10 Moments That Gave Fanboys A Bad Name
June of this year saw the launch a Kickstarter campaign to put a scale model of the Tardis containing a hard drive and a Go-Pro camera into orbit. It reached almost triple its funding goal of $33,000 and is a wonderful example of how fandom can bring people together and achieve incredible things. Sadly though, a lot of fandoms have a dark side. A small toxic element that ruins it for everyone or makes the entire fandom look like idiots because of their stupid antics. Sometimes it's one or two nutters like the fans who tried to cut off the power to a hotel JLS were staying in order to lure them outside, but sometimes it's larger groups embarrassing their fandoms. Here are some of these groups and the stupid things they did... 10. The Twelfth Doctor's Internet Backlash
It's pretty telling of the attitude of some Doctor Who fans that all Peter Capaldi had to do was walk onto a set and do a brief interview before the backlash against him playing the Twelfth Doctor began. Minutes after his reveal, a small but vocal minority of fans on social networking sites such as Facebook and Twitter posted criticisms that, at the age of 55, Peter Capaldi was too old to play the role and that the Doctor needs to be played by a younger actor. Despite the fact that William Hartnell was 56 when he took on the role, and that out of twelve, only four Doctors have been under the age of 40 in their first appearance. To get a sense of how some Whovians reacted to the casting of Capaldi, here are a small selection of some of the anti-Capaldi comments taken from Doctor Who and the T.A.R.D.I.S., a Doctor Who fanpage on Facebook with 328,000 fans: "the MAJORITY of people watching the show are YOUNG! So we dont want a freakin' old bat we want someone we could say "damn hes hot"" "I do not like this at all. I'm sorry, but you can't just throw someone as old and unattractive at us after 3 really good looking doctors." "Why an old guy, :( no fun in watching a old guy prance around with that new chick Clara o.o (pedo much)" "I have no idea who this guy is, all I know is that he's ugly as sin. What a bummer."And my personal favourite partly because it's still harping on about David Tennant three and half years after he left:
"dude.... HE'S SO OLD WHAT'S UP WITH THAT ?!?!?!?!?!?! NOBODY CAN BEAT TENNANT, STOP TRYING!!! JUST GET A GUY THAT'S AT LEAST CRUSHABLE FOR GIRLS!! COME ON BRO"This immediate criticism of Peter Capaldi over his age despite the fact that he had not even appeared in character and is a BAFTA-winning actor and Oscar-winning director showed that a sizeable minority of Doctor Who fans (most of whom are young women) are only interested in the programme if the Doctor is played by somebody they can have a crush on. Which is missing the point of Doctor Who completely.
9. Brokeback Mountain Fans Send Rewrites To Its Author
8. Free The Weatherfield One
Whatever you may think of soap fans (people with an unhealthy interest in the welfare of sheep if they're Emmerdale fans, and horny teenagers if they're watching Hollyoaks), one thing you can always say about them is that, on the whole, they have a fully functional sense of perspective and don't get sucked into it too much like some other fandoms. But then came the "Free The Weatherfield One" campaign and the line between fiction and reality began to blur. In 1998, when the ratings war between Coronation Street and Eastenders was at its peak, ITV pulled out its ace with a storyline where long-running character Deirdre Rachid was falsely imprisoned for fraud after being framed by her lover. What followed was an outcry from fans who clearly had too much time on their hands and more free publicity in the newspapers than anyone would be capable of buying. Granada's (the programme's producers) switchboards were jammed and the tabloids started a "Free The Weatherfield One" campaign, giving out free stickers and t-shirts. It's one thing when a few nutty fans jump on a bandwagon like this. But when a ludicrous campaign advocating the freedom of a fictional character gets the support of the tabloid press and a Birmingham MP as well as catching the attention of the Prime Minister, you know that something has gone seriously wrong. Bizarrely, the Daily Mail were the only ones making sense by accusing the nation of "mass madness". Eventually, Deirdre was released, ITV were able to chalk up a big victory against the BBC in the perpetual war of the soaps, and the nation returned to a state of relative sanity.
