10 Times WWE Went Too Far
Necrophilia, miscarriages, racism, and other uplifting topics...
Just when you thought 2018 couldn't get any weirder, WWE decided to use their controversial Crown Jewel pay-per-view to usher self-admitted racist Hulk Hogan back into their Universe, heaping further fuel on the garbage fire the show became months prior to its airing.
This isn't the first time WWE have crossed the lines of taste and decency, and it won't be the last. WWE's creative department is good at a lot of things, but dealing with difficult and potentially controversial topics isn't one of them, and they'll keep broaching subjects that should never be touched on a wrestling show ad infinitum.
It's all fantasy, and it's important not to good too carried away, but the company should absolutely be called out when they inflict such horrors on their viewership, particularly in the supposedly family-friendly PG era.
Honourable mentions are legion. Big Boss Man hijacking Big Show's father's funeral, Kurt Angle forcing himself on Sharmell, Kaientai choppy-choppying Val Venis' pee-pee, f*cking Eugene: each could easily have found their way onto our list, and WWE history is full of similarly gross examples.
These crimes against wrestling are just the tip of the iceberg...
10. Dr. Hiney
A cherished wrestling institution and sacred cow he may be, but poor ol' Jim Ross was one of Vince McMahon's favourite whipping boys throughout his full-time run with the company, and often the butt of the Chairman's jokes. In this case, literally.
The 24 October 2005 episode of Raw saw McMahon deck himself out in doctor's garb, ready to perform surgery on a rubbery representation of what was supposed to be JR's arse. 'Dr. Hiney' was accompanied by 'Nurse Slobberknockers,' because of course he was, and dived into the colonoscopy, pulling out BBQ sauce, an Oklahoma football helmet, and a bunch of other silly bullsh*t from Ross' balloon knot, accompanied by boatloads of JR quotes and fart noises. If you've never seen it, it was every bit as dumb as it sounds.
The reason for this? Ross had just taken time off from WWE to undergo real-life colon surgery, and the ever-classy Vince thought it'd be a grand idea to rib him with this brutal seven-minute TV segment. Great.
A crass moment, and a real career lowlight for Ross, but far from surprising. It was only four years prior that McMahon had made him join the 'Kiss My Ass Club' in his home state, after all...
9. Exploiting Reid Flair
Charlotte vs. Paige could (and should) have been an awesome feud. It was a pre-Women's Revolution standard-bearer facing off with the movement's new leader, and while Charlotte was still very much a developing prospect and the writers had greatly undermined Paige post-Divas Title run, they'd have almost certainly made magic together with the right creative approach.
Instead, WWE decided to exploit the death of Charlotte's brother, Reid Flair, who suffered a fatal overdose two years prior.
Less than a week before their Survivor Series match, Charlotte dedicated the upcoming bout to her departed sibling. Paige retorted in tasteless fashion, saying "your little baby brother... he didn't have much fight in him, did he?", prompting complete and utter disbelief from all who witnessed it, and visible discomfort from both participants.
Scripting this line was cold as ice. Paige clearly wasn't happy about it, and to make matters worse, WWE didn't even ask Reid's family for permission to use his passing to build heat. The backlash was entirely earned. Wrestling Observer readers soon voted it 2015's Most Disgusting Promotional tactic, and it remains the Revolution's darkest hour.
8. Piggy James
Fat-shaming is objectively gross behaviour regardless of the victim, but the mere idea that Mickie James was obese back in 2009 should have been preposterous to anyone with a working set of eyes. Nonetheless, this was the direction creative took with Mickie's late-year feud against Michelle McCool and Layla, resulting in weeks of grim, unwatchable angles.
Rechristened "Piggy James," Mickie was driven to tears as LayCool relentlessly bullied her with unending streams of fat jokes, "hilarious" graphics in which her head was Photoshopped onto a pig's body, and a particularly dumb fat suit angle. It was horrific, and it went on for months, with their first pay-per-view encounter coming in a traditional Survivor Series elimination match, a singles follow-up at TLC, a Royal Rumble rematch (where Mickie won Michelle's Divas Title), before the feud was finally blown off in February 2010.
The storyline was supposedly concocted because WWE officials were upset at James' (non-existent) weight gain, and wanted to punish her for it. Similarly, PWInsider's Mike Johnson reported that the company were uneasy with her non-wrestling endeavours, specifically her budding country music career.
These issues could probably have been resolved behind the scenes, but WWE gonna WWE.
7. Big Racist Jinder
The early complaints surrounding Jinder Mahal's WWE Championship reign were simple: "this guy sucks in the ring, moves like a broken action figure with his limbs glued in-place, can't really talk, and was typecast as a jobber a long time ago." These things are subjective, but this was the majority opinion.
Even 'The Modern Day Maharaja's' staunchest defenders found their stance waning during the Shinsuke Nakamura feud, however. The early days were fine, as the assumption was that Nakamura was there to end the drudgery, and eventually capture the WWE Championship in a heroic, brand-saving moment. That never came, though. Defeated on consecutive pay-per-views, Shinsuke was shuffled to the back of the pile, his once indomitable aura dented by a feud that painted him as a dork.
It's worst moments came in September, when, unbelievably, Mahal resorted to straight-up racism while addressing his Hell In A Cell opponent, mocking his trademark expressions, then claiming people of Nakamura's ethnicity "all rook the same."
A grotesque way to generate heat, it became an objective failure when the fans responded with chants of "that's too far."
6. Kane & Lita
The entire Kane & Lita saga was a shambles, and completely destroyed what remained of the goodwill 'The Big Red Machine' had earned on his post-unmasking psychotic break, thanks, primarily, to two particularly vulgar storytelling moments.
