Buffy The Vampire Slayer: 10 Worst Things Xander Ever Did
He may have been sold as a lovable goofball, but Xander Harris made some very bad choices.
Over twenty years after it first aired, Buffy The Vampire Slayer remains a cult-classic, with new fans still regularly discovering the series. Many believe the show was ahead of its time. The character of Buffy Summers is considered a feminist icon of the 90s, while her best friend Willow Rosenberg, who came out as gay in the series fourth season, engaged in one of the first long-running lesbian relationships in Network television, and remains a beloved role-model of the LGBTQ community.
However, like many early so-called progressive series, Buffy The Vampire Slayer still had issues. For every Buffy Summers or Willow Rosenberg, there is a Xander Harris. The third member of the series' main friendship group, Xander was portrayed as a lovable goofball, an everyman, a nice guy who spends the first few seasons nursing an unrequited crush on his best friend Buffy. However, in more recent years, new fans watching the series, or old fans revisiting it, are discovering that Xander regularly engages in problematic and even toxic behaviours over the course of the series.
Xander Harris definitely isn't the worst character out there, but he is far from the nice guy the series tries to paint him as. Here's the ten worst things Xander did throughout Buffy the Vampire Slayer.
10. He Was Basically Using Anya For Sex
Throughout Buffy The Vampire Slayer's early seasons, Xander is portrayed as unlucky, or in at least one case, an idiot when it comes to matters of love. His feelings for Buffy were unrequited, he ruins his relationship with Cordelia, and his brief dalliance with Faith meant a lot more to him than it did to her. However, things seem to be looking up for Xander with the arrival of former demon Anya Jenkins.
While at first attending Prom together simply because neither one of them have other options, Anya at least cares enough to try and convince Xander to flee with her before the Mayor's ascension. In season four, Anya returns in the hope of purging her feelings for Xander through a sexual encounter, but instead, the opposite occurs.
For a while, Xander doesn't admit to having feelings towards Anya, mostly keeping her around because she is an easy source of sex, which would otherwise be in short supply for a guy living in his parents' basement. It is not until mid season five that he acknowledges that his relationship with Anya is serious. Given how much Anya clearly already loves Xander by this point, it does make Xander seem a little selfish.
9. Attempting To Assault Buffy
Xander's unrequited crush on Buffy is at its strongest and most obvious during the first season. For the most part, it is all harmless puppy love, with Buffy seemingly unaware that her friend has feelings for her at all until towards the end of the season. When she is made aware, Buffy tries to let him down gently, believing he will eventually get over it.
Xander's so-called harmless crush takes a chilling turn in the show's sixth episode, The Pack, when Xander and a group of students known as Sunnydale High’s bad crowd are possessed by the spirits of a pack of hyenas. The spirits turn their hosts into little more than animals, heightening their strength, and their food and mating urges.
Once Buffy realises that something is truly wrong with Xander, she hurries to warn him, not realising that she will become his next target. Xander overpowers Buffy and attempts to rape her. She is only saved by the fact that her Slayer strength allows her to fight him off.
Though his possession means Xander cannot truly be blamed, it is still a chilling scene to watch, and one Xander counts among his own worst moments.
8. Falling Asleep While Guarding Oz
Season two of Buffy The Vampire Slayer introduces Daniel ‘Oz’ Osbourne, played by Seth Green, as a new love interest for Willow. Shortly after he and Willow begin dating, Oz is bitten by his young cousin Jordy while babysitting. He then learns that Jordy is a werewolf, and thanks to the bite, now Oz is as well.
Fortunately, this is not as big of an issue as it might seem. Oz is human the majority of the time, only transforming three nights of the month. On those three nights, Oz is kept confined to a cage in the Sunnydale High library, and the Scooby Gang take turns guarding him.
In one episode, Xander shows up for his shift watching Oz and promptly falls asleep. Soon after this, he is woken and harshly scolded by Giles, and the scolding is more than deserved. If Oz were to escape while in werewolf form, anyone he came across would be in grave danger. Anyone harmed wouldn't be Oz's fault, as he is not in control of his actions while a wolf. It would have been Xander's fault, as he was supposed to be watching him.
7. Summoning Sweet
One of the most well-known and loved episodes of Buffy is the show's musical episode, Once More With Feeling.
One night, a mysterious force leads everyone in Sunnydale to begin bursting into song. The Scooby gang spend much of the early part of the episode trying to uncover the cause. However, one member already knows exactly what is going on. The cause of life in Sunnydale turning into a musical is because Xander summoned a demon, believing that it wouldn't be a big deal.
The worst part of this is that Xander knows the whole time what has happened, and says absolutely nothing about it. He doesn't even own up when people start bursting into flame. He finally tells the truth to stop Sweet, the demon he summoned, from dragging Dawn to Hell to be his bride, but it is too late by then.
People are dead because of what Xander did. And to make things worse, he is never even punished for it.
6. The Love Spell
In season one of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, it is well established that Xander Harris hates Cordelia Chase with a passion. He and Willow are even proud members of the We Hate Cordelia club.
However, after connecting over the course of a few demon-related adventures, Xander and Cordelia form a relationship in season two. But, fearing for her social status, Cordelia ends things between them in the episode Bewitched, Bothered, and Bewildered. Angry, Xander goes to local witch Amy Madison for a love spell, not to win Cordy back, but to give himself the satisfaction of rejecting her.