7. Avatar Syndrome
6. One Direction Fans Riot
The more devoted fans of chart-topping boy band One Direction have a reputation for being... a little overzealous. A recent Channel 4 documentary showed the extent of some fans' devotion including waiting in the lobby of the group's hotel and hurling online abuse at Taylor Swift for breaking up with band member Harry Styles. But what happened in Los Angeles on the 3rd of August this year puts that in the shade. A cinema in LA was showing an advance screening of the One Direction documentary film This Is Us, which premiered in Leicester Square earlier this week. The screening had a limited number of attendees and a large number of the fans who had queued up (some as early as quarter to four in the morning) weren't able to get seats. So presumably they cut their losses, went home, and made plans to see it after its general release. Oh no. L.A. Times journalist Amy Kaufman (who was attending the screening) tweeted that roughly 200 fans had rushed the cinema and pushed past security in an attempt to get into the screening room after being turned away at the door. Things got so out of hand that the doors of the screening room had to be barricaded and the Los Angeles Police Department were called to restore order. All because of a group of teenage girls' unrelenting desire to see a film. And not one that was a live stream of a concert, but a documentary film that was only a few weeks from getting a multinational release. Boyband fandom certainly seems to have stepped up a gear since the days of The Beatles.
5. Ianto Jones' Death And Its Backlash
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fWEm49c4TRI I'd like to preface this entry by pointing out that the "Save Ianto Jones" campaign raised nearly £16,000 for Children In Need, which is another sign of how fandom can achieve great things. But beyond that, their disproportionate reaction to the death of Torchwood character Ianto Jones didn't help the fandom's image. In 2009, at the climax of Torchwood: Children Of Earth's fourth episode, Ianto Jones (one of the three main characters) was killed off. Most fans accepted it as a dramatic part of the narrative, some (like me for instance) couldn't give a monkey's right nut if he lived or died, and some took it hard. So hard that they decided to stand up for what they believed in and campaign for Ianto's resurrection, basically killing any chance they had of being considered well-adjusted in the process. The most well known reaction to Ianto's death is that there is a shrine in Cardiff Bay to the character. A shrine for a fictional character that still exists, is added to and maintained by fans four years after the character was killed off, and has now become something of a tourist attraction. But, as one of my friends pointed out to me, as disproportionate as that response is, it's relatively harmless. But away from the more or less harmless public mourning of a fictional character, there was an active campaign to resurrect the character and a vicious internet backlash to the episode where the character died.
Websites like this one were started shortly after the episode aired, urging viewers to inundate the BBC with letters of complaint and to send bags of coffee to the Director General, since one of Ianto's traits in Torchwood's early episodes was how good the coffee he made was. I personally see this as these fans having way too much investment in the programme since they were willing to spend time and money pestering the BBC about reviving a fictional character. But again, this was relatively harmless and probably cut the BBC's coffee expenditure down a fair bit. But it wasn't all harmless lunacy otherwise it barely would have qualified for this list. The episode's writer James Moran received a torrent of abuse over the internet which he discussed here, including accusations of homophobia because Ianto was gay, and requests for him to pass on abusive comments to other people who worked on the episode in question. As well as the abuse to James Moran and other people involved with the programme, a schism later developed in the "Save Ianto" movement and some members split off with the intent of ceasing the more fun elements of the campaign and militarising (for lack of a better word) the attempts to bring back Ianto. Luckily, this attempt at a more hardline approach never came to fruition and that side of the campaign died out while the other more reasonable side eventually stopped actively campaigning for Ianto's resurrection and now hold annual events to raise money for charity. We geeks have enough image problems to fight as it is without people like this who can't accept change and act both irrationally and hatefully, making it harder for the rest of us to improve the image of both geekdom and sci-fi fans in general.
4. Cut For Bieber
When it comes to mockery and general loathing, Justin Bieber is an incredibly easy target for people. He's like a great big hate magnet. And it's understandable to some extent, given that he frequently acts like a complete tool. But while Bieber's frequent gaffes make him an easy target for mockery, his fans shouldn't be treated badly for liking him. In 2012, somebody started a "Cut For Bieber" campaign on Twitter, urging Justin Bieber's fans to cut themselves as a way of urging him to stop smoking marijuana. The initial Tweets were revealed as a prank by some sick individual who should seriously reassess their life, but the disturbing thing is that some fans actually went along with it. Twitter was suddenly filled with photos of people's arms that had been sliced open in a bizarre act of devotion. How many were real and how many were fake is open to speculation but it's generally accepted that at least a few were real. I understand fan devotion but there never has and never will be a reason related to any of my fandoms that would cause me to self harm. Obviously, teenage girls are impressionable and some will always do stupid things but this takes the biscuit. Cut For Bieber not only proved that there are some people on the internet who seriously deserve a punch in the face (the pranksters, not the Bieber fans) but also that there are some fans of Justin Bieber who really need to try and establish some balance in their lives. The people who like Bieber's music and aren't squealing fangirls that treat him like some kind of deity (assuming that those two categories aren't mutually exclusive) have been overshadowed by these kind of crazies ever since he became a big star. A generalisation that isn't helped by people who believe (regardless of whether or not they are spurred on by some sicko on the internet) that he's worth scarring themselves for.
