Hulk Hogan: 5 Awesome Matches And 5 That Sucked

Hogan Vs Andreew The Hulkster is back in the WWE and he's brought Hulkamania €“ in all it's slightly faded yet still blinding red and yellow glory €“ with him. The ultimate wrestling phenomenon was resting on the other side of the coin for a while, funneled through the significantly less interested fans of TNA. But with WrestleMania XXX rapidly approaching and the WWE Network's grand arrival, Hogan has returned, to aid the company that made him a culturally transcendent superstar of still unparalleled proportions. Since the legend has returned, there's no better time to give his rather patchy career a well-deserved retrospective. None of Hulk Hogan's matches have been technical masterpieces, but as one of the most popular stars in the history of the business, he's had his fair share of epic, high-profile showdowns. Whether he's pitted against former friends, ex-business associates, youthful future film stars or mythical giants, Hulkamania has helped millions of Hulkamaniacs have something (even if it's just an overly tanned man in yellow tights) to believe in. However, at the same time, he's been involved with some of the worst displays of pointless, ego-driven rubbish that's ever occurred in the art, instilling disappointment and often complete and utter confusion in the minds of anyone subjected. Simply stated, Hogan doesn't always know best. So as he's been such a divisive figure, here are five of Hogan's battles that were just plain awesome, followed by five which completely sucked:

5. Hulk Hogan vs. Vince McMahon - WrestleMania XIX

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GB1WbBnn1bM 20 Years In The Making Billed as a match 20 years in the making, WrestleMania 19 played host to a face-off that could've very easily been one of the worst to have ever graced WWE screens. It was, in essence, a man who can't really wrestle very well, against a man who isn't really a wrestler at all. But with Vince McMahon claiming that he 'created Hulkamania and was going to kill it', the quivering hype for the collision was built-up in an intriguing manner. It became a battle to decide who was responsible for Hulkamania and therefore, for the success of the company as a whole. This set the stage rigidly for a ferocious brawl that was awesome, even before it'd started. The crowd was hot from the get-go. After an intense stare down - akin to the something that should be cast in silhouette on the page of comic book - the no disqualification falls count anywhere extravaganza was underway. Despite a lack of holds and moves in general, it managed to keep eyelids open throughout, never once letting up in intensity. Emphasizing chair shots, facial expressions and overall bloodiness, Hogan and McMahon went to war for the 54,097 capacity audience, proving that they're both as dedicated as each other, and providing some of the most cinematic moments of 2003. The satanically evil look on Vince's bloody face, as he peered over the ring apron like he'd risen from hell and pulled out a steel pipe from underneath the ring, was definitely one that sticks rooted in the nightmares of anyone unlucky enough to see it. Witnessing McMahon scale a ladder, mock The Hulkster like some kind of Wacky Races villain and hit Hogan with his own patented leg drop through the announcers table, provided a further highlight that would probably have become a video montage staple of the PG era, if it wasn't so saturated in the red stuff. Even after a bloated caricature of Roddy Piper intervened and smashed Hogan with the steel pipe, further instances of bar fight-style awesomeness occurred. McMahon hurled referee Brain Hebner out of the ring, hit a frantic leg drop on Hogan, tried to cover him, and then out of nowhere, Hulkamania ran wild. After a crazed comeback, The Hulkster hit three consecutive leg drops and pinned McMahon for the win. Even with their combined age at the time of 106 and extremely limited wrestling ability, this match was endlessly entertaining. It felt like a real, honest to god fight, settling a rivalry that many thought they'd never see the end of.

