10 Friends Timeline Mistakes You Never Noticed

The One Where Rachel Was Pregnant For Fifteen Months And Nobody Acknowledged It.

Friends Rachel pregnancy thumbnail
NBC

Premiering in September 1994 and continuously topping the list of distinguished sitcoms, Friends is an entertainment staple, creating a legacy that no other sitcom has yet rivalled. It remains a dependable facet of modern television guides, routinely airing back-to-back seasons and regular weekend specials promoting certain highlights of the series' history.

It was almost too big a show to fail - and fail it did not.

Now a calling for niche trivia prominent throughout quiz nights, Friends was crammed with lore that, lamentably, interchanged as Friends' writing team saw fit. These omissions to the normality can be written off as errors in the writing process, as it's unlikely the David Crane and Marta Kauffman-created sitcom set out to make viewers ponder Ross' (David Schwimmer) repulsion towards ice cream or Rachel's (Jennifer Aniston) need to wear glasses.

Such plot points - if they even qualify as such - weren't a necessity for the Friends umbrella of facts. They weren't commonplace in each episode, instead coming up once or twice and leaving the Friends gathering examining each episode for similar tidbits of story lapses.

Instead, viewers should be more preoccupied with studying why a titanic amount of Friends characters abruptly departed the series...

10. Several Key Characters Vanished

Friends Ben Ross
NBC

The index of Friends characters is eternal. Outside of the hexagonal ensemble, secondary characters include Phoebe's (Lisa Kudrow) eventual husband Mike (Paul Rudd), Monica (Courteney Cox) and Ross' parents Jack (Elliott Gould) and Judy (Christina Pickles), Chandler's (Matthew Perry) sometimes-lover Janice (Maggie Wheeler), and the late Central Perk barista Gunther (James Michael Tyler).

But what about the flock who swiftly left the series without so much as a whimper?

Ross and Carol's (Jane Sibbett) son Ben (Cole Sprouse) made a fleet of appearances throughout the show's first eight seasons before vanishing. He's also peculiarly absent from Ross and Emily's fourth-season wedding, despite being cited as the reason Ross couldn't move to England to be with his second wife.

Phoebe's parents also disappear after seasons worth of impassioned buildup, failing to appear at her and Mike's tenth-season wedding, though this could be put down to the snowstorm that swept across New York.

Joey's (Matt LeBlanc) troop of sisters were infrequently spotted together, but the most notable was Dina (Drea de Matteo); she reappeared in season eight, now pregnant. Joey assured Dina that he'd look after both her and his unborn niece before they both vanish from the series, the status of her pregnancy never again voiced.

It's a strenuous undertaking trying to create end points for everyone, but given the noteworthy nature of these characters, a bit more effort could've been put into their departure from Friends.


9. Rachel Needs Glasses, But Never Wears Them

Friends Monica Rachel
NBC

The One Where Ross And Rachel...You Know - the fifteenth episode of season two - centres on Ross and Rachel going on their first date to the movies, with Rachel thereafter grovelling about the movie's subtitles. Apparently, this is due to her need for glasses, which she forbade herself to wear on their first proper date.

It's unfortunate for the writers, then, that this plot point was instantaneously abandoned. Not once throughout the ten seasons of Friends was Rachel seen wearing her specs, nor was it acknowledged why she required them. An uncomplicated one-liner could've been inserted to resolve why, exactly, Rachel has poor vision; explaining that she doesn't want to discuss it, for example, heavily implies a traumatic and/or distressing moment in her life, but it fixes the flaw regardless.

Friends superfans will be aware that it's impractical to think she'd be wearing contact lenses, as it was entrenched in season five's superlative The One With Joey's Big Break that she's frightened of putting anything in her eye. Though this provides viewers with a priceless credits scene where Monica, Phoebe, Ross, and Chandler pin Rachel to the ground to apply her eye drops, it remains a lackadaisical gap in Friends' story.


8. Phoebe's Father Didn't Leave Before She Was Born

Friends Phoebe Frank
NBC

Though season five's The One With Joey's Bag is titularly focused on Joey's 'man's bag' as he attempts to come across chic for an audition, its prevalent story is centred on Phoebe meeting her biological father, Frank (Bob Balaban), during the funeral of her adoptive grandmother, Frances (Audra Lindley).

Sitting down with his daughter at Central Perk, Frank claims to have been a "lousy father" to both Phoebe and Ursula (also Kudrow), having purportedly burned baby formula, put diapers on back-to-front, and made the Buffay twins bawl when signing them a lullaby. He did, however, try his best - which negates what Phoebe had antecedently described her father as.

