10 Insane X-Files Episodes‏ That Went Unmade

Scully as Scrooge, anyone? We want to believe...

Basically everything good about the modern television renaissance began with The X-Files. Fox's pioneering sci-fi, conspiracy theory, supernatural drama was a total risk when it began in 1993 - a risk that definitely paid off, as it became a ratings and cultural phenomenon, the latter of which lasts until this day. It also paved the way for more daring, experimental and downright weird TV programmes, the likes of which had never been seen before, and acted as a proving ground for writers who would go on to create and run many hit shows we like to have oh-so-serious discussions about around water coolers and internet forums to this day. Pretty impressive given the show was, more often than not, downright insane. Seriously. You know the episode of The Simpsons where David Duchovny and Gillian Anderson guest star as FBI agents Mulder and Scully? That could practically be considered X-Files canon, because the events of that crossover are pretty tame in comparison to the weirdness they investigate on a weekly basis. Over the course of its nine seasons The X-Files featured evil genetically engineered twins, a running joke about porn addiction, Satanic cults, and a whole lot of alien abductions. Oh and that one time that a guy's shrivelled siamese twin kept detaching from his body and eating people. Despite that mountainous pile of insanity, that's not even the weirdest it could've gotten for Fox and Dana. Because whilst the show did include some of the best writers of their generation, who went on to make some pretty great films and other TV shows (although, really, what's creator Chris Carter been up to since the show ended?), they were quite obviously at the beginning of their careers. Early X-Files is a little rough in places, and they got away with far weirder stuff than they would now, but it could be so much weirder. We know, we have proof; rejected scripts and episode ideas have floated around since the show aired and, honestly, there are some gems in there. Totally bonkers, understandably unproduced gems. These are en of the most insane unmade X-Files episodes.

10. The Original Kitsunegari

Many of the original, wackier ideas that got pitched in the X-Files writers' room eventually got reconfigured into actual episodes. That's what happened with Kitsunegari, the fifth season episode about a serial killer nicknamed "The Pusher" for his ability to force his will on others (usually the will for them to, erm, die). Mulder and Scully pursue him after he escapes from prison, having been imprisoned by the dynamic FBI duo in the third season episode Pusher. There's that bit where they discover the prosecutor at The Pusher's trial dead and covered in blue paint. Remember that? That was pretty weird, right? Originally Kitsunegari began as a slightly more grounded, dramatic episode that had more in common with the classic Beyond The Sea story. Tim Minear pitched the idea that involved a convicted criminal, an atheist, who hears the voice of God commanding him to kill a truly evil man, and is teleported out of his cell. As usual, Scully looks for the rational explanation (he's a nut job who broke out of jail) whilst Mulder wants to believe (that he's on a holy mission, we guess?). Unfortunately they needed a script fast, a producer suggested that a prison break episode about The Pusher would be good, and that's what we ended up with.

9. Untitled Dog Stories

Again, the sixth season episode Alpha had its roots in two separate unproduced scripts written for The X-Files. Inspired by Stephen King's killer dog novel Cujo, Alpha centred on a series of murders credited to a bloodthirsty, possibly undead breed of Asian dog, thought to be extinct. Mulder and Scully get teamed up with an eccentric canine expert and the local sheriff - a keen hunter - to deal with it. As per there ends up being more to the episode than just, well, ghost dogs. Writer Jeffrey Bell got to Alpha by fusing together two different ideas he'd had which he rejected because they lacked "really cool visuals". We're not sure about the visuals, but the basic ideas sounded like they would've be kinda awesome. And definitely borderline insane. The first was a self-described reversal of The Incredible Journey, later remade as Homeward Bound - y'know, the live action Disney movie about a three pets who travel through 250 miles of Canadian woodland to get home - that instead featured "a desperate family moves three thousand miles to get away from their killer pet - who's waiting for them at their new house, really pissed". The other idea was about a child who released his anger through the dogs at a local animal shelter, like canine poltergeists.

8. Night Of The Living Dead

Yeah, that's already a film, but like, it's out of copyright, innit? Which is why every Tom, Dick and Weinstein can produce their own sequels, remakes, or just put out the sort of cheapo DVD copies with badly Photoshopped covers you'll find for a quid in The Works. There was a mooted idea, around about the seventh season of The X-Files, that they might produce their own, episode-long remake of the black and white zombie classic - the first movie to depict the undead as shambling, cannibalistic corpses. Only they were going to get George Romero, who made the original film, to direct it. Oh, and his mate Stephen King was going to write it. King had already penned an episode for the show's fifth season, Chinga, which was obviously set in Maine and involved a creepy doll. It was actually his idea to do a monster-of-the-week tale based on Night Of The Living Dead, using his pull with frequent collaborator Romero to not only have him okay the idea but come in to direct it, too. The X-Files staff met with King and Romero yet, for some reason, it never came to fruition. The closest we got was an episode of Millenium about zombies, but that wouldn't have been nearly as odd as Mulder and Scully doing the "they're coming to get you, Barbara!" routine. Imagine if it was in black and white, too!