4. Hulk Hogan vs. Ultimate Warrior €“ WrestleMania VI

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W9lt__ACbFY The Ultimate Challenge As with most of Hogan's top tier matches, WrestleMania 6's Ultimate Challenge was a classic battle of the titans. It was Hogan himself, facing off against the guy on the next rung down from him. Ultimate Warrior was beginning to look like an action figure based on himself, rising in popularity as Intercontinental Champion to such a level, that the only logical main event for WrestleMania was to have him clash with the top guy. The event was preceded by the dissipation of an alliance into a rivalry between the two men, which all came to a head when the two dominant forces collided. Most of the match itself consisted of lots of rest holds and tonnes of sweat-inducing rope sprints. It wasn't until a lengthy bear hug from Warrior and referee Earl Hebner got planted on his back, that the near falls began, and the two participants fed off the energy. Warrior became immune to Hogans punches, shaking the ropes like he was trying to head bang but didn't quite know how to, and hitting Hogan with his overbearing military press/big splash combo. The Hulkster then retaliated as Hulkamania ran wild once again. But at the last second, Warrior countered, hit another gargantuan splash and scored the upset pinfall. This match was awesome, simply because it showed that the WWF wasn't just settling on the power of Hulkamania to fight it's battles. Warrior was certainly an underdog going into the bout, but became Hogan's equal after it. The image of the two sharing a hug of respect after Hogan handed his title over proves this, and would be permanently etched in memories of fans for years to come.

3. Hulk Hogan vs. Andre The Giant €“ WrestleMania III

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hwbaywz8QO0 David vs. Goliath The capacity attendance for WrestleMania III is still the highest that the company has ever seen. 93,173 people witnessed in person a match that still arguably holds the position of being the biggest of all time, between Hulk Hogan and Andre The Giant. As the Pontiac Silverdome gradually faded from the daylight of Aretha Franklin's stirring rendition of America the Beautiful, into regal, judging darkness, the stage was set for one of the most epic showdowns in the company's history. Andre stomped into the stadium like a miniature Godzilla, to an overwhelming tidal wave of boos, amplified even more so by his signature lack of entrance music or bombastic fanfare. Hogan's entrance was the opposite, as Gorilla Monsoon rightly put, 'the roof of the Silverdome was about to explode'. The stare down that followed was another one for the ages. The match itself was a slow, plodding affair; such was the nature of Andre The Giant's limited ring style. However, the lack of movement was more than expertly concealed by the storyline of the match, which portrayed the ultimate David vs. Goliath tale. Andre was on top for the majority, whipping Hogan around like he was a piece of rotting meat, slamming him with gusto and standing on him with 500+ pounds of beer fed body weight. From time to time, Hogan discovered ways to escape, but the giant found more than one way to knock Hulkamania back down onto its backside. After a lengthy bearhug (as is typical of Hogan's matches) followed by a string of unsuccessful shoulder blocks on The Hulkster's part €“ a literal representation of the unstoppable force versus the immovable object €“ the match spilled out of the ring and then quickly back in it again. One of Hogan's shoulder blocks was finally effective and the crowd exploded when the giant was toppled. This was followed by the defining moment of Hogan's entire career, as he hoisted Andre into the air - in the style of Superman €“ slammed him to the mat and executed an atomic leg drop for the three count. Once again, it wasn't necessarily a great match, but it did provide at least two everlasting visuals that perpetually resonated years into the future of professional wrestling. That's definitely an accomplishment.

2. Hulk Hogan vs. The Rock €“ WrestleMania X8

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TOcJam18DVs Icon vs. Icon With only the sexuality and violence remaining on the tail end of the Attitude era, WrestleMania 18 was the perfect place for Hulkamania to return to PPV, even though it had now clad itself in a black & white feather boa as part of the nWo in WCW. Hogan's positioning as a merciless heel was integral to the power of why this match was special, as his dastardly antics in the video package set the tone for the bout as perfectly as one ever has. The stellar promos from both men provided a near-Shakespearian narrative that quickened the pulse of all in attendance, way before the bell had even been rung. As a result, once again, the battle was set to be an epic of ridiculous proportions. The angle was simple; to pit two of the greatest of all time against each other, past versus future, icon versus icon. Entering the show, Hogan was supposed to be a heel, but it soon became clear that in reality, Hulkamania was still alive, and he would have to play the good guy. The crowd's excitement was the reason that this match is already scrawled in the history books as 'legendary'. Near-falls and big moves were punctuated by some of the most eardrum bursting reactions in WWE history, elevating a collision €“ which wasn't even necessarily that good at face value €“ into the realms of awesomeness. Highlights of the match were always the loudest, most so when Hogan pulled off an impactful rock bottom, covering The Rock for a heart-stoppingly close two and three quarter count. But eventually The Rock managed to power through, hit The Peoples Elbow and score the pinfall in one of the most rapturously received matches of Hogan's career. Not bad for a 50 year old.

