Gotham: Ranking The Villains From Worst To Best

This town deserves a better class of criminal.

Gotham, the show exploring the origins of Batman's world, is now ten episodes into its first season and in that time appraisals of its overall quality have been all over the proverbial map. An aspect that has proven particularly divisive has been the treatment of Batman's rouges gallery, with some appreciating the consistent nods to the world's mythology, and others finding it contrived, stifling, and underdeveloped. Both perspectives make a great deal of sense. There are many problems with the writing behind the villainous characters, from far too much ham in their characterisations, to many of the references feeling superfluous and disconnected from the show's main storylines. Conversely, the show has gamely attempted to do some serious world-building, and has had some success with tying its villains to the actual progression of the plot. These successes have of course included the arc of Robin Lord Taylor's demonic Penguin, but also the way that John Doman's Carmine Falcone and Camren Bicondova's Selina Kyle have helped to further the progression of protagonists like Bruce Wayne and James Gordon. With Gotham currently on mid-season hiatus, now is the time to summarise what has worked and what has fallen on its face in regards to Gotham's villains. This list won't be including ridiculous, one-shot baddies like Balloonman or The Goat, instead the rouges who will more than likely continue to be major players in Gotham's future seasons.

10. Salvatore Maroni

Despite inhabiting a world populated with freaks, David Zayas rendition of iconic Gotham mafioso Salvatore Maroni is actually the show's most over-the-top character. Not only is he a walking gangster cliche, but everything about Sal comes off as big and broad. The lackluster writing is hardly elevated however by Zayas, who has unleashed a delirious barrage of s**t-eating smirks, stone-faced threats, and jovial exuberance in his few brief appearances. Watching him one actually starts fearing for the delicate scenery of Gotham, as the actor chomps into each line with a frenzied and disconcerting sense of relish. Thus, perhaps the most cathartic moment was when Zayas Maroni actually did grab a massive shank of meat and took an outrageously large victory bite after a successful criminal scheme. At that moment the show's sets were (at least temporarily) safe.

9. Black Mask

Almost as ridiculous as Salvatore Maroni is Gotham's take on the villainous Black Mask, referred to in the show by his actual name of Roman Sionis. The show's introduction of the super villain involves him forcing job applicants to compete for positions in his firm by fighting to the death in abandoned office buildings. This is a colorful enough story, albeit one that would have probably played out far better in Batman: The Animated Series. However, Gotham didn't think to quit while it was ahead. Instead of just having Sionis function as a sideline villain, the show actually features him letting his inner-lunatic loose, donning an outrageous mask, and hopping into the fray like some sort of demon (with what looks like too much nose hair). The result is pretty much what you might expect. It's not scary. It's not even absurd. It's just pathetic.

8. Edward Nigma

Edward Nigma's alter ego is The Riddler - who as most people know is one of The Bat's most famous villains. However, in the context of the show Ed is little more than a mild-mannered coroner and forensics specialist, and an annoying one at that. Wispy, awkward, and with a face you just want to punch, Corey Michael Smith's soon-to-be villain hasn't been well served by Gotham thus far. Maybe it's because he has been utilized primarily for laughs, always popping up in the face of Benjamin McKenzie's seething Gordon, and warbling about some sort of nonsense. Of course, it's still early in the show, and the character could obviously get some more development later. However, as it stands right now this twirp is definitely one of the show's most superfluous nods to the Batman rouges gallery.

7. Fish Mooney

As one of the few characters scurrying around Gotham City not possessing a comic book counterpart, Jada Pinkett Smith's Fish Mooney had the potential to be a great original creation. However, so far this has not be realized. While the show has admirably invested in her character, suggesting that she is motivated by a background of being economic woes, Fish still doesn't stick in the mind in any sort of significant way. Instead, it's all pomp, frills, and surface-level accoutrements. Take Jada Pinkett Smith's acting for example. She has clearly has been under the impression that because Gotham originates as a comic book she must act like a godforsaken cartoon. Her Fish can never just speak like a normal person; every single line must be either hissed, purred or shouted. Pair that with her jaw-dropping outfits, a dizzying array of bangles, feathers, and garish make-up, and you have a someone who is visually striking, but so far has been little more than an empty dress.

