not be a necessity to upgrade your sword but it seems like a deterrent to force players to seek out so many for one of the most useful item perks.
Not cool Nintendo, not cool.
4. Super Trendy Distraction
Who doesn't love a claw machine win? No one can say their life isn't enriched by repeatedly plunging a claw into a big pile of knock off plush toys until the machine finally grips tightly on the prize and you're stuck carrying it around all day like an inconvenient trophy - there's even YouTube channels with a million subscribers each solely dedicated to claw machines!
Step back from reality into the realms of video games and it's not really the same feeling, it just isn't. However, Nintendo decided that it was absolutely something everybody wanted and gave Koholint Island's 'Trendy Game' a new lease of life in the Switch remake.
Originally, the Trendy Game was only used to kickstart the trading sequence and was never really needed ever again. This was enough and the Secret Seashell you could pick up here was helpful to securing the Koholint Sword but the remake just goes totally overboard with the concept.
10 figurines are available for players to collect by playing the Trendy Game over and over again but there really isn't much point to it other than adorning the houses of Mabe Village with cutesy versions of Mario enemies... No one asked for this!
3. No Photo Quest
Nintendo seem to have a bit of a problem with trimming games down these days with the Pokémon franchise suffering from the most fan outcry: Sword & Shield having a tiny Pokédex, no Battle Frontier in Omega Ruby/Alpha Sapphire but the Zelda franchise has also seen some unnecessary cuts.
It's such a silly thing to complain about but Nintendo's decision to remove the photo sidequest from Link's Awakening pretty much exemplifies that they weren't interested in faithfully remaking the definitive version of the game: Link's Awakening DX.
There's probably even more stuff that got trimmed in favour of Trendy Game plushes and a reworked fishing game but the Switch itself actually has a camera snapshot button... It literally has the tool to do the job but that would be far too simple and, sadly, the quest was abandoned.
It wouldn't have taken much to keep this in the game and it just arouses suspicion as to what else fell by the wayside that no one has even noticed yet.
2. It Hasn't Opened Any Doors
Link's Awakening was definitely the best candidate for remaking in the Zelda franchise but not from the point of view you might be thinking. From the player's perspective, it wouldn't have been at the front of the queue for reworking but the developers couldn't have made a better decision.
Why? Because it was the easiest game in the entire franchise to remake.
Without question, Link's Awakening has a tiny map, very few dungeons and a low number of game mechanics meaning the developers would have had a relatively easy task to rework it for the Switch... but can the same be said of other classic titles?
The Oracle games use all of the mechanics and artistic style utilised in Link's Awakening but would be far more difficult to remake in this style because there's so much going on in both games, never mind linked games.
A Link to the Past? Dream on! Such a vast game with it's intense difficulty curve isn't getting remade any time soon.
Zelda II: The Adventure of Link? Just get out. That's never coming back.
There are a few other candidates such a Minish Cap or Four Swords Adventures but, in brief, Nintendo are very, very unlikely to remake these classics meaning the Link's Awakening remake could be a standalone effort/waste of time.
1. It's Not A AAA Zelda Title
When you think 'Legend of Zelda', you will no doubt immediately start picturing Ocarina of Time, Twilight Princess or Breath of the Wild... maybe a few envisioning Termina Field but no one is thinking of Crescent Island, Skyloft or Koholint Island right away - you make a beeline for the AAA titles and you know it.
So, with this in mind, you have to ask why Nintendo blew the dust off of Link's Awakening to be remade. Maybe it was a quick turnaround for the developers, maybe they were worried we'd have had enough of Ocarina of Time but the likely answer is that it was just different and exciting enough to keep players interested whilst Breath of the Wild 2 continues to gestate.
For the most part, it's okay. Returning players will have their irritations alongside nostalgic enjoyment and new players will have discovered yet another part of the franchise's rich history but it isn't one of the series' greatest hits no matter how much it influenced future games.
Truthfully, the fanbase would likely have been happier to be given the entire back catalogue, in their original forms, on Virtual Console so fingers crossed Nintendo are paying attention and we can put this one behind us as A+ for effort, C for execution.