25 Worst Wrestling Moments Of 2020

One of wrestling's weirdest years saw WWE and AEW produce some shockers.

Roman Reigns Baron Corbin
WWE.com

The period between late 2019-early 2020 was so foul that Roman Reigns decided he needed total reinvention if he was going to tackle a new decade without strangling members of the creative team. Truthfully, it was a strange time for everybody involved in pro wrestling. The COVID pandemic landed in March 2020 and changed everything.

Creatively, Vince McMahon had run out of ideas, but there was panic on the other side of the fence as Tony Khan realised his AEW revolution would have to pivot, pivot, pivot like Ross from Friends. Being fair to both WWE and AEW, they did provide millions with entertainment whilst stuck at home, but this article isn't obsessed with the good from 2020.

It's all about the bad. Johnny B. Badd.

Nah, WCW's erm...finest isn't here. He might well have popped up in some of the cinematic matches both companies put on that year though. Success stories like the 'Boneyard Match' between The Undertaker and AJ Styles at WrestleMania 36 or the banter-filled 'Stadium Stampede' at All Elite's Double Or Nothing set the standard most others couldn't match.

Here, you'll find some of 2020's worst gimmicks, bits of booking, match performances, match results and more. Wrestling was only trying to survive the closed door days and get everybody talking. It did that, but not always for the most glowing of reasons.

Regrettable personal angles, cinematic clangers, rubbish knock offs, sharks, tentacle monsters, fake deaths and more. 2020 was a trip, people. Here's the absolute worst of it.

25. Drew McIntyre’s First Reign Ends With No Fans

WWE Hell In A Cell 2020 Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

Timing is everything.

Drew McIntyre winning the WWE Title in front of exactly zero punters at WrestleMania 36 sucked for him, but the Scot showed himself to be a true leader by refusing to moan about it. Instead, McIntyre pointed out that a lot of people were suffering around the world due to the pandemic, so he didn’t have a lot to complain about. He was still living his dream.

However, WWE refused to ride out his first title reign until fans were back in. Drew lost the belt to Randy Orton at Hell In A Cell 2020. He'd regain it on the 16 November Raw, then drop it to The Miz at Elimination Chamber following a Money In The Bank cash in. Again, timing is everything.

The fact McIntyre never appeared once in front of fans with the belt is rubbish. Incredibly, Drew would have to wait until 2026 for that feeling. His entrance on the 16 January edition of SmackDown was personally satisfying - it was the first time the big man had strolled to the ring holding that belt in front of a sell out crowd, and it had to feel good.

Seeing him dance around the ring like an excited teenager after winning the 2020 Royal Rumble contrasted mightily with the sound of a giant fan accompanying his first title win at 'Mania 36 inside the quaint Performance Center. Thankfully, McIntyre got his moment after all, but that doesn't mean anybody needs to like his WWE Title losses in 2020 (first and foremost) or 2021.


24. AEW’s ‘Tooth & Nail’ Clanger

AEW All Out 2020 Britt Baker Big Swole Tooth & Nail
AEW

Watching 'Tooth & Nail' was almost as much fun as going to the dentist for real. In other words, it wasn't fun at all. Hell, most would've gleaned more enjoyment out of reading outdated issues of National Geographic in the waiting room than seeing Britt Baker and Big Swole struggle their way through one of wrestling's worst cinematic brawls.

All Out 2020 is generally considered to be one of AEW's worst pay-per-views to date. This stinker somehow opened the main card (what a dumb decision that was), and nobody was really impressed. The announcers tried to sell Swole and Baker scrapping through Britt's dental office as must see and dangerous, but it was actually pretty boring.

Ironically, Swole causing Baker to pass out due to laughing gas for the crummy finish had no-one giggling. It was simply the latest terrible moment in a stunt show packed with them, and it'd go down in history as perhaps the worst AEW match in history. That's covering a lot of ground considering some of the sideshow guff littering episodes of Rampage and Collision over the years.

