10 WWE Dream Matches That Happened On The Indies
Star-studded matches on the small stage.
Both WWE and AEW would like us to believe that they are dream factories. Their mission statement is to bring together the greatest wrestlers from all over the world and put them in the best matches on the biggest stage. As we all know, however, there's a whole other ecosystem out there.
For as long as there have been major wrestling federations, there have been smaller independent companies or 'indies' operating in the shadows. With limited resources but big ambitions, these promotions have given us some fantasy matches that the big leagues couldn't. Or wouldn't.
This list is mainly about WWE superstars, but it does feature some wrestlers who have never worked for the McMahon empire. All of them have at least had conversations with the Fed, so, in another world, they could have rocked up on Raw or SmackDown one day.
From generational crossovers to technical masterpieces to matches you didn't even know you wanted to see, this list highlights the bevvy of great work the indies have been producing for decades. Do yourself a favour and support your own local indie if you can. You might find yourself a hidden gem.
10. Rey Mysterio vs. Darby Allin vs. Carmelo Hayes
Despite having been in the same company since 2021, Rey Mysterio and Carmelo Hayes have never had a one-on-one match in WWE as of May 19, 2026. They did share the ring for Northeast Wrestling (NEW) in 2018, but even then, they weren't alone.
Mysterio and Hayes, the latter of whom was wrestling under the name Christian Casanova, were joined by a young upstart named Darby Allin. The trio wrestled a predictably fast-paced match that could have done with a few more minutes before the masked man got the win.
Allin fought Hayes a few times in NEW, including in a singles match. This was the face-painted daredevil's only encounter with Mysterio, however, who would return to WWE full-time later in the year. Allin was snapped up by AEW when it launched the following year, making it certain that the two would never fight.
WWE did make a play for Allin before he signed for Tony Khan, so there is a universe in which this triple threat could have happened under their watch. In this universe, though, it was never going to happen. Given that Rey will probably still be wrestling when he's 85 years old, there's still time for it to happen again.
9. Britt Baker vs. Chelsea Green
Fans of the first All In show - the event that effectively launched AEW - will remember a women's four-way match that took place in the middle of the card. Alongside Madison Rayne and Tessa Blanchard (uh oh), the match also played host to two women would go on to have very different careers going forward - Chelsea Green and Dr. Britt Baker.
This wasn't the only time the pair shared a ring. They used to be a tag team called Fire and Nice and competed in matches for promotions like SHIMMER and RISE. A company called International Wrestling Cartel (IWC) booked them in numerous bouts over their women's championship, which Baker always won.
The two women are actually quite similar. Both have dry senses of humour, and both have spent time on screen for their respective companies in a wheelchair.
Baker has been linked with WWE throughout her career, so there's a chance that this match could still happen on a major stage. For now, these two 'role models' are being kept apart.
8. Joe Hendry vs. Scotty 2 Hotty
This might not sound like a dream match, but you just try and tell anybody you don't want to hear the song that Joe Hendry would write about Scotty 2 Hotty. Think of all the rhymes there are for 'worm'? The possibilities are endless.
Before he wound up in WWE, Hendry had an extensive indie career that took him from his native Scotland to the United States and beyond. In 2022, long after he'd established himself on the other side of the Atlantic, the Prestigious One returned to the UK for a match at North Wrestling's 'Party Till You Puke' event. Charming.
His opponent was one of the biggest stars of the Attitude Era, and that's not hyperbole. Scotty 2 Hotty got a massive reaction from the British fans, to the point where Hendry was forced to work heel. The Scotsman got the win when a heel named Shreddy assisted him behind his back.
Instead of aligning with this villain, The Local Hero joined forces with Scotty and his son to beat up Shreddy and send him packing with a flurry of Worm attacks. You've gotta love a happy ending.
7. Gunther vs. Fit Finlay
Europe has a long and proud history of supplying the USA with incredibly tough wrestlers who aren't afraid to teach those Yanks a thing or two. Today, we have Gunther, the Austrian powerhouse who retired the great John Cena. In the 1990s, however, there was Fit Finlay.
Hailing from Northern Ireland, The Belfast Bruiser had some brilliant brawls with the likes of William Regal and Chris Benoit in WCW. He resurrected his career in WWE and when he wasn't lumbered with having to look after Hornswoggle, he proved that he could still very much go.
After he left WWE in 2011, Finlay embarked on an indie tour that saw him fight a whole host of unexpected names. One of them was Walter, the man currently known as Gunther. These hard-hitters met not once but twice in Germany; once for European Wrestling Promotion (EWP) and once for Westside Xtreme Wrestling (WxW). In the latter match, Finlay beat Walter when he was WxW World Champion, but only by DQ.
In their respective primes, these two would have torn the house down in a mind-blowing war. Alas, they saved their only two meetings for the good people of Oberhausen.
6. The Hardy Boyz vs. The Lucha Brothers
Wrestling history is peppered with examples of fantastic tag teams made up of brothers. The Dudley Boyz, Edge and Christian, The Brothers of Destruction... wait a second...
If you're looking for duos made up of actual brothers, then look no further than The Hardy Boyz and The Lucha Bros. For the better part of three decades, Matt and Jeff Hardy have been at the very top of the tag team game, winning just about every pair of doubles titles you can think of. As for Penta and Fenix, their limitless charisma and athleticism have made them household names in wrestling circles.
