10 Worst Managers In Newcastle United History

The statistics do not lie.

02-MAY-96 .... Nottingham Forest v Newcastle United .... Newcastle Manager Kevin Keegan and assistant Terry McDermott look dejected as their title chances disappear
Neal Simpson/EMPICS Sport
There's an old cliche about the North East - and in particular Newcastle fans: "the expectations are far too high up there." Media personalities who'e sat on panels every week for years still trot out the same garbage as if any fan, regardless of where they are from should be forced to temper their desires because of reality. That's not how fanaticism works for one, and secondly, it's also not reflective of the reality of about 80% of Newcastle's Premier League history (and even beyond that). By virtue of being considered one of the most passionate and committed fan-bases in the country, and apparently because of an inherent desire to see the team do as well as possible (and not merely to survive), the Toon Army are labelled delusional, arrogant and vicious. As if regular European qualification turning into mid-table mediocrity and relegation and then apathy over cup competitions was something that should be taken lying down without so much as a grumble. The reality of Newcastle United is that for too long it was run terribly (which is partly why Mike Ashley's austerity hurts so much), and too many under-qualified, misplaced managers were hired for way too much money and almost ran the first team squad into the ground. Among the motley crew of failures and disappointments have been international footballers, legends labelled new messiahs and glorified coaches. And while Alan Pardew walked away with at least some dignity intact, there is a strong culture of sacking at Newcastle that has a lot more to do with the pedigree of managers than fan expectations...

10. Alan Shearer

Newcastle United manager Alan Shearer is left dejected after the final whistle
Steve Drew/EMPICS Sport

Rating: 1 April 2009 - 24 May 2009

Played: 8 Won: 1 Drawn: 2 Lost: 5 Win %: 12.50

Hailed as a messiah, Shearer's inability to stop the rot and salvage something from a disastrous season saw his beloved Magpies relegated to the Championship. Whether he will ever returns is unsure, but it looks unlikely.


9. Osvaldo Ardiles

Ossie Ardiles Tottenham Hotspur
Neil Munns/PA Archive/Press Association Images

Rating: 26 March 1991 - 5 February 1992

Played: 47 Won: 10 Drawn: 18 Lost: 19 Win %: 21.27

He had no support from the boardroom and his commitment to blooding youth was admirable but the Argentinian legend was a disaster as Newcastle manager.


8. Joe Kinnear

Joe Kinnear
Owen Humphreys/PA Wire/Press Association Images

Rating: 29 September 2008 - 1 April 2009

Played: 18 Won: 4 Drawn: 8 Lost: 6 Win %: 22.22

Astonishingly, the man who claimed he had won everything and would have saved Newcastle from relegation won only a fifth of his games. His departure for medical reasons was a relief, no matter how distasteful that sounds.


7. Colin Suggett

Colin Suggett, Newcastle United.
PA/PA Archive

Rating: 10 October 1988 - 14 December 1988

Played: 9 Won: 2 Drawn: 2 Lost: 5 Win %: 22.22

The former Sunderland player was caretaker manager after Willie McFaul left. Needless to say, he didn't last very long.


6. Kevin Keegan

Newcastle's manager Kevin Keegan during an Open Day at St James' Park, Newcastle.
Owen Humphreys/PA Archive

Rating: 16 January 2008 - 4 September 2008

Played: 21 Won: 6 Drawn: 6 Lost: 9 Win %: 28.57

Blasphemy, but the third coming of the Messiah was far from the stunning success some might choose to believe it was for romantic reasons.


5. Richard Dinnis

Richard Dinnis Newcastle
NUFC.co.uk

Rating: 2 February 1977 - 9 November 1977

Played: 40 Won: 12 Drawn: 10 Lost: 18 Win %: 30

A morality tale concerning the dangers of letting the players hire a manager, Dinnis was simply way out of his league.


4. Jack Charlton

Jack Charlton, Newcastle United manager
S&G/S&G and Barratts

Rating: 14 August 1984 - 10 August 1985

Played: 48 Won: 15 Drawn: 15 Lost: 18 Win %: 31.25

The Irish international management legend was under-funded but produced boring football and left in a huff when the board wouldn't let him sign future Sunderland legend Eric Gates.


3. Bill McGarry

Bill McGarry, Newcastle United manager
S&G/S&G and Barratts

Rating: 18 November 1977 - 31 August 1980

Played: 118 Won: 37 Drawn: 33 Lost: 48 Win %: 31.35

Dire football, controversy and an unhappy dressing room: some of the reasons McGarry oversaw relegation in 1978.


2. Sam Allardyce

Newcastle United manager Sam Allardyce, reacts, during his teams English FA Cup third-round soccer match against Stoke City at the Britannia Stadium, Birmingham, England, Sunday, Jan. 6, 2008. (AP Photo/Simon Dawson) ** NO INTERNET/MOBILE USAGE WITHOUT FA
SIMON DAWSON/AP

Rating: 15 May 2007 - 9 January 2008

Played: 24 Won: 8 Drawn: 6 Lost: 10 Win %: 33.33

A massive ego, but diabolically bad football couldn't match up to his claims that he did a good job.


1. Ruud Gullit

Newcastle United's Manager Ruud Gullit kisses his lucky charm as his team run out of luck against Wimbledon
Steve White/EMPICS Sport

Rating: 28 August 1998 - 28 August 1999

Played: 52 Won: 18 Drawn: 14 Lost: 20 Win %: 34.61

So much for sexy football.


Content Producer
Content Producer

Video & written Content Producer for WhatCulture Wrestling. NCTJ trained journalist. BA Hons, Sports Journalism.