Rebooking WWE SummerSlam 2003: 7 Ways To Make It Better

One of the most disappointing SummerSlams ever gets a rewrite.

A lot of fans are very quick to point out how strong the WWE roster was in the early 2000s. It might have been strong enough to support two separate brands, but what people often neglect to mention is that some of the PPVs from that period are not very good at all. It's easy to look back through rose-tinted glasses and wax lyrical about a time when WWE featured a healthy Triple H, The Rock, Brock Lesnar, Kurt Angle, The Undertaker, Chris Jericho, Shawn Michaels, Goldberg and so on, but the fact remains that as loaded with star power as the company was, they often failed to deliver when it mattered. SummerSlam 2003 was one of those occasions. Whilst it should have been one of the biggest and best shows of the year, due to some lacklustre performances and bizarre booking decisions, it turned into a massive disappointment. As fans, we are inclined to step into our DeLoreans and go back in time to write those WWE wrongs (figuratively, of course). By using the roster that WWE had access to at the time (that is, only fit and healthy performers), I attempt to book the SummerSlam spectacular that WWE should have the first time around. So, without further ado, our new opener...

7. The Undertaker Vs. Matt Hardy

Matt Hardy did not wrestle on the SummerSlam 2003 card. Instead, he was relegated to dark match duty. Well, that should probably be 'dark promo duty', since his scheduled opponent Zach Gowen could not compete, following the brutal angle on Smackdown where he was destroyed by Brock Lesnar. The Sensei of Mattitude was declared the winner via forfeit. In this rebooked version of the show, Hardy would open the televised portion of the event with an obnoxious promo about how Gowen was 'too scared' to come out and face him and that, in fact, nobody on the Smackdown roster had the balls to take him on. If anyone did have the nuts to fight him, he would take them on right here, right now... Cue The Dead Man's music. Hardy and his Little MFer Shannon Moore would try to run, but both would be beaten down by 'Taker, who would throw Matt back into the ring signalling the start of the first match. This would be a seven minute match, with Matt getting the advantage thanks to illegal assistance from Moore. Undertaker would begin his comeback and look to finish off Hardy when A-Train would interfere and flatten Big Evil, making him the winner by DQ and setting up his next programme.

6. The World's Greatest Tag Team Vs. The Dudley Boys - Tables Match

It's hard to imagine but, in 2003, there was rarely, if ever, any Smackdown versus Raw conflict. The brand extension was but a year and a half old at this point and clearly the powers-that-be were saving the battle of the brands for further down the line. It wouldn't have hurt to give fans a teaser at a big event like SummerSlam. The Dudley Boys opened the PPV against La Resistance, in what was a poor match. How the overpushed Frenchmen got a spot on the show, and talented amateur standouts Haas and Benjamin didn't, is anyone's guess. The self-proclaimed World's Greatest Tag Teams had been having frequent blinders with all manner of opponents on the blue brand (including a minor classic against Rey Mysterio and Billy Kidman at Vengeance) whereas young Rene Dupree and Sylvain Grenier had been trying their hardest not to botch every other move in their Raw outings. TWGTT versus The Dudleys would have been a fresh, never-before-seen match. It would be non-title, with the Duds holding the World Tag titles and their opponents holding the WWE Tag Team Championships, but neither being on the line. To make things a little more interesting, the match would be a tables match, the Dudley Boys' speciality. The Dudleys would, of course, be victorious and also put Raw GM Eric Bischoff through the wood in a post-match angle.

5. Chris Jericho Vs. Kevin Nash - Hair Vs. Hair Match

In the weeks leading up SummerSlam, Chris Jericho and Kevin Nash had a mini-feud which resulted in Y2J cutting off Big Daddy Cool's long locks the Raw before the Elimination Chamber match. Nash needed to get a haircut for his upcoming role in the movie The Punisher, so WWE decided to write it into the storyline. In this rebooking, WWE would continue to build it for another six days and have the blowoff take place at SummerSlam. Would it be a good match? No, probably not. Nash was rarely good between-the-ropes when he returned to WWE in 2002. It might, however, generate a few extra PPV buys. Besides, now out of the Chamber, Nash and Jericho need something to do. Jericho would win, of course.

