10 Times Wrestlers Stole An Opponent’s Finisher (& Did It BETTER)

Being better matters more than being first - featuring John Cena, Seth Rollins, and more.

Randy Orton John Cena STF
WWE

Theft is a central theme of professional wrestling. WWE, AEW, virtually every promotion ever borrows, even if they pretend they don't. 

Take the concept of a wrestling 'gimmick'. Everything is stolen and subsequently labelled as inspiration. There is no more originality. AEW Women's World champion Toni Storm has been a revelation as 'The Timeless One', but her entire schtick is inspired by Marilyn Monroe. Will Ospreay became 'The Aerial Assassin' because he enjoyed the Assassin's Creed series of video games.

Wrestlers even steal from other wrestlers. Ric Flair became 'The Nature Boy' after Buddy Rogers got there first. Shark Boy was a staunch caricature of 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin. Hulk Hogan was 'Superstar' Billy Graham to a tee, brother. Don't even try to become a wrestler if you wish to don a faux supernatural persona; you will never escape comparisons to The Undertaker. Hell, WCW hired Christi Rock, an imposing bodybuilder, and burdened her with the alias of Asya to combat the rising popularity of Joanie 'Chyna' Laurer in the WWF. This was because Asia, the continent, is larger than China, the country. Accurate, yes, but Jesus Christ.

It is an endless conversation to have - and it isn't just gimmicks that are at risk of wrestling's biggest kayfabe crime...

10. Roman Reigns - Cross Rhodes (WWE WrestleMania 40 Sunday)

WM Roman Reigns Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Cody Rhodes vs. Roman Reigns II was a well-structured spectacle of a WrestleMania main event that benefitted from its poignant three-act structure, the third, interference-laden of which produced either the best or worst ten minutes of a wrestling match you will ever see, depending on the eye of the beholder.

It also featured the death of the Cross Rhodes.

A rolling Cutter, the move doesn't lend itself to the same level of opportunism that the Cutter was designed to have. The executor will grab their opponent in an inverted facelock position, and then, nothing. They'll stand there, pandering. The crowd, no matter how electric, will ponder why the victim doesn't simply snapmare their way to freedom. Furthermore, it took three of the things for Cody to end Roman Reigns' 1,316 days of tyranny over WWE; every subsequent match for Cody sees a similar amount of Rhodes being Crossed.

Still, the move provided a pivotal spot in the match, one of the first to grab a fatigued audience out of their chairs. Cody, attempting a Cody Cutter, was caught mid-flight by Roman Reigns, who grabbed 'The American Nightmare' in that fateful inverted facelock and rotated Cody's face into the canvas with the same remorseless, stomach-churning intensity as Cody himself would do in AEW.

The only negative aspect was the lack of a head spike.


9. Yokozuna - Atomic Leg Drop (WWF King Of The Ring 1993)

WWE Royal Rumble 1993 Yokozuna
WWE.com

Yokozuna once tipped the scales at an alleged 804 pounds. Of course, having his leg drop across your throat is going to be mental.

The King of the Ring 1993 encounter, which pitted Yoko against the defending WWF Champion Hulk Hogan, served as the superheavyweight Samoan's mandated revenge against Hogan, who had committed a different kind of robbery three months prior at WrestleMania 9. Yokozuna, you see, had just thwarted Bret Hart's reign as the WWF Champion when Hogan dug out his all-American red and yellow shovel, burying him as if Yokozuna was Enhancement Talent #51 loitering around his locker room.

Why?

Because 'Murica trumps all.

(Yokozuna was born in San Francisco, for those wondering.)

Here, at the WWF's second-biggest Party of the Summer, Yokozuna forced Hogan to a pinfall loss with his own finisher. Hogan lay motionless under the full weight of Yokozuna's right leg, which, while not quite as extreme a way to go out as having Yokozuna sitting atop him via Banzai Drop, still caused Hulk a great deal of pain - so much so that he fled the company and didn't return for nine years.


8. Johnny Gargano - Willow's Bell (NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn 4)

Johnny Gargano
WWE.com

The very best instances of finishing move thievery display not just theft, but a creative tweak.

When Will Ospreay and Swerve Strickland mimicked The Young Bucks' TK Driver at the AEW PPV All In: Texas, it wasn't a direct copy of the flagrantly obnoxious Piledriver variant. Anybody can put the spike into a spike Piledriver, much like how anybody can perform a Tombstone Piledriver as or more convincingly as The Undertaker; Will Ospreay certainly mastered the art form.

As for Swerve? He forewent the traditional springboard somersault with which Nicholas Jackson told opponents to eat sh*t by, instead, double foot stomping Matthew into the ground.

