8 X-Men Characters You Didn't Realise Had Died
Comic book death means nothing to these X-Men. Chances are you forgot they even died at all!
In your life, you've probably heard that death is no laughing matter. But what ig you were to discover that there is a world where death means absolutely nothing at all. Well, welcome to the wonderful world of comics! Specifically X-Men comics, where death has become so mundane you actually forget that some of your favorite characters have spent time six feet under.
The fact of the matter is that a lot of major comics icons have died over the years. Actually, you'd be harder pressed to find any major characters who haven't. But some character deaths are a little more memorable than others. Whether that's due to bad storylines, speedy resurrections, or just plain not liking a character, there a lot of reasons to forget a death here and there.
The killing off of a character used to be a huge, attention-grabbing event that was on the top of everyone's must-read list. Nowadays, most comic book fans are aware that the death of a character just means the character will be shelved for a couple of years before making yet another miraculous recovery. Publishers are lucky to get a collective eyeroll at the news of a beloved character's passing. Funny how that works.
Today, let's look at the X-deaths that never really left an impact and are only remembered in the dark recesses of our brains.
8. Multiple Man
Jamie Madrox, aka the Multiple Man, really came into his own in Peter David's X-Factor. David's '90s series run and subsequent reboot in 2005 gave Madrox a lot of much needed character development. And that's why his death is so strange.
Without getting into too much context, at the aptly named Death of X storyline the Inhumans sent clouds they call Terrigen Mist around the world to awaken dormant Inhumans. The problem is the mist was found to be poisonous to mutants, creating an inevitable conflict between the two groups.
Jamie Madrox was killed by the Terrigen Mist in 2016 as setup for the conflict. That in itself isn't that strange. Plenty of important characters are killed as fodder for crossover storylines. What is strange is that Jamie was killed in a single page as exposition.
Madrox wasn't being used in any X-books at the time. The mixture of his rather unceremonious death and his infrequent usage caused a lot of people to miss his death entirely.
7. Magneto
So right up front, let's make it clear. Yes, the version of Magneto being talked about here was technically Xorn in disguise as Magneto in disguise as Xorn. And yes, it is technically incorrect to say that Magneto died during this storyline. But when Grant Morrison wrote this story, there is little to no doubt that he meant to kill the real Magneto.
The storyline in question came towards the end of Morrison's stint on New X-Men in 2004. Magneto is revealed as the big bad who has been hiding in disguise just under the X-Men's noses as the superhero Xorn. He takes over New York City and turns it into an authoritarian deathscape. Magneto is ultimately killed by Wolverine and it seemed the master of magnetism would be out of continuity for awhile. So imagine readers' surprise when just a few months later Magneto was revealed as a main character in the new Excalibur series.
To explain this the writers ultimately retconned that Magneto was in hiding and the menace that attacked New York really was Xorn. Yes, it is terribly confusing. Some people may have been asleep at the wheel on this one, but the short of it is that Magneto was killed and resurrected so quickly even Marvel editorial seemed to forget he was supposed to be dead.
6. Cable
Usually Cable is more X-Force than X-Men, but he certainly applies for this list. Cable is a militaristic leader from a far away future, so in that way maybe it isn't that much of a surprise that he's died more than a couple times. But he keeps finding a way back.
Maybe it's because Cable's death feels inevitable - a future man who lives by spitting in the face of danger is certain to have a high mortality rate - but his absences from the book have always felt unreal. There's the time he was lost in a time vortex fighting his evil clone. There was the time he was shot in the head by Deadpool. There's even the time he gave his life to protect his daughter, Hope Summers. Cable "dies" a lot, but you just know he'll find a way back and that makes each death less memorable as a whole.
Even in current continuity, the Cable we are accustomed to seeing was killed by a kid version of himself who takes his place. If only that was the most confusing thing about this character...
5. Wolverine
Wolverine is the face of X-Men media. So when Marvel decided to off the Canadian brawler in 2014's Death of Wolverine storyline, lots of media attention was given to the character.
But then comic book fans remembered something: Wolverine makes Marvel a ton of money. There was no way he was going to actually die and the whole event was nothing more than a gimmick to sell comics. And inevitably, fans were proven right as, to no one's surprise, Wolverine came back from the dead in 2017.
