The WORST Moment From EVERY WWE SummerSlam
18. Chris Jericho Accidentally Socks HBK’s Wife For Real (2008)
2008's rivalry between Chris Jericho and Shawn Michaels is timeless. Not only was it one of the greatest stories of the year that led to countless stunning matches, but it also helped define Shawn's second full-time stint as an active wrestler. Jericho had to be proud of that fact. Both men locked horns on several pay-per-views and on weekly TV in promo skits as 'Y2J' badmouthed the guy he'd once considered a teen idol growing up.
Seeking resolution, both met in a frosty promo segment at SummerSlam. Shawn brought his wife Rebecca along with him for moral support, but she'd end up getting involved in the action. Jericho went to punch Michaels, who ducked, then accidentally clocked Rebecca right in the face.
Like, he literally socked her one. For real.
That wasn't in the script, obviously. Jericho forgot to pull his punch or misjudged the distance. Either that or Rebecca failed to whip her head back in time so she wouldn't eat a fist to the chops as a shoot. Shawn was understandably incensed by this, and Chris thought for sure he was going to get into a fist fight with his former hero once he went back through the curtain.
The famous foes didn't come to shoot blows behind the curtain, but Michaels made sure to warn an apologetic Jericho to be more careful with his hands in the future. For his part, 'Y2J' said sorry over and over again to Rebecca. She'd previously been involved in wrestling as a Nitro Girl over in WCW, but had never really taken many planned bumps until this point.
It was a nasty surprise for her when Jericho's fist connected. Ouch. Great segment, at least!
17. You’ve Got 8 Seconds, Lads! (2009)
What on earth were WWE thinking here?!
Management gave Christian’s ECW Title defence vs. William Regal just 8 seconds at SummerSlam 2009. Their entrances were longer, as you’d probably guess, and the whole exercise was an insult to workers that talented. By comparison, duff matches like Kane vs. The Great Khali (9 minutes) and MVP vs. Jack Swagger (8 minutes) received bags of time on the card.
Sadly, the ECW Title was made to look like a total afterthought. That might've been fair enough had the belt been on someone like future champ Ezekiel Jackson, but Christian and Regal were/are world class workers who deserved a lot better than this slap in the face in front of a packed Staples Center in LA.
Regal hadn't even removed his entrance attire before Christian smashed him with a quick Killswitch and pinned him to retain the belt. The announce team screeched with faux shock at what had just happened, and WWE chirpily pretended that any of this had been worthwhile. It wasn't, to be blunt.
Christian and Regal could've put on a clinic out there. They'd have done a better job with 8-10 minutes than some aforementioned matches on the same show, but it wasn't to be. Nobody would've been gutted (other than the wrestlers themselves, of course) had MVP vs. Swagger been relegated to the subsequent episode of Raw or SmackDown instead of taking place on PPV.
The same goes for a thoroughly dull Kane vs. Khali big man battle no-one actually bought SummerSlam to see.
16. ‘Super Cena’ Neuters Nexus (2010)
John Cena's retirement tour lauded his greatest accomplishments and downplayed the worst parts of his WWE career. Fans rejected a generational heel run for 2 reasons. Firstly, because the follow up on his heel turn sucked. Second, because people just didn't want to boo Cena during his final year as an active worker.
The irony here is that folks had been screaming jeers at JC for decades. Case in point: SummerSlam 2010. Back then, Cena was viewed as a poster boy for WWE ignorance, and he was booed heavily during his entrances, promos and matches by many. The Nexus crew might've been amongst those booing.
Get this: Despite taking a bump on the concrete and being at a handicap disadvantage, Cena ‘Super Cena’d’ up and beat both Justin Gabriel and Wade Barrett like they were Tekno Team 2000 to win the main event for ‘Team WWE’. Behind the curtain, both Edge and Chris Jericho disagreed with him on the finish, but John vetoed that to make Nexus look like losers.
It was a poor decision, and a senseless one.
Nexus looked totally nullified when they were supposed to represent a huge threat to the status quo. Edge and Jericho knew it was more important to hype the heel group up, but 'Super Cena' had to 'Super Cena' Sheesh, and people drone on about Hulk Hogan's creative power plays. This was ridiculously selfish from JC.
It also hampered the SummerSlam headliner by sucking fans out of the rebellious power fantasy Barrett and chums had been peddling since their main roster debuts in June.
15. WWE Fumbles The ‘Summer Of Punk’ (2011)
CM Punk winning the WWE Title from John Cena at Money In The Bank 2011 then kissing goodbye to the company whilst champion was one of the most compelling plot points ever. Somehow, the promotion bungled it completely by crowning Cena as an interim champ then bringing Punk back in time for SummerSlam and a 'Winner Takes All' collision.
