10 Doctor Who Moments That Were Improvised

Tom Baker and Elisabeth Sladen: the masters of Doctor Who improvisation.

Doctor Who New Earth Billie Piper Rose Tyler
BBC

With a show that features a lot of time paradoxes, parallel worlds, clones, robot dogs, and other complicated sci-fi elements, it's important that the scripts for each episode are tight, polished, and make as much sense as possible, so that the actors and filmmakers aren't left scratching their heads during shooting.

That being said, quite a lot of TV and movie productions are open to a small bit of improvisation on the day, and that's definitely the case with Doctor Who.

Not that the stars of the show are allowed to make up lengthy dialogue scenes on the spot, but over the last several decades, there are examples of actors improvising short lines or minor actions, those smaller moments that you might not have even noticed.

A lot of the time, these nuggets of improvisation will fit seamlessly into their episodes, and they won't really feel like anything special. But in some cases, they've actually gone on to become highly memorable moments for Doctor Who fans of all ages, proving that, sometimes, the magic of this show isn't always written on the page.

10. Amy's Letter (The Angels Take Manhattan)

Doctor Who The Angels Take Manhattan Eleventh Doctor Matt Smith
BBC

This bit of improvisation doesn't physically appear onscreen, but it's such a great story that it's definitely worth talking about.

After Amy and Rory are zapped back in time at the end of The Angels Take Manhattan, the Doctor reads a letter that Amy has written for him. Here, we get an intimate close-up shot of the Doctor's face as he soaks in her final words, with Amy's narration of the letter allowing the audience to hear those words along with him.

While the Doctor is alone in this scene, Matt Smith wasn't alone while shooting it. In fact, Karen Gillan was sat right next to him (just out of frame), reading the letter aloud so that Smith could hear the words in Amy's voice, allowing him to deliver a stronger performance - and this is where the improvisation comes in.

While Gillan was reading the letter, she realised that she didn't have the entire thing with her - she only had the first two pages. As a result, she had to improvise the final chunk, in order to help Smith keep his concentration and finish the scene. This means that Smith's performance is a direct result of Gillan's improvisation. Good job Pond.


9. The Synchronised Turn (Pyramids Of Mars)

Doctor Who Pyramids Of Mars
BBC

Pyramids Of Mars is one of the most entertaining classic serials to rewatch. Not only does it have a fantastic villain in Sutekh The Destroyer, but the chemistry between Tom Baker and Elisabeth Sladen is electric, and they're a joy to watch from start to finish.

You can just tell that Baker and Sladen had a really fun time while making this one, and that might be because they were given a lot of freedom to improvise, when the moment called for it.

The best example of this is in episode four, where the Doctor and Sarah Jane emerge from their hiding spot, see a mummy, do a quick synchronised turn, and dart back into cover, hoping to remain unseen. Supposedly, Baker got the idea for the turn from a Marx brothers comedy routine, and decided to do it while filming Doctor Who.

It's a throwaway moment in the grand scheme of things, but regardless, he and Sladen managed to make it one of the most memorable, hilarious bits in the entire serial.


8. The Disinfection Process (New Earth)

Doctor Who New Earth Billie Piper Rose Tyler
BBC

New Earth is another fun story to rewatch, mainly because of the over-the-top comedy performances from David Tennant and Billie Piper. Like Baker and Sladen in Pyramids Of Mars, Tennant and Piper are having an absolute blast here, with the episode's body-swapping shenanigans allowing the two leads to ham things up to the max.

But before the body-swapping starts, there's a scene where the Doctor and Rose are disinfected by one of the lifts inside the New New York hospital, which basically involves them being doused in water, and then blow-dried.

The Doctor - who clearly knows what's about to happen - seems to rather enjoy it when the water hits him, grinning from ear-to-ear and ruffling his hair like he's having a nice hot shower. Rose, on the other hand, yelps with shock once the disinfection process begins; being a time-travelling newbie and all, she doesn't really know about the safety protocols in this far-future location, despite the Doctor's attempts to warn her.

And as it turns out, Rose wasn't the only one who was in the dark about the lift's watery surprise - Piper herself was too. Apparently, the actress had no idea that she was going to be splashed with bucketloads of water (notice how shocked she is in the episode), meaning that this moment could be considered somewhat improvised.