6. Harvey Dent

With his farm boy good looks and posh suits, Nicholas D€™Agosto certainly looks the part of white knight Harvey Dent, the Gotham City District Attorney destined to become the dermatological nightmare that is Two-Face. However, his piss-poor introduction to the show made it feel like the showrunners adopted the character's proclivity for coin-flipping and just left it all to chance. Like many of the characters on this list, the character of Harvey Dent has suffered due to the actor portraying him. D'Agosto, saddled with suggesting the character's duality, has made some distressingly poor choices, alternating between portraying Harv as an earnest if somewhat lily-livered crusader, or as a fire-breathing hellspawn. There are no shades of grey for this litigious pretty boy, and the episodes where he has been featured have suffered because of it.

5. Copperhead

In her one appearance (the most recent episode Lovecraft) Lesley-Ann Brandt's Copperhead came off as completely mediocre. She didn't stink the place up, unlike some of her fellow rouges, but she was mainly utilized for utilitarian purposes, uttering barely a dozen lines throughout the episode, and basically doing a decent impression of Kristanna Loken from Terminator 3. That being said, there is no denying that Brandt's highly physical performance wasn't striking, especially the way she made mincemeat out of Gordon in about two seconds during the main confrontation.

4. Victor Zsasz

Victor Zsasz's entrance on Gotham was strongly realized. Built up as a fearsome enforcer of Falcone's will by the show's script, the character gained even more of a presence from the casting of Anthony Carrigan, who looked like a deranged baby dressed in his father's suit. However, the character's effectiveness isn't just due to his freaky appearance. Carrigan's performance was suitably unhinged, almost to the extent where you could buy him clearing out the entire Gotham police department. Perhaps the best thing about the character was that he was used sparingly. He made a strong, brief appearance, but didn't wear out his welcome like many characters on this list.

3. Selina Kyle

Gotham's initial treatment of young Selina Kyle felt like a bad joke. Leaping about on rooftops, stealing with a devil-may-care attitude, and thumbing her nose at the entire police force, the way this child was characterized was almost comically bad. Things changed for the better in the show's more recent episodes though, which featured a budding, tentative friendship between Kyle and a young Bruce Wayne. Providing some much needed character development, these later episodes helped put Selina in a more realistic context. They showed her behaving more like a recognizable teenager, and even helped suggest how Wayne's friendship with Kyle could potentially affect his own journey. Of course, this hasn't changed the fact that Camren Bicondova's acting has remained largely stilted and unconvincing (but it's still early on in the show's history).

2. Carmine Falcone

Veteran actor John Doman is no stranger to playing powerful, authoritative men, experience which has well served Gotham's depiction of Don Carmine Falcone. The character has been treated in a completely opposite fashion of someone like Salvatore Maroni or Fish Mooney. Whereas those characters are loud and hammy, Doman's Falcone is subtle, pragmatic and intimidating. With some strong writing and Doman effective performance, Falcone has been a breath of fresh air in Gotham's putrid sea of madness.

1. The Penguin

One of the biggest surprises with Gotham has been the ascendance of the Penguin. Long relegated to a more secondary position in Batman's rouges gallery, the umbrella twirling mobster has been established as the show's premiere villain. Much of this has to do with the breakout performance of Robin Lord Taylor, whose work in several episodes has been loaded with visceral thrills, but also hasn't skimped on complexity. However, the show has also admirably invested in the character, giving him one of the most complete arcs thus far, while also providing him with a number of memorable, scene-stealing moments. It will be very interesting to see where the character goes next. What is your favourite Gotham villain? How about your least favourite? Let us know in the comments.

In this post: 
Gotham
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Adam Mohrbacher has been afflicted with an obession for film since his earliest memories. In addition to his work with WhatCulture, Adam has been a contributor with Filmophilia.com, FilmMonthly.com and Examiner.com. You can also check out his personal blog here: adammohrbacher@wordpress.com. A devoted fan of all film genres and styles, Adam gets equally giddy over the sensitive, existential musings of Ingmar Bergman, and the brawny brilliance of Arnold Schwartzenegger. He loves fish tacos and misses the work of Heath Ledger and Jack Lemmon on a daily basis.