10 Ways WWE Can Improve Its Product In 2017
How can the company boost interest?
No matter how successful a company is or has been, improvements are a constant necessity in order to remain prosperous.
Even the greatest companies must make changes to improve their product every now and then. Businesses in poor shape often need an entire re-branding or re-launch to change their fortunes, and while WWE isn't part of the latter group (unlike another pro-wrestling company), enhancements to the output are still a must. With another NFL season underway, MLB playoffs starting, and popular TV shows like The Walking Dead returning, the newest fall television season brings stronger competition to WWE than the company has had all year. Thye can't afford to stand still.
WWE typically brings its A-game as we turn the calendar to a new year, but would be foolish to wait that long to step it up in 2017. This is without even mentioning that WWE's A-game has been more like a C-game in recent years. A month removed from SummerSlam and ways away from WrestleMania, WWE feels more stagnant now than it's been in a long while and desperately needs improvement.
But what can WWE do, specifically, to reverse the yearly trend of the post-SummerSlam lull? Even beyond the fall, what are the answers to improving WWE's product long-term?
10. Embrace Their Rich History
Remember that awesome video package WWE created back in early 2002? Often referred to as "WWE Desire", it's a great example of how WWE's perpetually growing history can really add to the current product.
Set to Kid Rock's "Lonely Road of Faith", this package was the first time, perhaps ever, WWE dug deep into their archives to present a tribute to their rich history of performers. Prior to this, WWE only recalled the history of current performers and a handful of legends still in the company's good graces.
Imagine if the NFL never mentioned Peyton Manning or Jerry Rice's illustrious accomplishments, or legendary coaches like Bill Walsh or John Madden? That's exactly what WWE does by ignoring selective, vital components that were integral in making WWE the juggernaut it is today.
While WWE acknowledges their history through WWE Network offerings, the weekly product often replicates the ignorance displayed back in the mid-90s. Chris Benoit notwithstanding, way too many talents are forgotten, ignored, or, for all intents and purposes, erased from WWE's history. It's incredibly short-sighted and cannibalizes the company's stature by not utilizing all of WWE's past to bridge to the future.
9. Create Different Babyface Characters
Part of that history includes some truly memorable babyfaces. Today, WWE seemingly uses the same template - an incredibly outdated one - to create faces fans will hopefully support. Categorically, Vince McMahon fails miserably at this even when he's gifted an already-over protagonist, either from NXT or elsewhere.
Quick, who is the most popular (read: cheered and supported) superstar in WWE today?
Nakamura? He was 100 times hotter in his NXT debut than now. Kevin Owens? He's a heel. Lesnar? Another heel. Finn Bálor? Again, hotter 18 months ago. Bayley? See Nakamura/Bálor. AJ Styles? Maybe.
Gone are the days of multiple, unique, babyfaces like Hogan, Warrior, Piper, and Jake Roberts. Hell, even during WWE's most financially disastrous year ever (1995), Bret, Shawn, Undertaker, and Razor were all very over.
Isn't it saying something that despite McMahon booking half his roster to be popular, so few actually are? It says even more that there isn't one WWE talent today who is better off now than they were at some point in the past, from a popularity perspective. I fear for Asuka just as I did for Bayley.
WWE used to make talents better, but in 2017, Vince paints everyone with the same brush. It's rarely gallery-worthy.
8. Book Real Heat
On the flip side, good heels are as useful a tool as any in getting over babyfaces. While Steve Austin would have still been a star on his own, how much did he benefit from the genius of Bret Hart? How big would Dusty have been without Ric Flair? Hell, even Virgil had a moment in the sun at SummerSlam '91 thanks to Ted DiBiase.
But with great heels came great heat that promoters of yesteryear weren't afraid to book. Sure, it's a different world today and the veil that covered pro-wrestling previously has been pulled back, if not completely torn down. Still, fans want to buy into the characters portrayed on-screen; it's no different than a movie or a play.
In WWE, heels aren't meant to be despised by the audience anymore. And don't ask WWE how they want their heels to be treated. One minute, heels are on Twitter belittling fans, the next they're shown doing charity work for underprivileged kids. Why must the heels' character integrity be constantly compromised because of wishy-washy, conflicting direction from leadership?
Unfortunately, between today's age of political correctness, pressure from corporate sponsors, and, most importantly, the seemingly neutered 72 year-old Vince McMahon, WWE just doesn't book the bite it used to.
7. Subtle Booking
Subtlety in television is such a simple thing to produce yet it can create the most rewarding effects for ardent, observant fans.
Great examples of using subtleties to foreshadow future events can be found in shows like Game of Thrones, Breaking Bad, Boardwalk Empire, or House of Cards. While it's been absent from WWE television for years on top of years, once upon a time the company knew how to book subtly. Granted, it was during the Reagan administration, but they did it nonetheless,
Remember WWE's slow-build break-up of Randy Savage & Miss Elizabeth and Hulk Hogan? How a seemingly innocuous hug or a gently placed hand was all fans saw for months before it ultimately led to the Mega Powers exploding? How about Bret Hart's slowly-but-surely evolving heel turn that culminated the night after WrestleMania 13 and made for some of the best television WWE ever produced?
Aside from the booker, or writers, creating these little nuggets of greatness, capable talent is an absolute must. While much of today's talents have not been tested in those scenarios, surely there are numerous superstars on the main roster who would excel at subtlety if given the chance.
6. Reduce The Creative Writing Staff.
On the subject of the writers, the pool is just way too crowded these days.