1. Hulk Hogan vs. 'Macho Man' Randy Savage €“ WrestleMania V

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ANJ2D2dUlU4 The Mega Powers Explode! The implosion of The Mega Powers was a rarity in Hulk Hogan's career. It was, for once, a storyline that felt as though it had emotion and pre-planning behind it. Within the build-up, Savage perfectly encapsulated all the weasely jealousy that was needed to make their WrestleMania V main event a classic. Low and behold, it was. Preceded by a timid promo from Miss Elizabeth €“ who was supposed to stand in a neutral corner for the battle - expectancy was unbelievably high in Trump Plaza. Macho Man was the reigning champion of the time, entering with a self-assured cockiness and a strut that suggested a burgeoning superiority complex. This provided an imposing obstacle for the recently doused yet still burning flame of Hulkamania to overcome. Miss Elizabeth demurely followed to ringside, matriarchal and beautiful in equal measure. Hogan entered to as much of an explosive reaction as always. It was business as usual. All the pieces were in motion. However, counteractively to most other Hogan matches, the intensity of the two men was visibly high from the bell. Macho Man played the cowardly heel for a while, slithering out of the ring, running away and even using Miss Elizabeth as a human shield to stop Hulkamania from reaching him. This sparked some uncharacteristically technical wrestling from Hogan, which quickened the pace of the bout. Momentum began to shift so quickly and suddenly, that it genuinely seemed as though the ex-Mega Powers stars knew each other so well, they'd become evenly matched by default. This refreshingly transcended the well-established 'Hogan overcoming the odds' trend that riddled itself throughout the 80s. After some time, Hogan's eye was busted open, which just made Savage appear more sinister and villainous. This sinister edge then peaked as he began to shove Elizabeth out of the arena and delivered a devastating double axehandle to Hogan from the top rope to the outside. Savage then increased the intensity further, choking The Hulkster with his wrist tape, as if he'd botched a gangster style garroting. He eventually soared through the air to hit his patented diving elbow drop from the top rope and went for a cover, but once again, Hogan kicked out at two. Then Hulkamania ran wild, and well, you know the rest. This was genuinely a great match from start to finish. Once again, it finished in predictable fashion, but €“ although it wasn't a masterpiece €“ there's no reason that it shouldn't be labeled as the greatest match of Hogan's career. But of course, with the good comes the bad...

5. The Mega Powers vs. The Alliance To End Hulkamania - Uncensored 1996

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pEWQSh3YAFk The Doomsday Cage Match Sometimes a novelty gimmick match can work extremely well. Case in point: Hell in a Cell. However sometimes, gimmick matches can be clouded in confusion, often when the rules aren't entirely clear. This was especially true of the Doomsday cage match that main evented WCW Uncensored in 1996. The concept of the match was for the Mega Powers to fight through three cages, each with various wrestlers trying to "end Hulkamania" in each cage. The idea doesn't sound too bad does it? Well it was. The structure itself looked as though it would've probably worked better as a cheaply made climbing frame for a kids adventure park. It was clearly unstable from the start, as each time the participants stood on the wire mesh floor, it looked as though it would embarrassingly collapse under the immense weight of everyone trampling around. This resulted in a distinct lack of moves €“ in fear of the floor hilariously caving in - that meant the entire battle consisted primarily of punches and angsty yet not too hard shoves. Ric Flair couldn't display his technical prowess or any of his quirks, Arn Anderson couldn't execute an explosive spinebuster and Lex Luger couldn't pull off any high impact power moves. It caused complete and utter restriction, and this €“ combined with confusion in terms of what the aim of the match was supposed to be €“ resulted in a dangerous, gimmicky, awful mess. After Hogan & Savage made it down to the second level, Ric Flair and Arn Anderson were (apparently) eliminated and the commentators began to forget the rules themselves, audibly asking "how do you win this match?" The proceeding action consisted of Kevin Sullivan dangling from the cage-side scaffolding like he was begging for attention. Eventually, The Mega Powers exited the cage after yet another 'enthralling' bout of restricted brawling. Complete and utter confusion became the order of the day, as even officials were wondering whether The Mega Powers were supposed to have won the match by escaping the cage. Taskmaster and Luger ended up in the ring with Hogan and Savage, brawling into nothingness, towards no objective, pointlessly ambling towards a conclusion that was not yet determined. When Z-Gangster and Ultimate Solution eventually turned up, Hogan and Savage were dragged back to the hilarious/ominous structure and another brawl erupted in the ring at the bottom of the cage. But even when the bout was taking place in a proper ring, it still maintained it's awfulness and aimlessness, as Flair and Anderson returned to the cage to make it four on two. The battle ended comically in a flurry of frying pan shots to the head, after The Mega Powers were aided by The Booty Man (whoever he is). Then, providing one last moment of hilarity, Hogan and Savage were about to leave and Macho Man suddenly leaped €“ after temporarily forgetting what he was supposed to do - into a pin at the last minute, to give The Mega Powers the big win. But in reality it was a big loss for Hogan and Savage, who were €“ in that moment €“ shadows of their former selves.

