7 Totally Accidental Wrestling Title Changes

Botched kickouts, forgotten stipulations, and everything in between.

WWE

A fan's delight and a wrestler's dismay, few things go viral quicker than a massive botch. For a myriad of reasons, human beings love watching others screw up, and as soon as somebody makes a mistake between the ropes, you can guarantee that X and Reddit will quickly be awash with gifs and gags.

It's bad enough when these mistakes happen in the middle of a bout, but they can become the main reason a match is remembered when they occur near the conclusion. Tossing a championship into the mix, and the effects are amplified even further, forcing promotions to chuck weeks of well-laid plans into the shredder.

Companies like WWE don't always treat their titles with respect, but they still want to maintain control. Unplanned title changes, though rare, give them an embarrassing mess to clean up, and while they're usually successful in doing so, these situations often leave audiences bewildered, and the promotion with a number of misplaced 1-2 day reigns sticking out in their title histories.

From the 1960s through to the present day, let's look at the most prominent examples.


7. Thea Hail Wins The NXT North American Championship

WWE

Thea Hail's victory over Blake Monroe on the December 16th edition of NXT would have been an excellent bit of business had absolutely any of it been a work.

As NXT booker, Shawn Michaels has crafted a shock title change or two in the past, and in doing so has at least created the in-universe rule that the unexpected can happen on the right night in the right moment with the right wrestlers.

This was literally none of the above.

Relatively early into the action, Hail attempted a springboard Coffin Drop/Trust Fall onto Monroe, who seemed to fail to crucifix her for a counter. Hail slid forward, the referee counted the fall, and kept counting to three without evidence of a visible kick-out from the Champion.

Having not been booked to win, Hail didn't really know what to do in the moment. Having not been booked to lose and lose her title at that, Monroe was even more unsure. As the referee scrambled to communicate the events to the wrestlers and ring announcer Mike Rome, somebody backstage played Monroe's music, presumably because it was cued up to go in line with the original finish. At this point, the wrestlers were at least locked in to their sudden new sell-jobs, but Rome misspoke too, announcing Hail as the World Champion rather than announcing the secondary strap.

A mess, but one the booking could move to clean up once people had stopped making fun of it. Such is the nature of live TV, as opposed to taking place under the former veil of secrecy that was the house show loop...


6. Men On A Mission Become WWE Tag Team Champions

By Mandy Coombes [CC BY-SA 2.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0)], via Wikimedia Commons

Men On A Mission were one of the New Generation era’s more cringeworthy acts. Flanked by their manager Oscar, Mabel and Mo were a couple of lighthearted, heavyset bruisers out to spread a positive, empowering message through wrestling (and rapping, unfortunately), and while they enjoyed moderate popularity, they were never cut out to be a headlining act.

WWE tried to push Mabel into the spotlight by having him win King Of The Ring in 1995, but as a team, Men On A Mission’s big moment came at a 1994 house show. The duo defeated WWE Tag Team Champions The Quebecers that night, but it wasn’t in the script, and only came through a botched kickout.

The finish occurred when Mabel, who weighed 487lbs at his heaviest, fell on top of Pierre Ouellet, stunning him. This rendered the Quebecer incapable of kicking out, and the referee was forced to make the three-count. WWE fixed the error by having the former champs regain the titles at another house show two days later, but the change was reported on WWE television, and remains in the title history today.


5. Mickie James (Briefly) Profits From Victoria’s Forgetfulness

WWE.com

The biggest challenge when dealing with a botched match finish of any kind, let alone a title change, is figuring out how to deal with it. The immediate aftermath can be extremely confusing, particularly if the performers panic and break character, but if calmness prevails and the decision makers think on their feet, the damage can be mitigated.

This is exactly what happened in April 2007, when Mickie James accidentally pinned Victoria in a house show triple threat match. Victoria forgot to kick out, and the botch saw James take the WWE Women’s Championship for the third time in her career, though Melina was originally scripted to retain.

Instead of having Mickie carry the belt until the next live event, WWE booked James and Melina in a singles rematch later that evening. MNM’s former manager was triumphant, leaving Paris with the gold as was originally planned, solving the issue less than an hour after it had arisen. WWE could have easily buried this quick fire switch in history, but they chose to acknowledge it, and Mickie’s brief reign was recognised.


