20 Greatest Moments In Modern Doctor Who

20 memorable moments from 20 years of modern Doctor Who.

Doctor Who The Pandorica Opens
BBC Studios

When Russell T Davies brought back Doctor Who in 2005, in the heat of the Saturday night wars between the BBC and ITV, he was keen to include something "irresistible" in each episode. And boy, did he deliver.

RTD's successor Steven Moffat went even further, conceiving of big Doctor Who moments that would play out on a big screen in global cinema screenings for the likes of The Day of the Doctor and Deep Breath. Chris Chibnall was no slouch either, giving us a whole new mythology for the Doctor and a six-part event series that blew up half the universe.

The past two decades have been absolutely packed with great Doctor Who moments, so it's hard to narrow them down to just 20. This list will focus on the biggest laughs, the most bombastic speeches, the most satisfying resolutions, the scariest monster moments... and of course, the Daleks.

While we may not agree on what constitutes the greatest moments of modern Doctor Who, we can definitely agree that it's been the trip of a lifetime!

20. Killer Christmas Tree (The Christmas Invasion)

Doctor Who The Christmas Invasion Christmas Tree
BBC Studios

Jon Pertwee famously said that there was nothing more frightening than a yeti on the loo in Tooting Bec.

Russell T Davies understood this in his bones, and his first era was defined by alien horrors lurking in everyday locations. Among the most memorable was the murderous Christmas tree from The Christmas Invasion – a rampaging, razor-branched nightmare ploughing through the walls of Jackie Tyler's flat as she cowered in a corner, delivering the immortal line:

"I'm going to get killed by a Christmas tree!"

All of which is set to an off-kilter Christmassy music track, courtesy of Murray Gold.

This is pure Doctor Who, Christmas or otherwise.


19. Rosa Parks Takes A Stand (Rosa)

Doctor Who Rosa Parks
BBC Studios

Doctor Who has dealt with the concept of non-intervention before, most notably in The Aztecs and The Fires of Pompeii.

However, that non-intervention has never been more loaded than it was in Rosa, when the Thirteenth Doctor and Graham were forced to comply with a racist policy so that Rosa Parks could inspire the Montgomery Bus Boycott. 

It's a gut-wrenching scene, and writers Chris Chibnall and Malorie Blackman should be lauded for not going the obvious route and having the Doctor make some inspiring speech to the bus passengers. Rosa Parks is the hero of her story here, just as she should be.

It was a Doctor Who historical in its purest, most old-school form, and felt utterly refreshing as a result.


18. A Silent Reunion (Partners In Crime)

Doctor Who Donna Noble Partners In Crime
BBC Studios

Russell T Davies' Doctor Who tends to be a bit sillier and more slapstick than Steven Moffat's and Chris Chibnall's, and rarely did this work as well than in the big, silly comedy sequence that was the Tenth Doctor and Donna's reunion.

Having spent the majority of the episode watching them just miss each other, seeing the Doctor and Donna finally meeting at opposite ends of a conference room, unable to speak, is laugh-out-loud funny. And it only gets funnier from there as the pair have to mime at each other, across the heads of an unimpressed Miss Foster and her captive journalist Penny.

Watching David Tennant and Catherine Tate wordlessly communicate vast chunks of exposition is to watch two performers at the height of their powers – even more impressive when you learn that Tate essentially ad-libbed the whole thing!


17. Constantine Transforms (The Empty Child)

Doctor Who The Empty Child Dr Constantine
BBC Studios

The Unquiet Dead had already established that 21st century Doctor Who wasn't afraid to terrify its young audience, but The Empty Child picked up that baton and set out to traumatise a generation of kids with the transformation of Doctor Constantine into a gas mask zombie.

It's an incredible scene, from the melancholic exchange between the two doctors about war, grief, and loss, to Constantine's desperate questioning of "Are you my Mummy?"

It's the fact that writer Steven Moffat and actor Richard Wilson imbue so much personality into Constantine in such a short space of time that makes the horrifying transformation so utterly chilling – and one that young eyes back in 2005 have not forgotten to this day!