7. Hey Missy You're So Fine (Death In Heaven)

Doctor Who Death In Heaven Missy
BBC

Whenever Michelle Gomez was onscreen as Missy, you never knew where things were going to go. She brought such danger and unpredictability to her scenes that it was hard to discern her true intentions, which made her an exciting character to watch.

Because of how wild Missy's antics were, it would be reasonable to assume that Gomez was constantly improvising, and while this isn't true (the actress has said that she didn't need to improvise, simply because Steven Moffat wrote her character so well), one of Missy's best moments was indeed thought up by Gomez on the spot.

In the Series 8 finale, there's a scene where Missy is being held captive onboard a UNIT aeroplane. Locked up and unable to move, she starts to sing a version of the Mickey song, replacing "Mickey" with "Missy" to give the tune her own unique spin:

"Hey Missy, you're so fine, you're so fine you blow my mind, hey Missy!"

According to Gomez herself, this musical moment was pure improvisation. Clearly, Moffat liked it so much that he decided to keep it in, and not only that, he also had Missy use this song again at the start of the following series.


6. Which One Is Mine? (The Day Of The Doctor)

Doctor Who The Day Of The Doctor War Doctor John Hurt
BBC

John Hurt didn't get to spend a lot of time in the Doctor Who world, but if this cool behind-the-scenes story is any indication, he didn't let his limited screen time stop him from embracing the spirit and sense of humour that the show is known for.

At the end of The Day Of The Doctor, Hurt's War Doctor bids farewell to two of his future selves: Matt Smith's Eleventh Doctor, and David Tennant's Tenth. While doing so, he observes the three parked TARDISes that are in the room with them, and quips "which one is mine?" prompting Ten and Eleven to look a tiny bit bemused.

It's a cheeky little joke that shows us more of the War Doctor's light side, which is good, because he's in quite a glum mood for the majority of the episode.

Even better, this line was improvised by Hurt (as revealed by Steven Moffat during a lockdown tweetalong of The Day Of The Doctor), which, hilariously, might also mean that the surprised reactions of Smith and Tennant are actually genuine.


5. Are You My Mummy? (The Poison Sky)

Doctor Who The Poison Sky Tenth Doctor
BBC

Utter the phrase "are you my mummy?" in front of any Doctor Who fan, and the image of a creepy gas mask zombie kid will instantly flash before their eyes.

Then, once that moment of horror has passed, Whovians might also recall the scene in The Poison Sky where the Tenth Doctor - while wearing a gas mask in order to shield himself from a Sontaran gas attack - repeats that phrase for comedic effect.

One of the best things about watching Doctor Who is noticing all the little callbacks that are peppered throughout each episode, and this is one of the most memorable examples that NuWho has ever had. But how did it come about? Well, supposedly, David Tennant ad-libbed the line while caught up in the moment, resulting in a hilarious bit of fan-service that makes us chuckle every time we watch it.

We should note that there's some dispute as to whether Tennant actually improvised this or not, but it certainly feels like he did. Since we can't see his mouth, he could've said literally anything while wearing that gas mask, and his dialogue could've been cleaned up (or changed) in post-production.


4. Chunky Gilmore (Remembrance Of The Daleks)

Doctor Who Remembrance Of The Daleks Seventh Doctor and Ace
BBC

Considering how quick-witted his Seventh Doctor is, Sylvester McCoy seems like he'd be a right cheeky chappie to hang out with. You get the impression that he could buff up the majority of his lines with a clever turn of phrase or a funny joke, and that's exactly what he did with this particular example in Remembrance Of The Daleks.

In the third episode of this serial, the Doctor and Ace walk through a school yard, and Ace questions him on what exactly they're supposed to be doing there. In response, the Doctor says that they're "keeping an eye on Group Captain Chunky Gilmore", adding that he has no idea why his men call him "Chunky".

At home, many viewers were also left wondering where that "Chunky" nickname came from, and the answer lies behind-the-scenes.

During filming, actor Simon Williams - the man who played Gilmore - misunderstood the script's description of his character's "chunky service revolver", which earned him the nickname "Chunky". Afterwards, McCoy thought it would be funny to ad-lib this into the episode, and so, he changed Gilmore's name to "Chunky Gilmore" on the day.


3. The Window Mime (Partners In Crime)

Doctor Who Donna Noble Partners In Crime
BBC Studios

When Catherine Tate joined Doctor Who as a full-time companion in Series 4, there were a lot of concerns that the show would become far too goofy and light-hearted, since the majority of viewers associated Tate with her comedy work.

