10 Bad WWE Pay-Per-Views One Tweak Away From Excellence

How to fix what WWE didn't actually have to break.

Cm Punk Rvd
WWE.com

Ignoring the mind-melting chaos of the days that followed for countless WWE Superstars, Crown Jewel 2019 as a show wasn't a total disaster.

Forget one tweek - WWE's most recent Saudi Arabia presentation was a long long way from excellence, but it was the best of four incredibly weird events in the country so far. Focussing on the glamour of invading two-sports superstars rather than weathered and weary industry icons getting a payday, the card was more in service of an audience that were extremely hyped to see their favourite stars. Bored billionaires on sofas waiting for Yokozuna and Ultimate Warrior, this wasn't.

Since the series kicked off with absurd Greatest Royal Rumble card in 2018, the Saudi Arabian Sports Authority have worked to humanise the biannual showcases to the point where Crown Jewel actually looked and felt like a wrestling show rather than a propaganda playground. The black smoke from Lost still hung over it of course, but (and assuming Vince McMahon doesn't pull out of the deal) the sense was that the company might have found a formula that works by the time the wretched decade-long deal has concluded.

The shows in this list wouldn't have needed half as long. Presented with just a single difference to how they eventually looked, these subjective turkeys could have been objective success stories.

10. SummerSlam 2010

Daniel Bryan SummerSlam 2010
WWE.com

Why it's bad: SummerSlam 2010 stacked its main event (and more on that in a moment) but it didn't half leave the rest of the event going wanting as a result.

Title matches featuring Randy Orton, Sheamus, Kane and Rey Mysterio weren't up to much, whilst a lean mindcard left the entire success of the show relying on a satisfying headliner.

One Tweak: Not to go with the blindingly obvious, but put The Nexus over.

WWE had failed to make the best of the WCW Invasion because they genuinely couldn't fathom how these supposed inferior athletes could defeat the great WWE Superstars...as if wrestling were real and they couldn't control it.

The same applied here. The Nexus were young rookies of varying different skill level, but he might not have felt that way if they'd have been permitted wins over major stars once in a while. Or in this case, been booked to dominate once.

There's a reason people only really fondly remember the night Wade Barrett and co debuted despite their run lasting the better part of seven months - it was the only point they actually felt like a threat.


9. Royal Rumble 1995

Dick Murdoch Lex Luger Royal Rumble 1995
WWE

Why it's bad: The talent pool was shallow in 1995, with the company's annual battle royal highlighting the worst of the financial peril WWE found itself in during those lean years. A very good undercard was overshadowed by the short sharp shart of the "most fast-paced Royal Rumble in history"

One Tweak: Let the match go an hour, in spite of obvious limitations.

If anybody from the field had it in them to go 60 minutes (or thereabouts), it was eventual winner Shawn Michaels. The story with Davey Boy Smith and 'HBK' going end-to-end was tremendous, but there are several stars in the match that could have split the task to allow for a similar story told twice with his biggest rivals.

A card featuring high quality matches for all three titles wouldn't have been so forgotten had the Rumble also delivered as it so often did in the 1990s. In the modern era of shows going far too long, this tighter turnaround actually harmed the end result - desperately needed 30 more minutes.


8. WrestleMania IV

Hulk Hogan Andre the Giant WrestleMania IV
WWE.com

Why it's bad: WrestleMania IV births the start of one of the biggest and most commercially and creatively successful angles in company history in crowning Macho Man Randy Savage as the brand new WWE Champion, but fans almost had to work as hard as the new titleholder himself just to get to the event's thrilling climax.

Long long long and dull dull dull, this one's a slog even for those watching through the rose-tint of 1980s nostalgia.

One Tweak: Clean it all up!

Nothing can be done with the funeral atmosphere within Trump Plaza nor the fact that the card has a lot of filler due to the 14-man WWE Championship tournament, but at very least offer a few less f*ck finishes (or finishes at all) to make it worth everybody's while.