4. Hulk Hogan vs. Sid Justice €“ WrestleMania VIII

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1jQXu6EAJGw The Warrior's Return This showdown was set up to follow the same Hogan blueprint that consistently repeated itself for years on end, However, due to the loose inclusion of a storyline, there was an overhanging air of speculation that it could be Hogan's last. The main title was on the line earlier in the card, between Ric Flair and Randy Savage, resulting in no foreseeable objective for the main event players to fight for. It's been speculated that the collision was originally supposed to consist of Ric Flair and Hogan, but for some reason this was scrapped as Vince saw a star in the size and power of Justice. The match kicked off with Justice attacking Hogan during his entrance, but Hogan fought back and heaved Justice out of the ring. All the while, 'Real American' was still playing weakly through the much too trebly arena PA, allowing Hogan to continue posturing his 24 inch pythons. Eventually the match began, and it ended up being less exciting than the scrap that preceded it. This bout was riddled with pure egotism on Hogan's part, as €“ on multiple occasions €“ he hurled Justice out of the ring and posed like a wannabe bodybuilder. Any actual clashes between the two were yawn inducing. It followed the same recycled, slow model that carried Hulkamania on a wave through the 80s, except this time, every bear hug and slam felt undeniably stale. Justice choke-slammed the Hulkster and pulled off an unconvincing mid-match promo, spitting "do unto the man, as he would do unto you, but do it first." Ridiculous. When Justice eventually managed to execute a sloppy powerbomb, Hogan kicked out - shaking his head - and it could've ended there, to the delight of everyone in attendance. The Ultimate Warrior's frenzied run-in just about saved the match from total abomination, but the outcome ended up as a mediocre Hogan victory by way of Disqualification, This was the Main Event of WrestleMania, and it didn't look as though it could be topped in terms of awfulness. That was, until the following year...

3. Hulk Hogan vs. Yokozuna €“ WrestleMania IX

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qk1nLeZoN4c 21 Seconds Later WrestleMania 9 at Caesars Palace didn't quite know what visual gimmick it was supposed to be going for. Ornate camels from Egypt were placed side-by-side with a homemade bed sheet toga dress code. It almost seemed as if the WWF had read every history book in existence, but decided to absorb the information all at once, and as a result, became confused about the linear nature of time itself. The show started with an awful comedy segment involving JR, Bobby Heenan and Macho Man Randy Savage. Even when an elephant appeared, it looked perplexed as to why it was clad in carpets and diamonds. Howard Finkel looked like a 40 year old man dressed up as cupid. The whole thing was just a bit strange. Running into WrestleMania, the main event was supposed to be Bret Hart (the champion) against Yokozuna. Yokozuna was on a roll, squashing Hacksaw Jim Duggan in his path with a Banzai Drop and attacking Hart during the contract signing for this match. But oddly, Hogan cut a promo before Hart and Yokozuna's match, giving his thoughts on the rivalry and challenging the winner of the main event. Hart and Yokozuna's match itself wasn't the best display of professional wrestling you're likely to see. Hart's intensity was expert as ever, but the overall match was just a bit too slow to be worthy of WrestleMania main event status. The man from the Orient eventually picked up the win after Mr Fuji threw salt into the eyes of Hart, winning the title. It wasn't great, relying mostly on nerve holds and Yokozuna's surprising agility for a man of his gargantuan size. However, it was a million times better than what was to come, as Mr Fuji followed the match by accepting Hogan's challenge and the actual main event started. Ridiculously, it ended just as quick. Mr Fuji accidently threw salt into the eyes of Yokozuna, Hogan hit a clothesline, leg drop and won the title again. This "match" lasted roughly 30 seconds, managing to claim it's place as possibly the worst WrestleMania main event of all time.

