10 Cancelled Sci-Fi/Fantasy Series That Deserved Better
Crossing our fingers for reboots and revivals.
With what many consider the golden era of Television changing the landscape for how high concept (and high budget) TV could really be, it's no surprise how many amazing titles have come out in the past couple of decades. With many of these shows falling under the mercy of ratings, views, or other behind the scenes issues, however, it's also no surprise how many fall under the axe before their time, or fall from grace even before their eventual cancellation.
The sci-fi and fantasy genres in particular have had a surge in excellent serial storytelling, going from niche to firmly mainstream in some cases (such as HBO's cultural phenomenon, Game Of Thrones), with many broadcasters and streaming services opening up to great, otherworldly fiction.
Though there might be many good reasons, and many terrible ones, that a TV show could end on a sour note, or never even get a proper ending, it's safe to say that when it comes to the really excellent ones, it and its disappointed fans often deserved way better than it got.
And though there are dozens of such shows in the sci-fi/fantasy genres that deserve to be mentioned, here are ten of some of the more recent ones fans still miss until today.
Spoilers ahead for general plot points of these series!
10. Grimm
Grimm had a great run, with six fairly strong seasons to its name, but its monster of the week format, its close to horror fantasy edge, and its increasingly intriguing overarching mysteries got an abrupt and unsatisfying conclusion after its announced cancellation.
There was clearly a lot planned for this show, with elements set up all the way back in Season 1 for the characters to discover, but unfortunately what fans got was a rushed conclusion, a weirdly set up romance between the main character and his longest running antagonist at the cost of a healthy romantic partnership, and a vision of the future where their kids take after their legacy without much setup or fanfare.
Characters were killed off, the story lost its more grounded elements to a somewhat convoluted conclusion, and while, unlike other shows that didn't get to have an ending at all, it actually got to bookend its tale, there was a lot left to be desired and a lot to be missed.
While it's uncertain that fans want a reboot, the world was interesting enough that more about it and its characters wouldn't be unwelcome.
9. All The Marvel Netflix Shows
All of these shows were still at their peak when they were pulled, and fans are still reeling from the loss.
Raising the stakes for what Marvel's properties could achieve in terms of darker themes, with mature content a stark contrast from their largely PG-13 film properties, Marvel's Netflix shows were fascinatingly grounded for what were still firmly entrenched in a world of superheroes. Magic and science fiction are part of this world, but do not shape it, with a modern MCU New York still feeling familiar to your average audience.
Some titles, like Jessica Jones and The Punisher, were effective for those who weren't as eager for the more fantastical leanings of The Iron Fist or the somewhat campier costumed vigilantism of Daredevil. Each show had their own flavour and colour schemes - like Luke Cage's uniquely Harlem musical profiles - that, in many ways, worked for a team-up in Defenders.
It was a shame, but not a surprise, to see them get pulled as Disney began expanding to streaming. Hope holds out that these characters will return, but whether they'll retain the brutal, honest darkness they had on Netflix remains to be seen.
8. Sleepy Hollow
A fantasy series about a modern detective in Sleepy Hollow, New York, partnering with a man who woke up from a centuries-long slumber Rip Van Winkle style, Sleepy Hollow was - similar to shows like Grimm and Supernatural - partly monster (or mysterious magical crime) of the week with an overarching plot and major villains, partly buddy cop odd couple shenanigans between the modern Detective Abbie Mills and her revolution-era partner, Ichabod Crane.
With witches and the occult, biblical references and other intriguing mythologies, and even some childhood traumas involving Abbie and her sister, this show was able to tackle some darker themes without feeling too horrific, and the dynamic between characters was fun yet genuine in a way few shows could manage in the same genre.
Part of the reason this show started dying out even before its cancellation was the killing off of one of its two leads - Abbie Mills - who was as important to the story as its fantastical revolutionary. Treating her like she was expendable was the death knell for this series, which was doing so well with its premise and its balance between old and new.
As with the show itself, Abbie deserved better.
7. Constantine
Based on the occult detective of Vertigo and DC fame, Constantine was a closer adaptation to the comics than its markedly different (yet admittedly solid) Keanu Reeves film adaptation. Actor Matt Ryan fit the rougher, chain smoking, vice-heavy grey-moral "hero" that John Constantine is, with the show even tackling the darkest parts of his own background, such as his arrogant mistakes allowing an innocent child to go to hell and the trauma sending him to a bleak mental institution as a result.
The series had a rough start, not knowing how to tackle its own dark themes and flubbing it with poor attempts at making some characters more relatable to a mainstream American audience. However, the episodes that adapted straight from the comics made for high quality horror fantasy storytelling, terrifying and disturbing, but purposeful and intelligent.
This series had immense potential, especially with the cult popularity of Constantine as a character and many fantastic acting performances - but was unfortunately cancelled before a second season.
Matt Ryan has since reprised his role in animated series for DC as well as cameos in Arrowverse. Hopefully they'll take another shot at putting him front and centre on a darker title.
6. Almost Human
An intriguing sci-fi series about androids gaining sentience, and another of the popular buddy copy genre, Almost Human was a visually and conceptually stunning series that sadly couldn't get past one season, despite gaining a decent following.
Recently, a video game, Detroit Become Human, came out with a similar premise, with a unique, possibly sentient android getting partnered with an older, foul-tempered, android-hating cop partner with whom he starts forming a bond.
Almost Human presented a fascinating future world revolving around newer technologies and androids as part of everyday life, with age-old problems like drug addiction, prejudice, terrorism, and newer issues arising unique to androids. The show also set up some fantastic mysteries behind the android character, Dorian's past, and how he relates to a rash of new cases he and his human partner John Kennex need to investigate.
