4 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (20 Dec - Results & Review)
Kevin Owens fires out a warning on a largely phoned-in WWE SmackDown.

It's obviously great that WWE's hardworking wrestlers and staff get a well-earned Christmas break to recharge and enjoy some time at home with their friends and families. Personally, this writer doesn't always think double tapings are something to get snippy about, but two things can be true at once: Triple H probably has to figure out a way to spread content out better across multiple episodes when filming several in one block.
Being fair, the weekend right before Christmas is probably the best time to phone it in a little bit. Also, 'The Game' will point to plot pushers like the Women's Tag-Team Title situation, a developing story involving old pals Alex Shelley and Johnny Gargano, Kevin Owens laying out his future plans and Drew McIntyre threatening Solo Sikoa as proof he still had the ol' brainbox switched on here.
That's valid, but it won't be some huge shocker if ratings and overall interest dip for SmackDown this week.
Most of the 'Ups' here are smaller fine print. They're important, sure, but they're not enough to make Friday's episode must see for those who want blockbuster matches, star power aplenty and killer angles in front of a red hot live crowd. WWE will be keeping some powder dry for Raw's debut on Netflix there, and understandably so. They'll also have SmackDown's imminent expansion to three hours in mind.
Look, the show wasn't bad by any means, and apologies if some of the 'Downs' come across as a little whiny. That negativity comes from a good place, because it's clear certain aspects of the program could've been a lot better.
Here's all the yay and nay from it!
Downs...
3. WWE Go Too Deep In The Weeds

What kind of pro wrestling fan are you? If you're the type who doesn't mind Tony Khan-esque claims that everyone should 'do their homework' on rivalries and matches that happened outside the confines of the product you're watching, then you might've loved Alex Shelley vs. Johnny Gargano on SmackDown. However, if you're the kind who'd rather not Google what happened on Cleveland All Pro Wrestling cards in 2005/2006/2007, then...
...you might've been scratching your head wondering why you should care about the match at all.
Michael Cole and Corey Graves tried their able best to add context to the bout in question by going hard on the independent wrestling chat. Sadly, that sort of thing just isn't as interesting to WWE's core audience as some might like to believe. AEW has found that out to their detriment in recent years. On Friday, Shelley vs. Gargano passed by without much energy from a bored live crowd. Eek!
Honestly, this was all a little too AEW Collision for SmackDown. The fact that Gargano and Shelley came up in the biz together and that's why the Motor City Machine Guns are shocked he went rogue to snatch their tag belts? Fine. Hammer home that point all you like, but there's no need to start talking about matches these guys had in a parking lot 15-20 years ago. That means nothing to most fans watching.
Another follow up scrap pitting DIY vs. MCMG should be ace, but this indy-riffic tale WWE are trying on is tenuous to those who want storytelling to happen in front of their eyes.
2. Please Ditch The Grayson Waller Effect

WrestleMania 40's title win aside, 2024 has been stinking for A-Town Down Under. Creative dropped Austin Theory splitting away from Grayson Waller cold after weeks/months of teasing it, and both lads have been stranded in WWE purgatory ever since. Now, they're reduced to whatever the hell this was supposed to be. Braun Strowman dressed as Santa Claus on the Grayson Waller Effect? Come on.
Behave yourselves.
The second half of the year has been so poor for Grayson and Austin that it's slightly surprising they haven't wound up on lists looking at the biggest losers of 2024. That sucks, because both guys are talented. Unfortunately, Waller's talk show segment is totally rudderless at the moment, and his nothing skit with Braun proved it. This was a time killing exercise and little more.
Grayson is at his best when he's aggravating everyone around him by thinking he's better than he actually is. That could be ideal heel foil for a Theory babyface turn, but WWE's writers just don't seem interested in pulling the trigger on it. Thus, there's next to no steam behind either member of A-Town Down Under. They barely even wrestle as a proper tag-team at the moment.
One can see Waller or Theory jumping to Raw in the "Transfer Window" without much incident. If creative quietly shelves the team without having them feud, then they've wasted their own time. This was genuinely one of the poorest and most inconsequential talk show segments in recent memory.
It made even the worst Miz TV bits look like Piper's Pit.
1. He Won (But At What Cost?)

Last week's squash match loss to the returning Braun Strowman typified Carmelo Hayes' luck, or lack thereof. The ex-NXT dynamo has all the tools to succeed, but it's pretty clear WWE doesn't have much of clue what to do with him. They're making this up as they go along - they must be. If they weren't, then WWE would've had a plan for Melo coming out of his well-received series vs. Andrade.
Instead, he's going down the 'in over his head but still crafty' route with Strowman. Here, Carmelo won via countout after taking a bit of a beating from big Braun. Y'know when you can just tell instantly that a combo/story/feud has nothing to offer? Yeah, this is one of those situations. It'd be a minor miracle if tangling with Strowman helped Hayes in the long run. Content like this is the living definition of treading water creatively.
Granted, at least Carmelo is still on TV every week, but trying to get positive about this is pushing it. It'd be an outright lie to say the mini-feud has been entertaining so far. Braun's soft reset button has been pressed, so he's a gentler version of the wrecking machine fans watched on Raw back in 2016. Meanwhile, the "resourceful" Hayes is struggling not to look like a heel Crash Holly.
Technically, Melo won this match and has a victory over Braun. That ties them at one win apiece, which means a rematch is incoming soon. At this rate, it'd be a shocker if Triple H resisted the urge to go full blown Vince and stick them in a Christmas-themed brawl on the 27 December episode.
Hands up who wants to see it? Thought so!
Ups...
4. “What Happens Next Is On All Of You”

