10 Star Trek Debates That Tear The Fandom Apart
These Star Trek topics are guaranteed to fuel a night of debate between the staunchest fans of the franchise
In any fandom, there are those passionate folks who will go out of their way to defend their positions. TrekCulture is no stranger to this, nor are we innocent. We believe what we believe, and we do our best to offer a balanced argument to support said beliefs. The differences through the fandom often show their hands in how these arguments are handled.
Two or more may stand on opposite sides of the aisle having an impassioned discussion as to whether Kirk or Picard are the better captain, but as long as it remains on either side, then it’s simple discourse. Every so often, something will come along that will whip people into a frenzy.
Sadly, many of these frenzies can quickly devolve into slanging matches, with all reasoned debate leaving the room as quickly as someone can say ‘not a real fan’. The goalposts as to what qualifies one as a ‘real fan’ often change mid argument as well, especially when one combatant realises that their position is less secure than they might like.
This article is not designed to paint any position (within reason - racism for example being a non-negotiable topic, as it should be) as more or less correct than any other. There are plenty of commenters who will do that without our help. Here, we will focus on the catalyst for many of these debates.
10. Tuvix
There mere mention of the name Tuvix is usually enough to inflame social media for a few days, with the usual arguments centering on whether or not Captain Janeway was justified in her actions. As most will know, Tuvix was the result of a transporter accident that fused Tuvok and Neelix, seemingly forever, until it was discovered the accident could be reversed. Though this would save the two men, it was certain death for Tuvix, who was a fully sentient being, one intent on staying alive.
Consider the arguments - who had the greater right to live? Two men who had gone into a transporter, just like any other day. These men had friends, families, responsibilities - they were living, breathing beings. Surely, they had the greater right to live. Next, there is Tuvix himself. He is a being created accidentally, yet is no less sentient than the other two. He quickly assumed duties aboard Voyager, and thanks to Tom Wright’s excellent performance, displays a grand depth of emotional understanding.
Let us be clear - sending Tuvix back into the transporter is an execution, despite it being one for the best possible reasons. By simple definition, Janeway is guilty of murder - something Lower Decks poked fun at in their fourth season opener Twovix. She is also a life-saver, returning both Tuvok and Neelix to life as they knew it. Much of the discourse focuses on this element, while other voices speak of right to life, and anti-corporal punishment. This is a topic where there is no clear correct answer - every turn seems to have at least some merit. It is therefore hardly a surprise that there can be little consensus on the matter.
9. The Kelvin Universe
STAR TREK IS DEAD!
In 2009, Star Trek exploded onto screens with a flurry of lens flares, fast moving ships, faster moving people, and a bombastic score that fit the mood. This came four years after the cancellation of Star Trek: Enterprise - a show with considerably less lens flares - and seven years after the poor box office that Star Trek: Nemesis received. In terms of Hollywood, it is a little bit remarkable that such a big budget endeavour was gambled on a franchise that had, for all intents and purposes, died.
Rebooting familiar properties is also something of a safe bet for movie studios that want more return than risk, but Star Trek had never truly dazzled at the box office - despite some impressive returns from The One With The Whales - so a complete tonal shift was employed to make it more marketable to the summer blockbuster crowd. Therein lay the first line that some Trekkies struggled to cross. How could this film - so utterly different in look and feel - truly be a part of the overall franchise? Having Star Trek exist within its own continuity was a wise move, even if that stoked more anger from those who wished to see the existing universe more fully explored. Casting Leonard Nimoy certainly helped allay some of those fears, as there are few more recognisable ears in Sci-Fi.
While there is little doubt that, financially at least, J.J. Abrams’ gamble paid off, the Kelvin Universe films remain hotly contested in the fandom. There are those who drink them up gladly, while others simply tolerate their existence. There are those who simply ignore them, while more vehemently decry their existence - resolutely stating that Abrams & co attempted to murder the franchise. With the years passing, and little hope of Star Trek 4 on the horizon, it seems as though this is one argument, at least, that may be confined to three films and a couple of television references.
