10 HUGE Problems With WWE's Raw Vs SmackDown Survivor Series Concept

Inter-Brand War, what is it good for? Absolutely nothing.

Baron Corbin The Miz
WWE

SmackDown Live! got off to a roaring start in the post-Under Siege world by listing longest reigning company commentator Michael Cole as 'Tom Phillips', despite the former NXT announcer's mysterious 'assignment' keeping him from blue brand duties this month.

The phone fornicator may be the lucky one if Raw's closing segment implies how unstable WWE's working conditions will be over the upcoming month. Stagehands and inanimate objects alike weren't safe from the wrath of a blue-shirted army blindly doing the bidding of Shane McMahon because it's Survivor Series time and...that's just what wrestlers do?

That's the conclusion viewers were forced to jump to anyway. As sure as Cells, Chambers and Chairs appear on demand as and when the company pay-per-view calendar randomly determines their usage, wrestlers can now count Survivor Series as the time of year to viciously assault friends and colleagues under a red (or blue) mist of artificial fury.

In leading his roster on a show-closing Raw raid, McMahon helped craft an impressive visual to kickoff this year's hostilities, was it all an empty gesture? The company may have been aiming for scenes akin to famous beatdowns from the Nexus, but the wafer-thin motivations undermined virtually all of the brutality.

Spared of having to plug Jolly Ranchers on Tuesday Night, Tom Phillips at least didn't have to encourage audiences to 'Keep On Sucking'. Viewers were presumably begging for the opposite.

10. Brand Loyalty

Raw Beatdown
WWE

Dean Ambrose was destroyed on this week's Raw. Besieged by SmackDown Live! stars after briefly gaining ground with a steel chair, he was ripped limb from limb by blue brand wolves aiming to put the 'Lunatic Fringe' and every other Monday Night loyalist in their place.

Only, back in April, Ambrose was on SmackDown himself. In fact, he was Daniel Bryan and Shane McMahon's very first choice in the 2016 Draft, and would be carried aloft as the hero of the hour by many of those now decimating him when he defeated Seth Rollins to ensure the WWE Championship took up permanent residence on Tuesdays.

It was never explained why he left for Raw in April's Superstar Shake-up. Nobody's switches were, and yet mere months later, he's being killed for working where he works, and willing to die for that very cause. He's a pillock for giving a toss, but not at fault for his oppressors showing similar rage. Especially front-line sh*tkicker Rusev.

'The Bulgarian Brute' was another April trade, and made no secret of his utter disdain for SmackDown Live! He then made demands of McMahon and Bryan that weren't met, and subsequently proceeded to lose every major match. He's actively acknowledged how little life in the 'Land Of Opportunity' has done for him, and brainlessly gone to war for it all the same.

It is the exact opposite of how a predetermined form of entertainment is supposed to work. Everybody looks bad, even though precisely nobody has to.


9. It's A Joke

Raw Fruit
WWE

Don't believe that? Just ask WWE writers and talent.

The New Day routinely walk the tightrope between WWE farce and knowing self-parody. Ahead of a nothing Monday Night Raw match with The Shining Stars earlier this year, Big E separated himself from a scripted line a split-second after he said it with a wry 'I didn't write that' exclamation ahead of swivelling his hips and encouraging a 'New Day Rocks' chant.

It was, in a microcosm, how The New Day get away with being who they are. Bucketloads of silliness satisfies Vince McMahon, but E, Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods have found a middle ground that ensures their own credibility isn't lost no matter what booking they may end up briefly subjected to.

Such was the case on television this week. The three lead SmackDown's charge through Raw in a visual rather unbecoming of the gentile babyfaces they normally portray. Keen not to alienate their more discerning fanbase though, the triumvirate feigned rage and hurled a load of 'RAW' produce in a bin before their match against Chad Gable and Shelton Benjamin to reduce the siege to the comedic foil it-is-but-shouldn't-be. For the second time in a week, vegetables came to represent WWE's unhealthiest habits.


8. Blue Bullies

Smackdown Roster
WWE

If and when Monday Night Raw take revenge on the SmackDown Live! crew for their wicked assault, it will be just that - revenge. But did WWE intend the blue brand's roster to be the outright heels in this storyline all along? Perhaps.

Daniel Bryan's disappointment with Shane McMahon's first strike philosophy bore out a minor undercurrent of forethought about how this may play out, but then on the very same show, AJ Styles, Bobby Roode and The New Day were to be considered lead babyfaces as normal despite their ugliest visages creeping out during Monday's violence.