7. The Song Of The Sun

The X-Files is famous for having one of the most dedicated fan bases in the history of dedicated (read: crazy obsessive) TV show fan bases - in fact, they pretty much set the template for the way online fandoms work, and the way they can affect the production of a show. One such obsessive fan went a step further and actually wrote an episode of the show, all freelance like, only he had a little more pull that the slashfic writers of the usenet message boards. He was Law & Order cameraman DW Paone, a fan of the series from its first broadcast, and he penned a story with author Frank Scoblete. And it sounds delightfully bonkers. Paone and Scoblete's idea centred on the esoteric concept of ancient astronauts, a fringe scientific theory that reckons extraterrestrial beings visited Earth way back in the annals of time, influencing our developments in society, religion and technology. Specifically their script was about the Egyptian Pharaoh Akhenaten as an alien who got resurrected in 1995 and got up to some naughty business, we assume. Thanks to their connections in television the script ended up in the hands of The X-Files producers, who liked it but ended up rejecting the idea as it was deemed to be too expensive to produce on a network TV budget. Which, if you've seen an episode of X-Files, you know it pretty low. Boooo.

6. A Christmas Carol

They actually did end up making a Christmas Carol episode of The X-Files, loosely based on the fifties film adaptation of Dickens' novel starring Alastair Sim, which had Scully going home for the holidays and getting wrapped up in a mystery involving weird phone calls and a little girl who may or may not be her dead sister, Melissa. Which doesn't sound a whole lot like the story of Ebenezer Scrooge, famous douchebag, getting visited by three ghosts and scared into being a better person; instead, she's somehow treated to a load of her younger selves dropping by to give her what for. It's a pretty sweet episode, all told. Originally, though, the writers basically wanted to just take the plot of A Christmas Carol and put Scully in the Scrooge role, without much change to the structure of the ghosts of past, present and future. David Duchovny was busy filming a movie nobody would see (Playing God, for the curious) so he wasn't available for filming Vince Gilligan, John Shiban, and Frank Spotnitz decided to write a Scully-centric episode. Their attempts at making Dana go full Ebenezer failed - since she's isn't a famous douchebag, for the most part - and they changed it up. We'd still like to see Scully telling an orphan to buy a big goose, mind.

5. Flight 108

Believe it or not, The X-Files often drew on real-world events for their scripts. We're not sure if, like, the Flukeman was a ripped-from-the-headlines deal - and for the sake of our nightmares, please say it wasn't - but they often took news stories and gave them a supernatural spin. One such event was the tragic fate of TWA Flight 800, a domestic airliner which exploded and crashed into the Atlantic Ocean on the approach to New York in July of 1996. All 230 passengers were killed, making it the third-deadliest aviation accident in US history. Sounds like a good case for Mulder and Scully, thought Jeffrey Reddick! Of course, just having them investigate a plane crash would not also be pretty un-X-Files, but probably not their jurisdiction. We know most of the things Dana and Fox get up to aren't actually the job of the FBI, but still. How do you make it weird? "I read this story about a woman who was on vacation and her mom called her and said 'Don't take the flight tomorrow, I have a really bad feeling about it'," remembers Reddick. "She switched flights and the plane that she would have been on crashed. I thought, that€™s creepy - what if she was supposed to die on that flight?" Sounds familiar, huh? That's because, after the idea was rejected by Chris Carter, X-Files writers Glen Morgan and James Wong took it, and made it into Final Destination.

4. Unsolved Mysteries

The X-Files has gotten pretty meta at times. For some reason it went all self-reflexive and post-modern in the seventh season with two episodes: X-Cops was a fictional crossover with reality show cops, as a camera crew followed Mulder and Scully over the course of an investigation, and had that fun reggae theme song we all know the words to. Then there was Hollywood AD, when an enterprising film producer buys the rights to make a movie based on the extraterrestrial escapades of our favourite FBI partners. Vince Gilligan was angling for such an episode way earlier than that, however, pitching an Unsolved Mysteries show all the way back in the fifth season. Unsolved Mysteries was an enjoyable bit of hokum that used to air on NBC back in the day, hosted by Hollywood actor Robert Stack, talking through ridiculous tales of the supernatural, weird coincidences and UFOs, accompanied by reenactments with an even lower budget than, well, an episode of the X-Files. Gilligan's plan was to frame an entire story as an Unsolved Mysteries episode, hosted by Stack, with Mulder and Scully played by stand-in actors wearing bad wigs. Unfortunately it never got off the ground, and it was switched in for the vampire story Bad Blood - when we could've had, like, sci-fi Crimewatch X-Files.