4. Razor Ramon Calls An Audible

WWE.com

Razor Ramon took part in two of the most iconic ladder matches of all time in the 1990s. Both saw him face Shawn Michaels with the Intercontinental Title on the line, and while the first (WrestleMania X) holds more historical significance than the second (SummerSlam ‘95), both are rightly held up as hugely important to the stipulation’s rise in prominence throughout the decade.

‘The Bad Guy’ fought a similar match with Jeff Jarrett on a May 1995 house show. As it was an un-televised event, ‘Double J’ was scripted to climb the ladder and retain, but he missed a vital cue towards the end of the match.

Razor, the challenger, was stood atop the ladder, waiting for Jarrett to dash into the ring and prevent him from grabbing the belt. He stalled, but there was no sign of Jeff. Ramon could only stay inactive for so long before looking like an idiot, so he decided to grab the belt for self-preservation’s sake, winning his third IC Title in the process.

Jarrett understandably regained the championship when they rematched two days latter, but the situation would’ve been avoided had he not missed his cue.


3. The Holly Cousins Mess Up At ‘Mania

WWE.com

The bulk of WWE’s accidental title changes have taken place at house shows, far away from the prying eyes of the company’s international audience. This one, however, took place at the biggest show of the year.

WrestleMania 2000’s second match saw a horde of lower-midcard wrestlers contest a Hardcore Title battle royal. The idea of having designated matches for a belt with a 24/7 defence rule always seemed moot, but WWE needed to fill up the PPV card, so they gave their trashiest division 15 full minutes of airtime.

The title changed hands ten times throughout the match. Crash Holly entered with it around his waist, but dropped it to Tazz within 26 seconds. It took him 14 minutes to eventually regain it, but while the original plan was to have Crash retain, his cousin Hardcore took the victory after cracking the champ with a jar of sweets.

Crash was supposed to kick out, but he forgot, even as referee Tim White deliberately delayed his third and final count. The Hardcore Title’s disposable nature meant it didn’t really matter, but it still wasn’t supposed to happen.


2. AJ Styles’ Bizarre US Title Screw-Up

WWE.com

Despite being two of WWE’s most exciting performers, the 2017 AJ Styles/Kevin Owens feud never really delivered in the ring. A fine match at Backlash was soured by a dumb count-out finish, while their Battleground rematch will ultimately be remembered for its unfortunate conclusion.

The finish was a complete shambles.

Owens, the challenger, rolled out of a crossface and into a cradle. AJ was supposed to kick out and retain, but the dazed referee counted the 1, 2, 3, and while the immediate speculation suggested the result had been changed on the fly, consensus later revealed that it had been a massive botch.

Styles was supposedly livid with the official afterwards, even though it was entirely his fault. He neglected to kick out, and the belt he’d won just two weeks prior was gone. AJ did regain it two days later on SmackDown.


1. Gene Kiniski Gets The Stipulation Wrong

Public Domain

Once considered American wrestling’s biggest prize, the NWA World Heavyweight Championship’s legacy was built by men like Lou Thesz and Pat O’Connor, who’d hold the gold for years at a time. It was an era of wrestling that almost seems alien in today’s environment, and there was an old rule stating that the belt could only change hands in 2 out of 3 falls matches, which saw many title fights stretch towards (and beyond) 60 minutes in length.

In 1969, Gene Kiniski wrestled Dory Funk Jr. under the assumption that this rule was in play. As per the man himself in WWE’s History Of The World Heavyweight Championship DVD, the original plan was that Kiniski would retain, so when Gene tapped to Funk’s spinning toe hold early in the match, he thought he was merely conceding the first fall.

Wrong.

The bout was actually booked as a rare single fall bout, and Kiniski suffered a lapse in judgement. Dory took his championship abruptly, but went on to hold it for a staggering 1,563 days. He was pencilled in to eventually take the belt from Kiniski later that year anyway, so really, Gene’s mistake only accelerated the inevitable, and the NWA ran with it.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.