9 Worst Times TV Shows Went Meta

Things can only get meta.

Game Of Thrones Ed Sheeran
HBO

We live in strange times, with reality increasingly resembling a poorly-written TV show. But you needn't panic, because TV screenwriters are on hand to blur the distinction between fact and fiction even further.

The last decade brought us sitcoms like Arrested Development, Community and 30 Rock - shows that boldly explored new frontiers of ironic deconstruction. Their influence has percolated throughout the entertainment industries (there was even an Arrested Development joke in Frozen, of all places). Whether it is self-referential jokes, a show-within-a-show, fourth-wall breaking or pulling back the curtain entirely, self-awareness in one form or another has never been more ubiquitous on TV.

But it doesn’t always work. Done right, an unintrusive meta joke rewards eagle-eyed viewers with a knowing nod from the filmmakers, giving the show a life outside of itself. Done wrong, it can derail a show and alert the audience to the artifice. It can be hard to suspend your disbelief when the script keeps actively discouraging it.

Here are 9 times that TV programmes have sailed too close to the sun in their attempts at edgy self-commentary.

9. Ed Sheeran Sings On Game Of Thrones

Game of Thrones Season 7 had its fair share of knowing lines. There was Ser Davos' nod to the Where is Gendry? meme, and Jaime's inability to keep track of all of the show's names (who can blame him?). But none of these moments strained credulity as much as a certain musical cameo did.

When other musicians have made appearances, they have had the good sense to remain lowkey - nobody noticed the Coldplay drummer in 'The Rains of Castemere', and Sigur Ros and Mastodon make more sense in Westeros than real life, anyway. 'Dragonstone', however, sees Ed Sheeran, clad in Lannisterian armour, singing an entire song. Whilst Sheeran's voice actually has the kind of nondescript blandness one would expect of a medieval balladeer, it was overkill to have the singer smugly say, “It’s a new one”, stopping just short of winking at the camera and providing the song’s iTunes details.


8. The Doctor Breaks The Fourth Wall

One of the tricky things Doctor Who has to accomplish each week is making its high-concept plots comprehensible to a family audience. This means simplifying a fifty-five-year-old canon, with hundreds of characters, intricate timelines and time-travel paradoxes, for the Saturday night viewing public.

Rarely has this been done as inelegantly as in the cold open of “Before the Flood”, during which the Twelfth Doctor inexplicably breaks the fourth wall and explains the episode’s wibbly-wobbly premise to the audience, with guitar playing to boot (pun intended).

Peter Capaldi has a fine stab at it, but the problem is just how unprecedented it is; okay, the William Hartnell's Doctor did break the fourth wall in the first ever Christmas episode (“The Feast of Steven”), but it’s not been a part of Doctor Who’s toolbox since. The result feels like a cheap attempt to hurry the necessary exposition out of the way.


7. Baywatch Knows It's Terrible

The cheapest trick in a screenwriter's book is drawing attention to the absurdity of a plot point for a cheap laugh - critics have even given it its own term: 'lampshading'. It is a hallmark of lazy writing, and an easy shortcut; the writer didn't know how to fix their script, so they just hung a weak joke on it, as if that alone absolved them.

There are too many instances of this trend to count (here's a supercut for the curious), but one of the most egregious examples of recent years arrived when producers resurrected Baywatch as self-aware, Frankenstein monster of a movie. Almost everything about the original series belonged in the distant past of the early-'90s, and Seth Gordon's attempt to relaunch it in a contemporary, naturalistic style was doomed from the start.

No amount of lampshading could fix this project, although that didn't stop the writers from trying, including a conversation in which the characters dismantle the entire premise of the TV series.


6. Count Olaf Knows He's On Netflix

A Series Of Unfortunate Events Count Olaf
Netflix

Although the tone of the Lemony Snicket books has always been arch (its self-reflexive title ought to be a giveaway), the first season of the Netflix adaptation tended to overdo its clever-cleverness.

Hyper-aware of its existence on an on-demand video site, there is an abundance of jokes alluding to the internet giant. Snicket tells us at the start "to turn away immediately and watch something more pleasant instead"' and namedrops the title on occasion; Mr Poe complains that things are getting "off-book". When this stream (get it?!) becomes a flood, things begin to get tiresome.

Possibly the most obnoxious moment arrives in the second episode when a disguised Olaf stares at the screen and intones: “I prefer long-form television to the movies. It’s so much more convenient to consume entertainment from the comfort of your own home.” Then he grins for an uncomfortably long time, just in case viewers didn’t get it. They did.


5. The Simpsons/Family Guy Crossover

Two animated comedies in their twilight years brought together for the crossover nobody wanted. What could be better than for the writers to constantly draw attention to the declining quality of both shows?