The idea of a Kane/Lita romance angle is daft, but not inherently problematic. A pregnancy as the result of coerced sex, however, is. Though it wasn't an explicit rape angle, Kane claimed that he'd impregnated her to "carry on his legacy." Lita, meanwhile, explained that she'd slept with the monster to keep him from going after her then-boyfriend Matt Hardy again.
Such angles rarely end well in this company (see: Mae Young and the hand), and this one concluded on a miscarriage. Kane accidentally tumbled on his betrothed when newcomer Snitsky hit him with a steel chair. Lita lost the child, and the two monsters started feuding, with Kane seeking revenge for his new foe effectively causing the death of his unborn son or daughter.
Snitsky's "It wasn't my fault!" proclamation turned him into a meme, which is about the only positive thing we can see of this turgid piece of sh*t.
5. Kerwin White
WWE have run boatloads of distasteful characters over the years, and it would've been easy to slot Eugene, Virgil, or Cryme Tyme into this slot. But as bad as those gimmicks were, none were as outright weird as Kerwin White, who came to life when Chavo Guerrero decisively renounced his Hispanic heritage after hopping to Raw in the 2005 draft, having been subjected to weeks of abuse at the hands of the equally problematic Mexicools.
A stereotypical middle-class white conservative, Kerwin's hair was dyed blonde, and he rode to the ring on a golf cart. It was a terrible image, but things got considerably worth as soon as he started opening his mouth. White's diatribes against literally any ethnic minority the creative team could think of (including Hispanics) were absurd, and he eventually transitioned into going directly after Shelton Benjamin, whom he feuded with through fall and summer.
His catchphrase? "If it's not White, then it's not right." Hilariously tone-deaf.
It's impossible to tell how long WWE planned on persisting with the gimmick, as they wisely pulled Chavo away from it following his uncle Eddie's passing. Speaking of which...
4. Eddiesploitation
An electric, charismatic performer whose near-universal love among wrestling fans was matched only by the respect he commanded behind the scenes, Eddie Guerrero's November 2005 passing hit like a mortar blast. It was the worst kind of shock, made even more tragic by reports that he was set to win the World Heavyweight Championship the night his body was found in his hotel room, and it jolted the sport to its core, with WWE airing a tasteful, well-done tribute on the next episode of Raw.
Unfortunately, WWE's next step was utterly heinous, and undid all the goodwill earned that night. The build towards the 2006 Royal Rumble focused around Rey Mysterio "doing it for Eddie." This got a tad gratuitous when Rey started riding down to the ring in lowriders, but it wasn't a problem in itself.
The ensuing feud with Randy Orton most certainly was.
WWE decided to have 'The Legend Killer' use Guerrero's passing to draw heat, the infamy peaking with Orton spitting the line "Eddie ain't in heaven... Eddie's down there in hell!" right in his opponent's face. It succeeded more in making fans hate the writers than it did Randy.
3. Muhammad Hassan: Terrorist
The right writing team could have done something big with Muhammad Hassan. A disgruntled Arab American fed-up with societal prejudices had potential in the mid-2000's climate, as, like many of the best wrestling angles, it tied in with what was going in the world around him, and played on the audience's paranoia. But it needed a smart, careful approach to avoid descending into offensiveness, and WWE creative wasn't up to the task.
The Hassan situation was an insensitive mess by the end, and reached its nadir when WWE ran an angle that saw a gang of black-clad pseudo-terrorists jumped The Undertaker on an episode of SmackDown. They battered him with clubs, before garroting the legend with piano wire, the move seemingly done to simulate a beheading. Bad, bad, bad, and made even worse by real-life events.
52 people perished in the London bombings three days afterwards. Outlets like the New York Post, TV Guide, and Variety all slated the company, and SmackDown's network (UPN) put WWE under immense pressure to remove Hassan from television. They did just that, and Muhammad was never seen again after being Powerbombed through the stage to the floor below.
2. Hawk's Attempted Suicide
Life wasn't easy for Road Warrior Hawk, whose struggles with drug and alcohol addiction were devastating.
His personal problems should have never been made part of a storyline, but WWE did just that in 1998. Vince Russo's drive for harder, edgier programming in the Attitude Era's nascent stages saw them exploit Hawk's issues against both his and partner Animal's wishes. A horrific programme saw him show up to bouts in various stages of intoxication, culminating in one of the most controversial angles of all time, as the Legion of Doom member scaled the TitanTron, ready to leal, before Puke, his other major ally, shoved him off.
Puke then announced that he was the one plying Hawk with drugs and alcohol in the first place. He wanted his spot in LoD, and these were his methods.
This unsurprisingly led to both Hawk and Animal quitting the company in protest, not returning until WWE called them in for a one-night angle with World Tag Team Champions Kane and Rob Van Dam in May 2003. It's a miracle they said "yes," given what they'd put them through five years prior.
1. Katie Vick
Destined to live forever as one of (if not the) most bone-headed ideas to ever make it out of a WWE creative meeting, the Katie Vick storyline presented the company's product at its absolute grimmest in 2002.
Kane was set to face Triple H in a bout pitting his Intercontinental belt against Hunter's World Heavyweight Title at No Mercy. The build saw 'The Game' claim his opponent was in a one-sided relationship with Vick, who was tragically killed in a car crash. Kane f*cked the corpse, Triple H reckoned he had footage, and tormented 'The Big Red Machine' for weeks as a result, before finally unveiling the tape on Raw.
What we got was Triple H slipping into a funeral home in a Kane mask, finding a mannequin dressed up as Vick, then simulating sex. "I did it, I screwed your brains out," Hunter said, pulling a handful of gray matter from the casket.
The angle's grotesqueness needs no further extrapolation. It fully deserves its legacy as one of the most embarrassing things this big, dopy company has ever done, and it's a miracle that Kane and Triple H were able to survive it with their careers intact.