8. Prime Universe Vs. Discovery
Bryan Fuller and Alex Kurtzman - the latter of whom worked on the Kelvin films, the former of whom worked on the 90s and 00s era shows - developed the idea for this prequel series, Star Trek: Discovery. The word Prequel alone is enough to fuel some fires, with an argument being - why go backwards to tamper with established history, when one can go forwards and create more? This same argument had been levelled against Enterprise when it was announced in 2001, yet Discovery went one step (well, several steps, but we’ll come to that) further - their main character was the previously unheard of sister of Spock.
Making Michael Burnham the adopted sister of Spock puzzled the fandom, to put it mildly. How would she fit into established canon? Why had we never heard of her before? There were those who were quick to point out that no one had heard of Sybok until more than twenty years after we had been introduced to Spock, so who knew how many children were running around out there?
Then that image of those Klingons having lunch was released, and the conversations erupted.
Even now, seven years, five seasons, and a time jump later, the debate about which universe Discovery exists in rages on. It signalled the beginning of an aesthetic shift in Star Trek that seemed to actively disregard what had come before, as well as upgrading technology that - according to strict canon - simply shouldn’t have existed in that time. The violence of the show’s first season riled people, as well as the dour overall tone. Discovery’s first season was polarising. The argument as to its place in canon has by no means faded but the arrival of four new shows - one of which being a direct spin-off from Discovery - with more on the way has diluted some of the argument.
Even some of the people involved in making shows like The Next Generation, Voyager, and Enterprise have come out to say that they consider it an alternate timeline. Now that the show has completed its run, we the audience have entered into our post-mortem phase. Much like Enterprise before it, it is receiving reappraisals. What might the discourse be in five, ten, or fifteen years?
7. Star Trek: Picard Season 3
The glorious return of The Next Generation crew was met with near-universal acclaim upon the release of Star Trek: Picard’s third season. This was a complete shift from the first two seasons of the show, both of which had met mixed reviews, with some of the discourse focusing on the tonal shifts from The Next Generation, while others felt the lack of familiar elements was the issue. The inclusion of the Discovery-era Constitution-class ship in the show’s second episode did little to quell these fires.
So, the Terry Matalas helmed third season seemed to listen to all of these criticisms and take them on board. We had far more familiar looking starships, with the Titan-A clearly inspired by the movie-era Constitution-class Enterprise. We knew going into the season that the entire main crew would return, and as the show went on we were treated to more Easter eggs than Cetacean Observations could really handle. All of our dreams came true, you’d think?
The discussions online in the aftermath of the season have been varied. There are those who only view it as the true Star Trek sequel since Enterprise, fuelling cries for Star Trek: Legacy to be greenlit, following the crew of the Enterprise-G. Then there are those who feel it relied too heavily on nostalgia, sacrificing logic to suit the adventure. Still others felt it suffered a lack of imagination, and yet more had serious concerns over the themes of family and identity that were presented.
Picard’s third season is one of the most discussed seasons of Trek in years, for all of the above and more. Now, over a year since its airing, the calls for Legacy seem to be falling on deaf ears, while the creative team have begun to move away and book other work. It is an oddity in Trek history - at once beloved, and decried, by a fandom that, if nothing else, certainly engaged with it.
6. Comedy In Star Trek
San Diego Comic Con 2024 saw the announcement of a new, live-action, comedy series set in the 25th century. The show is being developed by Tawny Newsome and Justin Simien, focussing on a group of Federation outsiders who discover they have been filmed and shown to the wider galaxy, without their knowledge, in an almost reality TV setting.
From the moment the news broke, the typing began. Comedy has a strange history in Star Trek. Clearly, it has been present since the franchise’s earliest days, but this was sometimes more piecemeal than others. Then, of course, there were episodes like The Trouble With Tribbles, Q, Pid, The Magnificent Ferengi, among others. The announcement of Lower Decks, however, was met with trepidation. It had the double whammy - it was a comedy, while also being animated. The first animated Star Trek since the original animated series in the 70s.
What did this mean for the franchise? In Lower Decks’ case, it meant five seasons and a live action crossover. The announcement now of a live action, purely comedic, series has been met with some extreme reactions. Some commenters have come out strongly in favour of it, saying that the franchise has grown sufficiently to make room for a series such as this. Conversely, there are those who have seen the words ‘reality TV’ and felt a sick swoop of worry sinking into their gut.