3. Cloppers
Despite Rule 34 of the internet (If it exists, there is porn of it), there are many things that, luckily, you will never find pornographic fanart of. I'm sad to say that My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic is not one of those things. I'd like to start by making the point that Bronies (fans of My Little Pony) are not bad people. I'm friends with several Bronies and they are all friendly and well adjusted people who just happen to be fans of a cartoon about magic ponies. But on the other hand there are the Cloppers, the disturbing lovers of pornographic My Little Pony artwork and fanfiction that give Bronies everywhere a bad name. Much like how a lot of people think that all Furries are Yiffers (the distinct minority of people whose interest in the furry fandom is sexual), any Friendship Is Magic fans that aren't pre-teen girls are automatically assumed to be your standard basement-dwelling weirdos, an image problem that isn't helped by the Cloppers. This Tumblr account contains a number of stories about how some Friendship Is Magic fans left the fandom because of Cloppers overrunning forums with My Little Pony porn, with some developing a persecution complex and others claiming that they are more devoted than the average fan because they spend their free time drawing pornographic images of cartoon ponies. If you masturbate to cartoon ponies and think that it somehow makes you superior to those who don't, then you are in serious need of some form of psychiatric treatment. And don't even get me started on the person who spent $1025 on a fan-drawn My Little Pony porn comic called Hoof Beat. Being a Brony comes with a stigma. It's a strong possibility that, no matter how intelligent and successful you are, you'll get pigeonholed as somebody with some kind of personality disorder simply because My Little Pony is perceived as something that only children should like. And the kind of perverts that create and share pornographic fanart are not helping that image problem.
2. Attack Of The Batman Fanboys
1. Steven Moffat, Twitter, And Death Threats
I've written about this in depth before but it was such a disheartening and ludicrous episode in the history of Doctor Who fandom that it bears repeating. A lot of Steven Moffat fans have no issue with people who don't like him. Discussing the issue is always interesting, there's a lot of room for give and take, and the arguments are usually restrained and civilised. But thanks to the advent of the internet, lunatic fans now have a large platform to make idiots of themselves, ruin fandom for the rest of us, and generally act like dicks with little fear of retribution. A minority of Doctor Who fans are unhappy with the way Moffat is running things, criticising what they see as an excess of overly complex stories, plot holes, and River Song as well as perceived sexism and homophobia which I discussed at length in my previous piece. Were this the 1970s, showrunners Robert Holmes and Graham Williams would most likely have received a few letters from lone fans. But because fandom has evolved since then (thanks largely to the internet itself), annoyed fans now take to the internet on various forums, blogs, and of course Twitter to vent their frustration. And that's when this sad debacle began. The anti-Moffat brigade decided to turn their attention to Twitter and a stream of Tweets were sent to him that actor Martin Freeman's partner Amanda Abbington described as "incredibly offensive". Moffat himself has said that " wanted to beat me up," and "I'm tired of being threatened and sworn at". Eventually he deleted his Twitter account and, in an interview with his son on YouTube, has ruled out a return to it. There has never been any direct confirmation that people were threatening to kill Moffat, but what is widely known is that Amanda Abbington received death threats for defending Moffat and calling out the abusive Tweeters, which she responded to brilliantly here. The official story is that Moffat left Twitter so he wouldn't be distracted by it when working. But I personally think that it's way too big of a coincidence and believe that his decision to leave was somewhere between the two. Both a way to minimise work distractions, and to deliver a much justified middle finger to the abusive non-fans as well as finding a way to escape the morons who think that he was deserving of abuse simply for not writing Doctor Who in a way that they approve of. Especially since, before deleting his account, he posted a Tweet asking if there was a way to limit the people following him. But obviously unless Moffat confirms otherwise, this is nothing more than a theory. Not only do these pseudo-fans have incredibly skewed priorities in their lives, but they also have serious entitlement issues if they think that threatening to kill Amdana Abbington and abusing Steven Moffat for not doing things their way is justified. In short: grow up. What moments do you think gave fanboys and fangirls a bad name? Leave a comment...
