American Horror Story: Every Villain Ranked Worst To Best
18. The Butcher (Roanoke)
In Roanoke, Thomasin White was the wife of the governor of the Roanoke Colony, who sold her soul to the powerful witch Scathach and spent years slaughtering people as sacrifices to her saviour.
Portrayed by Kathy Bates and Susan Berger in the season's two timelines, The Butcher was portrayed as soulless, vicious and murderous without remorse, a vessel of pure evil manipulated to give blood to the land and bring vengeance to those who wronged her.
Roanoke as a season was a mess and then some, but The Butcher was a terrifying sight and one of its best creations.