Buffy The Vampire Slayer: Every Major Relationship Ranked Worst To Best

Finally settling the Bangel vs Spuffy debate.

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Riley
Mutant Enemy

Buffy the Vampire Slayer may have been home to all manner of evil and surreal mythology, but the true power of the show came from its characters, and the way they balanced their fight against the supernatural underground with their personal lives in high school and beyond.

Throughout the show's seven season run, there were numerous romances between the characters, most of which played an intricate part in the overall story of that particular season and helped develop those involved in usually compelling ways.

Whether it was a forbidden romance between a Slayer and vampire with a soul, an ill-fated high school affair or a sadistic partnership between two villainous demons, Buffy was rife with major love stories, and rarely if ever dropped the ball when telling them.

With that in mind, here is every major relationship from Buffy the Vampire Slayer ranked worst to best. This article contains major spoilers.

14. Buffy & Scott

Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

Buffy's brief and ultimately directionless relationship with Scott Hope was only really in place to highlight how great Buffy and Angel had been together, and to emphasise how the Slayer simply wasn't made to date "normal" guys.

There could have been some kind of emotional poignancy with the pairing, allowing Buffy to have a relationship with a lot less danger, but between their rushed break-up and the fact that Scott himself was as dull as dishwater, it just never worked.

A wasted pairing they may have been, but Buffy and Scott's relationship is not one that fans missed...or even remembered once it was done.


13. Spike & Harmony

Spike Harmony
Mutant Enemy

Okay, so what Spike and Harmony had was far from your standard relationship - they were both soulless vampires, after all, each thriving off the pain and misery of the other, each driven mad by their differences and personal flaws.

That being said, they were linked for a surprisingly long time, from the start of the fourth season until the middle of season five, and in that time offered up a handful of decent moments of very dark humour.

Ultimately, Harmony was only with Spike to replace Drusilla and suffer through Spike's seesawing thirst for vengeance, and there wasn't too much to them other than that. Watching them reunite in Angel's final season is still hysterical, mind.


12. Willow & Kennedy

Buffy Kennedy
Mutant Enemy

Willow's third and last major romance came in the form of potential Slayer Kennedy, who by most fans calculations might be the worst character to ever grace the series (and, truly, she is).

Whilst the writing around the pairing is actually better than you might recall, injecting a genuine feeling of love and care between them by the end of the show's final season, the main issue with their relationship comes from how hard to accept it is.

Before Kennedy, Willow had been in a relationship with both Oz and Tara - two of the most innocent and kind-hearted characters on the show - and their bonds had taken a long time to build-up, making their romance all the more exciting.

With Kennedy, though, there was no development, and given how far removed from Willow's previous partner's she was, it was hard to take Kennedy seriously as her girlfriend. Following Tara was always going to be hard, but this wasn't the way to go.


11. Faith & Principal Wood

Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

And since we're on the top of forced, undeveloped relationships, next up we have former rogue Slayer Faith Lehane and high school principal/demon hunter Robin Wood.

Brought together in the show's final season, Faith and Wood found solace in each other's company before they faced the First Evil, and by the time the finale rolled around it looked as though their brief time together was meant to develop into a genuine relationship.

There is a lot that makes them a great couple, particularly their shared traumas over the hardships of being a Slayer (Wood's mother, Nikki, was a Slayer killed by Spike in the 70s), and Faith's growth from antagonist to hero, but there just wasn't enough time given to audiences to take to whatever relationship they were building toward.

An interesting couple, but not a well developed or memorable one, unfortunately.


10. Willow & Xander

Buffy Xander Willow Yellow Crayon Scene
Mutant Enemy

What Willow and Xander had in the early days of Buffy never really developed past hormone-driven high school crush, but it shaped much of the pair's development and personal growth.

Friends since they were kids, Willow and Xander had a mutual attraction to each other in the show's second and third seasons, which constantly threatened to become a real romance before other partners and world-ending catastrophes got in the way.

Admittedly good together on an emotional level, their feelings eventual ruined their relationships with Oz and Cordelia, before being indefinitely swept under the rug. It was short-lived, but was ultimately for the best.

In another life, they would have made a great couple, but in the big world of Buffy they were much better as friends.


9. Buffy & Riley

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Riley
Mutant Enemy

Initially, Buffy and Riley made a great couple. It might to hard to accept that now, knowing how their relationship would eventually end up, but in season four their compatibility was very strong.

Both demon hunters leading double lives, they made for a formidable pair, and their bond helped Buffy move on from her fraught, tragic relationship with Angel, and her cruel betrayal at the hands of sleazy Parker earlier in the season.

However, once big bad Adam entered the picture and the Initiative were revealed to be far from the good guys they claimed to be, the cracks started to show in their relationship. Riley proved to have a seriously fragile ego, which caused him to feel jealous of Buffy's power and her previous romance with Angel.

Their weaknesses were increased in season five, when they failed to communicate basically any of their feelings to each other, until finally their relationship exploded and Riley left Sunnydale. They had their bright spots, but not enough to save them from their failings.


8. Xander & Cordelia

Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy Productions

Xander and Cordelia's relationship was a complicated one to say the least, and perhaps the show's best example of hormonal teenage romance. Initially hostile to each other, in season two they grew close and entered into a serious relationship in season three.

Together, they were very likable, and through Xander Cordelia was able to get more time to shine, shedding her mean girl persona and becoming a full fledged member of the Scooby Gang in the process.

Unfortunately, their relationship was not meant to be. Xander kissed Willow in the mid-point of the third season, and Cordelia broke up with him. From there, they slipped into old habits of personal attacks before briefly reconciling as friends during prom.

