5 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Dynamite (December 6 - Results & Review)
MJF Vs. Hangman Page is teased on a very good if very slightly flawed night.
The bad thing about AEW television declining in quality - other than the general experience of your escapist fun not being so fun anymore - is that a lack of form dents trust in the process. You don't fizz about in the days before Dynamite in a state of rapt anticipation. You don't giddily discuss what's in store on TBS.
You start to worry, or, worse still, you start to not care as much. You start thinking that the thing you're about to watch will be bad. You start to wonder whether MJF and Samoa Joe will actually wrestle The Devil's Masked Men - eurgh - and not immediately attempt to reveal their faces the second that they grab them in a headlock.
That would be silly - but then, so was the show-long storyline at Full Gear.
Meanwhile, the Gold (Dynamite) League just isn't as good - as of yesterday - as the Blue League on Collision. Every result was predictable before last night, not one match has been unqualified great thus far, and Jay Lethal basically did what most expected Jay Lethal to do: wrestle gentleman's three-star matches and lose gentleman's three-star matches.
Were those worries unfounded - and did Adam Copeland justify the huge outlay and hype-job after a good, not great start to his AEW in-ring career...?
Downs...
3. The Roderick Strong Voice
Roderick Strong is done with the wheelchair!
Watch #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS!@roderickstrong | @RealMikeBennett | @MattTaven pic.twitter.com/Z95XBmZyqZ
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) December 7, 2023
Roderick Strong stood up in a live segment. That's nice. AEW has finally dropped the fake wheelchair gimmick that made a mockery of every character who even flirted with believing it.
In worse news, Roderick Strong now enunciates every name as he does "AD-AM!" Why?
Roddy said "Adam" in that way because he was desperate for Cole's time and affection. The delivery conveyed the needy side of his character. What does Strong need from Samoa Joe? Or Dasha Gonzalez? Nothing: he's just a caricature who has to talk in that voice all the time, for some reason. It's stupid. It's obnoxious. It literally makes no sense.
But he's wrestling Hangman Page shortly, so that's good.
2. Over-Gimmicked
Lutha steps up as a stand-in for Toni Storm!
Watch #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS!@Skyebyee | #ToniStorm pic.twitter.com/AFFE17C3eN
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) December 7, 2023
Toni Storm Vs. Skye Blue was your mileage may vary stuff. It's almost unfair to label this a 'Down', since the women worked hard, but the TV audience was distracted from their efforts.
The match followed the usual star versus prospect AEW TV match structure. Star dominates, prospect grows into it, back-and-forth, star narrowly wins. The first phase of that structure felt like a comedy vehicle for the Timeless character.
The long old-timey wind-up punch spot is dumb in the context of a title match (not that these any-challenger-will-do specials actually feel like title matches, exactly). Also, by hopping on his shoulders and throwing Blue from the apron to the floor, Storm effectively performed a tag team move with Luther. This was moronic. Storm could have sprinted across the apron herself, generating more momentum. That way, she wouldn't have risked disqualification or relied on a 50-year-old man's knees as a way into an attack.
The commentary team made sure to reiterate that AEW encourages lenient officiating, but that was a piss-take. Blue was the fool in a slapstick sketch for large parts of the match - the clown who gets the pie thrown at her, ironically enough - but to be fair, the crowd did get behind her comeback, to a degree. The crowd also loved Toni Storm. The screen turned black and white on more than one occasion, which is a demand of Toni's. The kayfabe explanation doesn't make the device any less ineffective.
The visual effect happened when she hit the Hip Attack. Did the effect make it look like the finish was a formality, lending the actual near-fall a bigger shock factor? Or did it just look contrived and hokey? Ultimately, the Hip Attack looked so much more devastating before the Timeless character and the black-and-white filming of it, the dumb metal plate business.
When the gimmick actively ruins the wrestling, that about says it all.
1. The Devil Angle Continues To Be Not Great
Moments before MJF & Samoa Joe's Tag Match TONIGHT on Dynamite, someone knocked out The Champ with a bottle! Watch #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS!@SamoaJoe | @The_MJF pic.twitter.com/2rrdzHTngE
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) December 7, 2023
Mercifully, MJF and Samoa Joe Vs. The Devil's Masked Men didn't happen. If it didn't begin and end with the MJF and Joe ripping at their masks, it would have been stupid. But do you know what else is stupid?
The idea of the match happening to begin with.
Did the Masked Men stay anonymous when they signed a contract for the match?
If so, and they could be anybody under there, how did the medical team clear them? Hell, they could be underage for all AEW knows. Wouldn't Tony Khan want to know who they are and potentially punish them? They have "run roughshod" over AEW, after all. They've compromised AEW's security system from the inside. They've shelved the Acclaimed for a month, effectively icing the Trios division. These renegades should be brought to justice, and yet they were rewarded with a match?