Triple H was installed as the special guest referee, but that wasn't the biggest problem. No, the biggest issue was that Punk looked silly for even agreeing to any of this when he'd won the title fair and square at MITB. Then, there was a nonsense screwy finish before Kevin Nash (of all people!) ran in and Alberto Del Rio cashed in his Money In The Bank briefcase to end the night as champ.
Urgh.
Look, booking a lot of drama can be fun, but all of this veered too far in the opposite direction of a story that had wrestling fans by the balls. People were invested when Punk blew that kiss at Vince towards the end of MITB, and they eagerly waited to see where the tale would turn next.
If the answer had been: 'It'll move away from the 'Summer Of Punk' angle you're clearly enjoying', then there might've been a riot. Nash's subsequent phone confusion with Hunter and Del Rio's own title reign proved to be useless sub-plots hanging off Punk's majesty. What a stupid way to handle one of your best storylines in living memory.
Punk must've been steaming mad, but at least they corrected things by putting the title on him a few months later.
14. Fans Troll Triple H By Chanting “You Tapped Out” (2012)
Brock Lesnar's return the night after WrestleMania XXVIII in 2012 was a real shot in the arm WWE's product needed. He attacked John Cena, then worked one of the most violent gimmick bouts in recent memory at Extreme Rules. Lesnar lost, but he still carried a lot of menace. It wasn't long before Triple H wanted in on that act.
Brock's next match post-Cena loss to a win over Hunter at SummerSlam in August. The pair headlined the pay-per-view, went nearly 19 minutes, and they tried to tell the tale of a celebrated badass (Trips) doing everything he could to take down 'The Beast'. Ultimately, HHH would fail, and WWE wanted fans to feel sorry for him as he wallowed in defeat.
Erm...about that.
Post-match, an emotional Trips shed crocodile tears and flashed puppy dog eyes (any other animals coming along for this party?!) as he repeatedly said: "I'm sorry, guys" to the live crowd. Not reading the memo, those same folks booed and chanted things like: "You tapped out" at 'The Game'. It was pretty embarrassing to watch live, so much so that WWE sweetened the response afterwards.
Sure, there were some cheers, but this 'he's one of us' moment didn't really land as intended. Instead of SummerSlam going off the air with emotional questions hanging over Triple H's full-time run as a wrestler, people just wanted to see Brock destroy some more fools and continue his post-MMA return against other workers.
The Hunter story would rage on though, whether fans demanded it or not.
13. The ‘Ring Of Fire’ Debacle (2013)
There's a good reason why WWE don't run with the 'Inferno Match' gimmick too often: It isn't anywhere near as exciting in execution as it seems to be in theory. The fire idea fit Kane's battles with The Undertaker back during the 'Attitude' days, but creative brought it out of storage for his bout vs. Bray Wyatt in 2013 too.
They shouldn't have bothered.
It was certainly bold to open SummerSlam with the renamed 'Ring Of Fire' speciality between the pair. Revisiting such an iconic set piece bout probably sounded like the right idea, but it didn't translate well in 2013 - definitely not as a launching pad for the entire pay-per-view.
Fire matches are a tough sell, because they’re legit dangerous. So, workers have to just stumble around teasing a few bumps into the flames and the whole thing loses steam pretty swiftly. That's the charitable way of putting it. Bloody boring would perhaps be more accurate and less kind.
The main problem with 'Inferno' or 'Ring Of Fire' bouts is that they'll never live up to the violence expected of such things. The lure is that you're going to see somebody set ablaze, but that rarely (if ever) actually happens. Instead, everyone sits around on their hands waiting for little teases that never lead to much of any note. It's dull.
Wyatt and Kane couldn't deliver what they'd promised on TV leading up to SummerSlam. That isn't necessarily their fault, of course, but...just give this gimmick a miss from now on, WWE. It isn't even all that fun to play in WWE 2K26!
12. Nikki Bella’s Lame Duck Heel Turn (2014)
Nikki Bella turned on her sister Brie to help Stephanie McMahon win a showdown nobody asked for at SummerSlam 2014. Listen, these women are only guilty of trying their best with the whole thing, but there was nobody to carry this into passable territory; Stephanie was never a worker outside select things like the ‘Mania 34 mixed tag, and Brie has been working largely the same match her entire career.
If anything, it's remarkable that this ended up as slick as it was (and it wasn't very slick).
WWE gave up on Nikki’s heel turn quickly too, thus rendering the whole thing pointless. They went hard and heavy-handed on the storyline for a while, including when Nikki told Brie she'd be happier if she'd never been born at all, but it didn't click with the audience so everyone called it quits. The Bella Twins were back to running "twin magic" in tag-team matches by the end of the year.
