10 Most Underrated South Park Characters

We all know roles like Cartman, but which South Park characters fly under the radar?

Craig Tucker South Park
Comedy Central

Trey Parker and Matt Stone are absolute geniuses when it comes to making a mark on TV. Their animated cartoon has had a profound impact on the world of the small screen, and a lot of that has come down to the wonderful and expansive collection of characters that permeate this small Colorado town.

However, when a show runs for over 20 seasons and features as many roles as this, some are inevitably going to fall to the wayside. That is certainly the case with South Park, as the large cast of the snowy mountain town have a fair few names within it who don't get the credit they deserve.

Some of the following entries feature characters who have major storyline significance and a constant presence in the series but aren't as respected as they should be. Whereas other entries include characters who have appeared very little, but are compelling and funny enough to deserve more.

With the show still running and remaining relatively appreciated, there is still a lot of potential for these characters to come into their own and gain the recognition that they deserve. However, it seems thoroughly unlikely this will happen, so for now let's give them the spotlight they have earned.

10. DogPoo Petuski

South Park Dog Poo
Comedy Central

You may recognise this strange character, but not entirely know him. He has been a persistent presence in South Park even since the pilot episode, and has appeared in the background of the school and town in almost every chapter of the show, but has only ever spoken in one episode.

The unfortunately named DogPoo Petuski is easily recognisable as he always appears covered in dirt and presumably some dog faeces. He didn't speak at all up until the season six episode Professor Chaos, where he was one of the potential new friends for the boys.

When interviewed, he spoke with surprising elegance and even discussed how he'd been here the whole time, but no one had noticed him. This meta-joke was a grand reveal, but sadly it never developed any further as after this, he went back to his standard position as an extra.

The character does deserve a little more focus, but it is quite funny that he receives none. Ultimately, he is a thoroughly underrated character who could have been built up to more significance in the show.


9. Shelley Marsh

Shelly Marsh South Park
Comedy Central

The Marsh family are arguably the most essential unit in the series outside of the leading boys' friendship group. The dynamic between this domestic household is incredibly wild and often leads to some of the most interesting narratives for the show.

Each of them has a strong position, as Stan is the leading boy, Randy is an absolute mess and Sharon is the voice of reason character. However, while Shelley has a strong personality as the aggressive and grumpy older sister to Stan, she does not get the screen-time or narrative potential that she is worthy of receiving.

As a tremendous antagonistic force for Stan, she really could be utilised more and be as a bigger part of the Marsh family. It is often easy to forget about her presence, as the importance of the other characters overshadows her. But her position as a young pubescent girl has a lot of potential that hasn't been explored as much as it could be.

In a sea of over the top characters, Shelley still stands out, and for that she deserves a little more attention.


8. Al Gore

Al Gore South Park
Comedy Central

When South Park first fully parodied Al Gore in season ten, it was by mocking his obsession with ManBearPig - a metaphor for global warming. The joke mostly revolved around the character's inflated sense of importance, and the fact that most people ignored him. So, when global warming and climate change became a much bigger deal in the modern era, it made perfect sense to bring him back.

The incredibly silly and always funny appearances of Al Gore are a highlight for the show, as his obsession with ManBearPig treads the line between too goofy and genuinely political perfectly. He has developed throughout the series, slowly becoming more elusive and odd, but always maintaining the same amount of laughs.

The reason he is an underrated character comes from the fact that his presence in the show doesn't occur as much as it could. Because Al Gore is a real person they probably don't want to include him too much, admittedly, but he has evolved into less of a parody and more a distinct South Park character.

As a character in his own right - ignoring his real world inspiration - he should be more appreciated by the fandom and the creators.


7. Scott Malkinson

Scott Malkinson South Park And The Stick Of Truth
Ubisoft

This poor little guy suffers so much at the hands of the leading boys - especially Cartman - but as a significant supporting character, he deserves a lot more attention.

Scott Malkinson's diabetes are a big point of contention for Eric, as he mocks him for it regularly. At first, this makes him seem like an insignificant role, purely put in the show for the sake of being bullied. But other characters have actually found themselves in a similar position and risen to prominence, with one prolific example being Butters.

So what does Malkinson bring to the table? For starters, his voice is incredibly amusing, as the performance given by Matt Stone feels entirely appropriate for the character, particularly the use of a lisp which helps give him this innocent and vulnerable appearance. Additionally, his position as a character with a genuine medical condition could actually be used more frequently, but as a source of narrative and not comedy.

South Park is a show that loves to take its minor characters and put them in the spotlight, and little Scott Malkinson deserves that light to shine on him.


6. Mr Hat

South Park Mr Hat
Comedy Central

Ditching Mr Hat was one of the best things Mr Garrison ever did, as after he lost the obnoxious finger puppet his character could delve into far more dark territory, without the childish and goofy presence of the silly puppet. However, just because the split from his owner was a good thing, doesn't mean that he isn't an underrated role.

The character of Mr Hat may not be anything but an inanimate object, but the little guy has so much personality. The last time we saw him was in episode six of season 14 entitled "201", but from then on it has been radio silence from the stripy hatted figure.

Mr Hat had a lot of fun potential as a character. However, his pairing with Mr Garrison just didn't work out in the end. Had he been placed with a slightly less interesting role then he could have made a perfect consistent addition to the cast. But with all that said and done, he is ultimately irrelevant, and the show treated him as such.