16. The Guardians Of The Edge (The Power Of The Doctor)

Doctor Who The Power of the Doctor Guardians of the Edge Peter Davison Fifth Doctor
BBC Studios

Jodie Whittaker's era of Doctor Who saved its best for last.

Watching the Thirteenth Doctor share the screen with David Bradley, Peter Davison, Colin Baker, Sylvester McCoy, and Paul McGann in The Power of the Doctor was an unexpected yet brilliant surprise that made her final episode something truly special.

They weren't just cameos for cameos sake either, as these past Doctors were cleverly woven into the plot, and there was even time for a couple of them to reconcile with their own companions!

It was something we never thought we'd see – Doctor Who's present and distant past colliding and colluding to take down their greatest enemy the Master, while the Edge itself was a fascinating device that could well be worth exploring in future episodes.

The power of the Doctor, indeed.


15. The Melody Reveal (A Good Man Goes To War)

A Good Man Goes To War
BBC

One of modern Doctor Who's longest-running mysteries was resolved in A Good Man Goes to War, and it was absolutely electric.

When Steven Moffat's on form, there's real satisfaction to be taken from watching him tie things up. Having smartly seeded the clues – the name "Melody Pond," Lorna Bucket from the Gamma Forests, and "the only water in the forest is the river" – Moffat stitched them all together on a prayer leaf, with one hell of an assist from Murray Gold.

We can argue across all of time and space about what comes next, but the way that everything clicked together to reveal that River Song was Amy and Rory's daughter was masterful, and ended Series 6A on a game-changing, iconic cliffhanger.


14. Time Lord Victorious (The Waters Of Mars)

Doctor Who The Waters of Mars
BBC Studios
"It's taken me all these years to realise the Laws of Time are mine, and they will obey me!"

So says the Tenth Doctor in one of the most remarkable sequences of his entire era.

In this one mad moment, the Tenth Doctor says the quiet part out loud – he's the last of the Time Lords, and he has mastery over past, present, and future... and why doesn't he exploit that more often?

It was a powerful moment that wasn't afraid to show the Doctor as a more complex, antagonistic character. In the modern television era, it would never have been enough to simply see the Doctor as a two-dimensional "goodie", and so the Time Lord Victorious revealed the monster the Doctor could become if left unchecked.

Bonus points for the preceding sequence of the Bowie Base One crew being wiped out by the Flood. The sense of dread, of desperation, of hopelessness – it's a truly brilliant slice of dramatic television that lives long in the memory.


13. Speech To Akhaten (The Rings Of Akhaten)

Doctor Who The Rings Of Akhaten
BBC Studios

It's a bit of a cliche when talking about Matt Smith's portrayal of the Doctor, but there were times when he really did nail the idea of an ancient god inside the body of a young man.

One of those moments was the speech he delivers to the old god Akhaten in Series 7's The Rings of Akhaten. The emotion and weariness that Smith puts into lines of dialogue like "I walked in universes where the laws of physics were devised by the mind of a mad man!" proved just what a great Doctor he truly was.

He's not even performing the lines to an actor – he's delivering the speech to a visual effect! And a rather stunning visual effect, at that. Incredible work all around.


12. Hello Sweetie (The Husbands Of River Song)

Doctor Who The Husbands Of River Song
BBC Studios

If there's one takeaway from the past 20 years of Doctor Who, it's that, yes, the Doctor can fall in love.

Sure, we'd seen it with the Tenth Doctor and Rose, but arguably the moment that the show explicitly confirms it is when the Twelfth Doctor turns to River Song and says "Hello sweetie". After all, it's in response to River's assertion that the Doctor wouldn't be stupid enough or "in love enough" to stand alongside her.

After spending the first 40 minutes of the episode comically delaying the inevitable, the eventual pay-off just makes your heart swell with joy, in no small part thanks to the amazing chemistry between Peter Capaldi and Alex Kingston.

And then... the Doctor and River finally lived happily ever after.


11. I Just Wanted To Say Hello (The Doctor's Wife)

Doctor Who The Doctor's Wife
BBC

The Doctor's Wife is incredibly effective in exploring the loneliness that defines the life of our hero. The Doctor's companions always leave them in the end, and the only constant is his TARDIS. What would it be like if they could actually converse with each other?