Are we looking at Star Trek: Below Decks? What would that even look like? The reactions seem to tie back into the question of comedy in Trek. Is the franchise a serious endeavour with moments of levity? Is it a dramedy, marrying both genres in equal measure? If that’s so, where does In The Pale Moonlight fit into that description? This new series is sure to drum up a plethora of reactions while it remains in development - but will any of them answer that age-old question: what does Star Trek need with a comedy(ship)?
5. Actors Vs. Characters
While each entry on this list is not only a serious topic, but has been considered in a serious manner, this is an entry that concerns a topic that has brought genuine upset to members of the fandom. What does one do when they discover that an actor they felt represented one thing actually doesn’t represent that at all?
In recent years, the question of the politics of Star Trek actors has played into more and more conversations in the fandom. This is by no means unique to this particular fandom either. Politics, as it has been described by many other writers more qualified than I, used to be dull. Say what you like for it now - it isn’t dull anymore. That, naturally, will deep into how one engages with the content presented. It has become increasingly topical to discuss an actor’s, or any member of the production for that matter, politics and stance on certain civil issues.
LeVar Burton spoke out about ‘consequence culture’, believing it to be a more useful endeavour than ‘cancel culture.’ Several Trek actors have evoked strong feelings in the fandom through the years, ranging from Trek’s earliest faces to its newest. While social media can be a microcosm of the world at large, it is also a forum where the fans can engage with these performers directly. An old phrase springs to mind - never meet your heroes.
Clearly, there is a negative connotation to that, assuming that they will always disappoint you. However, the opposite is also true - they can be so much more than what we see on screen which can, ironically, also affect how one engages with the content. This is a topic that is likely to become more prescient with the upcoming U.S Elections, as well as the cacophony of ‘once in a lifetime’ events throughout the world.
The sad fact is that it is very likely that more Star Trek actors will disappoint the fans in some way. The question, for which there is no easy answer, in to what extent do we absorb it?
4. 60s Racism
The Klingons have never really been ones to shy away from controversy, particularly when it comes to a spot of genocide. We’re not even joking - Errand Of Mercy saw Kor give the order to execute a large group of Organians. It was hardly his fault they were non-corporeal, was it? The Klingons, as the films went on, became more alien with the addition of forehead ridges. This was thanks to a budget bump and was something Gene Roddenberry claimed would have been the case since day one, had they the resources.
Though the Klingons of the movies, The Next Generation and beyond would use more prostheses to complete their look, the Klingons of The Original Series had no such adornments. John Colicos famously workshopped the idea for what Kor would look like when he arrived to receive his makeup and realised no one had any idea what a Klingon should be. Therefore, they used liberal amounts of ‘orient’ shaded make-up, and gave him a Fu Manchu moustache.
This look would effectively be the template for every other Klingon in the series, with successive warriors becoming increasingly darker in tone. While William Campbell was very fair as Koloth, Michael Ansara is clearly caked in paint as Kang - which makes The Day Of The Dove an uncomfortable rewatch in the modern era.
However, there are those who argue online that, as these actors were playing aliens and clearly not parodying people of colour, nor the minstrel shows that so widely showcased blackface, that this doesn’t actually count. Then there are those who believe that this look, well intentioned as it may have been, is a product of a bygone era, and should therefore remain.
This topic frequently rears in the cosplay community. Are Original Series Klingons ok to portray in 2024? Depending on who you ask, there remains a vocal part of the community who argue that Star Trek, a series known for pushing equality, would never knowingly use blackface to degrade anyone. Is this an argument that will die down as more and more examples of different Klingons appear, or is it one that will remain loud and poignant as those 60s Klingons are in our memories forever?
3. Woke
TrekCulture is currently running a series of ‘Time X Star Trek Series Went Woke’ with The Original Series and The Next Generation. The word Woke has seemingly lost its true meaning and is often to be found tossed around as a short-hand for progressive, liberal, or simply representing anything that seems different from the norm.