Swole would go on to fall out with boss Tony Khan and leave the company. Meanwhile, Britt did become one of the top female stars before everything fell apart for her too. If this 'Tooth & Nail' business was supposed to be a huge leap forward for AEW's women's division, then it failed miserably.

Revisit it only if you fancy cringing your way through a cinematic disaster that couldn't match up to the best from 'Boneyard', 'Firefly Fun House' etc.


23. Otis Loses Money In The Bank

Tucker WWE
WWE.com

There's more to come on the 2020 Money In The Bank match soon, but first - big Otis was the men's winner that year, and he was riding the crest of a wave as Mandy Rose's unlikely love interest at the same time. That didn't do much for his Heavy Machinery tag-team with Tucker, to be honest. It became clear that WWE wanted to move on from the duo.

So, that's what they did come Hell In A Cell. There, Tucker betrayed Otis by helping The Miz beat him for the briefcase. It was a shocking turn, albeit one that didn't bode well for the reborn heel "Tucky". Heavy Machinery's split went exactly nowhere, but there was a bigger problem in play: MITB was bouncing around between wrestlers.

The case, and the title shot that comes with it, just didn't feel all that important or high profile. Otis was realistically never going to cash in and win any of the major World Titles, and Miz was only ever going to be a transitional champ himself if he did. That proved to be the case after he cashed in on Drew McIntyre at Elimination Chamber.

Miz only won the belt so Bobby Lashley had someone to maul.

It was deflating to see Otis go from the highs of snogging Mandy and hauling down Money In The Bank to working a going nowhere feud with his old buddy Tucker. WWE gave up on his heartwarming push in a hurry, which led many to ask this question: Why bother booking him to win in the first place?!


22. That Rubbish “Doink The Clown” Knock Off

Doink the Clown money in the bank
WWE.com

WWE and TKO top brass have a lot on their plate annually. They need to thrash out huge, money-spinning international deals for high ranking PLEs, they need to decide who wins which top championships at any given time, and they're locked into producing countless hours of television every week. Something else should be atop agendas during key meetings though.

Doink The Clown's wig.

No, seriously. If "Doink" ever shows up on screen again, then the promotion badly need to get his hair right for the first time in a long time. A fake knock off clown showed up during the aforementioned 2020 Money In The Bank ladder match held in WWE's old headquarters (Titan Towers), and he looked bloody rubbish.

Even Dink was a better Doink than this Doink. If one's going to Doink, then one must always Doink properly or not Doink at all. Right, that's plenty of that gibberish. You can probably tell that this writer is passionate about Matt Borne's original gimmick, because all subsequent versions of the character (including cameos like this one) have largely tanked or been completely unsatisfying to witness for fans of the creepy clown.

This so-called "Doink" was one of the crappiest moments in a divisive MITB ladder brawl that saw 2 matches going on at the same time. Other cameos from Brother Love, John Laurinaitis, Vince McMahon and more were better placed or at least true to the original characters involved.

This Doink The Clown wannabe wasn't. It was just some WWE staff member with a painted face and rotten green wig. What was the buttoned blue shirt all about?


21. Nightmare Collective Stinks Up The Place

AEW Bash At The Beach 2020 Kris Statlander Brandi Rhodes
AEW

Gather a group of hardcore AEW fans around you, then scream "NIGHTMARE COLLECTIVE" and watch them scatter like the old WWF Light-Heavyweight division when 1997 Kane was around. Those 2 words will drum up a lot of bad memories for All Elite's faithful fanbase, no doubt. It still sticks out as one of the group's worst ideas.

Brandi Rhodes as head of the so-called Collective in late-2019 and early-2020 was poor. A match on Bash At The Beach in January put her and Mel vs. Kris Statlander and Hikaru Shida. Originally, Awesome Kong was supposed to be in there instead of Brandi, but she was injured and had to give it a miss. The quality nosedived ahead of time as a result.