When a plot thread can be unpicked with such ease over the course of a two hour show, there is genuine cause for concern about the wider story WWE is trying to tell. Concern from corners of the audience anyway, it's readily apparent how little the company themselves give a sh*t about it in comparison to creating a diversionary visual that will get people talking and gif'ing on Twitter for a few hours.

When Raw give SmackDown the kicking of a lifetime at some point the Survivor Series, they'll only have had it coming. Nakamura, Orton, the lot of them. Only Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens, the show's top heels should theoretically be absolved of blame.


7. Good Enemies, Better...Friends?

Titus O'Neil New Day
WWE.com

Amongst the gang of buffoons screaming bloody murder in the name of Shane on Monday were Dolph Ziggler and Bobby Roode, two men set to do battle in a two-out-of-three contest before the Survivor Series, having already fought twice as part of the 'Glorious' one's introduction on the main roster. But that somehow gets parked because WWE have now decided to infer that Brand Supremacy is a bigger issue than solo success?

Elsewhere, Chad Gable actively pushing his SmackDown teammates out of the way to deck Jason Jordan was the type of horrific character booking that gets completely mishandled in situations such as this. The idea that they may end up competing on either side of mythical dividing lines is not the problem, but the concept that two former friends would be ripped apart by nothing more than blind rage was infuriatingly shortsighted.

Gable and Jordan are not Hogan and Savage, or even Michaels and Jannetty. Their split was convoluted but amicable, and could have been one of the complexities explored by a more layered treatment of a Raw/SmackDown communication breakdown. Instead, the two's imagined hostilities will most likely manifest in the form of Jordan's rebuttal whenever the inevitable reversal of fortunes happens for SmackDown Live!


6. And Then There Were Two

Sami Zayn Shane McMahon
WWE.com

Sami Zayn was the lone voice of logic just hours removed from SmackDown's blue ruin of Raw. 'I fight for what's right, I don't fight for tyrants', he tweeted, astutely observing that his pr*ck boss had only really steered a campaign of unprovoked terror.

It was an inspired character moment for the revitalised 'Underdog From The Underground'. Why would Zayn support such actions if he's as sanctimonious as he now claims to be? Why would he fight for a man he helped destroy a fortnight ago? Why would he support SmackDown Live! full stop after pointedly describing the falsehoods of 'opportunity' on Tuesday Night. In this entire attack, Sami was the only character in real life or storyline to actually ask the questions that really mattered.

Then, WWE television steamrolled over the subtlety and had him fight to be on the team.

Yes, the involvement of Zayn and Owens was tacitly for selfish gains (which in itself carries more weight than the 'BECAUSE WE'RE ON SMACKDOWN DAMMIT, RAWSMASH' logic of their colleagues), but having them engage at all rather than turning on blind brand loyalty undoes much of what makes them unique.

Daniel Bryan is the last man standing. Smartly kept in the dark about the first gang attack, he gets to remain the sole rational voice in this entire mess. But it won't help the audience - we're stuck with this.


5. Stakes

WWE Survivor Series 2017
WWE.com

In the interest of fairness, WWE still have time to attach some semblance of importance to the two major Survivor Series elimination matches or the overall card itself, but when the implementation of the renewed brand warfare has been so shoddily thought-through, it's hard to imagine anybody bothering to flesh out minor details such as why superstars are actually fighting in the first place.

Annoyingly, there are actually a number of incentives the respective General Managers could and should be offering to talent in order to compete in this otherwise-meaningless p*ssing contest. The Royal Rumble is around the corner - the winning brand could be afforded the number 30 spot, or perhaps guaranteed spots in the back 15.

Though money is a tough concept to introduce into a world where men and women fight over gaudy belts instead, huge bonuses could at least be suggested as a reason for the stars to fight tooth and nail. Title shots for eliminations? Time off for titleholders that win their matches? Next November off for the winners so they don't have to endure garbage television like this again in 2018?

Despite how WWE often makes performers react when authority figures book them in matches, the performers are still actually there to wrestle. Like the audiences that cheer and boo them, all they require is a reason that the creative team are haphazardly failing to provide.


4. Hash Of The Champions

The Miz Baron Corbin
WWE

Imagine having both rosters to work with and the opportunity to position Monday Night Raw and SmackDown Live!'s best against one another. The raft of fantasy booking opportunities are endless, but a quick survey of the champions on both brands highlight the short-sightedness in blindly pitting titleholders head-to-head.