On a 16 match card, six of the matches don't have clean finishes, and three that do are cheapened by interference. Despite all the intended prestige and pomp of the event, a lot of it feels increasingly dirty.


7. December To Dismember

Cm Punk Rvd
WWE.com

Why it's bad: Unforgivably awful in between a decent opener and a passably-worked main event, ECW's one and only pay-per-view under the WWE umbrella set new standards for sh*te long before the company began making some of this sort of silliness their stock-in-trade. It didn't just reimagine disappointment - it appeared to luxuriate in it.

One Tweak: CM Punk becomes ECW Champion.

Wrestling can go far on good will, and 'The Straight Edge Superstar' retaining his undefeated streak at the expense of The Big Show, Hardcore Holly and Test would have been the kind of statement so rarely made by any property under Vince McMahon's watch.

December To Dismember isn't a disaster just because it's a two-match television taping presented as a pay-per-view - it's booked into oblivion as well as being a lazy and derivative version of both McMahon's Sports Entertainment and the infamous initials the third brand was supposed to represent. Punk, oddly enough, was the compromise between the opposing forces, but Bobby Lashley was yet another chosen one destined for doom.


6. WrestleMania XXVII

Jerry Lawler Wrestlemania 27 Gear
WWE.com

Why it's bad: The results that needed to be full of fan service were hugely, hugely unsatisfying. It had all the size and scale and madness of a modern WrestleMania, but none of the joy. The Undertaker and Triple H drew the crowd into their polarising display, but just about everything else booked so well in the build-up flattered to deceive on the night.

One Tweak: Jerry Lawler decimates, destroys and defeats Michael Cole

Ultimately, WWE were bound to a three year agreement between The Rock and John Cena that started here with 'The Great One's involvement in 'The Champ's main event against The Miz. The finish was drab but just about justified by the record buyrate their match drew at the following year's 'Show Of Shows'.

Considering how well it had been crafted on television in the weeks leading up to the event, WWE sh*t the bed with the clash of the commentators. Deciding against all good taste that the feud was worthy of a three-match series, their far-too-even encounter saw Cole steal a short period of dominance in the match and then claim the win itself. The enthusiasm of 70,000+ was flattened in the aftermath.


5. King Of The Ring 1995

Shawn Michaels King Of The Ring 1995
WWE.com

Why it's bad: Long considered an all-time worst WWE show, the fundamental problem with King Of The Ring 1995 remains the tournament itself. Mabel winning was part of a masterplan to propel him to the top of the card, but his success was lightyears away from the the commercial and emotional investment of the company's ever-thinning audience.

One Tweak: Book Shawn Michaels to win the whole thing.

In a year commonly considered the peak of the The Kliq's powers, it's truly astonishing that this was one of the few events they couldn't convince Vince McMahon to reconsider.

Much like the aforementioned Royal Rumble, the roster is thin enough that Savio Vega has to wrestle for the crowd four times in one night whilst The Roadie goes twice. But did genuine stars Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker really have to be sacrificed for it?

Ultimately, this tiptoes too far into fantasy booking because Vince McMahon had obviously fallen in love with his concept of pushing Mabel, but he had precisely two stars in the bracket, and he blew it with the pair of them. An irrepressible 'HBK' even appeared to chastise him for it on air following the conclusion of the 15-minute draw. He certainly found the hard camera with an almighty "bullsh*t" after the bell.


4. Survivor Series 1993

The Doinks Survivor Series 1993
WWE.com

Why it's bad: Steeped in the cartoon era of WWE, it jumps way over the line of acceptable bullsh*t with a chronic Four Doinks encounter that doesn't even feature the man behind the clown mask himself. The Bushwhackers and Men On A Mission go unbeaten against Bam Bam Bigelow, The Headshrinkers and Bastion Booger in an abomination of an encounter. Unfunny, unacceptable and the worst kind of unbelievable, it's astonishing this made it to pay-per-view. Or it would be if it wasn't clearly the sort of thing that made Vince McMahon p*ss himself on paper. He didn't sound as enthused on commentary watching it in execution.