3. Dark He Was and Golden-Eyed

Eugene Victor Tooms is one of the most frightening monsters not just in the history of The X-Files, but probably in TV as a whole. The stretchy, liver-eating immortal with the creepy eyes only appeared in the first season, but he remained in our nightmares forevermore. He was a pretty great villain, and everybody involved in creating him should be proud of the part they played; except Doug Hutchinson. Doug Hutchison was a little bit too into the character he played. Hutchinson also hit on the (married) Gillian Anderson on set and later gained notoriety for marrying 16-year-old Courtney Stodden when he was pushing fifty, so you know the guy's gotta be a little nutty. One of his more insane, early moments was when he decided to write his own sequel to Squeeze, the episode that introduced the Tooms character. With a Ray Bradbury-riffing title, Dark He Was And Golden Eyed was a little less workable TV script, more fan fiction. Hutchinson's script was "an experiment to find out how I could remain so young and immortal; he was infused with a drug that backfired and ended up escaping the asylum. So now he€™s eating livers like M&Ms - he€™s on a rampage!", positing Tooms was the reincarnation of "a ravenous, liver-eating Central American Indian God". Carter and crew returned the script for "legal reasons" and wrote their own, much less ridiculous, second appearance for the monster. And Tooms was involved too! Wacca wacca.

2. Abraham Lincoln's Ghost

Abraham Lincoln was a great man. He managed to outlaw slavery in the US, attempted to unite the warring sides of the Civil War into a more perfect union, and did it all whilst sporting some sweet muttonchops and a stove pipe hat. For many, however, he is remembered as the presidential ghost who simply can't get enough of the White House and haunts it to this day. Seriously, many are insistent that they've seen old Honest Abe floating around the hallways of the Oval Office, apparently ever since his death (one photo of his widow purportedly features her assassinated husband putting a calming hand on her shoulder). So, obviously, there should be an X-Files episode about it! A little less offensive than the airline crash inspiration, we suppose. Glen Morgan and James Wong were gearing up to start working on spin-off show Millenium, but not before developing a story that was a "sort of Abraham Lincoln€™s ghost in the White House type of thing". The script was to feature Mulder and Scully investigating reports of the presidential haunting, partly because Morgan had "done a lot of research and I had always wanted to write a feature about Lincoln€™s ghost". Unfortunately the writing partnership could never quite crack it, the amount of time they spent drafting and rewriting the screenplay meaning they had to move onto other things. They lost interest and felt the producers had, too, Morgan stating "I felt they didn't want my heart and soul anymore, so I wouldn't give this one to them". Goofy though the idea was - and undoubtedly a little insane - we would've liked to see what they'd done with it.

1. The Tilt-A-Whirl Hostage Taker

Vince Gilligan wasn't always the maverick TV writing genius we all came to admire/worship when he came up with Breaking Bad. Before he hit on the (admittedly insane on paper) concept of a meth-making, cancer-ridden chemistry teacher, he cut his teeth pitching and penning some of the weirder X-Files episodes we saw during the show's nine season run. He even wrote an episode starring his Breaking Bad lead, Bryan Cranston, about a crazy man who kidnaps Mulder and forces him to drive across the country - is he deranged, or is he onto one of those sweet government conspiracies Fox loves so much? He's definitely an anti-semite, that's for sure. The premise of Drive has its origins in a much different, much more ridiculous pitch Gilligan had, however. So insane and ridiculous, in fact, that it became something of a running joke in the writers' room. So, like, you know Tilt-A-Whirls? Over here we call them Waltzers, those low-risk, low-adrenaline fairground rides where you sit in a spinning cup that goes round and round a conveyer belt? Yeah, Gilligan's original idea was that somebody would get taken hostage on a circus attraction that doesn't even move that fast. That was an idea the creator of Breaking Bad pitched multiple times. Alongside the obviously ridiculous elements of that concept, the writers pointed out some other glaring flaws in the idea: the Tilt-A-Whirl lacked any explicit mystery for Mulder and Scully to investigate. Which is how he decided to add that, after the ride was shut off, the hostage taker's head would explode. Which was still very, very silly, and didn't work until it was adapted to the Speed-esque scenario of Drive, with secret government experiments into low-frequency waves as a weapon thrown in the mix. The end result is pretty great but still, an high-stakes hostage negotiation on a Tilt-A-Whirl starring Walter White? That would have been a sight to behold.

In this post: 
The X-Files
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/