Do dumb BS, invite snarky questions.
Anyway, the Masked Men surrounded Joe before MJF could make his entrance. They put on a light show, for some reason, before the lights went out altogether. When the lights came back on, so did the big screen, on which it was revealed that MJF had been struck by a glass bottle. This angle was designed to encourage the audience to ask two questions - was Jack Perry responsible for this attack with "real glass", or was it suspicious that MJF wasn't actually seen to be assaulted? - but it was just another TNA-style cheap production nightmare with crappy TV wrestling logic. The patience isn't even wearing thin.
There's just an apathy to the entire main event scene at this point - a big shame, following up MJF's excellent verbal performance last week and a great backstage segment last night...
Ups...
5. An Unexpected, Intriguing New Direction
In a curious and unexpected but not not compelling segment, MJF and Hangman Page interacted - for the first time since November 2019 - backstage. They traded insults, which can be a counterproductive race to the bottom, but the material was too good to care about that.
Page used hyperbole to get his digs in, saying that he didn't have time for MJF to talk at him for 30 minutes like he normally does, where MJF said he had enjoyed Page and Swerve trying to give each other STDs at Full Gear. Two killer lines, one great omen for the programme.
Before the exchange escalated into blows, Joe interrupted and scolded MJF for risking a beating ahead of their match. This was fun and fascinating - it felt big and quite shocking, underscoring the strengths of Tony Khan's über-patient booking approach, and MJF essentially played it like the Max of old: a brilliantly insufferable little turd.
This Page deal is one for later, you'd think (though Page working Roderick Strong next week indicates that he's set to be involved with this wider storyline imminently). Will MJF work it as a heel?
Surely Hangman, the main character, can't turn?
All very intriguing!
4. Battle Of The Jays Was Less Boring Than It Could Have Been
JAY FOREVER!!!#AEWContinentalClassic: GOLD LEAGUE
Watch #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS!@TheLethalJay | @JayWhiteNZ pic.twitter.com/5d8PlxasXy
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) December 7, 2023
Jay White Vs. Jay Lethal was better than expected, though eliminating a second wrestler from the Continental Classic with two rounds of fixtures left was hardly good storytelling. It's as if Tony Khan's almost feckless booking sensibilities have clashed with the format. You'd expect or even hope that Lethal's next matches are bound for Rampage. Happily, this was actually his best tournament offering yet.
Where sometimes his counter-driven matches can feel dry, almost too intricate for their own good, this was a quite exciting chess match that developed a different tenor deeper into the last third. Watching two heels poke each other in the eye in an attempt to win was a neat departure from the episodic TV norm: a funny byproduct of the round-robin format and how it necessitates the sort of all-heel matches that rarely occur beyond it. There's good reason for that, but every now and then, they work. This worked.
Two conniving bastards threatening to screw the other over: this was very well-worked technically, as you'd expect, and had a bit more personality to it than most Jay Lethal matches. It wasn't relentlessly compelling, or outright great - the fans amused themselves by chanting for "Jay Forever" before the pace accelerated towards the finish - but it was significantly less boring than the worst version of itself threatened to be.
Still, it was the third consecutive Continental Classic match that went heavy on the chop battles. in general, the agents should collaborate and intervene. This sequence is losing its potency. It shouldn't be happening in every bloody match, even if Rush and Jay White are exceptional at the art.
Every tournament match was good to excellent, but were all a bit too similar on the night.
3. Beautiful Match, Ugly Finish
What is Shayna Wayne doing here?!?
Watch #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS!@RatedRCope | @Christian4Peeps pic.twitter.com/WHA3m4U340
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) December 7, 2023
Christian Cage Vs. Adam Copeland was a very good and well-crafted wrestling match until the finish.
Following a hot start, in which Copeland just kicked Cage's ass over and over again, Cage attempted to cheat with a low blow, but Copeland just stomped on his hand. It looked as though Cage couldn't even cheat to get the advantage, but he found a way in when a combination of Copeland's red mist and adrenaline dump allowed Cage to drive him face-first into the ring post. This was structurally elegant and brimming with character and motivation - just beautiful stuff worked by two masters telling a great, believable story. As the match progressed, the counters worked wonderfully. You see them in every match, but you won't find two wrestlers better than Cage or Copeland at the timing and ingenuity, and you won't find two wrestlers who actually know one another inside out to earn them.
Cage's leapfrog over the spear was just fantastic. A great moment of action informed by years and years of mutual history.
At the finish, though, Copeland fell into referee Bryce Remsburg. An enterprising Christian Cage then hit Bryce in the balls. Remsburg, when he came to after the shenanigans, counted the three in Cage's favour. Realistically, who else hit Remsburg in the balls? Andre the Giant?
It was obviously Cage.