It was a masterful take on an already masterful move.

Similarly, at NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn's fourth outing, Johnny Gargano achieved something similar. He used Tommaso Ciampa's Willow's Bell - a DDT which requires a nefariously naff set up wherein the victim must be straddled between the top and middle ropes - while putting his own spin on the thing. Gargano had already grasped his own DDT, a slingshot version to be precise, so by combining his variant with his wrestling soulmate's, he concocted a sickening killer of a move, made all the better by Ciampa's hardened selling of the thing.

Gargano could have done without the flat back bump onto the exposed wood, mind.


7. Drew McIntyre - Angle Slam (WWE RAW, November 2018)

Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

There was a polished psychology with which Kurt Angle dropped goobers with the Angle Slam. Its set-up was simple because its only qualifier was that Angle had to be waiting at the rear of an opponent. He hooked them in a back Suplex-like position, and barely lifted them off the ground before they were slammed back down to reality, the bump being a bland flat back landing. Unless you were never trained in appropriate bumping etiquette, you'd have no problem taking the move.

Anyone could do it.

Drew McIntyre certainly could.

Trudging his way through a battered Kurt Angle, Drew distilled the essence of the Angle Slam perfectly. He stalked 'The Wrestling Machine' as if he were a piece of meat discovered in the jungle, striking when the iron was hot. Hoisting Angle high into the air, McIntyre spun him around a full 360 degrees before dropping him flat on his back. Remember: the very best iterations of a wrestler stealing another's match-ender is when they apply their own spin on the manoeuvre. Drew did just that.

Literally.


6. Sycho Sid - Tombstone Piledriver (WWF WrestleMania 13)

Sycho Sid
WWE.com

Everybody reversed the Tombstone Piledriver.

Kane stole - then outright adopted - the thing.

Triple H thrillingly pinched the migraine-inducing bump at WrestleMania 27.

Even Brian Lee, the imposter Undertaker, dropped 'Mean' Mark with his own weapon of mass destruction.

None were delivered as deftly as Sycho Sid's iteration. Headlining against The Undertaker at WrestleMania 13, Sid seamlessly countered 'Taker's attempt at securing victory by flipping backwards out of his grasp; think the Batista spot from No Way Out 2008. From there, Sid dropped to his knees and 'Taker to his head. There was no lessening the impact of his skull being dug into the mat, so much so that, had this not been The Undertaker, Sid would have gotten away with permanently stealing the move for himself.

Randy Orton, at Armageddon in 2005, pulled off a similar execution of the Tombstone. He fell, 'Taker's head was compacted, the spot wasn't the climax, rinse and repeat. The only differentiator was that, here, the Undertaker slyly dropped his arms from Orton's waist, taking much of the impact on his limbs.

There was none of that at WrestleMania 13, presumptively because concussion protocol was never discussed.


5. Mickie James - Chick Kick (WWE WrestleMania 22)

Mickie James Trish Stratus
WWE.com

It is a move as simple as it comes, the roundhouse kick. Very little, if any, cooperation is required. The opponent stands in position. The deliverer swings their foot into the side of their head. Done.

Your neighbour's dog could do a roundhouse kick if it wanted to.

Point is, Trish Stratus, a transcendent and flashy worker whose flawless bounce-off-the-ropes Stratusfaction bulldog eroded the need for any banal strike, executed it to perfection. Dubbed the Chick Kick because, lol, she's a woman, Stratus traditionally swung her entire lower leg into the opponent's face, wiping them out clean. It was the perfect out-of-nowhere strike to combat the more strenuous setup that her Stratusfaction required.

But at WrestleMania 22, Mickie James achieved in one night what it took Trish Stratus a career to.

A match designed to cement Mickie as Trish's successor, this was the spot - the match-winning spot - that she needed for audiences to believe in her. Rather than swing her leg across Stratus' entire face like a Power Slap knockout, Mickie used only her ankle to pull the trigger on such a believable killshot, an execution that was elevated further by Trish taking a tumble to the floor. She was in a heap.


4. The Undertaker - Spear (WWE SummerSlam 2008)

The Undertaker
WWE

Your writer's all-time favourite wrestler is Adam 'Edge/Cope' Copeland.

Your writer can also admit that Adam 'Edge/Cope' Copeland had zero right using the Spear.

His performance of the crowd-popper resembled more of an illegal football tackle than it did the gut-wrenching takedown it should be. Rather than lunge his full body weight into an opponent's torso, Edge would jog toward them, wrap his arms around their waist, and lightly take them off their feet, protecting their fall with his arms becoming like a crocheted blanket.