There are definitely flaws, but the core idea of the Eleventh Doctor finally finding someone who understands him, only to have them ripped away, is devastating. Except, the final interaction between Idris and the Doctor isn't a goodbye – it's a hello!

There's something hopeful and so beautifully melancholy about that, and it's played to perfection by Suranne Jones and Matt Smith. It's a moment that could so easily have been a bit hokey, but instead it'll have you sobbing into your custard creams.


10. Breaking Through The Wall (Heaven Sent)

Doctor Who Heaven Sent
BBC Studios

Heaven Sent is the best example of Steven Moffat's love of tricksy plotting and exploring the Doctor's psyche. By literally locking him inside a puzzle box, he gets to explore who the Doctor really is.

Terrance Dicks once stated that the Doctor was never cruel or cowardly, and never gave up or never gave in. The climax of Heaven Sent pushes this to the extreme, by having the Twelfth Doctor endure four billion years of unimaginable pain to punch his way through a diamond wall without once bowing to his Time Lord captors.

All set to the rousing tones of The Shepherd's Boy, Murray Gold's finest composition for Doctor Who, and edited to perfection by Will Oswald and Rachel Talalay. It's a sequence unlike any other in Doctor Who history.


9. The Curator (The Day Of The Doctor)

The Curator Tom Baker Doctor Who The Day of the Doctor
BBC Studios

Tom Baker's cameo in The Day of the Doctor was monumental. With the exception of the canonically dubious Dimensions in Time, it was the first time that Baker had played the Doctor on-screen in over 30 years.

Seeing him share the stage with another Doctor is incredibly rare outside the odd convention appearance, so it was a minor miracle that Baker and Matt Smith had such extraordinary chemistry together in their one short interaction. An utterly magical, spine-tingling moment that brought together the past and present of Doctor Who, while simultaneously setting it up for the future.

Truly the cherry (or should that be jelly baby?) on the top of the 50th anniversary cake.


8. Bad Wolf Bay (Doomsday)

Bad Wolf Bay
BBC Studios

Doctor Who's multiverse-crossed lovers Rose Tyler and the Tenth Doctor broke a nation's hearts when they were separated on Bad Wolf Bay in 2006.

The relationship between the Tenth Doctor and Rose caught the imagination of the general public in a way that was brand-new for Doctor and companion pairings. We all love a doomed romance, and what else could a love story between a 900-year-old Time Lord and a 19-year-old retail worker be but doomed?

Their final farewell has been dulled a bit by Journey's End, but "burning up a sun just to say goodbye" is still such a beautiful way to depict the tragedy of the Doctor and Rose's parting.

They really should've stopped Tennant's hair from flapping about the place though. He's supposed to be a hologram!


7. The Doctor Meets The Last Dalek (Dalek)

Doctor Who Dalek Ninth Doctor
BBC Studios

When Davros was introduced in 1975, he became the de-facto spokesperson for the Daleks, which kind of reduced them.

So it was incredibly powerful when, in 2005's Dalek, the Ninth Doctor and one of his arch-enemies went eye to eyestalk for the first time in what felt like ages.

It was also a confrontation that we'd never seen before, brimming over with violence and anger due to the recent scars left by the Time War. It completely changed how we looked at the relationship between the Doctor and the Daleks, and has continued to define them since.

It's exactly the sort of scene you cast Christopher Eccleston for, and by delivering this rage-fueled monologue at what he labels a "great space dustbin", he proves what a phenomenal Doctor he truly was.


6. Stonehenge Speech (The Pandorica Opens)

Doctorwhomattsmithpandoricaspeech
BBC

The Eleventh Doctor staring down all of his enemies and challenging them to try and take the Pandorica is an incredible moment from Matt Smith's five-star first year in the role.

Forgetting for a moment that this is basically part of the Alliance's plan to imprison him, the Doctor plays the role of the unwavering hero impeccably. "No plan, no back up, no weapons worth a damn. Oh, and something else. I don't have anything to lose!"

It's not just Matt Smith's delivery that makes this such a great moment, either. There's the rising score from Murray Gold, the glittering array of alien ships hovering and swooping overhead, and the earlier Stonehenge location work that makes this replica feel utterly, utterly real.

