12 WWE Face & Heel Turns That IMMEDIATELY Backfired
WWE fans wanted NOTHING to do with these botched babyface and heel turns.
WWE's writers don't script heel or babyface turns to deliberately fail. That'd be counterproductive, not to mention a complete and utter waste of their precious time. Ask anybody who has ever worked any shifts on the company's creative team and they'll tell you that time is scarce - they need 48 hours days for each 24 on offer, so they're not exactly going to muck about coming up with stuff they know will be crap.
That's a bit of a scary thought when considering some of the junk that's been hurled in front of fans this century alone, but it is what it is. Being overworked likely explains away some of the nonsense served up. Remember, every single one of the turn angles examined here was supposed to work - WWE wanted you to cheer prior villains just as much as they wanted you to boo prior heroes.
Where's Mick Jagger to belt out a quick, "You can't always get what you want" refrain when you need him?
Many on the active WWE roster will suffer the same fate these poor sods did. They might've had good intentions, and turns might even have made sense on paper during crunch creative team meetings, but actually working in front of the cameras? That's a different story.
The tricky part is that nobody can predict with 100% accuracy whether a turn will work or not until it's happened. Finding out live in real time is likely hellish, but it's unavoidable.
Check out all of these heel and baby switches that tanked pretty much immediately.
12. Mustafa Ali Is Behind Retribution (2020)
Good lord, the Retribution experiment truly was rubbish.
A mysterious band of no good vandals began destroying WWE property during the earliest knockings of the pandemic in 2020, then they revealed that they were all ex-NXT hopefuls who were sick and tired of waiting for their big break. Their goal? To get WWE contracts, even though they...had WWE contracts. Yeah, nothing about this made any sense. It was about as well-thought out as most things during Vince McMahon's creative death rattle.
Then, poor Mustafa Ali was drafted in to try and save the whole thing. He isn't Tom Cruise, and this was a real mission impossible rather than a fictional one. Sure, WWE is fiction, but the reality was that Retribution was already stinking to high heavens by the time Ali unveiled himself as the mastermind behind it all. That, dear readers, just made the high-flying babyface turned scheming heel look like an absolute fool.
WWE abandoned Mustafa's hacker gimmick (which actually looked like it had some potential) in favour of turning him into a mouthpiece and leader for Retribution. Several problems became clear straight away: Firstly, Ali didn't need to turn heel and hadn't even scratched the surface of his babyface run on the main roster. Second, it took him far too long to target Kofi Kingston for "stealing" his WWE Title shot in 2019.
By the time that happened, most fans were bored of the Retribution thing. Hell, WWE's creative team was sick and tired of it come the feud with New Day. No wonder Ali requested his own release from contract after living through this televised purgatory.
11. Faarooq Falls Flat As A Face (1998)
It's easy to forget that walking charisma machine The Rock was only placed in the heat-seeking Nation Of Domination faction to give him a prayer of working out on the WWF roster in 1997. Before that, young poodle-haired Rocky Maivia had been about as popular with fans as a Kurrgan vs. Giant Silva 60-minute 'Iron Man' match would've been. They were chanting, "Die, Rocky Die" at the poor kid!
Joining the Nation and morphing into a cocksure heel turned out to be a blessing for The Rock. He gained in confidence, started quelling the doubters (backstage and in the bleachers), and everything looked like it was heading in the right direction. Sadly, Rock's rise means that original NOD leader Faarooq had to be unceremoniously booted out of his own faction. Not to worry though, eh, because a babyface run awaited Ron Simmons.
That face sprint between March-November 1998 felt more like a marathon.
It was seriously tepid, because the Faarooq character was a natural heel and Simmons wasn't a patch on the worker he'd been in WCW beforehand. It was crystal clear during even his first few matches as a so-called good guy that fans didn't give a toss about ol' Ron as a hero. Plus, it was super-weird to see him still sporting the usual Nation attire as he awkwardly high-fived fans en route to the ring.
Realising the error of their ways and keen to correct it, the WWF returned Ron to a heel role as part of The Acolytes alongside Bradshaw later in '98. They had to - he defo wasn't going to pan out as a face. Not until he started chain smoking and sinking beers in an office without walls, that is.
10. Fans Don’t Want To Boo Eddie Guerrero (2004)
The butterfly effect of Chavo Guerrero's injury in mid-2003 was insane. He tore his biceps, which stalled WWE's plans for the Los Guerreros tag-team with Eddie, and therefore forced 'Latino Heat' to sub in Tajiri as a temporary replacement. They'd win out at Judgment Day, then drop the tag titles back to Charlie Haas and Shelton Benjamin on the 3 July episode of SmackDown.