In the end, those concerns turned out to be needless, because Tate's dramatic chops were revealed to be just as strong as her comedy chops. Still, the actress did have some jokey moments to work with, and while she nailed all of them, the best one has to be the window mime scene from the first episode of the series, Partners In Crime.

After having several close encounters during the opening ten minutes of the story, the Doctor and Donna finally notice each other through an office window, but since they can't hear each other, all they can do is mime their conversation.

It's genuinely hilarious stuff, and while David Tennant rises to the challenge, it's Tate who steals the show with a series of exaggerated expressions and funny gestures.

While watching this scene, you might assume that the whole thing was heavily scripted, but in reality, Tate was given very little guidance on how to actually perform her mimes. Showrunner Russell T Davies simply said "see what Catherine comes up with", and as a result, she had to improvise this entire sequence on the spot.


2. The Doctor's Best Friend (The Seeds Of Doom)

Doctor Who The Seeds Of Doom Fourth Doctor Sarah Jane Smith
BBC

The Fourth Doctor and Sarah Jane Smith were an all-time-great Doctor-companion pair, and simply by watching their serials, you can tell that Tom Baker and Elisabeth Sladen thoroughly enjoyed their time together.

Aside from Pyramids Of Mars, the pair also did a spot of improvising in The Seeds Of Doom. During the scene where Scorby holds the Doctor and Sarah Jane at gunpoint and brings them to meet Chase, the Doctor - in a heartwarming move - introduces Sarah Jane as his "best friend", which was fully improvised by Baker.

There's also a funny bit of improvisation earlier in the story, when Scorby tells the Doctor to "turn around" - again, at gunpoint - only for the Doctor to do a full 360-degree spin, clearly mocking the instruction that his assailant gave him. According to Sladen in her posthumous autobiography, Baker decided to do this little move in the moment, with the actress remarking that nobody expected the scene to go like that.

Finally, Sladen's autobiography also mentions that she herself ad-libbed a line. While the Doctor and Sarah Jane are escaping from the chauffeur in the third episode, Sarah Jane yells "down here, cloth-eyes!" to lure him into a trap. Sladen improvised this while filming, because she thought it was something that Sarah Jane would say.


1. The Curator's Congratulations (The Day Of The Doctor)

Doctor Who The Day of the Doctor Tom Baker the Curator
BBC Studios

If this list has proven one thing, it's that Tom Baker was Doctor Who's improvisation master, and even when he returned to the show 32 years after regenerating, he was still up to his old madcap, ad-libbing tricks.

The Day Of The Doctor was a real treat for Who fans, but arguably its biggest treat was Baker's cameo as the curator of an art gallery. In his only scene, Baker interacts with Matt Smith's Eleventh Doctor, discussing the true meaning of the "Gallifrey Falls" painting, and hinting that Eleven should head out in search of his lost home planet.

In the middle of their conversation, there's a slightly random moment where the Curator says "congratulations" and Eleven replies "thank you very much." Again, it feels completely random... but that's because it was random.

During the same tweetalong where he revealed John Hurt's improvised joke, Steven Moffat also noted that this small exchange was ad-libbed by Baker and Smith. In addition, Baker has previously stated that he didn't discuss the scene with Smith beforehand, giving the entire thing an air of improvisation.

Basically, if Tom Baker is in something, you're bound to get a magic moment or two - even if they aren't in the script.


Watch Next


Doctor Who Quiz: How Well Do You Know Matt Smith's 11th Doctor?

Doctor Who The Eleventh Hour
BBC Studios

1. The Eleventh Doctor First Gets His Clothes From Where?

Contributor
Contributor

Danny has been with WhatCulture for over ten years, and is currently Doctor Who Editor and WhoCulture Channel Manager, overseeing all of WhatCulture's Whoniverse coverage. In 2022, he took charge of WhoCulture and has grown it into the biggest Doctor Who channel on YouTube, and one of the biggest Doctor Who communities on the web full-stop. He has been writing and video editing since his early teens, and first got a taste for content creation after making his own Doctor Who trailers, off the back of a burning obsession with the Matt Smith era of the show. Like many his age, he first got into Doctor Who with the 2005 revival, but has since gone back and fallen in love with the classic years too. If you need someone to recite every Doctor Who episode in order, or to give you a random factoid about the making of Gridlock, Danny is the person to ask!