The best, most Doctor Who thing of all, however? The fact that he drops the microphone right before his big heroic speech. Moffat, you cheeky, brilliant devil.


5. Rose Meets The Doctor (Rose)

Doctor Who Rose Ninth Doctor Christopher Eccleston
BBC Studios

"Nice to meet you Rose. Run for your life!"

Included in an early teaser trailer, these were the first words we heard from the 2005 revival of Doctor Who, and well... don't they just sum up the last 20 years better than anything?

In the context of the episode, it's one of the best-ever introductions to the Doctor – he's in the thick of the action, saving people's lives, blowing up evil aliens, but still taking a second to say hello and ask your name.

In just a few words, RTD and Christopher Eccleston solidified the Doctor for a new age, and it's an approach that continues to influence the show to this day.


4. You Are Not Alone (Utopia)

Doctor Who Utopia Derek Jacobi The Master
BBC Studios

The Sutekh reveal in The Legend of Ruby Sunday was an earnest cover version of Russell T Davies' incredible Master reveal in Utopia – and there's a reason he chose to replicate it.

Professor Yana's mysterious origins, his fob watch, and the Face of Boe's dire warning all come together at the end of the universe in one of Doctor Who's most thrilling cliffhangers.

The Doctor's realisation of what YANA spells out (and the voices of the old Masters) is edge-of-your-seat stuff, topped off by Derek Jacobi's memorably serpentine delivery of the words "I am the Master." And let's just have a round of applause for Jacobi's performance in general, shall we?

Yes, the Master's alias somehow being an acronym for You Are Not Alone is ridiculous, but what a ride it was! That feeling of impending doom is something Doctor Who has almost never done as well before, or since.


3. Hello Sarah Jane (School Reunion)

Doctor Who School Reunion
BBC Studios

The moment in School Reunion when Sarah Jane Smith finds the TARDIS and realises that "Mr Smith" is actually the Doctor is such a heartwarming moment.

It's beautifully directed and performed as David Tennant and Elisabeth Sladen start off cool and detached, before moving closer and closer together until they're the Doctor and Sarah Jane Smith again, running off to fight the monsters.

It was the moment that any doubts about whether this was a reboot or a revival melted away, along with the decades that had passed since Elisabeth Sladen last played Sarah Jane. Our Sarah Jane. To see her back in the show again was a proper delight, and it was like she'd never been away.


2. Vincent's Legacy (Vincent And The Doctor)

Doctor Who Vincent and the Doctor Tony Curran
BBC Studios

Vincent and the Doctor is an extraordinary episode of Doctor Who for a number of reasons.

Chief among them is the final scene in which the Doctor and Amy take Vincent Van Gogh to see how he was remembered, years and years after his death.

Surrounded by his work, seeing it appreciated by future generations, Vincent is overwhelmed by the love for his art, and we're overwhelmed watching him! Bill Nighy enhances the scene with his passionate speech about Vincent's life, while Tony Curran tackles a challenging moment with impressive levels of vulnerability and earnestness.

However, this doesn't heal Vincent's pain, whose mental health struggles are rooted in much more than the lack of appreciation for his work. It's a complex and honest portrayal of depression that to this day feels groundbreaking for Doctor Who.


1. Where I Stand Is Where I Fall (The Doctor Falls)

Doctor Who The Doctor Falls
BBC Studios

Peter Capaldi's speech in The Doctor Falls is an extraordinary moment that poetically sums up who the character is, and what marks them out as different from other heroes.

The Doctor doesn't stand for truth, justice, and the American way – he saves lives because it's the right thing to do. Because it's kind. Just... kind.

It's an excellently constructed scene, from Peter Capaldi's insistence that the two Masters should walk away from him, to Murray Gold's decision not to place any music over the speech.

It's pure, undiluted Peter Capaldi, and he speaks for not just his incarnation, but every single incarnation of the Doctor from 1963, to now, to well into the future.

If any moment defines the Doctor, defines modern Doctor Who, and defines Doctor Who in general, it's this one.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Citizen of the Universe, Film Programmer, Writer, Podcaster, Doctor Who fan and a gentleman to boot. As passionate about Chinese social-realist epics as I am about dumb popcorn movies.