10 Times Star Trek Should Have Known Better
Star Trek has always tried to be a beacon of a better tomorrow, but sometimes the beacon faded.
Star Trek has a reputation for progression and for being aware of the injustices of society. This was earned in The Original Series, even if some of the episodes may seem dated today. The fact is, Star Trek was pushing the envelope in the 60s in ways that were as shocking then as anything its doing today. A black woman on the bridge, and she isn’t a maid? What bizzarro world did we wake up in?
This reputation comes with scrutiny and Star Trek is no stranger to dropping the ball. If it is held to a higher standard today, that is simply because it is that franchise that continually tried to get it right yesterday. Did it always succeed? Well, no, not always. For every Balance Of Terror, there were episodes like Turnabout Intruder. For every Doomsday Machine, there was a Spock’s Brain. This has been true of every Star Trek iteration from the beginning, but which are those times when Star Trek really did let us down?
There can be any number of reasons as to why and how. Sometimes, a script just slips through that should never have been greenlit. Some episodes fall apart in the filming stage, while others were always hoping for the best, though suffering from a lack of planning for the worst. There are examples across every iteration of Trek of episodes that simply dropped the ball, for one reason or another. Does that make them all terrible? Of course not. Does it make them unwatchable? We actually have a list of unwatchable episodes, which you can check out here. There are the episodes that just left a bad taste in the mouth, suffering from a lack of subtlety, shoddy delivery, or a combination thereof.
Brace yourself, this isn’t a list of the better moments from this finest of franchises.
10. The Omega Glory
The Omega Glory was one of the early contenders for Star Trek’s first season of stories. Along with Mudd’s Women and Where No Man Has Gone Before, it was one of Gene’s earliest ideas for Trek. Thank goodness it didn’t end up becoming the pilot, for who knows if there ever would have been a Star Trek in that case. Captain Ron Tracey loses his entire crew, believes a planet holds the key to the fountain of youth, and Captain Kirk saves the day by quoting the American Constitution.
There’s lack of subtlety and then there’s forgetting the mission that Starfleet was supposed to be on. George Takei has spoken many times about Gene’s wish for the bridge of the Enterprise to represent ‘Starship Earth.’ Nichelle Nichols was there to represent people of colour, while George was there to represent Japanese people, and indeed Asian people as well. Walter Koenig was there to show that in the future, the superpowers would be at peace with each other. While there was certainly an American focus, the captain was played by a Canadian.
The Omega Glory seemingly abandons the idea of Starship Earth and instead lifts the United States Constitution up as an example of a better way of governing. It was a bit of a stark reminder that the writers were, unsurprisingly, predominantly Americans. This example was an early slip in the attempt for a unified earth. The Yangs and the Kohms may have attempted to find peace through a ‘we, The People,’ lens, but Star Trek needed to do better if it was to truly show a unified future. Thankfully, much of The Original Series stuck to that initial premise.
9. The Naked Now
The Next Generation was the first live-action spin off for Star Trek, spurred on by the success of the Original Series movie franchise. Specifically, Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home was so successful at the box office that Paramount gave the thumbs up for the new show, though there had been plans brewing before that official notice. The registry of the Enterprise-A directly affected the registry of the Enterprise-D, for example.
While it makes perfect sense that any show would seek to encourage existing viewers to give the new series a chance, remaking one of the seminal Star Trek episodes, The Naked Time, as the second episode of The Next Generation was a poor decision, one that earned derision from George Takei specifically. He described watching the episode as seeing children dressing up in their parents’ clothes, playing imitation.
Introducing a comedic episode so early on, as well as including that scene between Data and Yar (we’re still not sure how Data was infected with the virus in the first place), combined to give the impression that no one was really taking this new spin-off seriously. Crusher and Picard can barely control themselves, while almost everything that fuels anti-Wesley sentiments are present in this show. Add to this the reused plot of the Enterprise being unable to escape collision with an astral body (this time, an asteroid), and this was a straight up retread of the earlier episode.