In season two's The One With Phoebe's Dad, the idiosyncratic Buffay sister claimed that her father had walked out on the family while Phoebe's mother was pregnant with the twins.

This isn't directly an example of Phoebe's word against her father's; it's probable that either Phoebe's biological or adoptive mother told her that's what happened. It's equally as plausible that Phoebe has an erroneous order of events. She was a baby when Frank left and had an agonising childhood, so recollecting the events as they happened in a differential order wouldn't be out of the ordinary.


7. Monica Calls Chandler Her Soulmate - And Then Doesn't Believe In Soulmates

Friends Monica Chandler Wedding
NBC

Friends' seventh season finale - The One With Monica And Chandler's Wedding - is not only the season's most-viewed at 30.1 million viewers, but it's one of the series' most moving, as was the case with the lion's share of Friends' wedding-centric episodes.

Monica and Chandler's vows are distinctly emotional, during which Monica utters the mushy, yet dewy-eyed line, "My prince, my soulmate, my friend". It was an affectionate, dreamy, and tender performance from Monica during what was an affectionate, dreamy, and tender two-parter.

Shame she didn't mean it.

Not in its fullest sense, anyway. Mere episodes later, in season eight's The One Where Joey Tells Rachel, she divulges to Chandler that she doesn't believe in the notion of soulmates after her satirical husband makes the same daring remarks. Instead, Monica claims that she and Chandler weren't predestined to be together, but rather fell in love spontaneously.

This is another delicate performance from Monica as part of the show's most pragmatic relationship. However, if she didn't believe in the concept of soulmates, why did she include the word in her self-written wedding vows? It insinuates that she's going along with the idea due to thinking Chandler does believe in them, which is hardly the best start to a marriage.


6. Phoebe Isn't Entirely Fluent In French

Friends Phoebe
NBC

Season ten's thirteenth episode The One Where Joey Speaks French was subject to what is an uproarious top-five Friends highlight, if not the undisputed funniest, with Phoebe tackling the absurdly hopeless task of teaching French to Joey. Having lied on his résumé about being eloquent in the purported language of love, Joey fails spectacularly.

The comical stint concludes with Phoebe persuading the director (Tim Rhoze) that Joey is her mentally disabled brother, causing him to have sorrow for Joey and letting him down gently. It's an invaluable piece of Friends history for its cheerfulness that stands out as a cherished and revered remembrance of Friends' final season.

While Lisa Kudrow can actually speak some French, it's affirmed that her in-universe character isn't fluent.

Phoebe legitimately did speak French to both Joey and the director, but in season eight's The One With Rachel's Date, she fails to grasp the French meaning of 'sous', believing that Monica's sous-chef Tim (Kevin Rahm) is her boss, rather than Monica being his boss. As someone who's supposedly fluent in the language and given that 'sous' is one of the most commonly-used French words outside the country, it's rather peculiar that Phoebe didn't immediately comprehend who was in charge of the kitchen.


5. Chandler And Rachel Met For The First Time, Twice

Friends Flashbacks high school Ross Chandler Rachel Monica
NBC

Friends nailed the sitcom pilot better than most, but even it didn't come without its own inconsistencies. Such was the case when, upon bungling into the coffee house in her sodden wedding dress, Rachel is acquainted with the gang by Monica, who we come to realise is her friend from high school. This is where Rachel meets for the first time Joey and Phoebe, and sees Ross for the first time in years.

Chandler is also introduced to Rachel, seemingly for the first time, but ensuing seasons of Friends show Rachel and Chandler together almost a decade before the current-day setting Friends is set in. Season ten's The One Where The Stripper Cries even displays the duo making out during a college reunion, the same night that Ross and Rachel allegedly shared their own first kiss, while it's also noted that they spent many Thanksgivings together at the Geller household with their respective closeness with Monica and Ross.

The Friends writing team presumptively didn't expect the show to blow up like it did, leading to such blemishes in the interminable story, and this is barely a scratch on the surface when juxtapositioned against other story-based blunders - but it's still inaccurate.


4. Ross Hates AND Loves Ice Cream

Friends Ross Elizabeth
NBC

Ross is Friends' most perplexing character, requiring several repeat watches of the series to fully fathom each chestnut of his backstory development. He's insecure, a serial husband, and at times a debatably dubious human being, evident when he strikes up a relationship with Elizabeth Stevens (Alexandra Holden), at the time one of Ross' students. It's sketchy and a crude depiction of Ross' underlying character.