Post-match, Eddie was furious and attacked Tajiri for his part in things. Old 2002 Guerrero was back again, but fans wanted nothing to do with it. They'd fallen in love with Eddie's "Lie, Cheat & Steal" gimmick alongside Chavo, so they didn't fancy booing him just because he'd slapped a Cruiserweight about; Tajiri didn't have enough sympathy to heap hatred on Guerrero.
Not even close.
By September, WWE gave in to the cheers that accompanied every Eddie appearance and turned him babyface on TV yet again for a feud opposite rising star John Cena. They had no choice. People point blank refused to boo or jeer Guerrero even when he was cutting menacing promos, telling them to shut up or kicking the ever-loving crap out of babyfaces right in front of them.
In fact, they encouraged him to do that. 'Latino Heat' was over, man. WWE's fanbase was more than ready to embrace Eddie as a top star, which is something they'd get to do when Vince McMahon strapped a rocket to him in early-2004 and had Guerrero beat Brock Lesnar to become WWE Champion.
The heel turn on Tajiri backfired as soon as it happened. No question.
9. The Miz Just Isn’t Likeable (2012)
Some wrestlers are born to be babyface or heel. Charlotte Flair springs to mind as somebody who's naturally an elitist villain, whereas Ricky Steamboat always worked best as a mild-mannered but very accomplished in-ring technician who had a sweet rapport with fans worldwide. Forcing square pegs into round holes with workers like that is never the best idea, but knowing that won't stop WWE trying from time to time.
Enter The Miz.
Yep, in 2025 he's a WWE lifer who's cherished for being such a world class a**hole on screen. That's undeniable, and there is something to be said for legacy stars becoming likeable by default over time. It's one of those, 'He's an insufferable jerk, but he's our insufferable jerk" situations. Arguably, Miz had that tag on him way back in 2012, so it was puzzling that WWE's writers thought they could turn such an excellent heel into a genuinely adorable goody two shoes.
Suddenly, rather than berating fans and demanding they listen to him, The Miz was acting like the least-cool Saturday morning kid's TV host ever. Remember when substitute teachers seemed cool when you were 10 but then got grating once you turned 14? Yeah, that. Even Ric Flair stopping by to gift Miz his figure four finisher didn't work.
Nobody wanted to see Miz wooing. It was too forced. "Too forced" would perfectly sum up this shortlived babyface attempt as a whole. At least our Mike managed to learn from this failure and become a slightly less-irritating baby years later. He was born to be a heel though. There's no getting away from that!
8. Rikishi Did It For The Rock (2000)
WWF boss Vince McMahon was hoping that dancing midcard comedy act (who could wrestle) Rikishi could make a difference to the top line mix in 2000. 'New Generation' faithful will see what we did there. Make a difference, Fatu! Here's the story: Rikishi might've worked as an occasional main-eventer had he stayed true to the babyface persona people had come to know and love, but that wasn't McMahon's plan.
No, he thought outing Kish as the guy who had run over Steve Austin back at Survivor Series 1999 was the best course of action. Worse, Vince installed one of the crummiest/laziest race-related storylines of all time by having Rikishi claim that he "did it for The Rock". Acting Commish and would-be detective Mick Foley was so shocked that his other ear fell off.
OK, not really, but the bottom certainly fell out of federation plans for the big chap from Too Cool.
He bizarrely kept wearing the comedic thong that had captured fan hearts on the undercard, but spliced in some leathers as commentators assured everybody that the big powerhouse was definitely a "Bad Man". It felt half-hearted, and Rikishi never once looked on the level of somebody like 'Stone Cold'. Austin seemed to agree - he battered Kish, then Triple H replaced him in the rivalry as the true genius behind Austin's gritty Survivor Series fate.
Rudderless, Rikishi trundled along as a heel for a while longer before quietly returning to his old dancing gimmick. In truth, and despite being cut short, the heel run had gone on too long anyway. Bloodline-esque "cinema" this was not.
7. Matt Hardy’s Brother Hate Flops (2009)
Sibling rivalries range from the classics like Bret vs. Owen Hart to real clangers like Booker T vs. Stevie Ray over in the creative wasteland known as latter-day WCW. There's rarely any middle ground, and it's a pity to report that Jeff vs. Matt Hardy fell into the latter 'one to forget' camp. It backfired instantly because fans just didn't want to boo either brother.
Matt nonsensically turned on his bro at Royal Rumble 2009 amidst rumours that Christian was set to return from TNA and assume that role alongside Edge. Then, the Hardys feuded through WrestleMania XXV and Backlash, but the matches were only so-so and outlandish suggestions that Matt had set fire to Jeff’s house (and killed his dog) didn’t do them any favours.
Things were so humdrum that Matt had returned to a babyface role in August after saving Jeff from CM Punk and The Hart Dynasty. He explained away his erm...erratic behaviour by claiming he wasn’t actually behind the fire, and the brothers patched things up. The whole thing was a gigantic waste of time that cut into Jeff's ride to the top of the WWE cards.