2. Hollywood Hogan vs. The Warrior - Halloween Havoc 1998

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_onsAu6SZH8 The Fireball Fiasco This was undoubtedly Hulk Hogan's worst lengthy showdown. Although DDP and Goldberg headlined the show, The Hulkster was booked just before, against his longtime friend and rival, The (Ultimate) Warrior. Hogan entered the match as part of the nWo (New World Order), which he joined €“ turning heel in the process €“ two years before at Bash at the Beach. By this point, the nWo were an established force, gaining the WCW ratings galore and forcing wrestling fans to take a second glance when faced with a baffling choice between the two main companies. This match was built up with a bad storyline, involving €“ amongst lots of other things €“ a segment involving a mirror that just has to be seen to be believed. Thus, the stage was set for a battle that could have at least be a little bit entertaining, even if that was just because it was comically bad. Kicking off with a predictably lackadaisical pace, the two dinosaurs traded similar spots as at their epic Wrestlemania 6 showdown, but without any of the hype and prestige of the former classic. Hogan no longer had Hulkamania behind him and The Warrior was certainly no longer The Ultimate Warrior of his heyday. As a result, these same spots were diluted due to a complete deficiency of emotion. Eventually, The Giant (now better known as Big Show) intruded once the referee was knocked out. The match sloppily continued as The Warrior overcame a selection of run-ins from the nWo and Hogan began to whip Warrior with his weight lifting belt. It was at this point €“ as Warrior went for a splash €“ that the crowd essentially lost interest in the bout. Hogan tried to light something from his pocket €“ presumably a fireball - but it didn't work, to the utter disappointment of all in attendance and the embarrassment of Hogan himself. Horace Hogan (The Hulkster's nephew) intervened, hitting The Warrior with a chair on the back of his rock-solid head. Hogan eventually scored the pinfall and the match was over. Horace and The Hulkster were about to set The Warrior on fire, but were wrestled out of the ring by security instead. This match was so bad, not just due to it's content, but because of the complete and utter disappointment that it instilled in the hearts of all that watched it. Disastrous.

1. Hollywood Hogan vs. Kevin Nash - Monday Nitro January 4th 1999

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uPNq3hGWolM The Fingerpoke Of Doom It's arguable that this could even be considered a match at all. In no doubt one of the most irritating screwball finishes in wrestling history, January 4th's Monday Nitro pitted Kevin Nash (the champion and leader of the Wolfpac faction of the nWo) against Hogan, who led the Hollywood faction, for the title. The crowd was electric for the start of the match. But as the two men stared at eachother and Hogan poked Nash in the chest with his index finger, knocking him to the ground, it became clear that the nWo had reunited into a singular entity again. This was also the same episode of Nitro at which announcer Tony Schiavone gave away the results of WWF's Raw, prompting 600,000 fans to change channels in order to see Mick Foley win his first WWF Championship. Never before has a singular match potentially had as much of a devastating effect on a company as this. As has been said multiple times, it was arguably integral in kicking off the impending descent and eventual dissipation of WCW, in one careless, swift blow. But of course these are just opinions. Do you agree or disagree? Are there any Hogan matches that sucked more than the previous five? Or are there better matches than the first five? Leave your comments below!

Contributor
Contributor

Obsessed with punk rock and pro wrestling. Writer (obviously) and Features Editor at Audio Addict Magazine.