Predictably, the spell goes wrong, affecting every woman in Sunnydale except Cordelia. Things quickly spiral out of control, with Buffy turned into a rat, Willow heartbroken at Xander's rejection, and the women of Sunnydale swept into a violent frenzy, all desperate to have Xander for their own.
Dealing with the situation bonds Xander and Cordy once more, and she ultimately chooses him over her friends.. Nevermind the fact that people got hurt, and Willow is still upset. Not for the first time, or the last, Xander is rewarded for doing the wrong thing.
5. Fetishising Willow And Tara
For Buffy and friends, as with many other young people, the College Years are a time of great change, learning about yourself and who you want to be as an adult. One of the biggest changes for the Scooby Gang is when Willow comes out as a lesbian, embarking on a relationship with her fellow witch, Tara.
Buffy, while surprised, is supportive of Willow right from the start, and on the surface, Xander is too. However, a few comments he makes regarding Willow's relationship in the latter part of season two show that he doesn't quite understand the seriousness or permanence of Willow's new love.
During Xander's fantasy sequence in the episode Restless, he imagines a scantily clad Willow and Tara in the back of his van, supposedly inviting him for a threesome. This shows that, at least at that point, he views Willow's relationship as something to lust over. He fantasises about his best friend and her girlfriend rather than his own girlfriend, Anya. Definitely not a good look.
While played off at the time as something of a joke, fetishising his best friend's relationship does not paint Xander in a great light.
4. Shaming Buffy And Anya For Sleeping With Spike
One of Xander's worst acts throughout the series is abandoning Anya at the altar at the end of season six, but we'll get to that later. For now, we're dealing with the aftermath of that sad event.
Following her abandonment by Xander, Anya has her Vengeance Demon abilities restored so she can seek revenge for having her heart broken at his hands. Unable to curse him herself, and with Xander's friends refusing to make a wish against him, she seeks out Spike instead.
Spike is equally heartbroken over Buffy at the time, and as he and Anya talk, one thing leads to another, with the pair eventually sleeping together.
When Xander finds out, he is furious, expressing disgust with Anya for what she has done, and is equally cruel towards Buffy when he learns she, until recently, had also been sleeping with Spike.
Xander is unwilling to accept that he can take at least a little of the blame for both scenarios. He won't listen to the fact that Anya was heartbroken, or that Buffy was struggling badly after her resurrection. He simply shames both women as a way of absolving himself from blame, and only succeeds in hurting Anya further.
3. Cheating On Cordelia
Despite the early wobble, once Cordelia makes the rather brave decision to choose Xander over her friends, she is fully committed to their relationship. She throws herself into the Scooby Gang's adventures, and cares enough about Xander that she vows to remain by his side, even when she briefly believes that he has been turned into a Fish Monster in the episode Go Fish.
Unfortunately, Xander fails to show Cordy the same respect or loyalty. In Season Three, Willow and Xander embark on a brief affair, while both are still in relationships. While Willow expresses at least some guilt for the full duration of the cheating, Xander only appears truly guilty once the pair are caught.
The situation gains extra layers when rewatched through a modern lens. Willow had loved Xander for years, and yet Xander only took an interest in her once she was in a relationship. Two relationships were almost destroyed because Xander wanted something he could no longer have.
2. Leaving Anya At The Altar
Throughout season six, as his wedding to Anya approaches, Xander is seen to be having doubts. Not about his relationship with Anya, necessarily, but marriage in general, and fears that they will end up like his unhappily married parents.
Rather than telling Anya about his concerns, he keeps everything bottled up until the day of the Wedding. The situation comes to a head with a man who shows up claiming to be Xander from the future, and shows Xander a horrifying Vision of what his future with Anya could be like.
Of course, it turns out that the man is simply a disgruntled former victim of Anya's, and everything he showed Xander was a lie. Despite knowing this, Xander abandons Anya at the altar anyway, leaving her completely heartbroken, and leading to her decision to become a Vengeance Demon once more.
This has a knock-on effect for Anya, who struggles to carry out her demonic duties after her time amongst humanity, eventually leading her into dangerous territory in the first half of Buffy's final season.
The worst part is, the whole situation might have been avoided if Xander had only had the sense to talk through his concerns with Anya earlier.
1. Not Telling Buffy About The Spell To Re-ensoul Angel
For a significant portion of Buffy The Vampire Slayer's second season, Buffy and the Scooby Gang's biggest problem is dealing with Angelus, the scarily evil vampire that Angel becomes after losing his soul. Things get worse when Angelus teams up with Spike and Drusilla to summon Acathla, a demon that will end the world.
Thankfully, the gang are thrown a last minute lifeline when Willow discovers Jenny's research into the curse to re-ensoul Angel. Willow, who has been studying magic since Jenny's death, readies to perform the spell herself, while Xander is sent to inform Buffy of the plan before she departs to battle Angelus.
Instead, Xander simply tells Buffy to kick his ass.
Some argue that it was for the best that Buffy didn't know, that waiting for Angel to be restored might have led her to pull her punches while fighting Angelus. It's also very likely that it would not have changed anything. Even after he was re-ensouled, Buffy had to kill Angel to stop Acathla.
Whatever the outcome though, Xander still lied to his best friend. He kept vital information from her regarding the fate of the love of her life.
Buffy never finds out about the lie, so Xander never faces any consequences. For many fans, lying to Buffy about Angel will always be the worst thing that Xander has ever done.