While Vince McMahon likes to throw around phrases like "the company has evolved" or "it's a different business today", the fact is these are excuses. Excuses for why a team that consists of over a dozen script writers, very few with a pro-wrestling background, cannot come close to crafting the type of content Pat Patterson and Vince McMahon did when it was just two dudes booking by the pool.
Granted, some of WWE's current writers probably are capable but are forced to cater to the style and preferences of their 72 year-old boss in order to keep their job. Still, with a number that seemingly grows every year, the bloated writing staff needs to go - at least as it pertains to drafting the content of the weekly television shows. They can be used for the WWE Network or to pen scripts for talents to use at press events, charities, and media appearances, but leave the most important writing - the content of RAW and SmackDown - to the individuals who have great minds for the business.
5. Employ More "WWF" Minds.
No disrespect is meant here, but why is it that almost immediately after WCW went out of business, WWE began employing failed WCW personnel in powerful positions? WWE loves reminding everyone that WCW lost the Monday Night War, and while this far from disqualifies WCW alumni from providing positive contributions to the business, why wouldn't WWE stick to their own personnel that helped them defeat WCW? In other words, why doesn't WWE hire more "WWE" or "WWF" minds?
Maybe you're not aware, but here are just a few of the names that fall into this category: Arn Anderson, Dusty Rhodes, John Lauranaitis, Billy Kidman, Fit Finlay, Scott Armstrong, and Dean Malenko. Tell me, these are names most often associated with which major wrestling promotion?
While incredible minds with a WWE pedigree are available in the likes Scott Hall, Bret Hart, Sean Waltman, Jake Roberts, Edge, or even Paul Heyman, these are names that never appear in the list of contributors to WWE Creative.
Unless WWE wants the quality of their product to continue devolving into WCW-levels circa 2000, why continue to empower components from the ship that sank rather than the ship that sailed?
4. Eliminate Heavily Scripted Promos
Promos are such an important part of WWE today that it's understandable how the company came to scripting nearly every word that comes out of every talent's mouth. Unfortunately, they went overboard with it and now need to scale back... way back.
Thanks to WWE's corporate sponsors and partners, the company does not want to risk talents going off-the-cuff and saying anything deemed inappropriate. With that said, WWE regularly seems to forget the type of business they're in and that speaking in carefully crafted terms is often counterproductive to producing entertaining television. Especially in 2017, nobody talks the way 99% of the main roster does.
Identifying the problem is the first step towards solving it, and in this case, WWE needs to give some creative freedom back to the talent. This is what made Talking Smack so popular before VKM killed it. Some talents already have more liberty than others, but even that is nothing compared to the '80s or '90s when it was the talent's responsibility to create their own verbiage. After all, who knows the character best?
3. Quit Insulting Fans' Intelligence
In addition to viewers having to put up with phony, wooden promos in 2017, the storylines and product in general is insulting to anyone that doesn't call themselves a "wrestling fan". I dare you to try and watch 15 minutes of RAW or SmackDown with any casual television viewer that does not watch WWE and you'll see what I'm talking about. Hell, even the most loyal WWE fans are tired of having their intelligence insulted on a regular basis.
Can we please go back to the attitude that the fans aren't dumb? It's actually become quite fashionable in television today, if WWE needs another reason.
Could you imagine David Benioff and D.B. Weiss approving the dreck that's seen on RAW for even a single episode of Game Of Thrones? How about Vince Gilligan adopting Vince McMahon's "fans won't remember" attitude when working on Breaking Bad or Better Call Saul?
There're countless reasons why insulting the viewer's intelligence in 2017 is not a smart move. Unfortunately, WWE just doesn't seem to care.
2. Present A Babyface Who's Actually Popular As The Top Star
Remember when fans used to cheer for the top star of the company? Whether it was Hogan/Warrior, Austin/Rock, or more recently, Daniel Bryan, the top babyface used to genuinely elicit a majority of cheers. For whatever reason, WWE's been dead set on pushing, as Diesel said in 1995, "a corporate puppet that [Vince] decided to create," in lieu of talent that's actually popular.
John Cena was rejected by half the audience (if not more) for over a decade before Roman Reigns made Cena look like Stone Cold. Is it a coincidence that WWE's popularity has waned considerably ever since they changed philosophies on what a top babyface is or needs to be?
WWE wants to control everything and everybody. They don't want anyone getting too big for their britches and risking another 2004 Brock Lesnar situation. Still, there're plenty of superstars with strong enough support that would be better received than Cena or Reigns have been over the past two decades. But despite all their posturing and lip-service, WWE's actions prove they really don't listen to the fans or care what they think. It's really only concerned with the opinion of one man...
1. Much Less Vince McMahon Input
The reality is that Vince McMahon is the biggest hindrance to WWE producing a fresh product in 2017. Hell, he's been the main roadblock since the 2000s ever since WCW went under and WWE began resting on their laurels. It's not going to change, but would need to if WWE is to spruce up their product.
In all fairness, Vince McMahon is still a marketing and business guru. His decision to scrap the old pay-per-view system and move towards the ever-popular streaming service model back in 2014 is going to be the move that sets his company up for the future. McMahon was, at one point, a creative genius - not perfect, but far more successful than unsuccessful. Vince had a vision that was finally realized in 2001 and the man will likely go down as the greatest promoter in the history of live entertainment.
But when it comes to producing and approving compelling, eye-catching, entertaining television in the 21st century, he doesn't have it anymore and it's hurting the product. A quick comparison to the quality of NXT Creative (which has maybe a tenth of the talent roster WWE has) shows that wrestling doesn't have to be cringeworthy in 2017. Unfortunately, with Vince McMahon's fingerprints on anything and everything, it will be.