His and Elizabeth's relationship is the centric plot point of the season six episode The One Where Ross Dates A Student, during which they grab some ice cream together. This, however, later becomes one of the Geller son's more irrelevant plot holes, as in season seven's eighth episode The One Where Chandler Doesn't Like Dogs, he describes ice cream as "too cold" and harmful to his teeth, purportedly loathing the frozen treat. It's ridiculous and nonsensical, lacking the requirement to be a mentioned plot point; the episode focused on Chandler's apprehension towards dogs, not Ross' towards ice cream.

It's an inconsequential piece of his story as it offers no benefit to following it. It's evidently a transgression on the writers' part and nothing more, though it isn't an exclusive example of Ross being absentminded regarding his past admittances...


3. Ross Forgets His Own Love History

Friends Ross Joey
NBC

Describing Ross Geller as a serial husband and possessing a wedding addiction is an understatement. He was married three times, all of which ended in divorce, had at least five further girlfriends, and a handful of one night stands and one-off kisses; his relationship history categorically rivals that of Joey's when comparing the two.

Ross' infamous time in the bedroom is so padded, in fact, that he can't recall who came first.

A subplot of the fourth episode - The One With George Stephanopoulos - focuses on Chandler and Joey attempting to comfort a despondent Ross, who's mourning the anniversary of when he and Carol first slept together. While at the hospital after Ross has been hammered in the face by a hockey puck, he discloses to the guys that his first time with Carol was his first time with anyone.

Except it wasn't.

In season seven's fourth episode The One With Rachel's Assistant, Ross recalls in college when an inebriated Chandler supposedly slept with the lady who cleaned their dorm. However, Chandler alleges that this was actually Ross, who fails to rebuff the rebounded allegation. Ross was doubtlessly drunk, too, and can't recall the night, but his lack of denial, puzzled look, and third rebuttal that Chandler had slept with a guy in Atlantic City - thus getting the spotlight off his own sexual humiliation - corroborates Ross as the remorseful suspect.


2. Chandler Cries More Than He Realises

Friends Chandler Monica
NBC

Ross' petulance with hastily fast-forwarding relationships is universally as eminent a piece of Friends lore as Chandler's crying impotence.

The backstory was the key plot of season six's fourteenth episode The One Where Chandler Can't Cry, where Monica, Joey, and Phoebe badger Chandler until, eventually, he does finally shed some tears, caused by Ross and Rachel being unable to work out their relationship. Having had his "crying gate opened", Chandler cried again during the episode's credits when Rachel's sister Jill (Reese Witherspoon) storms out of the coffee house.

Although this appears to be a tied-up piece of Friends lore, given how salty and disparaging he often comes across, Chandler has cried on a scattering of occasions, including twice in the fourth season alone. He sobbed in the fourteenth episode The One With Joey's Dirty Day after Phoebe yelled at him for languishing the end of his relationship with Kathy (Paget Brewster), and then in the twenty-second episode The One With The Worst Best Man Ever, where Ross profoundly and emotionally expresses his eagerness for both Chandler and Joey to be his best man.

It's not a vital plot point, but ostensibly the writers implemented the crying impotence storyline as a means of balancing Chandler's leading characteristics so that the typically sarcastic character can, when it's needed for the episode, display empathy and affection without overstepping the mark.


1. Rachel Is Pregnant For 15 Months

Friends Rachel Sandra
NBC

With Monica and Chandler wed, season eight concentrated on Rachel's pregnancy, closing with her giving birth to Emma in the season finale. Upon closer analysis, however, it appears that Rachel withstands an incomprehensible and agonising fifteen-month pregnancy.

For transparency, it's accepted in Friends that one season is proportionate to one year. Rachel first takes a pregnancy test during season eight's first episode The One After I Do, which is still set on the day of Monica and Chandler's wedding. From prior episodes, the wedding date is recognised as being 15 May; this is approximately one month after she would've fallen pregnant, given that Ross states in the third episode - The One Where Rachel Tells... - that he had slept with Rachel "about a month ago".

The season's eighth episode The One With The Rumor is a Thanksgiving-themed episode, indicating Rachel should be seven months pregnant and yet, she has no sign of a bump before she goes into labour in The One Where Rachel Is Late, the twenty-second episode. It's here that Rachel refers to it being summertime, stating that the temperature was 100 degrees. The episode denoted that Rachel was late from going into labour - but up to six months late?

Rachel's pregnancy journey reads like a lethargic attempt was made at plotting the fundamental milestones.


In this post: 
Friends
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Can be found raving about the latest IMPACT Wrestling signing, the Saints Row franchise, and King Shark in The Suicide Squad.