The two sets of siblings missed each other in WWE, but were in AEW at the same time. Incredibly, they never fought each other. The closest they came was when they were on the same side of an eight-man tag on an episode of Rampage in 2023.
On the indies, however, they've two straight tag matches. One was in Lima, Peru, for a promotion called Imperio Lucha Libre. The other came at the WrestleCon SuperShow in Orlando, Florida just six days later. The Hardys were victorious on both occasions.
5. Bryan Danielson vs. Johnny Gargano
One night after Johnny Gargano defeated Tomasso Ciampa at NXT TakeOver: New Orleans, another small, gifted performer with prominent facial hair had his first match after a career-ending injury. Now that Daniel Bryan and Gargano were both on WWE's books, it would only be a matter time before they met in the ring, right... right?
Unfortunately, by the time Gargano made it to the main roster, Bryan was long gone. He was in AEW and, at time of writing, Johnny Wrestling has yet to follow his former partner Tommaso Ciampa over to the other side. For a match between these two, we have to go back to a time before either man was in WWE.
Bryan Danielson (as he was known at the time) wrestled Gargano twice for a promotion called Absolute Intense Wrestling (AIW). The future DIY member actually defeated The American Dragon in their first battle in 2009. The following year, the two wrestled to a time-limit draw with Gargano's AIW Championship on the line.
With Danielson now retired, this clash of the generational babyfaces will remain a fantasy to everyone except a select few.
4. Kenny Omega vs. Kevin Owens
It's easy to forget that Kenny Omega was technically signed to WWE at one point. He was a part of their Deep South Wrestling (DSW) developmental system, but left in August 2006, citing an inability to express himself and a Japan wanderlust.
Of course, if Omega hadn't have left, he wouldn't be the demigod he is today. This fateful decision did rob us of a number of dream matches, though, including one with a fellow Canadian.
Before he was Kevin Owens, the acid-tongued prizefighter was known as Kevin Steen. He first met Omega in Ring of Honor, where they were on the same team in a six-man tag. They would have their first and only ROH singles encounter one year later, in which Steen was victorious.
If ROH isn't indie enough for you, then Steen and Omega also had a match in Pro Wrestling Guerrila (PWG). They were drawn together in the first round of the Battle of Los Angeles tournament and this time Omega got the win on his way to winning the entire thing.
3. Cody Rhodes vs. Kurt Angle
In 2006, compounding health and substance abuse issues forced WWE to come to terms with the release of Kurt Angle. In 2007, a bright-eyed, bushy-tailed youngster named Cody Rhodes made his WWE debut. This was the first of many near-misses between these two icons.
Rhodes left WWE in 2016, only for Angle to come a year later. When Cody made his return in 2022, it was four years after Kurt had retired. To get this clash of the uber-American heroes, we have to turn to the brief period when they were both free agents.
Angle was one of the names on Rhodes' famous wish-list when he struck out on his own. He ticked this name off thanks to our old friends NEW. The pair had a match in 2016, which the younger man won. Two months later, they faced each other again at WCPW's True Legacy show, with Angle getting his win back.
Finally, Angle and Rhodes faced off one last time in NEW in 2017. Cody's win in this steel cage match marked him out as the future of the business, and was also one of the last great matches of the Olympian's legendary career.
2. AJ Styles vs. Will Ospreay
Nothing that Will Ospreay has accomplished in his remarkable career would have been possible without AJ Styles. The Phenomenal One paved the way for so many high-flying superstars of the future. There's a reason why Ospreay uses the Styles Clash as part of his arsenal.
Any indie promoter would salivate at the prospect of booking these two on the same show. By the time Ospreay was a big star, however, Styles was already firmly entrenched in the WWE system. They did have one singles match before this happened, and it took place in Will's homeland of merry old England.
Revolution Pro Wrestling (RevPro) put on their High Stakes event in February 2015. On a card featuring Rocky Romero, Ricochet, and Christopher Daniels, Styles and Ospreay closed out the show in a match that was every bit as exciting as advertised.
The only other time they shared the ring was also in RevPro in 2015. It was a triple threat for Styles' British Heavyweight Championship. Like so many other British wrestling stars from this era, the third man has been firmly cancelled.
1. CM Punk vs. Eddie Guerrero
Of all the matches on this list, this one feels the most like it was plucked from the code of a WWE 2K game. Eddie Guerrero's tragic death in 2005 meant that he missed out on wrestling so many dream matches. Luckily for us, we have his short indie run from the early 2000s.
After he was released from WWE following a DUI, Guerrero embarked on a world tour. He fought a wide range of current stars and future legends, but it's his stint in IWA Mid-South that is of interest here.
On March 1st 2002, Guerrero won a triple threat for the promotion's heavyweight title. His opponents were his old pal Rey Mysterio and the defending champion; a man by the name of CM Punk. One day later, Punk got his one-on-one rematch for the title, ending Latino Heat's reign after just one day.
Guerrero vs. Punk is one of those beautiful crossover moments in wrestling history. Had Eddie lived a longer life, he and Punk could have been storied rivals. It's a travesty that we never saw this match in WWE, but at least got it once.