8 Babyfaces The WWE Universe Turned Heel
3. Randy Orton
This one was something of a misguided decision by WWE creative. Randy Orton experienced one heck of a rise in 2004, starting the year a bland nobody before benefiting hugely from a fabulous feud with Mick Foley. His rise continued all the way to SummerSlam that year, where he defeated Chris Benoit for the World Heavyweight Championship and became the youngest champion in the process.
The crowd were firmly behind Orton on that night in Toronto, and WWE took this as a sign to move ahead with plans to turn him babyface. The turn came the next night on RAW, as Orton was betrayed by his buddies in Evolution.
The problem was that that the Toronto crowd was firmly based in Bizarroland, and Orton as a face was as bland and generic as they came. The crowd turned on him practically instantly, and once he dropped the title to Triple H it was back to the bad side for the Legend Killer.