A short but sweet relationship, Xander and Cordelia were a blast to watch, and one of the Buffy franchise's biggest failings will forever be the fact that Xander never got to see how much Cordy had changed whilst working with Angel in Los Angeles.


7. Giles & Jenny

Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

Without question one of the most tragic love stories in Buffy, Giles and Jenny first met in the show's debut season, and pursued a relationship in the second amidst the growing threats of Spike, Drusilla and Angelus.

They seemed to a match made in heaven, both teachers with a love for history and mythology and a knack for working together to help Buffy and the gang take down otherworldly threats. This all fell apart when it was revealed Jenny was a gypsy sent to spy on Angel and ensure his curse remained intact.

Briefly estranged with little trust between them, Giles and Jenny eventually reconciled, but before they could take things any further, Angelus snapped her neck and left her in Giles' bed for the smitten librarian to find.

Jenny's death was a cruel but important one, highlighting how dangerous Angelus could be, but it still hurts to no end that the couple never got to live happily ever after.


6. Spike & Drusilla

Spike Drusilla
Mutant Enemy

Though far from the most romantic duo, Spike and Drusilla were nonetheless one of the show's most deliriously fun couples to watch. Two twisted, centuries-old vampires brought together by bloodlust and a love for inflicting pain, they barged into the second season and instantly stole the show.

Between Spike's infamous history with killing Slayers and Drusilla's madness (she was tortured into insanity by Angelus before he sired her), they proved to as devoted to each other as they were darkly funny, sexy and unpredictably evil.

They were only really together in season two, though a brief reunion in the fifth season served as a nice reminder of just how great they were paired-up. They were never going to break your heart like other couples on this list, but they surely stood out from the pack.


5. Xander & Anya

Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

Xander and Anya started off on a rocky foot, since she was an ancient vengeance demon with a deep distrust of men and he was the most immature guy in school. But after Anya lost her powers and Xander had no one else to take to prom, they ended up hitting it off.

Despite some rough patches in season three and early season four, the pair ended up having perhaps the show's longest-lasting relationship, which saw a great deal of growth and maturity from both of them.

Anya got over her fears of relationships, Xander his anxiety over commitment, and together they brought out the best in each other and made a vital duo within the Scooby Gang. That is, until Xander left Anya at the altar, ruining their entire wedding and sending her back to her demonic ways.

They briefly reconciled in season seven, just before Anya was killed in the final battle against the First, and despite their obvious issues they still managed to be one of the series' best couples at their strongest.


4. Willow & Oz

Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

Buffy the Vampire Slayer's first three seasons established it as a high school drama as well as a supernatural fantasy series, and in that respect few relationships on the show were ever better than Willow and Oz's.

Together throughout seasons two, three and the first part of four, Willow and Oz were the ultimate high school romance, both super intelligent students with supernatural gifts (she was an amateur witch, he was a werewolf), and a knack for being a calm and collected voice of reason within their friend group.

Also, it probably wouldn't be a stretch to call theirs the most stable relationship on the show, since they only broke up because Oz's werewolf side had become too hard to control and they needed some time apart.

A sweet relationship, Willow and Oz were together for a long, happy time, and their break-up remains one of the saddest moments of the entire series, despite leading to some fairly great things down the line. But we'll get to that...


3. Buffy & Angel

Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

Buffy and Angel's relationship was the backbone of the show's first three seasons, and continued to play a major role in the rest of the series (and its spin-off).

Though initially sceptical about Angel's allegiances, Buffy was soon won over by his mysterious, brooding allure and selflessness, despite his vampiric nature and sordid past. Their relationship was incredibly romantic and caring, but of course hit a major snag when Angel lost his soul and became his old, evil self.

At the end of season two, Buffy was forced to kill Angel, knowing they couldn't be together, but when he miraculously returned in the next season, they started up again and for a while seemed to be stronger than ever.

Their reunion was short-lived, however, with Angel realising their relationship couldn't possibly last long-term, leaving for Los Angeles to escape her. Angel was the first love to end all first loves, and once he was gone it took them both a painfully long time to get over each other.


2. Buffy & Spike

Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

Put those pitchforks away and hear me out: Spike was better for Buffy than Angel, even if it took a long time for it to become clear.

The reasons for this are simple: First, Spike was able to love Buffy without a soul, something Angelus could never do; second, Spike was willing to fight for his soul to win her over and be the man she wanted him to be; and finally, whilst Buffy and Angel were great together, theirs was a more naïve relationship.

Of course, Buffy and Spike had their flaws, what with Buffy using him to combat the trauma of being resurrected, and Spike attempting to assault her, but once season six was out of the way and Spike had come to terms with having a soul again, they connected in deeper, more personal ways than she and Angel ever did.

Simply put, Angel was perfect for Buffy when she was a young woman coming to grips with the world, but Spike was the perfect match for the woman she became, and for that reason Spuffy has to win the timeless Spike vs Angel debate.


1. Willow & Tara

Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

As great as many of these relationships are, though, none can compete with the perfection of Willow and Tara's groundbreaking, adorable and ultimately tragic romance between seasons four and six.

Not only was Willow's coming out story a landmark in TV history, but watching her realise her feelings for Tara - perhaps the most genuinely likable, innocent soul to ever grace Buffy's ugly world - remains one of the most beautiful developments of the entire series.

Sure they had their issues when it came to Willow's brief magic addiction, but despite this hiccup were undeniably the best couple of the show, noticeably made for each other and a strong, magical team to boot.

Even after all these years, the fact that Tara had to die so Willow could become season six's main antagonist is a bitter pill to swallow, but this horrific conclusion does nothing to dampen the great relationship they had beforehand. Pure bliss.


Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/