4. Randy Orton Vs. Shawn Michaels

Randy Orton was really starting to hit his stride in mid-to-late 2003, following a couple of depressing injury setbacks. The newly-dubbed 'Legend Killer' was getting a decent push in the upper midcard as a member of Evolution. At SummerSlam 2003, he had a good showing in the Elimination Chamber main event. What Orton really needed was victories against top singles guys. The WWE booked Orton to go over Shawn Michaels at Unforgiven a month after SummerSlam. Michaels was also involved in the Chamber match and looked good but it was clear by this point that he should be being used to work with the stars of tomorrow. HBK and RKO had a good match at Unforgiven and the result (although it was a cheap finish) certainly raised Orton's profile. So why not do it at SummerSlam, a show that would be seen by a lot more people than Unforgiven would? This would be a 15-20 minute match with a clean Orton victory.

3. Six Pack Challenge For The US Title - Benoit Vs. Guerrero Vs. Tajiri Vs. Rhyno Vs. Cena Vs. Mysterio

Eddie Guerrero was the hottest thing on Smackdown in the summer of 2003. He was the United States Champion, he was over and he was wrestling the matches of his life. Latino Heat, booked as a heel but actually getting face reactions from the crowd, could do no wrong. It was only a matter of time before he was elevated to the top, but he still had a lot to contribute to the midcard scene before his eventual ascent. Eddie spent much of 2003 feuding with (and p****ng off) Chris Benoit, Rey Mysterio, John Cena, Tajiri and Rhyno. So why not put them all together in the same match and see if Eddie could defy the odds and lie, cheat and steal his way to retaining the gold. The original SummerSlam match was similar, with Eddie taking on Tajiri, Benoit and Rhyno. That Cena and Mysterio (who wrestled Shannon Moore in a dark match) were not on the card was criminal. There are many interesting combinations of matches with those six guys and, if given enough time (say 12-15 minutes) it could be a total show-stealer. Eddie would retain his title because, well, it would be made to take it off of him, considering the hot streak he was one.

2. Goldberg Vs. Kane - No.1 Contender For The World Heavyweight Championship

SummerSlam 2003 should have been Goldberg's night. All signs pointed to him emerging from the Elimination Chamber match as World Heavyweight Champion. SummerSlam marked the first time he had looked like the real Goldberg since debuting in the company in April. Cutting through the competition with high octane power moves, he looked every bit the star that he had in WCW. The fan response was positive and it seemed implausible that he wouldn't be crowned champ. Unfortunately, then-champion Triple H entered the Chamber with a serious groin muscle and could barely walk, let alone wrestle. So WWE booked the finish they did, with The Game hitting Da Man with a cheap slegehammer shot and retaining. Triple H shouldn't have been wrestling that night...so in this version, he won't be! Instead, Goldberg will go up against the rampaging Kane. The Big Red Machine recently turned heel and began destroying everyone from Rob Van Dam to Linda McMahon and Jim Ross. Kane would logically want revenge, and a title shot, against Triple H, since it was he who beat him, leading to his unmasking. This would be a powerful big man match, but it wouldn't be booked to go too long, like a lot of Goldberg's WWE matches were (it was not his strong suit). Instead, this one would be wrapped up in about ten minutes, with Goldberg coming out on top, due to interference from either Rob Van Dam or Shane McMahon (or both).

1. Kurt Angle Vs. Brock Lesnar - I Quit Match For The WWE Championship

Ah, the Brock Lesnar/Kurt Angle saga of 2003. Angle and Lesnar had a traditional rivalry leading up to WrestleMania XIX but it changed somewhat when Angle came back following neck surgery as a babyface. They became an uber-competitive friends/rivals who spent more time cracking jokes than actually wrestling each other. That all changed when Angle won the WWE Championship at Vengeance. Lesnar couldn't deal with that and formed a pact with the tyrannical Mr. McMahon. He developed (or rediscovered) his mean streak and destroyed the likes of poor Zach Gowen and Paul London. The Angle/Lesnar showdown at SummerSlam was oddly sandwiched in the middle of the card and had no stipulation. It was just a regular match, something we had seen out of Lesnar and Angle several times before. In this version of SummerSlam 2003, Angle and Lesnar would clash in an I Quit match. It makes sense because not only does it play into their submission styles, but Lesnar could also show a little more of his vicious side. It would be a brutal, bloody and epic match, with the Olympic gold medalist coming out on top by making The Next Big Thing tap out to the ankle lock. What would you have done to improve SummerSlam 2003? Would you have kept the Elimination Chamber match but used different competitors? Is Kurt Anlge leaving as WWE Champion? Let us know in the comments section below!

Contributor
Contributor

Student of film. Former professional wrestler. Supporter of Newcastle United. Don't cry for me, I'm already dead...