Saturday Night's Main Event ended with a package/stump piledriver that Mick Foley's Mankind character would've been proud of. Kevin Owens spiked Cody Rhodes right on his bleach blonde head, then left with the 'Winged Eagle' version of the WWE Title. On Friday, Kev stopped by to cut a pre-taped promo discussing his attack on Cody. Unsurprisingly, he blamed everybody else for what happened.
More specifically, Owens said the refs and Nick Aldis helped to screw him out of the championship, and that brought him close to snapping. This was key, because KO was effectively saying that his violent attacks on Randy Orton and Rhodes haven't been brought on by him losing his temper. That's still to come. "I haven't snapped yet". That's tasty.
Once Owens does, blood will be on the hands of everyone in WWE. As always, Kevin skirted the fine line between ominous and believing his own rubbish. The best heels think they're right, and they can point to plot points to back that up. KO has been there, done that, and now he's in that sweet spot where it's totally possible to push his own character arc along without the need for anything physical.
The one thing WWE wanted to put across here is that the worst is yet to come. Cody will return with vengeance on his lips (and fists), which means Owens has to meet that halfway. It's cool that he isn't backing down or acting apologetic for anything he's done to date, it really is.
Side note: Something just looks right about a worker like KO with that 'Winged Eagle' draped over his shoulder.
3. Naomi Pulls Her Weight

WWE must be rubbing their hands with glee at all the reports talking about whether or not Jade Cargill suffered a legitimate injury and that's why the promotion penned her out of TV with a mystery attack angle. Staff will know they can ride this out all the way towards WrestleMania 41 season and either reveal that Bianca Belair ambushed her partner or somebody else was responsible.
Naomi is the best bet currently, but that could change. After all, she ignored an attack on her husband Jimmy Uso last week in favour of putting herself forward as a sub for Jade in the Women's Tag-Team Title picture. Then, perhaps to throw everyone off the scent, Naomi turned down the chance to hold one of the belts at Gorilla before "earning" that right vs. Nia Jax and Candice Le Rae.
Ooh, the intrigue.
If this was part of some master plan, then it's working. Naomi was sinking as Bayley's bestie, but she makes a fabulous tag partner substitute next to Belair. These women have chemistry together, and it's certainly for the best that WWE came up with a contingency plan for Bianca rather than vacating these much-maligned titles yet again.
Being honest about it, the match with Nia and Candice was routine, but it pushed the story along nicely and that's all anyone could've reasonably expected given the circumstances. Now, Naomi can talk about pulling her weight before the big reveal happens on exactly who roughed up Jade. Naomi, Bianca or somebody else. Take your pick.
2. Drew Hasn't Forgotten About Solo Sikoa

Cast your minds back to Clash At The Castle 2022 in Wales. There, Solo Sikoa debuted as the new member of a Roman Reigns-led Bloodline and cost Drew McIntyre the chance to become champ. If you think the Scot has forgotten about that whilst running rampant through all who have wronged him in the past, then think again. McIntyre reminded Solo that he's coming on this week's SmackDown.
Drew's promo revealed that he's happy to play the waiting game. He proposed that both men wait to settle personal business between them until he's taken out the rest of the OG Bloodline and Sikoa cuts off the head of the snake in Roman. Jimmy Uso attacked McIntyre with a crutch after that, which sent the heel scurrying away to safety and left Solo's crew ready for their six-man tag vs. LA Knight, Andrade and Apollo Crews.
The segment was formatted well, and it left more questions than answers lingering. It's a lovely bit of context to know WWE wouldn't balk at a heel vs heel showdown between Drew and Solo in the future. McIntyre should hate everyone in The Bloodline regardless of character alignment, basically. He's been gunning for everyone from Sami Zayn and The Usos to even distant Roman associates like Seth Rollins, so why not?
Solo refusing to back down, but also seeing reason by holding off Jacob Fatu and Tama Tonga, was also the right call. WWE can let this one brew for a while longer, 'cause there's definitely something to Drew vs. Sikoa.
1. This Was More Like It

Creative went 50/50 on Solo Sikoa and LA Knight last week when they really needed to be all in on the former heading into ’Tribal Combat’ at Raw’s Netflix debut early next month. Good news: Here, Solo looked strong and dominant in a six-man tag win alongside Jacob Fatu and Tama Tonga vs. Knight, Andrade and Apollo Crews. Crews taking the fall was the most logical outcome, and LA can point to Shinsuke Nakamura’s interference as a reason why his side lost too.
That's a solid piece of business all round, people.
It's cracking to see Sikoa getting his hand raised before facing Roman Reigns in a crunch match that'll surely have WrestleMania implications. To prep, Corey Graves did a real good job of putting over how “ferocious” Solo looked towards the end of the six-man. He dragged Tama Tonga to the corner, tagged himself in, then went to town on Apollo before scoring the three. This was a bit more like the old 'silent killer' version of Sikoa, and it rocked.
WWE has to be full steam ahead with him before the Netflix bow. There can be no half measures if he's going to stand across the ring from a credible megastar like Reigns, put it that way. Solo has to go into that match with momentum, some swagger and a background threat from his troops in the New Bloodline.
Yep, this was more like it. Jacob must've been looking up from the floor and thinking, 'Man, I love you Solo'. He really does, you know. Man's smitten with his 'Chief'!
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 50 Things You Learn Binge-Watching Every WWE Royal Rumble and 50 Things You Learn Binge-Watching Every WWE WrestleMania!