So much for that then. This heel turn couldn't have been more half-hearted, man. Also, Stephanie's Pedigree on Brie following Nikki's reveal looked a little wonky. You could definitely file this under 'Matches WWE Fans Didn't Ask For (But Got Anyway)'. The company seemed determined to go with their Bella split story.
It's always baffling when creative types book something without a coherent plan for it afterwards. One could almost see the puzzled looks on everyone's faces as they looked over to Vince McMahon and asked, 'What now, boss?'. He didn't know. He really didn't know.
11. Charles Robinson Tells You When To Ring The Bell! (2015)
SummerSlam 2015 was some show, at least on top. John Cena vs. Seth Rollins ruled, Kevin Owens vs. Cesaro was a fun ride, and Brock Lesnar's first match with The Undertaker since ending his WrestleMania winning streak in 2014 had plenty of gusto going in. It's just a pity they booked such an utterly baffling finish.
What was that finish? Well, Brock had ‘Taker in a submission when the ref began counting Lesnar's shoulders down. Charles Robinson had only counted once before the timekeeper rang the bell. As Chuck argued about it, Undertaker smacked Brock with a low blow and put him in his own submission for the tap out win.
Yeah, nobody really knew what was going on. It was so messy.
First of all, why did the timekeeper ring the bell without Robinson's say so? Second, Brock's shoulders kept coming up off the canvas anyway, so it barely made sense to believe that the ref was going to reach a 3 count. Third, the announcers acted like this was a mistake timekeepers occasionally made, which wasn't true.
On top of all that, it just flattened the live crowd and those watching the pay-per-view back home. 'Taker and Brock had been inching towards a dramatic conclusion right before this spot, but the ending counterproductively sucked any energy out of the match rather than adding to it. Hmm. Pat Patterson-style creativity this most definitely wasn't.
It was the kind of clumsy finish people once expected from WCW, not WWE, and it sure scuffed the ending to SummerSlam.
10. Fans Reject The Universal Title Design (2016)
One of 2016's big lures was the brand new Universal Title that Seth Rollins and Finn Bálor would be fighting to hold first. This happened during the 'colour scheme era', which meant that Raw's new World Championship had to be red. It looked like a toy version of the pre-existing WWE Title, and fans weren't too chuffed about it.
A rowdy live crowd in Brooklyn trolled WWE for the red dip look, and that reaction had a negative impact on the otherwise-great bout between Rollins and Balor to crown the first champ. Honourable mention must go to Finn getting injured and thus being unable to hold the belt for longer than 24 hours though.
He was stripped on the following Raw.
Fans didn't know that when SummerSlam was raging on. All they knew was that co-GMs Mick Foley and Stephanie McMahon had looked rather silly by ignoring general sentiment to pretend that the new fangled Universal prize was cooler than the other side of the pillow. Nobody was buying it, and that red aesthetic would stick around until the belt moved to SmackDown and got a blue paint job instead.
Thankfully, WWE has moved away from colour scheming their straps depending on Raw or SmackDown ownership. Today, titles have a much classier gold or silver motif that makes them look more credible and less like toys you'd see packed in with some action figures.
Even Mick and Steph must've known that this was a hard sell, but no-one expected the arena to rebel so loudly.
9. A Nothing WWE Title Clash (2017)
Career midcarder Jinder Mahal shocked the world by becoming WWE Champion at Backlash 2017. However, his reign made the belt look midcard, sadly, and few bought him as the kind of worker who'd realistically succeed a top name like Randy Orton. Still, surely the WWE marketing machine would kick in and shine Jinder up.
Or not.
Mahal's follow up summer feud with Shinsuke Nakamura was soaked in unfortunate race-baiting, and then their match at SummerSlam flopped. It was also Naka’s first loss on the main roster, so he was sacrificed to make Jinder look like a million bucks. Or, at least, that was the plan Vince McMahon had in mind.
Naturally (no-one reading will be surprised by this), McMahon lost all interest in Jinder after his initial flurry heading into the summer. His title reign died a slow death before AJ Styles ended it on a special episode of SmackDown taped over in Manchester, England. The top belt had been saved from further ignominy at the hands of an ex-3MB member not named Drew McIntyre.
People didn't want Mahal poking fun at Shinsuke's Japanese heritage via lame "comedy" skits on SmackDown, and they certainly didn't want to see Jinder working top billing at shows like SummerSlam. Even WWE knew that wouldn't fly, so they relegated the WWE Title match between Mahal and Nakamura to the sub-main event slot and let a far more enticing Fatal-4-Way clash for the Universal Title go on last.
Jinder's win over Shin couldn't even muster excitement for a possible babyface triumph, and that says it all.