This was a thoroughly miserable 12 minutes that exposed the worst of AEW’s women’s division. Why anyone thought it was a good idea is beyond yours truly. The Nightmare Collective had been cutting off hair and cutting off interest in anything they were doing for a while, but the BATB special's bout was next level stinky.

AEW fans had already grown accustomed to match quality above all during the earliest days of Tony Khan's booking. Then, this tag effort came along to remind everyone that expecting 5-star classics across the board wasn't going to be realistic. Poor Statlander and Shida suffered as they tried to unconvincingly pull something out of Brandi and Mel.

Mercifully, Khan would eventually pull the plug on the Collective and move on. The women's division needed that respite, because it really had been naff.


20. Akira Tozawa Is…Eaten By A Shark?

R-Truth Akira Tozawa Shark 2020
WWE.com

Mick Foley still sees fans shaking their heads and thoroughly disgusted with him during meet and greet sessions to this day. OK, probably not, but Mick did introduce the dire 24/7 Title. WWE wanted him to put it over as the second coming of the old Hardcore Title concept, but the belt itself looked like a fancy chocolate biscuit brand more than a rowdy wrestling championship.

24/7 was reintroduced in 2019, but some of its worst moments happened in 2020. On the 21 September Raw, one Akira Tozawa was apparently eaten alive by a shark when trying to joust for ownership with walking punchline R-Truth. The next week, Truth received a letter revealing that Tozawa had faked his own death so he could show up to surprise him.

Maybe don't send that letter in advance, Akira. You fool!

Perhaps the worst thing about all of this is that it took place during the last stretches of a saccharine, Vince McMahon-led WWE environment. It was like the old boss took anything potentially funny and painstakingly stripped it of any humour. Comedy became "WWE comedy", and that's not meant as a compliment at all.

Putting Truth and Tozawa at the beach was one thing, but pretending that the latter had been munched by a great white was too much. Truth didn't care - he was far too busy hugging the 24/7 Title like his name was Gollum and he'd found his precious.

Man, some of the 24/7 stuff they wheeled out truly was the pits.


19. AEW Stupidly Hypes An “Empty Arena Match”

Jake Hager Jon Moxley
AEW

Jake Hager looked like the man on the debut episode of AEW Dynamite in late-2019. Chris Jericho brought the former Jack Swagger in as his heater (the Diesel to his Shawn Michaels, if you like), and it was a role well-suited to the big guy. Sadly, he was never as compelling in-ring as he'd be as a bodyguard, and the 15 April 2020 Dynamite proved it.

That show saw Jon Moxley defend his AEW World Title vs. Hager in what was billed as an “Empty Arena No Holds Barred Match”. The catch? Well, arenas were empty because All Elite management had no choice. The world was in the midst of a pandemic, and that meant fans couldn't attend events at all.

Thus, the whole "Empty Arena" thing looked a bit laughable. Every match was like that!

Also, the brawl went way, way, way too long. Not only was the branding silly, but it exposed just how dull Hager was capable of being when he wasn’t just acting as a heavy for Jericho and the rest of the Inner Circle. This was not a banner moment for Moxley as he visibly toiled when trying to squeeze something interesting out of Jake.

Some critics were kind to this bout at the time, but they really need to go back and watch it again. AEW hyping the whole "Empty Arena" thing like it was a selling point mid-global pandemic only made them look foolish, and Hager was woefully overexposed in such a lengthy setting against someone who really needed better opponents.

Not 2020's worst moment, but it deserves a place on the list.


18. Ricochet Gets Squashed Flat

WWE Super ShowDown 2020 Brock Lesnar Ricochet
WWE.com

WWE never viewed Ricochet as someone who could climb above midcard level, and he's been pretty outspoken and resentful about that since leaving the company for AEW. Rico is likely also playing up to online trolls with some of his comments, but he has gone in hard on how he was treated during a 6-year stay with the market leader.