Each of the series that have been released since Discovery have received this moniker, though perhaps Discovery most of all. The word Woke has its origins in remaining ‘awake to the injustices’ perpetrated by the authorities, with a particular focus on crimes committed against BIPOC people. Therefore, this is one of the more puzzling debates. To decry something as Woke seems like a compliment - highlighting that the episode or series is using its story to highlight modern day issues.
Like The Original Series did. Gene Roddenberry hid the contemporary issues that he was trying to discuss in the ‘morality plays’ of the show, attempting to tackle such topics as racism, social inequality, bigotry, gender divide, and class struggles - all within an hour including adverts. This was no mean feat, nor can we say it always succeeded. There was, however, the attempt from the beginning to show a future that was free of such divisions as he saw in the worlds then.
The recent Star Trek series have raised the ire of those who struggle with the diverse casts of Discovery and Strange New Worlds in particular. They argue that the message was more subtle in the 60s, while the counter argument goes that what was shown then was just as radical at the time as a gay couple brushing their teeth is today. To be fair to those who attempt to solely discuss the difference in how television has changed in sixty years, they often get sucked into the argument against diversity - effectively killing constructive debate.
2. Gene’s Vision
Gene Roddenberry was a visionary, one who was also a savvy businessman. He tested the waters of what he could get away with in the 60s, pushing the boat farther than many of his contemporaries. Critiques levelled against The Original Series can sometimes come via a modern lens. However, when discussing what was featured in that show, one must also consider the censorship of the day.
The Dominion War inspired much debate over what Gene’s vision was for the future. There were those who argued that big interstellar wars were antithetical to Gene’s vision, so adverse were they to the idea of a Utopia. Deep Space Nine as a whole has inspired many debates on what Starfleet truly is, or what it must be to remain the way it should be. Section 31 is another introduced idea in that show that seems anathema to his vision - how could Starfleet, of all things, have its own version of the CIA?
Deep Space Nine argued that the perfect idea of the future was very much the issue. This is easily seen as the main argument against how Gene did things. Gene wanted no conflicts at all in the future, specifically interpersonal drama between crewmates. The writers for The Next Generation have often spoken out against this edit, bemoaning how difficult it made writing for a series. Deep Space Nine effectively threw this edit out the window as it was the brainchild of Rick Berman and Michael Piller. Perhaps this contributed to the initial lower ratings for the show, removed as it was from Gene’s ideals.
In the intervening years, it has seen a reappraisal, now confident in its popularity. Gene purists argue that The Original Series and The Next Generation are Star Trek in its purest form, encapsulating Roddenberry’s ideas and beliefs, while there are those who argue that without shows like Deep Space Nine, Enterprise, Discovery and beyond, this version of the future is incomplete.
1. Legacy
Anyone following Star Trek on social media over the last year will have seen the calls for a Star Trek: Legacy series to be commissioned by Paramount. TrekCulture has been among them - we’ve even designed our own logo for the show! This of course has been inspired by the third season of Star Trek: Picard, so this entry can be seen as an extension of that one, yet this point is more specific.
Legacy would, in a perfect world, follow the crew of the Enterprise-G or another contemporary Starfleet vessel in the 25th Century, thus continuing the era of Star Trek that combines everything from The Next Generation to Prodigy. Legacy would serve, at least initially, a single purpose: nostalgia. While that isn’t a reason not to do a thing, it cannot simply be the only reason.
The easy answer there, of course, is hire a good group of writers to create the stories for the show. Now, that begs the questions: who would the fandom be happy with? A very vocal section of the audience wants to see Terry Matalas return to run the series, but he has recently been announced as the show runner for Marvel’s Vision series, so it unlikely he would have the capacity to return.
Is this an all or nothing request? Alex Kurtzman serves as the head of Trek for Paramount (we could write an entire list on the debate over him) and so would naturally be in charge. There are those who would welcome this and those who would cry foul.
What is clear is that until the show is or isn’t announced, there will be fan casts - both in front and behind the camera - that will make some people happy, piss others off, and continue the cycle of debate on and on again.
You know the saying - the only worse than being talked about is not being talked about.