The fact that no one really believed that this was permanent makes Wolverine's death more of a comic trivia footnote than an actually important aspect of the character. Unless you were specifically looking for Logan during that brief time he was dead, you might not have even noticed he was gone. For a character as oversaturated in comic media as Wolverine, this seemed more like a much needed break than anything else.
It seems impossible to imagine a Marvel universe today without Wolverine, and many have appropriately blocked it from their memories entirely.
4. Colossus
Colossus gave his life in an effort to save all mutants by injecting himself with a cure for the Legacy Virus, a disease that was killing mutantkind throughout the '90s. It was a gripping sacrifice in a time where the stakes couldn't have been higher. So how can one of the most emotional and moving X-deaths of all time become forgettable? Easily, it was published in 2001.
The 1990s were a dark decade for comics and are infamous for the bevy of bad storylines produced. In 2001, X-Men comics were still stuck in some fairly lacklustre story cycles (though that would soon change). Many readers left the scene to avoid it all, and because of this, many never realized Colossus was gone for a brief stint in the early 2000s.
Doubling down on the forgettability of it all is the fact that his sacrifice is rarely talked about after his resurrection in Joss Whedon's Astonishing X-Men. It seems kind of weird that no one ever really thanks Colossus within the pages of the comics, so maybe his teammates forgot he was gone too?
3. Cyclops
Cyclops feels like the immortal X-Men. Wolverine is the icon and Professor X is the founder, but Cyclops is the forever symbol of what the X-Men are. That's what makes it pretty incomprehensible that he was ever killed in the first place.
Cyclops, like Multiple Man, died in 2016's Death of X. Maybe it says something about the story if two very notable characters were killed so forgettably. While investigating an infested Muir Island, Cyclops is exposed to Terrigen Mist which very quickly kills him.
As you can imagine, this would be a big deal to mutants. Cyclops was leading the band of outlaw X-Men that ran in opposition to the conventional mutant team. He was a face for something much larger than himself, so when he died, Emma Frost decided to continue his legacy... by creating a psychic impression of him to live on. She believed the idea of Cyclops was too important to let perish and decided he should stand as a symbol for mutants to unify under. And ultimately her plan worked, as the psychic Cyclops was sacrificed to be a martyr for mutants everywhere.
So Cyclops (sort of) died twice? Once as himself and once as his legacy. He was quickly resurrected in 2019, but even when he died in comics he never truly died. Maybe that's why it feels like he never did to readers.
2. Shadowcat
For those not in the know, X-Men comics have changed considerably in the last few years. For starters, the X-Men now live on a mutant island called Krakoa and have built a system that can resurrect any mutant upon the event of their death. For that reason, it feels a little like cheating to call any death in the new status quo forgettable. But Kate Pryde is an exception. From the beginning of this new era, Kate had a problem: all this new mutant tech didn't seem to work for her.
And of course, to comic book writers who can't pass up on the drama, that means she had to bite the big one. In Marauders #6, Kate was murdered by Sebastian Shaw and she was unable to be resurrected. It really did seem like Kate was dead.
But then they brought her back. It seems almost anticlimactic how quickly it all got resolved. In total, her death lasted a whopping five issues, which will surely be a forgotten trivia tidbit in years to come. In the grand scheme of things it is like she didn't even die at all.
1. Nightcrawler
Kurt Wagner is the soul of the X-Men. A man of many hats, Nightcrawler has been a jokester, a confidant, a swashbuckler, a leader, and most of all, the moral center of the team. This is all to say this character means a lot to both fans and the X-Men themselves. But honestly, Nightcrawler felt a bit out of place on the X-Men roster in the late 2000s. For whatever reason the character felt aimless. He still carried that emotional role on the team, but with such an everchanging and expanded roster, he seemed to always be on the periphery. So it's for that reason that he was chosen to be the sacrificial lamb of the "Second Coming" storyline in 2010.
X-writers needed a death that would mean something, and Nightcrawler fit the bill. He gave his life by teleporting to protect Hope Summers and preserve "the mutant messiah." Like most of the characters talked about on this list, Nightcrawler stayed dead for a couple of years but was brought back to the X-Men after giving up his spot in heaven to save his friends. Tough break.
Ultimately, Nightcrawler's death is forgettable for its brevity and his relative insignificance in the comics at the time. As sad as it is to say, few readers could tell he was gone.