Thankfully, The Next Generation would begin telling its own stories not long after this. Perhaps it is best to skip the following episode, though - as it’s called Code Of Honor.
8. Shades Of Gray
Full disclosure, the Writers’ Guild Of America Strike in 1988 was the direct reason for this episode’s inception, so there were other factors at play. However, was there no other thing that they could have done?
Television was no stranger to the clip show in the 80s, and even the 90s continued the trend with shows like The Simpsons and Stargate SG-1. However, this clip was a rushed affair, with a wraparound story so dull that it’s hard to sit through. It is also the last appearance, to date, of Dr Katherine Pulaski. She deserved far better a send off than to be relegated to a few lines in a clip show.
Riker is stung by a plant. Good feelings make it grow faster, bad feelings make it fade. This equates to memories, and so the clip show begins. To be fair, as we have said, clip shows themselves were nothing new at the time, and reusing footage was hardly new in Star Trek at all. So one can understand the simple drive to do a clip show, pad out the season, and hope that the writers’ strike would end before the third season began.
Unfortunately, the lack of true engagement with any kind of plot line in this episode makes it a slog to get through. It really is a reminder that, rather than an enjoyable forty five minutes of television with Riker lying on a bed, one should simply seek out the episodes that it draws its footage from - quickly, so that everyone has a chance to do better the following season.
Thankfully, the third season of The Next Generation largely ironed out the issues that plagued its first and second, proving that Trek could learn from past mistakes. Though we are only on the third entry of this list.
7. Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country
Though the sixth theatrical Star Trek film was mostly a triumph of storytelling and direction, director Nicholas Meyer has spoken in recent years about his regret for one scene in the film. That scene, tough to watch at the time, is the forced mind-meld on the bridge. Though the scene has an undeniable power, pushing Spock into territory we had never seen him venture before, the events of the real world have only compounded Meyer’s feelings on the matter.
Though he couldn’t have known this at the time, the revelations of the torture, by the US military, of Afghan citizens in the years following 9/11 have contributed to the scene aging badly. If we put that aside for the moment, as indeed these events happened after the film’s release, the scene is given a deeply uncomfortable edge when one remembers that a Vulcan mind meld is meant to be an intimate, personal act. Though it is not inherently sexual by nature, there is both a romance and a bond that comes with it - one that is usurped in this scene.
Spock, by forcing Valeris into revealing her mind’s secrets by use of this technique, is betraying the sanctity of the mind meld, and also showing how something so meaningful can be so easily corrupted. Meyer included a moment immediately prior to this where Kirk orders Spock to do something, thus taking some of the responsibility from the man, but the damage is done. Every mind meld seen on screen after this scene carries the weight of the possibility for the act to do serious harm to the recipient.
The scene may be crucial to the plot and tone of the film, but the impact has shown that Meyer was right to have second thoughts.
6. Tattoo
Truly, this connects almost everything about the conception and execution of Chakotay’s character arc on Star Trek: Voyager, with Tattoo being the symbol of the mistakes made here. In summary, the producers for Star Trek: Voyager hired a known fraud - Jamake Highwater - as their consultant for Chakotay’s Native American heritage. They were promised an accurate guide for how to portray him and instead they were given a laundry list of stereotypes, half-facts, and nonsense.
Due diligence may have been slightly more difficult in the pre-Google days, but there is no excuse for not checking your sources when it comes to representation. Highwater had been outed as a fraud years before Voyager went into production, with that information on public record. When Chakotay was included in Voyager, he quickly slipped into Native stereotypes that were already deemed harmful by 1995. Notice how quickly his heritage stops playing a part in his storyline, as they attempted to phase out its importance.
Tattoo meant well, with a story about Chakotay coming to terms with his differences with his father. The tree spirits that his tribe were inspired to follow are revealed to be aliens from the Delta Quadrant, periodically moving from planet to planet, inspiring the locals. When evidence of them is discovered on Voyager’s journey home, the audience is treated to an episode exposing the spirits from Native American culture being portrayed as aliens, while Robert Beltran was given a censored, then digitally painted, scene, all while he remembers his Dad. The episode was one of a number of second season stories that didn’t really work and, though it was not the final time that Chakotay’s Native heritage was mentioned, it was probably the most overt.