If he hadn't Speared Jeff Hardy that one time, nobody would think twice about calling his Spear the worst in history. That is what makes The Undertaker's theft of the move, at SummerSlam 2008, stand out.

Fighting Edge inside Hell in a Cell in what was their fifth(!) pay-per-view match of the year - this was only August - The Undertaker used the Spear as part of a four-part, crowd-pleasing arc. He stewed behind Edge, stalking him almost, and struck the very second Edge turned his body. 'Taker sliced into Edge like a knife, whipping his body around his opponent's without grabbing on for dear life. His body hit the mat before Edge's did. This was no light tackle into a flowerbed; it was a callous execution, the sort of which nobody had - or has since - associated with the now-Cope.


3. Hook - Judas Effect (AEWxNJPW Forbidden Door 2024)

HOOK AEW
AEW

The Judas Effect is executed by Chris Jericho either as crisply and as cleanly as Kenta Kobashi's wildest, stiffest Burning Lariat, or as clumsily and haphazardly as Byron Saxton's Saxtonation.

If that comparison reads as too harsh, then apologies, but it is true: Chris Jericho is yet to master the technique of a spinning back elbow. The very prospect of the thing is almost too simple by Jericho's standards. He steps forward, turns his body ever so slightly to the left, and strikes his elbow back without as much impact to concuss a wasp. It is a p*ss-weak match-ender that, astonishingly, got over during his AEW peak as 'Le Champion'.

But Hook's was better.

It wasn't a crisp delivery. Hook and Jericho awkwardly stared daggers at each other before Hook even stepped toward his rival, theoretically allowing Chris ample time to evade the possibility of a broken jaw, but he stood motionless. Then, Hook struck - and he struck deep. His elbow connected directly with Jericho's cheekbone, Hook having used his other arm to increase the revolution of his swing, thereby putting his full body weight into Jericho's cranium. It was, if nothing else, a stark reminder that, like Jericho, he should adopt a wild strike that complements his pre-established submission finisher.


2. Randy Orton - STF (WWE Royal Rumble 2014)

Randy Orton John Cena STF
WWE

John Cena's STF is horrendous.

It is egregiously crap because Cena can apply the hold with bite and ferocity behind it. He doesn't; not all the time. It makes the occurrences when he does put all his might into the submission mean something, though it isn't quite the character beat he views it as. He is in essence burying both himself and the opponents who he has beaten with the, shall we say, fundamental version of the STF.

Shawn Michaels and Triple H have succumbed to the "normal" version, at WrestleMania no less, but he required his full knowledge and application of the hold against...The Miz...at Over The Limit...but not seven weeks earlier...when they headlined WrestleMania themselves.

Again: horrendous.

It means that whenever you witness an STF being applied to its fullest extent, you let out a sigh of frustration toward WWE's prophesied 'Greatest of All Time'. Case in point, the 2014 Royal Rumble, and Randy Orton's unleashing of a legitimately killer STF attempt. It began with Orton wrapping up Cena's leg, contorting the limb at a rough 45-degree angle. From there, he tucked his right arm under Cena's chin and cinched, later moving to a sleeper hold position to succinctly cut off the flow of oxygen.

It was made even better by the look of absolute fear in Cena's eyes. In that moment, it became clear that WWE had wasted an all-timer of a submission.


1. Roman Reigns - The Stomp (WWE RAW, March 2025)

Roman Reigns
WWE.com

Contrary to the other entries on this list, Seth Rollins does not deliver a damning rendition of the Curb Stomp. It is a brickhouse of a spot: at its roots, Rollins is leaping into the air in preparation for stomping an opponent's head into the canvas. There is no protection. Wrestlers were oftentimes spiked upright upon Seth's foot forcing them downwards. It was a move so dangerous that WWE sent it to the dungeon for several years, never to be seen.

Roman Reigns' version was just better.

Unleashing the insta-kill on Rollins after aiding him to victory in a Steel Cage match - he viciously dragged Seth through the cage door in a genuine contender for one of WWE's all-time great camera shots - Reigns decided against the traditional method with which Rollins would come crashing down upon his opponent's neck. While Seth would use the back of a foe's neck to assist his vertical leap, Roman opted to take a running start, lunge in, and come down with all his might across Rollins' head, the equivalent being Peter Griffin having his head caved in with an anvil.

Like the Family Guy patriarch, there was nothing Seth could do: he was done for.

Until, like Peter, he came back the next week because professional wrestling is all one big work.


Contributor
Contributor

Can be found raving about the latest IMPACT Wrestling signing, the Saints Row franchise, and King Shark in The Suicide Squad.