The dynamic between John and Dorian is the best part of the show, however, with Dorian being disobedient and full of sass, completely unlike other androids, and John unable to help liking him for being unusually human-like while also being disturbed and intrigued by Dorian's strange quirks. The two have fantastic chemistry, and for their banter alone, this show deserves another chance.
5. Galavant
https://www.theworkprint.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/Galavant-Cast-Season-2-Official-Picture.jpg
A side-splittingly hilarious musical series that unsurprisingly featured music by Alan Menken (who was the man behind most of Disney Renaissance era music), Galavant was a campy, ridiculous, and joyful series about an arrogant fantasy hero named Galavant, who is roped into helping a princess named Isabela to save her parents from the same evil king that took the love of his life.
The show isn't actually that straightforward, though, with the evil king turning out more pathetic and likeable than the series first implies, and Galavant's love turning out competent, dangerous, and mercilessly self-serving and more evil than he ever was.
With a completely likeable cast, catchy and hilarious songs in every episode, anachronistic humour mixed with many medieval fantasy tropes, and even fairly frequent self-aware jokes about their own impending cancellation and/or series renewal, this show deserved way more attention than it got.
It leans into its Spamalot levels of ridiculousness, and it's clear that the cast is having the time of their lives, with song and dance numbers every so often allowing them to express it. One hopes it finds new life on TV or onstage, with how unique and high quality it was.
4. Pushing Daisies
A quirky, charming show about death and murder, Pushing Daisies was a fairytale-like series about a pie-maker who can reanimate the dead by touching them, who gets involved in some murder mysteries while also living with the reanimated love of his life without touching her.
In the show, Ned The Piemaker resurrects the murdered Chuck, his childhood crush and love interest, but must never touch her again to prevent her from dying permanently. The two of them try to solve her murder and others, alongside Private Investigator Emerson Chod, who uses Ned's gifts to solve crimes and splitting the reward money with him (while also searching for his daughter, who was taken by his con-woman ex, through self-published pop-up books), and waitress Olive Snook, who helps around the shop, often helps on cases, and has a crush on Ned.
The show has the bold colours and fantastic visuals showrunner Bryan Fuller has become known for (with other legendary show Hannibal getting the same unfortunate early axe), the cutesy quirk never getting in the way of darker, more serious moments.
Fans still wish it'd be rebooted today, the original multi-award winning show cancelled much too early.
3. Da Vinci's Demons
https://cdn2us.denofgeek.com/sites/denofgeekus/files/da-vincis-demons-515864565ebca.jpg
A fantastical re-imagining of Leonardo Da Vinci's life based on his works and secrets, as well as based on occult conspiracies and mythologies of the Renaissance, this series was a visually stunning, proto sci-fi spectacle with fantasy elements and an epic sense of scale and action.
It was strange, mysterious, and firmly adult, taking narrative risks many shows at the time didn't, and though it was about as historical as its own outlandish time travel elements, it brought many of Da Vinci's surprisingly real life experiences and inventions and concepts to a modern audience, and provided a fascinating, compelling, flawed genius protagonist in Leo, with extremely likeable and complex characters as his friends and enemies, from the Medicis to the Vatican itself. It also did a fantastic job showing the real life diversity of people, religions, and cultures in Renaissance era Italy.
Something unique about the series was its stunning visualisations of Leo's thought processes, bringing his beautiful sketches to life in animation onscreen.
Its uniqueness and mature nature seemed not to garner enough attention to renew it for a third season, but this was a series that deserved renewal for its epic scale, gorgeous visuals and music, and high concepts.
2. Sense8
With a fanbase so loving that it got a proper finale after cancellation, Sense8 was a remarkable feat of sci-fi storytelling, following a multinational cast who form a psychic connection, people known as "sensates" becoming connected mentally and emotionally, able to pass skills and knowledge along to each other.
The series by famed Wachowski sisters explored what many shows didn't at the time: themes of gender, sex (including an infamous orgy between the eight main sensates) and sexuality, religion and culture, and inter-personal relationships.
For a series that involved a lot of life-threatening situations, some of the sensates having more dangerous lives than others (though all of them were under threat by a man called Whispers, who hunts sensates down), there are remarkably sweet moments present with all the sensates becoming emotionally invested in each other - one such moment being the feel-good sing-along to What's Going On by the 4 Non Blondes, as well as the loving tribute to fans that was the series finale.
Though stakes were still high by the time the cancellation came, the fans at least got a decent sendoff by popular demand. Still, the series deserved more time to tell its compelling, exciting story.
1. Firefly
The space opera most missed by fans, and topping the lists for TV series cancelled too soon, Firefly is the poster child of great shows that deserved better, with even its eventual additions.
Nearly cancelled before it even got off the ground, sabotaged by the network with episodes aired out of order, Firefly was cancelled quickly, despite its loyal fanbase. So great was its cultural impact that it found life in multiple media such as novels and its film followup, Serenity, and is still a staple at conventions to this day.
Partially inspired by stories of the wild west and reminiscent of shows such as the critically acclaimed anime Cowboy Bebop, Firefly was a space Western chronicling a likeable crew of outlaws with complex backstories and motivations, living in a world where the US and China formed an Alliance that ends up governing the star system.
The Serenity's crew, who ran jobs like smuggling and cargo runs, encountered many dangers, mainly from the cannibalistic roaming humans called Reavers.
With fantastic world-building and a beloved cast, there's a reason Firefly still resonates with fans today. And for how it was treated even during airing, it deserved - deserves - so much better.
The ULTIMATE Firefly Quiz