It is a shame too, as the offensive and often aggressive personality of the finger puppet was a unique part of the show, and he deserves to be remembered more fondly.


5. Pip Pirrip

South Park Pip
Comedy Central

This peculiar little guy stood out like a sore thumb in the early days of South Park, and that seemed to be a deliberate effort from the creators. His British accent and a rather pathetic personality made him an instant target for ridicule, and this was practically all he existed for. However, other characters like Butters quickly took over in this position, and as such, Pip faded into irrelevance.

The character was heavily inspired by the protagonist of the same name in Charles Dickens' Great Expectations. This literary connection was funny but did make him feel thoroughly out of place in a mean-spirited cartoon. As we've already noted, he was always treated poorly, and that was particularly evident in his demise which saw him crushed by Mecha-Streisand in episode "201".

By the point of his death, he had already fallen out of the recurring cast, and had simply become an unimportant relic of the show. But Pip was still an amusing character and an early example of the more mature and informed comedy that Parker and Stone would bring to the series later on.

He even took the leading role in the episode Pip that parodied the book he is based upon, a real outlandish move for this silly cartoon.


4. Clyde Donavan

Clyde Donnavan South Park
Comedy Central

It is easy to think of Clyde as one of the blandest characters in South Park, but that is essentially what makes him such a funny part of the show. The little Colorado town is full of over-the-top characters who are either aggressive, mean, or ridiculous, but Clyde exists outside of these archetypes, as his flaws and personality are more grounded.

One of his most prominent character traits is his vanity, which is fully exploited in the episode "The List". This character - who never had much reason to be in the show outside of enlarging the cast - suddenly became a pivotal role in this episode and fully allowed his arrogance to consume him. This was incredibly funny and would go on to be a factor of Clyde's persona from then on.

Clyde is simply a child that feels "normal" in this collection of wild students, and as such he fits into any slot that he is given perfectly. The other children treat him with a similar lack of interest, which is a source of conflict for Clyde, even going on to turn him into a primary antagonist in the Stick of Truth game.

He isn't as vibrant as the others, but his vanity combined with a sense of dullness makes him one of the more realistic depictions of an elementary school student in South Park.


3. Bebe Stevens

South Park Bebe Stevens
Comedy Central

If there is one place where South Park lacks, it is undoubtedly in its female characters. When thinking about the children of South Park, the two most prominent female voices are that of Wendy Testaburger and Bebe Stevens. Although Bebe doesn't shine as much as Wendy, she has had some great showings in the series, albeit sporadically.

Viewers have seen glimpses of her potential as an important figure, such as in the episodes "The List" and "Bebe's Boobs Destroy Society". In both of these narratives, she played a vital role, first as an antagonist, and then a central figure.

Another of her most notable appearances was the episode "Clubhouses" which saw her develop a crush on Kyle and become obsessed with his "fine ass". Seeing this kind of behaviour in the show, and Kyle's ignorance towards its implications was incredibly juvenile and amusing at the same time.

Having an additional female perspective outside of Wendy is a great way to invoke narratives, and it's a shame that there isn't more frequent use of it. One thing is for sure, and that is that Bebe could be capable of a lot more, and doesn't get the respect she deserves for the flirty yet aggressive antics she brings to the show.


2. Craig Tucker

Craig Tucker South Park
Comedy Central

The build-up to Craig's introduction was executed with so much skill, as he was a persistent presence - much like DogPoo - before he finally got the chance to speak. Every time the boys were taken to the counsellor's office, audiences saw Craig sat outside. It was clear that whoever this kid was, he certainly knew how to get into trouble, and when he first spoke, it was easy to see why.

From the offset, Craig Tucker is presented as not caring about anything. The rules and regulations of the school do not matter to him as he sneakily flips off Mr Mackey with no concern at all. This personality trait would continue with him and become a central part of his character.

Craig is funny because he simply doesn't care, and delivers everything with a flat, deadpan tone. He has been given plenty of notable moments in the show, with the most prevalent being his part in the Peruvian flute pandemic two-part special and his relationship with Tweak.

Despite his prominent position, Craig tends to fly under the radar as his comedy relies more on reservation and subtlety, making him appear less interesting than the outlandish and louder humour of the other characters. Despite this, he deserves far more recognition than he gets.


1. Karen McCormick

South Park Karen McCormick Guardian Angel
Comedy Central

This character's position at the top of this list is less conventional than the other entries, and that comes from the fact that she isn't necessarily underrated because of her personality. Karen McCormick isn't given much in regards to her character, she is simply the youngest member of the McCormick family, but it's her connection with Kenny which is under-appreciated.

One of the most emotional moments in the entire show comes from the relationship Karen has with her brother. He uses his Mysterion persona to protect her multiple times, and thus she dubs him her "Guardian Angel". It is a delightful narrative that lends a lot to the character of Kenny and reveals a lot about the innocence of Karen.

This narrative itself just isn't appreciated as it should be, and the dynamic between the two could be a far more prevalent part of the series. She does get some development, even turning into a Vampire kid in the games and show, but doesn't get the spotlight away from this.

The dynamic between this brother and sister could have been a great aspect of the show, and one of the characters behind it is thoroughly underrated.


In this post: 
South Park
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Michael is my name, overanalysing comedy is my game! Anime, wrestling, TV, movies and video games all live in my head rent free!