Sure, trying to drag Matt along with him made sense, but crowds weren't ready to treat the pair differently. It was obvious from minute one that Matt would have to be on the midcard/upper midcard whilst Jeff soared through the air in headline banner bouts. There was no getting away from it.
No amount of surly promos soaked in jealousy could change that. The Hardy in-fighting had flopped and would go down as a failed experiment.
6. Edge Shelves Sympathy For Judgment Day (2022)
In his pomp, Edge was the "ultimate opportunist". He was the kind of sick, twisted dude who'd steal your girl then flash a toothy grin after bagging yet another World Championship. In short, he was one of the best heels in the biz for a long, long time. Then, injuries claimed another career and he was forced to retire from the ring in 2011. A 9 year absence (sort of - Edge still showed up in non-wrestling spots) followed.
All of the pain and misery washed away in a heartbeat once Alter Bridge blared out at the 2020 Royal Rumble and the beloved 'Rated-R Superstar' made one of the best comebacks ever in the #21 slot. Visibly emotional, Edge himself could scarcely believe that he was back in the saddle doing his thing, and therein lies the problem with his unwanted 2022 heel turn.
Fans could never truly despise him after everything he'd been through or those tears in 2020. They were too real, and everybody knew the sort of insane damage Adam Copeland had done to his body after decades of big bumps and memorable moments. He was a firm sentimental favourite, so garnering authentic heat was going to be impossible.
Edge formed Judgment Day with Damian Priest and Rhea Ripley before being dumped out of the group just as Finn Bálor joined. It was hollow, unsatisfying and frankly second-rate to then see him limp back into a babyface gig like nothing had happened. Current AEW star Cope might've yearned to do something different before hanging up the boots on his own terms, but this wasn't it.
That was evident straight away after he ambushed AJ Styles pre-WrestleMania 38.
5. Kane’s Deplorable Actions Make Cheers Impossible (2004)
What on earth were they thinking?!
Lowlight moments from the whole 'Kane loves Lita, pass it on' saga included the ex-Team Xtreme member trying to goad him into chokeslamming her so she'd miscarry their kayfabe unborn child, Kane fending off Matt Hardy in some seriously duff matches, and Gene Snitsky punting a fake baby high up into the air like he was defending an NFL lead deep into the 4th quarter and just wanted the ball anywhere but close to his goal line.
To combat this, Kane turned babyface. Kinda. He went from sadistic monster who'd forcibly impregnated the Diva and bragged about it to a...good guy who was doing everything he could think of to stop Snitsky? Let's get real: Gene hoofing the doll was nowhere near as bad as Kane being cast as an actual rapist WWE then wanted you to feel sorry for. This was deplorably bad.
Why did the company think for one second that people would champion this version of Kane? Good grief. The whole episode did nothing to halt the creative slide of a story fans wanted to stop. Just stop the pain, writing team. Don't bloody well add to it! Sadly, they did. WWE attempted to sell everyone on Kane being a concerned daddy who actually cared about Lita's part in everything and was terrified of losing his child.
Some of the skits booked around this time must be seen to be believed. Actually, avoid them like the plague. Read this entry, take one writer's word for it and avoid, avoid, avoid. Zero stars. 0/10. Not recommended. Dud.
4. Becky Lynch Turn Exposes Charlotte Flair (2018)
Becky Lynch was supposed to be the villain of the piece when turning on Charlotte Flair at SummerSlam 2018 (after the pair's Triple Threat with Carmella). Instead, fans rejected that booking and cheered hard for her because they legit looked at Becks as somebody who'd been overlooked and deserved a shot at glory. That led to grumbles behind the scenes.
WWE’s writers were forced to pivot, and fast. Fan response to Lynch hammering Charlotte exposed the truth that Flair couldn’t be a likeable/sympathetic figure no matter how hard she tried. The warped thing about all of this is that Charlotte often comes across as a likeable person away from the ring in interviews. She has fears and issues just like every one else, but her silver spoon presentation is what it is.
Crowds rebelling against WWE's wishes accidentally created Becky's iconic 'The Man' character. Had people not hopped on her bandwagon as hard as they did, then there's simply no way she, Ronda Rousey or Flair would've headlined WrestleMania 35 like they did. That was a byproduct of the rebellion first seen during the summer of 2018. The 'Summer Of Punk'? Nah, this was the 'Summer Of Becks'.
Lynch's promo on the post-SummerSlam edition of SmackDown was supposed to be riddled with heel heat as she portrayed herself as a snot-nosed victim, but an organic response in Brooklyn to her fiery words paved the way for Becky's rise towards 'female Stone Cold' status. Unfortunately, as aforementioned, it also laid bare just how little peeps were into the thought of rooting for Charlotte.