The finish was also a victim of AEW's selective and convenient approach to enforcing the rules. The Continental Classic is sacred. Stablemates of the wrestlers will get fired if they dare interfere. The TNT title?
Don't send a second referee out there, it's fine. Adam Copeland will certainly get the opportunity to win the title fairly.
This reeked of AEW attempting to have cake and eat cake. Have wrestling, eat sports entertainment. With Bryce down, Shayna Wayne walked to the ring. She deliberated over hitting Cage with the belt before turning on Copeland. Th acting was...not good here, even by the standards of self-aware, unashamed soap opera.
The belt shot looked weak, but that was understandable. Less understandable was the actual finish.
Cage draped the TNT title below Copeland's head and curb-stomped him onto it. It looked flimsy, but was sold by the commentary team as if it was as devastating as the Con-chair-to.
2. Jon Moxley Vs. Rush Kicks Ass
RUSH wants some more!#AEWContinentalClassic: GOLD LEAGUE
Watch #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS!@rushtoroblanco | @JonMoxley pic.twitter.com/jrhVZo5oYp
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) December 7, 2023
Two of the best brawlers of their generation beat the ever-living hell out of one another in an ace opener not without the odd flaw.
Mox won, again, and didn't carry the leg injury he seemed to suffer in his match against Jay Lethal last week. In a great, almost scarily candid promo cut afterwards, Mox wondered aloud whether the last four years have caught up with him. This mindset and ravaged body didn't factor into the match. Also, it wasn't quite as good as their sick, blistering Fight For The Fallen effort last year. Still, viewed on its own terms, this was a lovely, unvarnished scrap. Move-for-move, you've seen it. You might have seen everything at this point. Masculine challenges via chop battles, bird flips to express defiance, duelling strong style forearms.
But Rush looked such a smug pr*ck throughout that you almost forgave the anticlimactic finish: at least that look was wiped off his face with Mox's Bulldog choke. Mox wore a look of defiance throughout, and when he wasn't pulling off those badass facials, he sold big for those stunning Rush chops, involuntarily or otherwise. Mox, as Minoru Suzuki once said, is a great wrestler because he "can't do sh*t" - but he was so dialled-in here that even his wonky suicide dive looked super-charged. Rush threw so much behind a forearm that he almost stumbled over his feet with his own momentum.
Great opener - but still not TV Match of the Year-tier great, being brutally honest. That may read as pedantic, but fans were promised the greatest wrestling tournament ever, and other than the stakes and the refreshing lack of episodic TV trappings, the match quality in the Gold League is actually beneath the top tier of Dynamite matches in 2023.
Kenny Omega Vs. El Hijo del Vikingo, Rush Vs. Bryan Danielson, Hangman Page Vs. Jon Moxley, Omega Vs. Moxley, Chris Jericho Vs. Roderick Strong, MJF Vs. Adam Cole, Swerve Strickland Vs. Orange Cassidy, Darby Allin Vs. Samoa Joe: the Gold League can't yet compare to these matches and several others.
1. Swerve Strickland Is So Close To Being THE Man
THIS MATCH IS WILD!!!#AEWContinentalClassic: GOLD LEAGUE
Watch #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS!@swerveconfident | @SussexCoChicken pic.twitter.com/xgQ2phCDjO
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) December 7, 2023
Swerve Strickland Vs. Mark Briscoe turned into something awesome by the finishing stretch.
This might scan as pedantic - again - but to be the man in wrestling, you must be virtually flawless. Swerve is closer than ever, but...
For a while, the match was merely good, if somewhat affected by Swerve's attempts to evade his opponent and lure him into danger with his more convoluted move set-ups. That's where the Swerve part of his name comes from, but it feels like he's shedding his old skin to become a proper headlining player. His escapologist bit looks a bit weird, even downright clumsy at times, with that bigger main event body and aura. The fans were jolted awake when Swerve blasted that maniac Briscoe with an inside-out suplex over the barricade to the matting that just barely covers the cement. That unhinged spot acted as the segue to the commercial break, after which the match developed into a dramatic shoot-out.
After a series of matches that while good to very good didn't feel like urgent, G1-adjacent masterclasses, the stakes and the characters elevated the wrestling in the second half of this match. Everybody believed that Swerve could win, but equally, everybody wanted Briscoe to stay in it. This dynamic and atmosphere elevated an electrifying closing stretch from which every drop of drama was extracted. The false finishes were wholly convincing, and if Briscoe had to lose, taking a death valley driver on the apron was a gnarly way of going out.
The impact was brutal throughout an intoxicating finishing stretch, the emotion felt just as hard. Taking Briscoe out of the tournament so early has to be considered a mistake, mind.
You don't get many wrestlers with such a strong audience bond, and frankly, AEW has fumbled too many of the few.