Jinder Mahal and Brock Lesnar will fight in something of a soul-crushing necessity rather than a gold-laden prizefight. Nobody in their right mind would want to see The Miz take on Baron Corbin if they happened to be on the same roster, so why go there now when a slither of creative forethought could have avoided it? Natalya and Alexa Bliss could do much better than fighting each other in their current incarnations. The tag scrap between The Usos and The Shield should be excellent, in fairness, but one out of four is a pathetic return from the concept.

Annoyingly, the titles are largely in good standing at the moment. But solid foundations may need to crumble in order to fix these p*ss-poor pairings. Either Corbin or Miz have to lose before the Survivor Series in order to save the 'WWE Universe' from such a miserable affair. Similar unwelcome changes could be afoot in the Women's division too. Never mind the pay-per-view, the current crop of champions will do well just to survive the next few weeks with their credibility in tact.


3. Fan Loyalty

Kurt Angle Shane McMahon
WWE.com

'What's up Milwaukee', said an unrepentant Shane McMahon in his first address on SmackDown Live! following the devastation caused by his charges on Monday Night Raw.

The crowd cheered. Milwaukee, like most other places WWE select to tour, like getting to see the product in the flesh and broadly respond well to 'Shane-O-Mac' himself. The same would have been the case if Kurt Angle had introduced Monday Night Raw there 24 hours earlier.

WWE fans (as carefully trained by WWE) are not Raw fans or SmackDown fans. They will go to the show that visits their town. In cases such as in the UK, where both brands go back-to-back in one city, many fans will attend both in order to enjoy the festival of action. Fans simply do not (nor should they) loyally follow only one show at the furious expense of another. It's an absurd way to ask audiences to behave, and a trait that passes on to talent too.

Kurt Angle will probably request and receive sympathy from the crowd on next week's Raw, but he'll get it because he's a babyface and a bonafide industry legend. Imagine Stephanie McMahon begging for similar love. Wrestling is (and always will be) about good guys and bad guys, not red ones and blue ones. Supporters should be partisan, yet this storyline forces the exact opposite.


2. Oh Captain, My Captain

Becky Lynch Carmella
WWE.com

On Monday Night Raw, Alicia Fox became captain of the red brand's women's team captain after defeating Bayley and Sasha Banks. Becky Lynch went through similar motions against her entire team to become SmackDown Live!'s equivalent. But what does it even mean anymore? And how on earth will it actually help the team win the match? Is winning matches is still even important in WWE?

Lynch had to nearly break Carmella's arm in order to win the top spot on her team. But why would she go to such lengths, especially as a babyface? Raw, meanwhile, is in dire straits. Fox was given the win ostensibly because otherwise she probably wouldn't warrant a place on the team at all. Asuka and Emma had two excellent matches in 48 hours, Bayley and Banks are reliable hands, and Mickie James came within touching distance of a record-equalling Women's Title win against Alexa Bliss. She hadn't won a match on Raw since May. What even is a leader that has shown no propensity to lead?

Cavernous cracks such as these will be what WWE will have to paper over for an entire month of television. Not known for nuance, it's hard to imagine writers even bothering to plug such inconvenient gaps.


1. A Month Of This Sh*t

Brock Lesnar Jinder Mahal Survivor Series 2017
WWE.com

And after all of those logic flaws, plot holes and narrative conundrums, the grim reality is still gritting teeth through a full four weeks of this nonsense in the run-up to a pay-per-view that, ironically, will probably be broadly enjoyable.

In Brock Lesnar/Jinder Mahal, the company have stumbled into almost a no-win situation. In real terms, the indestructible 'Beast' can't lose to Mahal because of course he can't lose to Jinder f***ing Mahal, but the company have done just about everything else in their power to reap at least one solitary benefit from the misguided Maharaja experiment. A pinfall victory (no matter how pathetically cheap) over the invincible Universal Champion ahead of the long awaited India tour seems but another crushing inevitability.

Meanwhile, the company is so loaded with talent that both elimination matches should deliver huge on the night. The company have proven themselves expert in laying out multi-person affairs this year, and the five-on-five battles should be no different. The aforementioned scrap between The Usos and The Shield has match-of-the-year potential based on the separate efforts of both squads in the past few months.

The broad potential quality of the card only makes the ham-fisted journey that much more frustrating. TNA in the mid-2000s confirmed that pure talent cannot overcome rancid creativity, and WWE have never been so close to aping the much-maligned brand.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.