The idea to include a Native character in Star Trek was an excellent choice. The execution was not.
5. The Disease
There are many rules about being a Starfleet officer. One must represent the uniform with dignity. One must obey their duty to the truth. And one must ask their Captain and Doctors’ permissions before hopping into bed with an alien. Funnily enough, while Harry Kim was being raked over the coals for a violation of that last rule, he must have been thinking, loudly, of the names Kirk and Riker.
The Disease is a bizarre episode that seeks to slut shame Harry Kim for having a physical relationship with Derran Tal, a member of the Varo species. While no one would bat an eyelid if Riker got off with half the crew, Kim is dragged to Janeway’s ready room, forced to recite the above rule, and held to a far, far higher standard than any other member of the crew. This, according to Janeway, is because he is Harry Kim. She expected better of him.
In this episode, Harry is portrayed as both rightly indignant, and also out of control, muddying the message here. Is Janeway right to be angry at him? Is the Doctor right to report him for having his encounter with Tal? Is he right for being a little confused when the book of Star Trek love, written by William T. Riker, has a forward by James T. Kirk?
This plot simply didn’t make sense. Star Trek had already depicted a more sexually free future many times in The Next Generation, Deep Space Nine, and even The Original Series. Why, then, is Harry Kim made to report to the captain and punished for doing something that other characters had done many times before. Frankly, no one comes out of this one looking good, making it a strange episode overall, especially so late in Voyager’s run.
If the episode’s message was to engage in safe sex (there is a plot point that suggests the Varo imprint on their partners, leaving Harry in a kind of withdrawal), it is lost in the righteousness of the Captain.
4. Cogenitor
Trip helps an alien without status learn to read, form self-reliance, and even choose a name. The alien is then forced back into servitude, takes their own life, and Trip is held responsible. End of episode.
The tone of Cogenitor is a wild swing for the fences and one that makes Captain Archer seem obstinate to the point of pigheadedness. The Vissians require a third participant to have children, with mothers and fathers engaging a Cogenitor to produce a baby. These Cogenitors are rare, but also have no status in society. They simply exist, moving from couple to couple, doing their job until they die.
That is, until one Vissian ship encounters Enterprise. Then, after meeting Trip, the Cogenitor begins to want more from their life. They go so far as to choose a name - Charles - and eventually ask for asylum. The Vissian couple with whom they were paired are furious. From their point of view, they did everything correctly, and have now lost the ability to have a child until they can find another cogenitor. Rather than grant Charles asylum, however, Archer sends them back to their people. With no options left, they take their own life, and Trip is called to Archer’s ready room.
Archer berates him heavily, telling him not to interfere in the workings of other alien cultures. Trip is devastated, feeling personally responsible for Charles’s death, a notion that Archer does nothing to deny. It is a deeply unsettling episode, one that is not helped by the slightly forced reference to the Prime Directive thrown in as an easter egg toward the end. Playing around with suicide for shock value is something that rarely lands the way the writers intend and using it to send Trip into a guilt spiral is hardly any better.
3. Imposters
Our head canon is always - no body, no death! We even have lists on the topic so that we can live in our land of make believe. In that happy place, Commander Ro Laren is alive and well, perhaps with a nice, cushy office job at Starfleet Security. If we are to take Star Trek: Picard’s third season as gospel however, Ro is most certainly not in a comfy office chair. Instead, she was trapped aboard a hijacked shuttle, sacrificing herself to help the Titan-A get away from the USS Intrepid.
However. Michelle Forbes’ return to Star Trek was a wonderful moment in the show, though her exit left a sour taste in our mouths. This character had last been seen in Preemptive Strike, one of the final episodes of The Next Generation, wherein she left Starfleet to join the Maquis. In Imposters, she says that she left them before the Dominion wiped them out (that was lucky) and earned her commission back. She rose through the ranks, eventually starting to suspect the Changeling infiltration of Starfleet.