Well, that’s exactly what they did. There were numerous references to Family Guy's plagiarism (there was even a Duff Beer vs. Pawtucket Patriot Ale trial) and allusions to The Simpsons' diminishing returns (Peter proclaims "I am over The Simpsons" at the end of the episode).

But the worst instance arrives right out of the gate: the very first scene finds the Griffin family watching an “All In The Family/Modern Family” crossover. Chris smirks: “Yay, a crossover always bring out the best in each show! It certainly doesn’t smack of desperation; the priorities are always creative, and not driven by marketing…”

Some self-awareness is to be expected, but do we really need Family Guy dragging The Simpsons down to its level?


4. Supernatural Goes Slash Fiction

Supernatural has never been afraid of mind-bending meta turns. In fact, few dramas have ever gone to such committed lengths as the series, with its fairly-frequent outings into postmodern territory.

These excursions tend to offer a fun change of pace. In the episode “The French Mistake”, Sam and Dean are transported to an alternate reality where they are actors on a show called "Supernatural", with the suspicious names Jensen Ackles and Jared Padalecki. The 200th episode was dedicated to fan fiction (it was called "Fan Fiction", strangely enough), and finds Marie admitting to not liking the meta episodes. This hasn't stopped the creators though: the most recent episode was a Scooby-doo crossover.

It hasn't always worked, though. Perhaps the most distractingly smug example is found in the episode "The Monster at the End of this Book", which sees Sam and Dean spending an entire minute and a half discussing online slash fiction about themselves. That’s a long time in TV-years.


3. Sherlock Goes Fan Fiction

Sherlock Fall From Roof
BBC

Sherlock season 2 was a bona fide hit, creating an enormously dedicated fan base online, and ending on a killer cliffhanger. When Season 3 arrived after almost two years of intense anticipation, however, it became increasingly clear that the writers had no intention of properly answering the questions they’d raised, and were instead content to drift into increasingly meta territory.

Baiting the fans with the fake-out of Anderson’s explanation was a very amusing beginning to the season, and surely irresistible to the writers given the amount of intense online speculation they had inspired. But unfortunately this scene was more than a playful opening: it set the tone for a batch of overly-self-conscious episodes. This was a season that gave us a Derren Brown cameo, homoerotic slash fiction, on-screen #SherlockLives hashtags, and a deerstalker-donning superfan - it was Tumblr brought to life.


2. Lost Kills Nikki And Paulo

Lost Nikki Paulo
ABC

Lost was always destined to go meta. The show married a rich mythology with a sense of mystery that the creators could never hope to pay-off, spawning an army of online theorists and sleuths. The island’s inhabitants, scrambling hopelessly for a sense of meaning amidst chaos, soon became audience-surrogates, and, like a snake eating its own tail, Lost became consumed with its own mysteries, rather than solving them.

When the writers of Lost introduced Nikki and Paulo in the show’s third season, they set the internet ablaze. Their characters' conception was prompted by a very meta question, asked on every message board: what do the background survivors do all day? Unfortunately, the pair were universally loathed, and the episode 'Expose' was written to kill them off.

It’s not a terrible episode, and watching creator murder creation to appease the audience is oddly satisfying. But it does mark a point in the show’s history when the creators paid more attention to fan theories and postmodern hijinks than to the characters themselves. “Who the hell is Nikki?" Sawyer asks, "Who the hell is Paulo?" Good question.


1. The Office Turns The Camera On Itself

One of the things it’s helpful to ignore when watching The US Office is the documentary format: it’s patently silly to think that a team of filmmakers has stuck around an office for a decade.

Not only do they gain seemingly nothing for their diligence, they fail to intervene in emergencies. They’ve mutely stood by as a man with dementia goes missing at a wedding, an employee has started a fire within the office for a drill, and countless other incidents. They are wordless sentinels, offering neither comfort nor acknowledgement, eternally watching, waiting.

So it was entirely distracting for the show to turn meta in its ninth season. Although in some ways the move made sense, upping the stakes and offering closure, it raised far more questions than answers.

Worst of all was the introduction of Brian, a handsome boom operator who is a “big fan” of Jim and Pam (every TV show needs an on-screen superfan these days). He even intervenes at one point, saving Pam from a furious Frank. Brian ultimately loses his job for the indiscretion, but not before we’ve been allowed to peak unhelpfully behind the curtain, raising awkward questions about the creakiness of the mockumentary format. It was the moment when a floundering show finally lost any sense of itself.


In this post: 
Ed Sheeran
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Another wayward English graduate who makes money by arranging words into the correct order. Is really at it good!