Oops.
3. Randy Orton’s Post-Evolution Struggles (2004)
Hey, nothing you can say. Nothing's going to change what you've done to me. Now it's time to shine, I'm gonna take what's mine while you're burning inside my light. Sorry, no particular reason for belting out the lyrics to Randy Orton's old 'Burn In My Light' entrance track, but it is nice to even the score now WWE crowds singalong to his 'Voices' classic en masse in 2025.
In fairness, Def Rebel hasn't given them many choices!
Young Randall certainly had every reason to say: "Now it's time to shine, I'm gonna take what's mine" after being kicked right out of Evolution following his surprise World Heavyweight Title win over Chris Benoit at SummerSlam 2004. Triple H, Ric Flair and (to a lesser extent) Batista were unhappy that he'd decided to shake hands with the Canadian. How dare he - Evolution didn't play well with others. They were brutes.
The Evolution split launched Randy into a hopeful babyface role, but he wasn't ready for it and that was glaring straight away. No, it didn't help when Hunter beat him to win the belt at Unforgiven so quickly, but maybe WWE figured Orton was better as chaser rather than as head hunted champion. Whatever way they sliced it, something else was staring them in the face.
They had to cut their losses on clean cut, Rocky Maivia-like baby Randy.
WWE turned Orton heel in time for a WrestleMania 21 match with The Undertaker. That was an inspired decision that completely re-energised the relative newbie and let him sneer at fan hatred rather than putting on puppy dog eyes to beg for their sympathy. Being babyface is more challenging than being heel, and Randy found that out the hard way early into his main event days.
2. Steve Austin Regrets Joining Mr. McMahon (2001)
Remember earlier when it was said that WWE fans didn't want to boo Eddie Guerrero, Matt Hardy or Becky Lynch. Well, stack that trio into the one package, crank up the frustration and then double it for one 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin. He'd turned anti-hero babyface at WrestleMania 13 in 1997, then Austin became the biggest star in the entire industry.
He was the everyman who called it like he saw it and never backed down in the face of sustained corporate pressure. So, imagine how weird it was for people to boo 'Stone Cold' once he turned on The Rock at 'Mania X-Seven to "shake hands with the devil himself" and become Vince McMahon's new puppet. That was a swerve, one possibly justifiable by Austin's 'I'll do anything to become WWF Champ' speech pre-show, but facts are facts: It was a swerve the fed audience didn't want, or at least weren't ready for.
They half-heartedly jeered Austin for brutally beating long-time pal Jim Ross on SmackDown shortly after 'Mania, but that's all it was. Half-hearted. Soon, Steve would regret not calling an audible to kick McMahon in the gut and haul him in for a huge Stunner in Houston's Reliant Astrodome. To this day, the legend believes he should've done just that.
Again, one could defend Austin's heel turn by saying he was a wounded/fallen hero desperately clawing his way back to the top, but that's merely playing devil's advocate for fun. The harsh reality is that changing anything about Steve's act in 2001 (especially considering he'd only just returned after a year away the previous October) was a mistake.
He'd never be the same again before retiring from a full time schedule in 2003.
1. Batista Isn’t The People’s Choice (2014)
Are they saying "Boo-tista"? Big dishy Dave Batista had previously left WWE as a spoilt brat/crybaby heel in 2010, but was all set to return as a hero 4 years later. The problem here was that WWE’s fanbase had moved on to newer things - they'd evolved, if you like, and they wanted a Daniel Bryan push badly. People set their hearts on seeing a technical mastermind that Vince McMahon likely found dull rocket to the top of the pack.
Batista was in the way of that.
Things came to a head quickly when 'The Animal' won the 2014 Royal Rumble and was booed out of the building for doing so. WWE had no choice but to run with this and turn him heel all over again so he could moan about Bryan’s popularity (thus not-so-subtly returning to his crybaby antics from 2010) like someone whining via X that a wrestler they've never heard of is booked on a WWE-meets-AAA crossover show.
Except, well...Batista really should've known what he was in for. He'd have realised that fan rebellion was right around the corner had he been tuning into WWE programming since 2012. Bryan had charmed everybody alongside Kane as part of 'Team Hell No'. Actually, he'd been making folks chuckle since his days as a heel who shouted "NO" in the face of "YES" alongside AJ Lee.
Batista's Rumble win was meant to be greeted like the best thing ever, but it was volleyed right back at McMahon and his writers like it was 2025 and they'd booked Bill Goldberg to squash everybody on Raw.
What other WWE babyface or heel turns immediately backfired? For more wrestling, check out 15 WWE Gimmick Changes That IMMEDIATELY Backfired and 15 Times WWE Stars Made Cameos BEFORE They Were Famous!