One Tweak: Take it off the f*cking card because it's an inexcusable piece of sh*t.

Away from this atrocity, the show is quite good in spite of itself. A raft of replacement performers up and down the card overachieve, the seeds of the of the Bret/Owen Hart feud are magnificently sewn despite Shawn Michaels' late insertion into the match and an impending feud between Yokozuna and The Undertaker generates a red hot reaction despite the simultaneous reality that Lex Luger's main event dreams had been crushed.


3. WrestleMania IX

Hulk Hogan Bret Hart Wrestlemania 9
WWE.com

Why it's bad: Though very fondly remembered because of the aesthetic by casual fans old enough to live through it, it's loathed by many for the very specific standout moments that came to define it. Objectively speaking, the card fails to deliver a single genuinely great match, and whilst the booking is questionable on the undercard, it's downright reprehensible in the main event.

One Tweak: Have Bret Hart lose, cheaply, at the start of the night.

Vince McMahon was clearly (and somewhat understandably) still very easily swayed by Hulk Hogan's presence when he returned in 1993, so it's pointless trying to imagine a world where 'The Hitman' leaves Las Vegas with the WWE Championship. But there were more elegant ways of solving the conundrum.

Had Yokozuna cheated horribly to beat and hospitalise a gallant Hart in the opener, Hogan - whilst celebrating a Tag Team Title victory riding the crest of a return popularity wave - could challenge his larger foe to an impromptu match at the end of the night. Victory there would send everybody home happy without emasculating the men that would actually still be there when 'The Hulkster' f*cked off in June.


2. WrestleMania 25

Shawn Michaels WrestleMania 25 Entrance
WWE.com

Why it's bad: Ask Shawn Michaels, because god only knows.

How WWE conspired to make their 25th edition of the 'Show Of Shows' one of the most boring in its history remains confusing in the extreme. Almost every major name from the time was available, several of the programmes going in had heat, and most of the booking was in relatively good faith.

If nothing else, it revealed a darker truth about the John Cena era under the glare of a mammoth spotlight - plenty of guys were getting over, but nowhere near enough of them were over over underneath 'The Champ'.

It fell to two elder statesmen to show everybody how it was done, but even one of WWE's greatest ever matches proved fatalistic on the night

One Tweak: Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker go on last.

Triple H had been in this situation at a WrestleMania back in 2002, but at least he was winning the Championship as a babyface rather than retaining it. 'The Game' and Randy Orton never had good chemistry anyway, but the last thing the putrid pairing needed was to have to follow 'HBK' and 'The Deadman' blow the roof Houston's Reliant Stadium.


1. Greatest Royal Rumble

Braun Strowman Greatest Royal Rumble
WWE.com

Why it's bad: Saudi Arabia Saudi Arabia Saudi Arabia Saudi Arabia Saudi Arabia Saudi Arabia. This was the genesis of a 10-year deal between WWE and a country with one of the most reprehensible human rights records in global history. Money - and absolutely loads of it - ensured that the company were willing to check their morals at the door for the good of the dollar. Never a great look, not least when it was so nakedly apparent.

One Tweak: Host it anywhere else like a regular show that's just insane for some reason.

On balance, Greatest Royal Rumble is an absurdly fun show stacked to the gills with loads of reasons to watch, and not just because of a 50-man Royal Rumble taking place in April. WWE rather sloppily talked this up as an event of WrestleMania-sized proportions because it was. Imagine the likes of the Triple H/John Cena tribute to Hulk Hogan/Ultimate Warrior or Roman Reigns Vs Brock Lesnar in a cage if anybody had an ounce of good will about the event itself.

If only this Sports Entertainment was about Sports or Entertainment instead of politics and greed, the event would have been one for the ages.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.