Super ShowDown 2020 might sum up his WWE career in a microcosm.

During the build, Ricochet was rightly portrayed as an underdog who'd have to take the fight to Brock Lesnar and use his speed if he stood any chance of winning. Come the card over in Saudi Arabia, the high-flyer was squashed in around 90 seconds like this was Brock lowering himself for a one off showing on 'C' show Main Event against a jobber.

The whole thing was fairly pointless. If Vince McMahon didn't see Ricochet as someone worthy of challenging Brock (which he blatantly didn't), then he shouldn't have booked it at all. Such 'spirited underdog' stories are only worthwhile if there's something for fans to chew on. Some probably hadn't even sat back down again by the time the bell was ringing for Lesnar's comprehensive win.

What a waste of time, not only for Rico but also for the show as a whole. Flying both guys out to Riyadh for something this meagre was puzzling. The fact it was followed up by an unwanted steel cage bout pitting Roman Reigns vs. Baron Corbin only added to the pain fans felt.

Not a landmark night for Ricochet then.


17. The First Rule Of Raw Underground Is…

RAW Underground Shane McMahon
WWE.com

...that WWE will lose interest in the entire concept quickly.

In August 2020, a sweaty Shane McMahon introduced his new underground fighting ring. Fight Club, this was not, and no-one's quite sure why Shane-O was cast as the ideal guy for the gig. Is this how he found the Mean Street Posse? Was there a bare knuckle fighting culture in Greenwich, Connecticut or something?

The general gist of Raw Underground is that it was gritty, edgy and completely unlike anything else fans would see on the flagship. Only it wasn't. In fact, other than the bareknuckle 'fight to a finish' element of the scraps shown, there wasn't much to separate it from the usual brawls fans could watch on your typical episode of wrestling telly.

Also, Shane gooning over some extras brought in to act as 'Underground Girls' got a tad awkward. This was typical of the McMahon family. They figured that interest was down, so they wanted to shake things up by mimicking a film franchise 21 years on from its release. Vince never did have his finger on the pulse of pop culture post-'Attitude', did he?

Shane's excitable yowls conjured up images of his annoying commentary on old video game release WWF Attitude ("Bam!"), and the whole deal was just never going to last. There was never any attempt to link this in with the core product either, so it felt like you were watching a different show for a few minutes before regularly scheduled programming resumed.

Swing and a miss creatively.


16. The “Wyatt Swamp Fight”

Bray Wyatt Braun Strowman Extreme Rules Swamp
WWE.com

Those who watched it at the time know all too well what a trip the Horror Show At Extreme Rules was. Again, like with many ideas from 2020, WWE were trying to 'think outside of the box' and present something a little different for fans stuck at home. If company booking was a Monopoly board, then they landed on 'cinematic matches' at every turn.

Bray Wyatt and Braun Strowman dipped back into their shared past for Extreme Rules. Wyatt cut his usual cryptic, meandering promos (which are still being used by Uncle Howdy and The Wyatt Sicks on episodes of SmackDown today), then he invited Braun to meet him in a bespoke 'Swamp Fight'.

Bring your best wellies, big man.

It turned out to be one of the worst cinematic bouts of the era by a mile. WWE produced it like a homage to 1990s children's TV scare series Goosebumps, but they hoped the storytelling lore between these ex-Wyatt Family members would carry things through. If wishes were fishes, eh? Speaking of which, both guys almost ended up with a few swimmers stuck in their ring gear as they traded blows in the bayou water.

Roman Reigns returned at SummerSlam the following month to vastly improve WWE's main event scene overnight. His realistic work as the 'Tribal Chief' collided with the cartoonish 'Swamp' nonsense happening in July. Taking a break from Bray's 'Fiend' offshoot for this cult-like throwback was a poor decision by the writers.

All of that planning and cinematography just wasn't worth the effort.


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.