Why WWE Just Made Its Biggest Mistake In YEARS

The biggest potential departure in WWE isn't Roman Reigns...

Sasha Banks
WWE

At time of writing, it's looking rather a lot like the relationship between WWE and Sasha Banks is over.

Nestled below the sensational story of Vince McMahon's sex scandal on social media - what year is this? - was Raj Giri's report that Banks has been released. Is "below" the correct term however? This isn't the most reliable metric, but WhatCulture's analytics confirm that the Sasha story is actually of greater interest to WWE fans. Indeed, a story about Sasha changing the colour of her hair is one of the most popular stories published by the website in June. This month alone, CM Punk was reported to have undergone surgery, a man many consider to be the greatest wrestler on the planet debuted in All Elite Wrestling, and - again - Vince McMahon is under investigation by his own board for allegedly making a $3 million hush payment to a former employee with whom he had an affair. Sasha Banks changing the colour of her hair is of equal interest to transformative narrative developments and what should be the biggest story of a year in which an AEW EVP jumped ship to WWE.

Sean Ross Sapp of Fightful is currently working to confirm Raj's report; Sapp has clarified that it hasn't been rubbished, and Giri is so confident that he has declared his intention to step away from the scoops game if his source has worked him.

It's not an unexpected development, in the wake of the furore of the May 16 episode of WWE Monday Night RAW, on which Sasha Banks and Naomi threw down their Women's Tag Team Titles on the desk of John Laurinaitis, refused to work the main event of the show, and in effect left the company.

CONT'D...(1 of 6)


Chris Jericho
AEW

It was speculated in the aftermath that the contracts of both performers were set to expire in the next two months. Of course, this means nothing; in the past, the very recent past, WWE has frozen contracts when they have adjudged talent to be in breach of them by refusing to work. This was the case with Neville in 2017, and he didn't resurface in wrestling for a full year. The optics of doing this again, in the wake of Vince McMahon's sex scandal - it's still wild writing that in the present tense - are quite untenable. Perhaps the stories are linked in some way. That is baseless speculation, but if there's ever a time for WWE not to be...itself, it is now.

If Banks has indeed gone, this represents a big mistake. Not huge, not astronomical - WWE makes so much money and is guaranteed to make more over the next several years that they can get away with and have gotten away with putting their biggest star on ice for the next several months - but it remains a big blow to the company's look, roster and numbers. And there's possibly more to it than that.

Sasha Banks is a major draw, the A to Roman Reigns' 1, at the very least, and she's not even the focal point of the show. Beyond a SmackDown Women's title programme with Bianca Belair, she has spent much of the last year or so preoccupied in the dreaded Women's Tag Team Title picture. The booking was barely there, it reeked of a compromise to accommodate the returning Ronda Rousey, and yet those drawn to Sasha - i.e., the largest television audience in the United States - absolutely refused to sell the idea that she was less of a star. This recent ratings performance is consistent with a record incredible by modern standards. In overall viewership, she defeated AEW's Demogod Chris Jericho when she headlined the NXT Great American Bash in 2020; strangely, given who is always pushed more strongly, Charlotte Flair failed to defeat AEW in any demographic when she cameoed on Wednesdays.

CONT'D...(2 of 6)


Sasha Banks Bayley
WWE.com

Up against coverage of the 2020 U.S. presidential election, competition more fierce than sports, Sasha's November 6 victory over Bayley represented WWE's biggest ratings hit of the COVID-19 pandemic.

The bleak, sterile compromise that was the ThunderDome didn't matter to the viewing public; they, 2.52 million of them, were deeply invested in watching Sasha Banks in a big time title fight with the promise of an actual finish. WWE could not hope to draw that number now, even as fans have returned and everything feels less unremittingly grim. Dave Meltzer of the Wrestling Observer attributed the "entire" rating to Sasha's match; the overall and 18-49 numbers declined sharply the second that Sasha retreated up the ramp, title belt in tow.

Sasha is still only 30 years old. Her wrestler's prime years are ahead of her. She is the best women's wrestler in North America, and if that's a subjective opinion, it is close to the consensus. Her frenetic bursts of offence are wild and engaging, she links her repertoire brilliantly and with high intensity to come across as a tenacious submission wizard, and few wrestlers on the planet, irrespective of promotion or gender, sell like total death for her opponents as she does. Most impressively, she works (or worked) for a promotion that aims to regulate the level of danger between the ropes. She isn't getting dumped on her head or being smashed in the safer spaces of her face; she is just incredible at making the physicality feel far more violent than it actually is.

CONT'D...(3 of 6)


Sasha Banks
WWE.com

She is a firecracker of a performer who is also demonstrably capable of breaking the internet whenever she debuts a flattering new outfit or displays...suggestive body language.

It's just as well that this is a truthful and passionate take, because if you bury Sasha Banks online, you best log off.

Her fanbase is the most loyal of any pro wrestler in an era defined by tribalism and stan culture. Her fans are obsessed with her. In the right context and with the most committed build, she moves the needle more than any other independent contractor in the entire world. And yet, this year, she had to petition to do something of note with a midcard belt that only she gave a sh*t about it. Vince McMahon is extremely erratic and impatient when promoting a star act. He loses interest quickly in most cases. The "three weeks" principle is a meme, and Austin Theory is scant evidence that he will sometimes persist for longer than that, but generally, he really can't be bothered to play the long game. He doesn't have to do anything with Sasha Banks other than push her in a prominent position.

And, weirdly, he barely ever did.

CONT'D...(4 of 6)


Four Horsewomen WWE
WWE.com

WWE is potentially losing a major ratings draw at a time in which Roman Reigns has opted to go part-time, Cody Rhodes is facing a long spell on the shelf, and WWE just barely drew a 3,000 gate for RAW this week. Vince McMahon slapped Austin Theory to endorse him, so that's probably an overreaction and everything is going to be OK.

The impact of Sasha's potential departure has indirect ramifications, too. WWE has to market itself effectively for all manner of reasons. The company must be able to brag about itself in the public eye when attracting sponsors, negotiating rights fees, and generally not looking like a sh*t-show of a circus that the average person thinks is as backwards as f*ck.

Sasha Banks represents two of WWE’s most well-received developments in recent years, and realistically, there haven’t been too many of them. She was a highlight of NXT and more importantly, for optics purposes, was instrumental in the "Women's Revolution".

She was a Horsewomen.

CONT'D...(5 of 6)


John Laurinaitis
WWE

She was supposed to make it look like WWE wasn't a seedy misogynistic old boys racket, and, well, WWE seems to be sh*t out of luck in that department as of this moment.

Sasha’s legacy is inextricably linked to the best of WWE’s modern, marketable heritage, but her departure brings into focus just how little they ultimately meant. In parallel, WWE cannot build new stars nor, increasingly, draw from the stars of the past. Triple H can't wrestle anymore. The Undertaker is done. John Cena can do the summer tour again, but he didn't compel his old fans to stick around when he left again last year.

If it was thought that WWE could persist with its part-timer model, and just use the likes of Roman Reigns and Randy Orton on a part-time basis to replace 'Taker and Trips, that theory is being tested far quicker than most might have thought just three months ago.

Sasha might not go to AEW. If she does, and Tony Khan knows what he has, he - potentially - holds the key to winning the war that couldn't be won.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!