The WORST Moment From EVERY WWE SummerSlam
8. Ronda Rousey’s Flat Raw Women’s Title Win (2018)
The overall story going into Ronda Rousey's match with Alexa Bliss at SummerSlam 2018 was that someone like Bliss was totally out of her depth. That tale made for a boring match, surprisingly so considering it was only 4 minutes long. In retrospect, Rousey’s Terminator-like facial expressions were one-note.
SummerSlam marked her first singles match on PPV, and it just didn’t work. Unfortunately for 'Rowdy' Ronda, it wouldn’t be long before fans were turning on her and she...just couldn’t handle it. The concept of being booed was lost on Rousey, but that wasn't a hurdle WWE had to jump early on during her honeymoon period in the company.
It is, however, worth noting that Ronda's presentation changed for the worse between her fab WrestleMania 34 debut and this battle with Bliss. She started painting her face like some long lost female member from Powers Of Pain, and the creative cast her as akin to a cyborg who found this pro wrestling lark far too easy.
There was an elitist air to Rousey that fans found difficult to get onside with. If she was going to destroy everyone in her path and act unlikeable doing it, then why should people in the building cheer her? If anything, Alexa was the sympathetic underdog in this situation.
WWE dropped the ball almost immediately by reimagining Ronda as Bill Goldberg-lite. She did have credibility when coming from the MMA game, but wrestling needs more than that. The cartoonish vibes of her face paints clashed with that realistic aesthetic too.
7. Double Countout Hurts ‘KofiMania’ (2019)
Kofi Kingston was never supposed to reach the mountaintop and become WWE Champion in 2019, but he defied the odds to launch 'KofiMania' by beating Daniel Bryan at 'Mania 35. The entire wrestling world melted in unison. They recognised Kingston's passion, and they were happy that he'd been able to bite back against a bungled 2008-2009 push by forming New Day then seizing the moment a decade or so later.
At SummerSlam, Kingston vs. Randy Orton for the WWE Title deserved better than the lame double countout finish it got. If nothing else, this was clear evidence that Vince McMahon just didn’t see Kofi as a long-term main eventer. He’d eventually drop the belt to Brock Lesnar during the first SmackDown on FOX not long after this, which put a bad taste in the mouths of millions.
It wasn't that Lesnar was a poor choice to supplant Kingston - it's that he ended a reign spotlighted for much of the year without breaking a sweat. It was back to tags and the midcard for 'KofiMania'. He'd have to perhaps win a 'KofiRumble' if he wanted another crack at the main event pack, and that was never realistically going to be the case.
Fans in Toronto for SummerSlam jeered the weak double countout result, and rightfully so. They'd waited a long time to see this rematch between old rivals, and this was what WWE's power brokers thought was best for one of the bigger pay-per-views of 2019?!
Stupid. Stupid, stupid, stupid booking from Vince and gang.
6. It Was ThunderDomed (2020)
This could be considered harsh by some, which is fair enough.
2020's version was the only SummerSlam in history to take place in front of exactly 0 fans live. In fairness, WWE didn’t have a say in the matter due to the ongoing global pandemic. Rallying, they had to make the best of a bad situation, but the lack of natural ambience makes 2020’s show pretty eerie to revisit today.
It didn't help that Vince McMahon and others repeated the, "You'll Never See It Coming" tagline over and over until everyone was sick of it before the pay-per-view had even aired. That line was in reference to a bold Roman Reigns return and alliance with Paul Heyman. He's still going strong with that 'Tribal Chief' gimmick today, so that's cool.
Almost everything else? It was a big meh, but that had more to do with the complete lack of organic crowd noise inside the "ThunderDome" (Amway/Kia Center in Orlando, Florida). Thus, matches like Bayley vs. Asuka, a grudge bout pitting Sonya Deville vs. Mandy Rose, Asuka (again) vs. Sasha Banks, Drew McIntyre vs. Randy Orton and Bray Wyatt's 'Fiend' vs. Braun Strowman struggled to gain much momentum.
Everyone was working hard, but the gist of this collection is that every single SummerSlam had a duff moment. For 2020, it was the "ThunderDome" setting itself. In fact, most wouldn't remember this at all had Roman not returned with a bang towards the end of the so-so headliner between Wyatt's alter ego and Braun.
Needs must, sure, but Homer Simpson would've renamed this facility the ThunderD'oh.
5. Eva Marie, Lilly & Zero Bliss! (2021)
Alexa Bliss vs. Eva Marie was a stain on SummerSlam 2021.
It was almost like WWE decided to throw it on back to the Divas division with their match, and that isn’t meant as a compliment. Poor Piper Niven as Doudrop was a rotten role too. Having her play second fiddle to Marie’s second stab at WWE life was rough, and Alexa’s Lilly doll fixation was permanently painful.
No, not even Doudrop turning on Eva post-match could save it. It was painfully clear that she would've done a better job than her "mentor" inside the ring with Bliss. At least fans would've been guaranteed some slick exchanges and worthwhile action had that been the switch-a-roo, but bosses were determined that going from 'All Red Everything' to 'All Pink Everything' would work for Marie.
Narrator's voice: It did not work. Eva's focus on Lilly dragged this bout through the mud, and leaning on that gimmick was always going to toil inside the cavernous Allegiant Stadium. Lord only knows what fans way up high in the nosebleed seats thought when Marie dangled a doll in front of Alexa and slapped it around the place.
Meanwhile, those camped out (who had paid a pretty penny, by the way) around ringside looked around awkwardly waiting on the segment to conclude. It was short at less than 4 minutes, but then Bliss vs. Eva shouldn't have been on the card at all.