Her arrival aboard the Titan-A is to seemingly investigate Jean-Luc Picard for his culpability in the rerouting of the ship to the Ryton System, as well as the rescue of Beverly Crusher. However, after some truly emotional scenes between the characters, she leaves - only to be immediately betrayed by her two aides, revealed then to be Changelings themselves. There is a bomb placed aboard her shuttle, but stopping to allow the Titan-A to rescue her would put it at risk of destruction. She pilots the shuttle into the bussard collector of the Intrepid, exploding along with her shuttle.
At which point, Riker immediately turns to Captain Shaw, using Ro’s death as proof of their tale. Shaw relents and the Titan-A warps out. To be clear, the term ‘fridging,’ coined by comic book writer Gail Simone, originated after the release of the Green Lantern comic in which Lantern Kyle Raynor’s girlfriend Alexandra DeWitt was killed and folded inside a fridge as a warning to him. It has come to mean the deliberate killing of a female character so that a male character will understand the stakes.
Ro deserved better and no amount of ‘she was in the original script for the finale’ can fix what was presented on screen.
2. What Is Starfleet?
A recent example of Star Trek trying to sit on the fence and ending up struggling to say anything is Strange New Worlds’ third season episode What Is Starfleet? Here, a young documentary filmmaker, Beto Ortegas, has been working on a feature about Starfleet, told through the lens of life aboard the Enterprise. While the documentary is presented as in universe footage, edited and released via the freedom of information act, the result is a very rough hit piece on Starfleet, though with enough evidence to seemingly justify some of Beto’s prejudices.
He contends that Starfleet is a military, taking care to point out the heavy armament of the Enterprise, as well M’Benga’s redacted military records. He questions the role of security in Starfleet, and attempts to manipulate Uhura into going on the record against Starfleet. His bias is exposed, though nothing happens - he is still allowed to complete his documentary, which is given a somewhat hopeful ending - despite the fact that we the audience were apparently watching the finished piece.
The background mission sees the Enterprise first ordered to escort a weapon of mass destruction to one side of a warring people, then later engage in the self-destruction of that weapon, once it is discovered that it is sentient. It is described as being a weapon only, and that it wants to die rather than live to cause pain. This is Starfleet - surely they will at least try to help? Nothing of the sort. They communicate with the creature, but that’s all.
Starfleet facilitating a war, then simply taking away the weapon, seems to be a poor message to place in a show that is supposed to be about a utopian future, and one that is designed to show that peace is the best option, as opposed to the option forced on people without their consent.
It was not the only time that Star Trek was guilty of that crime, but it was particularly egregious in light of real world comparisons.
1. The Expanse
Star Trek did their take on 9/11 and the War on Terror mere months after the terrorist attacks on the World Trade Centre and Pentagon. Should they have waited a bit longer before tackling the subject? Arguably, yes. What is now known about the war on terror, the invasion of Iraq, and the torture at Abu Grabe prison makes the entire campaign seem ill conceived and dangerous for all concerned.
In Star Trek, the Xindi weapon arrives over Earth and fire a concentrated energy beam at the East Coast of the United States, resulting in roughly 7 million deaths. The parallels are obvious, with the episode releasing in 2003, long before the full extant of US involvement in the Middle East was widely known, while the finger of blame was still moving from person to person for the attacks. Enterprise flies off into the Expanse cocked and ready to go, ready to rain vengeance down on the Xindi, while also hoping to try and avoid the attacks in the first place. Time travel is involved.
There are many things that came out of the third year of Enterprise that benefited the show, and the franchise as a whole. One could easily say that from that initial idea, the writers picked a strong storyline and developed it, whether or not the Nazi Space Vampires were truly necessary in the final shot of the season.
However, that first opening volley, the one that so clearly represents 9/11, barely two years after the dust settled from the buildings’ collapse, felt like they were trying to run before they could walk. The storyline was strong, but even another year may have benefitted everyone concerned just a little bit better.