Literally nobody tuned into SummerSlam for this match. Sorry, they just didn't. Damian Priest and Sheamus must've been thanking their lucky stars that they had to follow it.
4. WWE Makes Liv Morgan Look Weak (2022)
2026 Liv Morgan is a much bigger deal than she was 4 years ago. Now, Liv could probably withstand punishing creative like she slogged through at SummerSlam 2022, but things were different back then. Fans wanted to embrace her, but WWE made that mission impossible because they also fancied appeasing Ronda Rousey.
So, on the pay-per-view, Morgan tapped out as she was pinning Ronda mid-armbar. Despite submitting, she still scored the win. Ronda apparently didn’t notice/care that her shoulders were on the mat, so she stupidly lay there as the referee counted 3. The whole deal tanked.
Liv looked out of her depth and fluky, which led to boos on coming episodes of TV when she bragged about winning. It was a bad idea all over from beginning to end. Think about this: Someone high up in the food chain believed having Morgan laugh about such a screwy finish would endear her to the core audience. How wrong were they?!
This was not the right way to build a fresh star or make Liv look like a credible player in the women's division for years to come. It says everything about her resilience and emerging star power that Morgan was able to shrug this tripe off and grow stronger. It might've destroyed a lesser performer.
For her part, Ronda had to go heel and act like some big-money MMA prize fighter to explain what had gone wrong at SummerSlam. WWE botched their handling of this bout badly, and they'll never get a pass for it.
3. MMA Rules Sinks (2023)
One last bit of Rousey bashing, honest.
Man, she was involved in some rotten SummerSlam stinkers, huh? Ronda saved her worst for last when going up against real-life pal and former tag partner Shayna Baszler in 2023. Their 'MMA Rules' showing will always be viewed as one of the worst PPV/PLE matches WWE has ever put on.
It was a frankly rubbish way for Ronda to bow out of her second run with the company, and creative didn’t even do anything with Shayna afterwards anyway. We're talking 0/10 levels of success rate between these 2 women here. If this was supposed to reposition Baszler as a star worth taking seriously, then it was a miserable flop.
Shayna and Rousey didn't 'WWE up' their fight. No, they slowed things down and performed some realistic (albeit still worked) mat work as both jockeyed for position on the canvas. Throughout, a bored 50,000+ in Detroit's Ford Field yawned and chatted amongst themselves.
A supposedly intense mixed martial arts showcase between former teammates was reduced to the dreaded pee break spot on the card. Nothing else came close to it, not even LA Knight winning a 25-man Battle Royal sponsored by Slim Jim. That was WWE bliss compared to this utter crud.
There's a fair chance that Rousey will never work another match for the promotion, which is a shame. Departing on such a low note, and in a match designed to show off what you do well, told the full story of somebody who'd washed her hands of WWE life.
2. Jelly Roll Goes John Cena (2024)
WWE and Triple H put on a pretty great SummerSlam overall in 2024, so there weren’t many lowlights.
That high standard across the board means it's challenging to pick out anything truly crap. It also means that the dubious award goes to Jelly Cena for his ‘Five Knuckle Shuffle’ on Austin Theory during a segment with The Miz, R-Truth, Theory and Grayson Waller. Jelly Roll was flown in for some time filler.
Critics (and harsh ones) will suggest that he's always time filler, but the singer has done a good job with his speaking parts on WWE TV in 2025 and 2026. At times, he's been one of the biggest highlights on episodes of SmackDown. That might well be damning for the blue brand's output, but it's nonetheless true.
Whether talking passionately to Randy Orton or Cody Rhodes behind the scenes, Jelly has excelled. He's even managed to look decent enough inside the ring when called upon, but that wasn't really the case back in 2024. Nah, his John Cena impersonation alongside Miz and Truth plugged a gap between Gunther vs. Damian Priest and the Cody Rhodes vs. Solo Sikoa main event.
That was it. Being completely fair, it was hardly like these guys were going to work the best segment in WWE PLE lore, or anything. Again, it speaks to just how tidy the show was as a whole that this is considered its worst lowlight.
Side note: Go back and watch Drew McIntyre vs. CM Punk with Seth Rollins as special guest ref if you haven't since it happened. You won't be disappointed.
1. The Brock Lesnar Controversy (2025)
It'd be churlish to handpick anything else from SummerSlam 2025 for this slot. Tiffany Stratton vs. Jade Cargill was a blight on the weekender, and some probably hated Jelly Roll teaming with Randy Orton vs. Drew McIntyre and Logan Paul, but nothing could touch Brock Lesnar's comeback in terms of pure shock value.
Lesnar had been removed from WWE programming (and even video games) after being named in the ongoing Janel Grant lawsuit against Vince McMahon, the company and others back in 2023. His last showing was actually at SummerSlam that year, but Brock marched back into view 2 years later to blast John Cena with an F5.
Cena had just turned babyface again shortly before, so it was clear that he and a heel Lesnar were going to meet one last time during John's retirement tour. That'd happen at Wrestlepalooza, but WWE's PR team had to sift through some controversial fallout following SummerSlam first.
Some didn't like the way TKO/WWE went about bringing Brock back in, especially when legal stuff was hanging over everyone's heads and had dominated discourse for years. Despite that, it happened. Many were torn between being excited to see such a huge name back on screens and feeling let down that TKO valued box office dollars over morality.
Individual fans don't need a lecture on this. They can make their own minds up, but it was impossible for WWE and Brock to escape scrutiny or controversy.
What other SummerSlam moments could be considered WWE's worst ever? For more wrestling, check out 10 WWE Jobbers Who Became Wrestling GAME-CHANGERS and The Hardest WCW Quiz EVER - Test Your Knowledge!